News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by battani on Sunday March 30, 2014 @10:57PM (#7499308)
The IRS now treats bitcoin as a property asset, very much the same way they treat stocks, and not all stocks are prone to speculation. So this is expected news for those who hold bitcoin as an investment.

The major impact of this decision will be on consumer adoption. Now, every time I want to make a transaction, I need to keep track of my taxes. I know that some wallet services are already developing ways to keep track of this automatically, but that's just an extra headache for the average consumer. This in essence will force consumers to think of bitcoin more as an investment, rather than a "currency" they can spend, and that will impede adoption.

I know nobody here likes to hear it, and I feel like a lot here in SV are tuning this out, but bitcoin is really, really struggling to find a relevant use case with consumers. Regular consumers have absolutely no reason to use bitcoin. The "1-click" payment and 1% price discount are not appealing enough to the average Joe who already gets 1-2% cash back, airline miles, and consumer protection on his credit card (and 1-click checkouts on many e-commerce platforms). And more regulation isn't helping the "crypto-anarchist" decentralization angle either. Add price volatility to that and it kills the consumer use case.

But... micro-payments? Consumers have always hated them. http://www.openp2p.com/pub/a/p2p/2000/12/19/micropayments.ht... (Shirky, 2000)

But... international transactions? Hard to beat the fees at https://transferwise.com.

Bitcoin is great, FOR MERCHANTS. But consumer adoption is going to determine whether or not it succeeds on a grander scale. Unfortunately, Bitcoin does not solve a problem for consumers. Especially with tap-tap mobile payments around the corner.

When it comes to money, consumers want to be insured and cuddled and protected and not run the risk (however small) of being criminally liable for transactions and have someone to speak with if they make an erroneous transaction or have their card stolen. And they can already do all that, which makes it tremendously difficult to compel them to change the habits they've had for in forever to adopt a system that does not provide them with significant advantages.

I've been in bitcoin since 2011 and used to be a big believer, but I don't see bitcoin gaining traction with consumers, in part because of the huge regulatory risk. Any significant threat to the banks' business will be met with harmful regulatory control (friendly reminder: Wall Street banks fund the largest political lobbies in Washington). It could be destined to eternally remain an investment instrument (like gold) or find very targeted applications (like machine-to-machine payments). The underlying blockchain technology could be of more use (if adopted by the banking system, for example) but that is still far in the future.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by 2arrs2ells on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:16PM (#7499381)
The "one-click" payment and 1% price discount is not gonna appeal enough to the average Joe who already has 1-2% cash back, airline miles, and consumer protection on his credit card (and 1-click checkouts on many e-commerce platforms).

Yes! The credit card is an amazing tool for consumers, and I won't be giving mine up unless I get something significantly more amazing in return (Merchants would need to offer 5-10% discounts on purchases with bitcoin, for me to begin to be interested).

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by sitkack on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:42AM (#7499854)
Not sure how it relates to bitcoin, but Visa and Master Card will pull a merchants account if they give cash discounts. They do this, ofcourse, to make cash and cards equal in the eyes of the consumer even though the merchant takes a pretty sizeable hit.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by willlll on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:04AM (#7499903)
Except this hasn't been true for several years in most states http://usa.visa.com/personal/get-help/checkout-fees.jsp
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by sitkack on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:20AM (#7499954)
True here, http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/credit-card-f...

But thanks for that, I wasn't aware.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by rdl on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:08AM (#7499919)
Or for products which can't take credit cards -- e.g. buying gold coins, high fraud purchases, illegal stuff, etc.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by danieltillett on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:12PM (#7499363)
Bitcoin will always have value as a new way to think about money. It has started some really smart people thinking about the next system - this is really the norm for any major breakthrough. Nothing is ever perfect the first time or doesn't evolve as things change. I think that given how good bitcoin is has led some people to believe it is perfect.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by battani on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:21AM (#7499616)
I agree. But it's very difficult to find a system that is so appealing to consumers that they'll make the switch, simply because consumers don't have a payments problem. Incremental reductions in friction (e.g. the consumer won't have to enter their credit card details, or, the consumer will save a percent on their purchase) are certainly not compelling enough to justify changing a deep and old habit.

And a new system would have to figure out a way to mitigate the regulatory risk.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by tlrobinson on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:19PM (#7499391)
"Now, every time I want to make a transaction, I need to keep track of my taxes. I know that some startups are already developing ways to keep track of this automatically, but that's just an extra headache for the average consumer."

Fortunately we have machines that are really good at keeping track of numbers and adding them up.

I expect Bitcoin wallets will just calculate your taxes for you automatically.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by battani on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:15AM (#7499595)
I agree, but it just adds friction. Already, consumers are very comfortable using their credit cards. If you add the mental cost of thinking about taxes, especially when you have to pay capital gains when you pay for something (!!), that's a deterrent for most regular consumers.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by greenyoda on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:53AM (#7499877)
Exactly. Many people have never had to fill out a Schedule D before and have no idea what long-term vs. short-term gains are, how to compute capital loss carryovers, etc. So their taxes would suddenly become more complicated just because they had a few dollars worth of capital gains/losses from Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by fpgeek on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:26AM (#7499625)
Unless they had an enormous amount of personal information, Bitcoin wallets couldn't possibly calculate your taxes for you automatically. At best, they might be able to calculate the potential trading gains and/or losses of your Bitcoin transactions (and even then there would be issues about how you divided your Bitcoin purchases and sales into lots and ...).
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by tlrobinson on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:43AM (#7499672)
Of course that's what I meant, not your entire tax return.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by fragsworth on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:10AM (#7499562)
> Unfortunately, Bitcoin does not solve a problem for consumers.

That's not true. It took a while to convince my friends, but now we normally use bitcoin to settle restaurant bills and other debts that used to be difficult to keep track of and error-prone. It's not a godsend from heaven, but it works and is much better than what we used to do.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by battani on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:14AM (#7499589)
Is there any reason in particular you're not using existing solutions, like Venmo or Splitwise?
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by fragsworth on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:51AM (#7499709)
I don't know, those services are probably good, but Bitcoin works perfectly and we don't mind the volatility, and I kind of enjoy it.

There are plenty of minor reasons to prefer Bitcoin, like how nobody can prevent you from accessing your funds for something like "suspicious activity".

But there are a some bigger reasons - if you're good with your security, you don't have to do things like check another statement every month to see if someone stole your account information.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by mike_hearn on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:43AM (#7500022)
Venmo is unavailable outside the USA (or at least, it's not available in my area).

Splitwise appears to be just a web2.0 accounting type app? I didn't see any mention of actually moving money around. Bitcoin isn't actually that great for splitting bills at the moment because wallets don't have Splitwise type features. But in theory once added it should be quite convenient, assuming you can tolerate the usual Bitcoin downsides.

I think you're right that currently there's not a whole lot of incentive for people to use Bitcoin in the USA, especially for local transactions. But the system is still very new. It's hard to know how things will work out in future. All we do know is that the payments market, especially the American payments market, is extremely stagnant. The USA is stuck in a timewarp from most of the worlds perspective despite a proliferation of little startups that try and do something hip with magstripe cards. I mean, this is a country where people still routinely use cheques. So it may well be that Bitcoin, as it matures and adds features, finds a way to be competitive against credit cards, especially now the rules forbidding price differentials are being struck down.

The IRS decision is a problem for sure, but it's also specific to one geography. The UK tax authority decided the same thing (Bitcoin is not a currency) and then changed their mind shortly afterwards. Bitcoin quite clearly IS currency by any reasonable definition that doesn't boil down to "a currency is whatever the government says a currency is", and so hopefully at some point the IRS decision would be changed in favour of common sense.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by tzs on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:23AM (#7499618)
Could some of the multiple people who down voted battani's comment please explain why?

For the application in question (settling restaurant bills among a group of friends), Venmo looks ideal. No transaction fees, easy to use and flexible, no exchange rate issues, it's operated by a company that is actually licensed as a money transmitter in every state of the US, and no tax collection or reporting issues.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by dragontamer on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:12AM (#7501540)
And when BTC's price changes by 20% to 30%, do yall still pay each other back in BTC or do you convert into USD before paying each other back?

Or... you can be like everyone else and just have a guy go to the bank and grab a bunch of $5 and $1 bills when you know your group is getting together. CASH is the easiest way to settle debts and keep track of payments.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by darksim905 on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:14AM (#7499588)
Get friends who know how to do math, go to less expensive restaurants or learn how to divide.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by fragsworth on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:30AM (#7499634)
That's not the problem, it's more about remembering debts later, or needing to split the bills (wasting extra time) and/or not having the right cash denominations.

And there are plenty of other situations where you might owe each other money.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by Amezarak on Monday March 31, 2014 @07:35AM (#7500774)
If the problem is sending money to your friends electronically (otherwise I'm nto sure how Bitcoin solves the problem of remembering debts or splitting bills), this is a solved problem for some people.

My credit union lets my transfer money to any other member of the credit union instantly with no fees. As it happens, nearly all my friends are members of this credit union (it's local and offers a much better deal than the banks) - and they have a mobile app so you can do it from your phone.

They've just added a general ACH function to it, to transfer to any account, but I haven't used it so I don't know if there are any associated fees. It doesn't mention any, but I associate the word ACH with some kind of fee.

So to me, this isn't a "find a new currency and financial system" problem, it's a "find a better bank" problem.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by neilk on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:31AM (#7499988)
Thanks.

> I know nobody here likes to hear it,

For what it's worth, I do like to hear it! I have a very small amount of Bitcoin but just for fun, really.

That said, I'm not sure that "machine to machine payments" is all that small of a market, in the world that we're apparently hurtling towards.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by panabee on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:47PM (#7499495)
perhaps this is what you meant, but isn't the major impact that the stated price is potentially different from the bitcoin price? in other words, buying something for $10 might actually cost $12 because of capital gains. i agree that wallet software can track tax data automatically, but it seems like the true impact is that consumers won't know what price they're paying unless wallets compute a real-time real price. unless bitcoin prices stabilize within a very tight band, it seems like this issue is what would impair consumer adoption the most? i'm new to bitcoin, so please lemme know if i'm missing something.
Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by maxerickson on Monday March 31, 2014 @08:40AM (#7501007)
It isn't an additional cost if you look at the overall situation of the buyer. The taxes owed will always be less than the gain realized.

If anything, using bitcoin that have appreciated in value probably reduces the perceived cost of the item.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by gnaritas on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:33AM (#7501672)
> buying something for $10 might actually cost $12 because of capital gains

No. The cost of goods isn't affected by your taxes. You simply have to realize that your Bitcoin stash is pre-tax just as your 401k is pre-tax; spending it incurs a taxable event that means it's time to pay taxes on your gain, those taxes were always going to be due, the good didn't cost more, you're just paying your income taxes late since you haven't paid them yet.

Re:Bitcoin Slips In The Wake Of The IRS’s Tax Decision by battani on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:16AM (#7499598)
Yes, price variability (measured against USD) would deter consumers.