People will gamble on anything, as long as the price isn't fixed (and it will never be), there will always be those willing to throw money at it and dream big.
Keep in mind: Big players haven't really yet bought in yet, Bitcoin is currently inflationary, and so on. Bitcoin certainly has little hope to become stable any time soon.
The major impact of this decision will be on consumer adoption. Now, every time I want to make a transaction, I need to keep track of my taxes. I know that some wallet services are already developing ways to keep track of this automatically, but that's just an extra headache for the average consumer. This in essence will force consumers to think of bitcoin more as an investment, rather than a "currency" they can spend, and that will impede adoption.
I know nobody here likes to hear it, and I feel like a lot here in SV are tuning this out, but bitcoin is really, really struggling to find a relevant use case with consumers. Regular consumers have absolutely no reason to use bitcoin. The "1-click" payment and 1% price discount are not appealing enough to the average Joe who already gets 1-2% cash back, airline miles, and consumer protection on his credit card (and 1-click checkouts on many e-commerce platforms). And more regulation isn't helping the "crypto-anarchist" decentralization angle either. Add price volatility to that and it kills the consumer use case.
But... micro-payments? Consumers have always hated them. http://www.openp2p.com/pub/a/p2p/2000/12/19/micropayments.ht... (Shirky, 2000)
But... international transactions? Hard to beat the fees at https://transferwise.com.
Bitcoin is great, FOR MERCHANTS. But consumer adoption is going to determine whether or not it succeeds on a grander scale. Unfortunately, Bitcoin does not solve a problem for consumers. Especially with tap-tap mobile payments around the corner.
When it comes to money, consumers want to be insured and cuddled and protected and not run the risk (however small) of being criminally liable for transactions and have someone to speak with if they make an erroneous transaction or have their card stolen. And they can already do all that, which makes it tremendously difficult to compel them to change the habits they've had for in forever to adopt a system that does not provide them with significant advantages.
I've been in bitcoin since 2011 and used to be a big believer, but I don't see bitcoin gaining traction with consumers, in part because of the huge regulatory risk. Any significant threat to the banks' business will be met with harmful regulatory control (friendly reminder: Wall Street banks fund the largest political lobbies in Washington). It could be destined to eternally remain an investment instrument (like gold) or find very targeted applications (like machine-to-machine payments). The underlying blockchain technology could be of more use (if adopted by the banking system, for example) but that is still far in the future.
Yes! The credit card is an amazing tool for consumers, and I won't be giving mine up unless I get something significantly more amazing in return (Merchants would need to offer 5-10% discounts on purchases with bitcoin, for me to begin to be interested).
But thanks for that, I wasn't aware.
And a new system would have to figure out a way to mitigate the regulatory risk.
Fortunately we have machines that are really good at keeping track of numbers and adding them up.
I expect Bitcoin wallets will just calculate your taxes for you automatically.
That's not true. It took a while to convince my friends, but now we normally use bitcoin to settle restaurant bills and other debts that used to be difficult to keep track of and error-prone. It's not a godsend from heaven, but it works and is much better than what we used to do.
There are plenty of minor reasons to prefer Bitcoin, like how nobody can prevent you from accessing your funds for something like "suspicious activity".
But there are a some bigger reasons - if you're good with your security, you don't have to do things like check another statement every month to see if someone stole your account information.
Splitwise appears to be just a web2.0 accounting type app? I didn't see any mention of actually moving money around. Bitcoin isn't actually that great for splitting bills at the moment because wallets don't have Splitwise type features. But in theory once added it should be quite convenient, assuming you can tolerate the usual Bitcoin downsides.
I think you're right that currently there's not a whole lot of incentive for people to use Bitcoin in the USA, especially for local transactions. But the system is still very new. It's hard to know how things will work out in future. All we do know is that the payments market, especially the American payments market, is extremely stagnant. The USA is stuck in a timewarp from most of the worlds perspective despite a proliferation of little startups that try and do something hip with magstripe cards. I mean, this is a country where people still routinely use cheques. So it may well be that Bitcoin, as it matures and adds features, finds a way to be competitive against credit cards, especially now the rules forbidding price differentials are being struck down.
The IRS decision is a problem for sure, but it's also specific to one geography. The UK tax authority decided the same thing (Bitcoin is not a currency) and then changed their mind shortly afterwards. Bitcoin quite clearly IS currency by any reasonable definition that doesn't boil down to "a currency is whatever the government says a currency is", and so hopefully at some point the IRS decision would be changed in favour of common sense.
For the application in question (settling restaurant bills among a group of friends), Venmo looks ideal. No transaction fees, easy to use and flexible, no exchange rate issues, it's operated by a company that is actually licensed as a money transmitter in every state of the US, and no tax collection or reporting issues.
Or... you can be like everyone else and just have a guy go to the bank and grab a bunch of $5 and $1 bills when you know your group is getting together. CASH is the easiest way to settle debts and keep track of payments.
And there are plenty of other situations where you might owe each other money.
My credit union lets my transfer money to any other member of the credit union instantly with no fees. As it happens, nearly all my friends are members of this credit union (it's local and offers a much better deal than the banks) - and they have a mobile app so you can do it from your phone.
They've just added a general ACH function to it, to transfer to any account, but I haven't used it so I don't know if there are any associated fees. It doesn't mention any, but I associate the word ACH with some kind of fee.
So to me, this isn't a "find a new currency and financial system" problem, it's a "find a better bank" problem.
> I know nobody here likes to hear it,
For what it's worth, I do like to hear it! I have a very small amount of Bitcoin but just for fun, really.
That said, I'm not sure that "machine to machine payments" is all that small of a market, in the world that we're apparently hurtling towards.
If anything, using bitcoin that have appreciated in value probably reduces the perceived cost of the item.
No. The cost of goods isn't affected by your taxes. You simply have to realize that your Bitcoin stash is pre-tax just as your 401k is pre-tax; spending it incurs a taxable event that means it's time to pay taxes on your gain, those taxes were always going to be due, the good didn't cost more, you're just paying your income taxes late since you haven't paid them yet.
Since the IRS is now imposing a capital gains tax, that penalizes speculators. One of the issues with Bitcoin right now is that so many people are speculating (myself included) that it probably increases the volatility. If people are encouraged to spend, invest, or convert BTC into fiat currency ASAP, the price of a BTC should go down and remain very stable. In this scenario BTC becomes a decentralized money transfer network, for the most part.
The only issue is going to be doing all the accounting for the government, but that seems eminently doable since every transaction is perfectly recorded.
I'm not very experienced with financial matters, so perhaps someone can correct me.