News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by jader201 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @10:54AM (#7492402)
> Beyond our core community, we expected it would be positive.

> If you actually understand [Facebook’s] vision of letting us be who we’re going to be, just like they wanted to let Instagram be who they are.

The reason people don't get this -- or at least, why I don't get it -- and thus responded negatively, is because VR should have nothing to do with Facebook's vision, and Facebook -- or social gaming in general -- should have nothing to do with Oculus' vision.

Gamers cared about Oculus and Rift because they felt Oculus was innovating in the interest of gaming as a whole. But being bought out by Facebook makes it seem that Oculus is "selling out" to someone that is historically more interested in monopolizing innovation than they are in gaming, or at least the type of gaming that Oculus was originally innovating towards.

It's hard for many to see anything under the umbrella of Facebook doing a service to gaming -- look at the direction social gaming has taken us.

This is how I see it, in my admittedly limited view, anyway. And since the views of those "beyond their core community" are likely similarly limited, it makes sense that others may have a similar reaction.

So I'm baffled how Oculus is surprised by the reaction.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bstar77 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:15AM (#7492486)
> Beyond our core community, we expected it would be positive.

How can you go in understanding that you are going to upset your core community and expect anything other than a negative response?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by codeflo on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:25AM (#7492521)
This is the part that stuck out for me as well. They quite plainly state that they knew this would alienate their existing audience, and that they were perfectly fine with that.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by stingraycharles on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:46AM (#7492596)
And in the end, it's their choice anyway. People respond mostly negatively because of their expectations about how Facebook will monetize this. It's now up to Facebook to prove them wrong.

I personally think it's not going to be as bad. Oculus has a clear path to monetization, while Facebook, with their other products, have always been struggling to monetize their user base, which lead them to implement controversial features like Beacon. In this case, all they have to do is back off and make sure the right people are leading Oculus -- and so far, I think they are doing fine with that.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by teacup50 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:09PM (#7492693)
> "Oculus has a clear path to monetization"

"Monetization" is a bastardization of a term that was necessary to describe how non-profitable companies could somehow make money from giving away their product for free -- usually by abusing the userbase they're handing the free product to.

See the second paragraph: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetization

I think what you meant to say is:

"Oculus has a clear product that they will sell for money, because that's how businesses that actually sell products to their customers survive".

This is a major reason why the Facebook buyout is so terrible for a product company. Facebook doesn't know how to make and sell a product that isn't their own users.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by threeseed on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:37PM (#7492806)
> Facebook doesn't know how to make and sell a product that isn't their own users

And how is this any different to Google ? They have exactly the same business model as Facebook.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by albeec13 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:24PM (#7492992)
My initial reaction was to ask why you brought Google into this conversation. Upon further thought, while Google does have a similar business model to Facebook, they have also built actual products and sold them directly to consumers, which Facebook has not. They also build an operating system, Android, used by the majority of smart phones sold worldwide.

So no, they're not quite the same, but ignoring that, why bring up Google when no one is talking about them here?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by XorNot on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:30PM (#7493311)
Because Google used to be just a search engine. Seriously, is the idea that "things change with time" so alien to the HN audience?
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by albeec13 on Sunday March 30, 2014 @08:43PM (#7498762)
That still has nothing to do with what I said. The poster I responded to brought up Google in a conversation that was completely unrelated to them. Not only that, his comparison wasn't even apt, because Google has built and sold hardware and develops Android, so saying their business model is exactly the same as Facebook isn't even remotely accurate.

I have no problem with companies changing their focus and direction, and my response was strictly related to the poster's out-of-left-field comment.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by whatevsbro on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:27PM (#7493002)
> And how is this any different to Google ?

It isn't, they're both raping their users' privacy for money, and that is why Oculus selling to Facebook is disgusting. Facebook will only use it for more privacy-raping, since that's just what Facebook does.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by threeseed on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:32PM (#7492786)
Why do people think Facebook has a problem making money ? They had over $7 billion in revenue in 2013.

And should they ever decide to compete with Google's AdSense they would be able to make a significant amount more.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by checker659 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:26AM (#7492524)
Money clouds proper judgement. (I'm not implying if this is good or bad, fyi).
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:51AM (#7492613)
> It's hard for many to see anything under the umbrella of Facebook doing a service to gaming -- look at the direction social gaming has taken us.

Yes, look at social gaming. At least inside the retrogaming communities, people who take a very long view of gaming, social gaming is not well loved. It's seen as a shackle not a new experience by and large. Even among new games, Skyrim and GTA V are hugely popular even though the experience is mostly single player.

There have been some good examples of it (Team Fortress 2, World of Warcraft, EVE), but by and large you end up with Farmville and the new SimCity more often. Both of which are horrible and/or exploitive games.

Getting dozens of spams a day from your "friends" to play this or that shallow psychological-reward hack social game on Facebook is what people are envisioning with this acquisition when what people wanted was Half-Life 3 VR edition or a Star Wars 3D game...or even non-gaming "take a virtual tour around the Pantheon" experiences.

And just as important, social games have no lifespan. I'm used to being able to pull up a 20 year old game and get it working (even on PCs with a little work). Social games in general have a short half-life. Remember the huge hit that was Farmville? Is it even still around? I dunno.

I'm definitely in the camp that thinks this acquisition will come to no good. But to be hoenst, if somebody waived $2b in my face I'd take it and skip off to a comfortable retirement in Malta without giving two shits about the community that supported it in the beginning.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:04PM (#7492915)
> But to be honest, if somebody waived $2b in my face I'd take it and skip off to a comfortable retirement in Malta without giving two shits about the community that supported it in the beginning.

Would you? Really? It is my understanding the Oculus folks were working on that partly for fun, partly because they have a purpose (the purpose being "VR gaming would be soo cool!"). Their idea of a "comfortable retirement" may very well be to continue working on the Rift. I would also be surprised if they didn't care at all about the community.

Seriously, what would you do if you won $2b tomorrow? I know I wouldn't retire in Malta or such, because it would quickly bore me to death. I would need to do something, and I suspect, so do you.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:39PM (#7493057)
Absolutely. I wouldn't even look back. I have plenty of other things to occupy my time that isn't work. Painting, writing, photography, music, and the list goes on forever. Freed of the daily grind I would nothing but things I expect no return on simply for the pleasure of it. I'd probably even give away the output of those activities for nothing.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by vinceguidry on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:49PM (#7493109)
What if you wanted to do something bigger? Like, say, design a next-generation VR platform?
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @04:57PM (#7493892)
Why is that bigger? I can already instantaneously communicate with whomever I wish anywhere on or near the planet...cheaply or for essentially free.

To play games? I love gaming as much as the next guy, but at the end of the day it's just a toy.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by vinceguidry on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:06PM (#7493934)
It's bigger because it requires more than your own efforts. One person can draw, paint, make music all they want and never have to interact with others at all, and these were the sorts of things you were saying you'd do in retirement.

But you couldn't move to Malta and make a next-generation VR platform. You'd need funding, facilities, people to take care of managing these things. That's what I meant by bigger.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:23PM (#7494014)
Ahh, bigger as in "involves more people" rather than bigger as in "moral crusade to change humanity".

Yeah, no thanks. Once I get the construction crew out of my retirement home, I'd like to deal with as few people as humanly possible. I don't even like the social interaction of dealing with cashiers, I love the self service lines.

If I hit on a retirement hobby that requires more people, I'm sure I'll always just be able to just form a company and hire people to do the work with my swimming pool full of money.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 29, 2014 @06:42PM (#7494291)
> at the end of the day it's just a toy.

I'd say VR headsets are as much of a toy as Otto Lilienthal's hang gliders. As such, sure, they won't do much more than cool games. But the future is obvious: they're a first step into the Matrix, and from there to fully fledged Mind Uploading. (It may not help us develop the necessary technology —though it may help us figure out crucial neurological facts. But it will give us a glimpse of what is to come.)

Not to mention, VR will probably help us get to AR, which will surely have an even bigger impact.

At this point, we're not looking at a toy any more, but at a Prophecy.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:42PM (#7493070)
Ah, so you would do something. Okay.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by mbrameld on Saturday March 29, 2014 @07:52PM (#7494505)
I didn't see him say anywhere he wouldn't do something, only that he would retire to Malta.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:34PM (#7494079)
Well yeah, I wouldn't just stare off into space till my heart stops functioning.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nightski on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:14PM (#7493218)
Wow I am sorry that you enjoy your life's work so little. Maybe you should do something about that? I couldn't imagine a life where I was not stoked to do what I do every day.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by rfrey on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:26PM (#7493282)
Wow, I am sorry that your interests are so narrow. Maybe you should do something about that? I couldn't imagine a life where there was only one thing available that would fulfill me.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nightski on Saturday March 29, 2014 @04:00PM (#7493704)
Who said my interests were narrow? I enjoy a multitude of hobbies including hiking, biking, homebrewing, reading, cooking/grilling, etc... I just said that it is a shame you do not enjoy your daily work (i.e. the grind as you call it).
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @04:59PM (#7493907)
So if you had a billion dollars sloshing around in your bank account...and you could do the things that interested you the most, it would be having a job to go to?

I'm not knocking that, I know lots of people who hit retirement and literally don't know what to do with themselves. So work gives their day structure and meaning. I'm not one of those people. For me, work gets in the way of what I want to do.

I personally cannot conceive of a job, working for any company (my own included) or any other person or group of people, that I'd rather do than those things.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nightski on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:08PM (#7493942)
First of all, I don't have a job. I run my own consulting business that does very well. I don't think I could ever have a job working for someone else ever again.

That is my entire point, that I keep getting downvoted on like it even matters. That what I do today is the same thing that I would do if I had a billion dollars. That is I'd be working in technology (specifically software). I might use that money to build ideas faster but it really is what I am the most passionate about.

I feel it is the same for the Occulus Rift guys at the moment.

Because if you aren't passionate about what you spend your daily life doing (and consider it a grind) what is the point?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:32PM (#7494074)
I'm not going to make any value judgment on how much fulfillment you get out of working for your customers.

But you're getting downvoted probably because you don't understand that, as a consultant, you have a job, and you work for your customers.

Everybody who does work has a boss of some sort.

If being a consultant is what you'd be happy to do in perpetuity, even in lieu of retirement, more power to you.

The OR guys also now have a master. Facebook. Ultimately, their reporting chain is to Zuck and then to the board and then to the FB shareholders. They might feel really passionate about what they're doing, but it's not like they don't have jobs.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by TheSurge on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:33AM (#7495245)
"Choose a job you love, and you will never have to work a day in your life."

I think that this quote is very much true. Take it how you wish to.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by mikeash on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:34PM (#7493342)
I'd rather be stoked to do what I do every day and have $2 billion in the bank than be stoked but not have a massive pile of cash.

It's not as if there's only one thing in life that I could possibly enjoy.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nightski on Saturday March 29, 2014 @04:01PM (#7493710)
A strawman. I never stated this. Merely was stating that if you consider your daily profession a "grind" it might not be the one for you.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by mikeash on Saturday March 29, 2014 @09:56PM (#7494802)
"The daily grind" doesn't mean it's unpleasant, it simply means that you have to do it in order to e.g. continue eating.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by charlieflowers on Saturday March 29, 2014 @03:16PM (#7493534)
Weird. When I ask myself this question (as I do often), I don't usually get such a strong answer from myself. But my self just said, "I would work on VR." Fascinating.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by s3r3nity on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:58AM (#7492641)
Depends on what you mean by that -- The Halo & Call of Duty franchises have been getting by on great social multiplayer experiences. (Halo also has a great campaign, but I digress...)

The great experiment & test of your theory would be to see something like Titanfall only last a year or so, since it's ALL a social/multiplier experience.

In theory I think social gaming has strong networking effects that have to potential to cement a game, especially in crowds that aren't maybe hardcore gamers. For example, I thought one of the best things to come out of the Zynga era was the fact that middle aged mothers were the core gaming segment. Why is this awesome? Because as a life-long gamer I thought it was awesome that more than teenage boys were welcome into the community, regardless if the niche/genre was not my style.

Yes, there are a few problems that no one has quite figured out yet in regards to hyper-social, and solutions have been kind of lazy at best, but there's a big market opp here for somone who DOES figure it out.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:08PM (#7492690)
Well remember, for every successful social game, there's a Star Wars Galaxies or Age of Conan. Or if successful, try to play Mario Kart Wii or Mario Kart DS. Suddenly tens of millions of gamers get $0 of value out of their purchase because a company has decided it's time for gamers to move on and make their next purchase.

The problem of course is that most companies don't go the way of Quake3 and let people run their own servers. Because that's hard to monetize after the initial purchase. Valve has found a way to make it work, but outside of some very rare exceptions (WoW, 2nd Life), the age of the short-lived social game is here.

It's hard to imagine, but FarmVille isn't even 5 years old.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by pekk on Saturday March 29, 2014 @03:19PM (#7493545)
"social gaming" (as in what Facebook fostered) really means something different from good old "multiplayer gaming". It means the application of "social" as a buzzword and business model (meaning to intentionally exploit network effects) to games, like spamming people's facebook walls against their will, giving in-game benefits for spamming the game to other people, etc.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by grkvlt on Saturday March 29, 2014 @04:15PM (#7493753)
> Getting dozens of spams a day from your "friends" to play this or that shallow psychological-reward hack social game on Facebook

So, much like the responses to '2048' here on HN, and among members of its community? And, seeing how highly voted those posts and comments were, I assumed that wasn't seen as a bad thing?

> social gaming is not well loved. [...] Even among new games, Skyrim and GTA V are hugely popular even though the experience is mostly single player.

Do you mean un-popular here? Or among new gamers not games? Not sure...

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:01PM (#7493913)
I'm glad that the 2048 craze has petered off a bit. But social gaming is the same thing essentially. It hits, involves lots of people, then the next hit comes around and everybody is off to the new thing.

"new games" vs. "older games"

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by dragontamer on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:11AM (#7492466)
Case in point: Facebook games are Mafia Wars and Farmville... games that represent raking in tons of money by offering very poor (but addicting) gameplay.

The core gamer audience is pissed off at Facebook as it is, and that is the audience Oculus Rift is aimed towards. If Oculus sold out to Valve, Sony, Microsoft... hell... maybe even EA or Activision... they wouldn't have nearly as bad of a reaction as with Facebook.

Because as bad as EA or Activision is... they have demonstrated an understanding of the core "hardcore" gamer audience that appreciates greater depth and vision in gameplay. Facebook however, does NOT.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by threeseed on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:44PM (#7492843)
See this is why I like that Facebook acquired Oculus. VR shouldn't be the exclusive domain of hardcore gamers.

I want the equivalent of Playstation Home in VR. And nobody can pull that off except Facebook.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by dragontamer on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:28AM (#7496415)
Or you know... Sony. The maker of PlayStation Home and the Oculus competitor "Morpheus". Or Valve, the creator of Steam... one of the largest online video game social networks.

Or Second Life, who has a very agreeable model of virtual space and virtual goods.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by Geee on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:12AM (#7492475)
Don't you see it? Facebook can't currently monetize face-to-face interactions, but in virtual reality they can.

The purchase makes a lot of sense for Facebook. Facebook's business model is to monetize human interactions. Today, most of human interaction happens over the Internet (with messages and images), and in the future, it will happen in virtual environments. VR will be the ultimate platform, and Facebook wants to own that platform.

Virtual reality is not about gaming. Would you describe Matrix as a game? Facebook's wants to put everyone in the Matrix, so they can monetize us.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by dragontamer on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:16AM (#7492496)
This is what people fear from Facebook.

Selling out to Microsoft or Sony would have been "monetize by making awesome games". Selling out to Facebook means virtual reality ads will penetrate everywhere you walk.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by freshyill on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:26PM (#7493284)
Just like on Instagram! Wait.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by danabramov on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:45AM (#7492589)
Do you seriously believe this? Then there will be competitors without ads.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by Geee on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:05PM (#7492676)
You can't compete with 'without ads' business model. Look around: Google search, Youtube, Facebook etc. They all had first mover advantage and there's no way someone can compete with these. These services (and companies) operate around the idea of giving away free candy and locking everyone in with network effects. This is what will happen to VR as well under Facebook's control.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by Turing_Machine on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:39PM (#7492817)
"Look around: Google search, Youtube, Facebook etc. They all had first mover advantage and there's no way someone can compete with these."

They did? What about Yahoo, Alta Vista, WebCrawler, MySpace, Friendster...?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by evan_ on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:17PM (#7492722)
Maybe it's harder to be #1 without being free but there are many video sites competing with YouTube that do pretty well. Vimeo, Netflix, Amazon Instant Video, etc- they're not FREE but they're still very popular. There's no reason to believe that Facebook's VR network will be the only one.

Also, none of the products you listed had first mover advantage. They're all excellent examples of things that upset a formerly dominant major player.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by rayiner on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:23PM (#7492751)
For movie distribution, network lock in doesn't matter so much. But for video sharing they do, and for VR they really will. Competing with Netflix is a lot easier than competing with Facebook or YouTube for that reason.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:23PM (#7492753)
> You can't compete with 'without ads' business model. Look around: Google search, Youtube, Facebook etc. They all had first mover advantage and there's no way someone can compete with these.

Nonsense, there are dozens of very expensive data providers and search companies out there who do very well for themselves thank you very much.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:28PM (#7493008)
Could you name three? (I fully expect that you can, but it'll make your argument that much more convincing).

Of the top of my head, I think of DuckDuckGo, which does not spy, but it still have ads.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:50PM (#7493110)
LexisNexis

VersusLaw

various legal, bio, tech, IP, etc. sites.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:33PM (#7494075)
doesn't let me edit, but Merck also has an entire slew of searchable information as does places like Bloomberg or other financial data companies.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by dragontamer on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:21AM (#7496394)
And therefore, Oculus Rift has "sold out".

We are now looking for more legitimate competitors, and are pissed off at the Oculus.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by randunel on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:12PM (#7492705)
There are ad-less video sharing websites, yet youtube is #1. Same will happen with Oculus, targeted ads in vr.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by superuser2 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:27PM (#7492763)
Other businesses that are about monetizing human interaction: telephony (pay us to talk to people), restaurants (pay us for a venue to have a conversation/date, show off your wealth), clothing (pay us to increase your apparent status/attractiveness), theater and movies (pay us to have an activity with your friends/date), beyond-low-end housing (pay us so you can entertain and impress and be in a city with lots of humans to interact with).

You say this like it's a dirty, disgusting thing to do, but is Facebook really that different from all of these industries in terms of wanting to monetize human interaction?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by freshhawk on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:05PM (#7492926)
All your examples are charging the user for facilitating interaction rather than monetizing on information gleaned from surveilling the interaction. That's a substantial difference.

I would say that the walled garden aspect also makes it pretty substantially different from those industries. I think we all agree that if there was only one restaurant chain or one movie theatre chain it would be a pretty awful experience in comparison to our current reality. It would make financial sense to degrade the experience quite a bit for a relatively small increase in profit per customer. In telephony this experiment was already run and the answer was, yes, it was substantially worse.

So yes, Facebook really is that different from your example industries.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by silentOpen on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:08PM (#7492937)
Yes. With the exception of telephony, each of those industries also delivers material/entertainment/comfort value. Telephony is just voice communication and benefits from a network effect and natural monopoly. Facebook has a far more sophisticated model of communication but is most similar to telephony.

The difference between Facebook and telephony is striking. You pay for a telephone connection. Other people pay for your Facebook experience to be mediated to their wishes. Telephony is p2p and we typically frown on operator intervention and worry about excessive centralization. Facebook could be p2p but is centralized and has heavy operator intervention.

Offering communications services for free and then attempting to 'monetize' the interactions that you mediate is distasteful.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by Geee on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:00PM (#7492895)
There's the obvious difference that there's no platform lock-in with these, and therefore there's choice and competition. Telephony, Internet, are open technologies without locking you in as a customer for any company.

Think back when we lived in caves. We shared stories, we shared cave paintings, we shared music by singing together, we had fun together, we explored and shared our curiosity, we created new things together. Most technology today is still just tools to do these same fundamental things, but in novel ways. Facebook wants to be the middleman in this. They didn't invent 'social', they brought it into digital world, they want to own it, and they want to monetize it.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:24PM (#7492995)
> Telephony, Internet, are open technologies without locking you in as a customer for any company.

No, they are natural local monopolies. It takes explicit effort in policy making to avoid actual monopolies. The result is mixed: while it is possible to change your provider, it is much less convenient than changing the theatre you will go to next time. Switching costs aren't negligible. And in the US, I hear you have only two provider at any given place: the DSL provider, and the cable provider.

As you suggest, there is nothing wrong with Facebook wanting to monetize human interactions. The problem is how they do it. If they charged their user for the service, and didn't bother them with ads and constant spying, that would be fine. Heck, they could even prevent most spying and cut down the server costs by selling little servers you could plug into your home, have them talk peer-to-peer, and charge for updates or something.

But no, they had to violate our most intimate conversations constantly. Okay, maybe not the most intimate (those actually go through Gmail), but you get the idea. That is what's wrong with Facebook (and Google, and Apple…). Not charging for the service, but the hidden costs, the spying, and other totalitarian artefacts.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:44PM (#7492840)
No FB is exactly the same. They monetize interactions. So what kind of interactions will you be having with an OVR strapped to your face that they'll now be monetizing?

I upvoted you because I thought your comment didn't deserve the downvoting it was getting

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:06PM (#7492684)
How will you do a face to face interaction when you are both wearing VR goggles ?
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by corysama on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:28PM (#7492772)
You and I can be in different locations. But, with the goggles on, we can be face to face inside VR.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:04PM (#7493926)
Looking at some avatar that distinctly isn't you I presume?

Because a video (no matter how good) of you wearing a pair of displays on your face is decidedly not as good as just video chatting.

What specific experience is benefited by communicating in this way over just video or voice chat?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Sunday March 30, 2014 @06:44AM (#7495795)
It is ridiculous beyond belief, it's getting to Kurzweil levels of "woooo, the future"
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:54PM (#7496799)
Here's a reply to another thread.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7496786

TIL one of the buzzwords that makes people really lose grasp of reality is VR.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Sunday March 30, 2014 @02:45PM (#7497289)
That sums up my sentiments exactly.

But just to add, I've already owned a VR headset 20 years ago. Ok the screens were 320x240 but the resolution wasn't the downside, it was the neckache from wearing the damn things.

I've also got some NVidia 3d shutter glasses. You can play any OpenGL or DirectX game with them. They are great fun and really enhance a game. I've already played Everquest in 3D. (Although Dungeon Keeper 2 is my favourite, you can go into first person mode as a fly was wander round your dungeon - I've spent hours doing that).

3D porn is great also, I can recommend that.

I've not tried an Oculus but it looks like a neckache device to me.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Sunday March 30, 2014 @07:45PM (#7498506)
I'm not sure what it is about VR that short circuits people's brains and they lose all concept about how things still have to work in the physical world.

I mean, can you really see a fashion conscious teenager coming home to chat with their friends looking like this? http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/images/manampli...

There's lots of issues with VR, it's definitely got some cool potential, and I've seen some really nice applications of it over the years.

One of the problems I remember from the 90s was the disembodiment problem. You can't see where your hands and arms are (even if proprioception informs you where they should be). Some versions tried to map your virtual body to your real body, but it's never the same and the illusion breaks. Other cases just ignored it, but then you're left fumbling for control surfaces you can't see. It's an uncanny valley you can't overcome unless you track every part of every limb and map it to a realistic simulacrum in the virtual space.

Haptics and feedback then become the next problem and on and on and on, there's a very long stream of issues that need resolution before it comes close to what people think they are fantasizing about in their heads. 3d head tracking goggles are the simplest problem to solve in this equation.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Monday March 31, 2014 @03:38AM (#7500168)
The goggles I had were head tracking which I found worse than the shutter glasses for the reasons you allude to. In RL when I look to the left I don't just move my head, I move my body, chang emy feet, move the weight of myself around ready to act. I've now to move my control equipment to orientate myself ready for action. It just doesn't work.

It's why Wii games are not FPS shooters, they are stand and slash and they only have control to deal with.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:23PM (#7492987)
An incredible waste of effort and talent for gee-whiz nonsense.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by cookiecaper on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:04PM (#7492918)
Spot on. The problem is that it's very difficult to conceptualize a merger of the two companies' products that ISN'T really, really unpleasant. Most people are already tired of and/or annoyed with Facebook and having it strapped to your face and watching everything you do in a "virtual reality" is very offputting. Facebook is linked to publication and noise, and it creates an aura of intrusion. When you post on Facebook, you are performing for your hundreds of acquaintances and friends. People don't want to feel like they'll have to be doing that every time they use an Oculus product, let alone one so intimate that you literally strap it to your face. I know no one who sits back and thinks, "I need more Facebook in my life".

I don't know why they didn't see it coming, but almost anyone would've been less creepy than Facebook. People would have still have concerns, but I think they'd be more optimistic if it was Google or something.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by wiremine on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:00PM (#7492657)
> The reason people don't get this -- or at least, why I don't get it -- and thus responded negatively, is because VR should have nothing to do with Facebook's vision, and Facebook -- or social gaming in general -- should have nothing to do with Oculus' vision.

Honest question: why shouldn't VR be in Facebook's vision?

_Someone_ is going to create a Google Hangouts-style product that incorporates VR. I'm not excited that it is FB, per say, but I can see how a company built on social interactions is going to want a piece of that pie.

I get the frustration about the short-term impact on gaming, but I don't (yet?) understand why this is a bad move for VR in general...

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by potatolicious on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:16PM (#7492719)
There are IMO two angles to this that I identify with (to different degrees):

1 - People wanted Oculus to be a driving force in gaming, and based on recent post-acquisition statement it looks like the company is much more interested in the Metaverse than they are in gaming.

This is certainly a more ambitious goal and a harder problem overall to tackle than gaming, but a lot of Oculus fans don't give two hoots about the Metaverse and just want to fly airplanes, shoot monsters, explore dungeons, or what have you.

There is (IMO a justifiable) fear that the company is going to abandon, or at least scale back, their efforts in promoting Oculus for gaming, in favor of its own goals creating the Metaverse. Like you said, Google Hangouts in VR.

2 - People are excited that the Metaverse a la Snow Crash is actually going to happen, but do not believe Facebook to the be right people to bring this about. The reasoning for this varies, but mostly comes down to privacy protections, prevalence of advertising, and Facebook's seemingly infinite capacity for nickel and diming their users.

In this case people understand perfectly well why VR would be part of Facebook's vision - it just scares the bejeezus out of them.

The perceived bad move for VR in general is that Oculus is going to become a Facebook product, rather than a well-supported, well-evangelized platform on which a whole VR ecosystem can be built (i.e., the original vision). The chief fear is that eventually people are going to by the Oculus purely to access Facebook Presents the Metaverse instead of to access a wide ecosystem of VR products.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:40PM (#7493062)
Nevertheless, there will be competition.

Let's say your worst fears realize, and the Rift is a locked down Virtual Facebook Experience. Well, they still need to solve presence, and that means:

- Higher resolutions panels.

- Higher frequency panels.

- Low persistence panels.

- Ultra-high bandwidth, ultra-low latency video feeds (a better HDMI or something)

- Graphics processing from Moore's Rabbit Hole

- And lots of other thing that like the above, they won't develop in-house.

Once they have that, somebody will swoop in and create a "Trif" using the better, cheaper material than what the demand driven by the Evil Rift made possible. Remember, the Rift itself is possible because of Retina phone displays.

Or someone will jailbreak their Rift.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by jader201 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:20PM (#7492741)
> I get the frustration about the short-term impact on gaming, but I don't (yet?) understand why this is a bad move for VR in general...

That's just it. Fans of Oculus and the Rift were (mostly) interested in the gaming of VR. You have a point, that Facebook can certainly leverage VR to expand their product. But I think it's not in the direction previous/current fans (or even followers) of Oculus were/are interested in.

I'm not necessarily questioning whether this move is in the best interest of Facebook or Oculus. I think both companies will benefit from this long-term.

My point is that this isn't in the interest of the fans/followers of Oculus, and there's no explanation as to how Oculus would be surprised by the negative reaction of those outside the core community.

In fact, the only ones I can think of that would not react to this move negatively are fans of Facebook, and those invested in Facebook and Oculus.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by pfraze on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:02PM (#7492667)
It's not that VR shouldn't be in Facebook's vision. It's that Facebook's vision shouldn't be a primary player in VR.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by XorNot on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:48PM (#7493424)
Why?
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:37PM (#7494087)
Have you ever used Facebook?
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by teacup50 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:11PM (#7492699)
> _Someone_ is going to create a Google Hangouts-style product that incorporates VR.

Are they? Why is VR inevitable?

We already went through this once in the 90s, and the same truths are still true: nobody wants to put a face-covering headset just to communicate with other people.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by wiremine on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:27PM (#7492765)
> Why is VR inevitable?

Good point, I agree that I am making a big assumption.

That said, I don't think the argument that "it didn't work before" is valid. I don't think people want face-covering headsets that _suck_.

If I can wear an _awesome_ headset and have a virtual conversation with my family across the country, I'd purchase one in a heartbeat.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:44PM (#7494121)
Who would you be conversing with? A video of your family with screens attached to their faces or some avatars representing your family members? I don't understand why so many people have trouble understanding that you can't see the faces of people who have something blocking their faces.

So if it's avatars, what are those avatars going to be? Some off the shelf selection of Mii/Second Life/WoW avatars?

But you'll say "modern technology can provide avatars that are very realistic simulacrums of actual people!"

and I say, who will build those models? Now people have to buy high-res 3d scanners for their home as well? Or spend loads of money on modeling teams to build these avatars? Or go to Facebook centers where people get their faces scanned and avatars built?

And the rift doesn't yet even support facial expression mapping.

How do you think this is going to work?

You think people lose their shit over privacy issues now? Wait until Facebook has a sub-mm accurate 3d model of every person's face!

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nknighthb on Sunday March 30, 2014 @02:17AM (#7495405)
You are experiencing a fundamental failure of imagination. VR goggles do not necessarily have to remain large, face-blocking objects forever, nor do high-resolution 3D scanners have to remain large, expensive items.

Other people are thinking about the future. You are stuck in the present.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Sunday March 30, 2014 @02:25AM (#7495412)
So your premise is that something you need to put in front of your eyes to see, won't be in front of your eyes at some point imaginary point in the future, and it doesn't matter if they are blocking your face because 3d face scanners, for which people will use them approximately once, will also become so cheap that people won't mind buying them in some imaginary point in the future.

Okay. Sure. I can't argue against arbitrary hypotheticals composed of arbitrarily defined technological sophistication measured against some indefinite point in the future with an unspecified price point that will always fit the future you happen to want.

Just like when I was six, and my friend kept changing the rules of the game we were playing so he always won, you got me.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nknighthb on Sunday March 30, 2014 @02:59AM (#7495471)
I have many possible answers to your statements, such as an observation that we already have head-mounted displays that do not block faces, or that real-time 3d face scanning is a potential advancement, but you're such a depressingly cynical person to try and converse with, I don't know why I'd bother.

Your statement about when you were six is unwittingly apt. Such a concern with "rules" rather than nuance and discourse is befitting of a six year old, not the adult I optimistically presumed you to be.

I suppose this was inexcusably optimistic, given that I'd already read your statement that you would, seemingly regardless of circumstance, take a $2 billion offer and "retire to Malta", and feel no remorse for what effect that might have on anyone else.

Your worldview is sad. Sufficiently so that you have literally ruined my day. It's hard to forget having encountered such cynicism and conscious disdain for the possibilities open to us through technological and social advancement.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:51PM (#7496786)
Sorry I didn't realize I was talking to somebody with a completely made up and fantastical worldview, where hard problems are instantly solvable with fairy dust and dream juice.

No wonder you feel like you can invent any future you wish whole cloth and in just a couple years, reality will bend to your will and products will appear on the market that bring your future to life at a price so cheap as to basically be commodities.

If thinking about how things work in the real world, identifying the problems and doing the hard grunt work to solve them is cynicism, I want some of what you're smoking. Because nothing happens as easy or as quick as you optimistically imply.

You've probably never brought a product to market, even one with zero R&D cost. Gone from idea to box on store shelves. It's hard. A few words of pithy advice and hard wishing don't cut it.

If it did we'd have hard-AI, FTL, jetpacks, and would live full-time in the metaverse from our isolation tanks on an orbital platform around Venus or Proxima Centauri fed only by our immersion in a pool of reconfigurable nanoparticle nutrients. We'd live lives as long as we care to in a post-monetary society.

We've been doing VR for the better part of 30 years and still barely understand the interaction models. I've used state-of-the-art haptic feedback systems intended for VR that are so new that there haven't even been articles written about them. They're the result of a hundred million dollars of nation state level R&D by teams of PhD researchers and they're still impossibly crude approximations of what real-life interaction feels like. The time-to-market on just this kind of device is expected to be 30 years at best. The expected cost in 2013 dollars when that happens is $150k-200k per limb.

Things have to be possible on the technology curve we're already on and have to respect physics. You can't waive your hands and insist that in your fantasy world it should just be possible. They have to be something that can be taken from nascent R&D to market at a cost consumers can actually buy. More importantly they have to be useful, non-fatiguing interfaces that don't take up half of somebody's living room. Most importantly, they have to be socially acceptable enough that the majority of the population won't feel weird participating.

Even the smallest of practical concerns, like will the headset smudge a woman's makeup can make or break something. Sweeping social change, where everybody on the planet suddenly stops what they've been doing for a lifetime (or in a larger context for thousands of years in their culture) and suddenly adapts to whatever fantasy product you've placed out are among the hardest things to push forward. Look at the near panic about somebody walking around with a near invisible screen on their face and a single low-resolution camera -- Google glass.

> such as an observation that we already have head-mounted displays that do not block faces

Like what, Glass? It also doesn't provide the necessary optics via physics to provide VR. If what you're talking about are two Glass-like displays, positioned like Glass, no matter the resolution or latency, you are no loner talking about VR and we're in a different discussion.

Here's a even did a mockup for you http://i.imgur.com/njToujz.jpg

Glass isn't even capable of AR, let alone stereoscopic VR. So let's shift the displays down a couple inches. Then what's the point? I may as well just be looking at a 3d monitor. This buys me nothing and doesn't buy me convenience. You won't be walking around with this gear on, there's no camera to shoot your face and nobody wants to talk around with a quad copter taking video all day. And then you're literally obscuring your face because the displays are literally in front of your eyes. Physics is a ruleset we can't wave our hands at and get around.

> or that real-time 3d face scanning is a potential advancement

There's only two possible interaction models for the kind of virtual communication, the glass one which is trivial to demonstrate isn't a good model and the fully VR model which then requires you to be modeled and your conversation partner to be modeled to you each have something to look at. Presumably people will want to use their actual faces and a static model isn't very interesting to talk to. So you either need a model that's fully rigged and a device to recognize your expressions and translate them into controls for the rig.

https://cdn.tutsplus.com/ae/uploads/legacy/637_vfx/AvatarFac...

http://metalarcade.net/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Resident-E...

Which we already do have, but it kind of sucks for any kind of general use.

Let's pretend for a minute that you don't have to markup somebody's face with dots to track, and some kind of near-term kinect-like system solves this.

Is this your vision of what people will be walking around with on their head? Except with two Google glass-like displays in front of their eyes?

Here's I did another mockup of your vision. Sorry for the shitty photoshop skills.

http://i.imgur.com/BaPV2Va.jpg

Is this really better than just video conferencing? Do I get anything out of this at all?

You can call me a cynic, and sorry if I killed your fantasy buzz, but not a single thing I've said here or before isn't true. Today or tomorrow.

Yeah sure, I read Snow Crash and got into the notion of the Metaverse. I think it's cool. I'm on board with the idea in principle. I'm just as upset as the next guy that the closest we've gotten to that vision is Second Life, EVE or WoW. It feels really close, but there are lots of gotchas that need lots of work to get past. Fantasy speculation isn't going to cut it.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nknighthb on Sunday March 30, 2014 @08:00PM (#7498567)
Once again, your cynical rant focuses entirely on the present state of COTS technology with no allowance for advancement.

Your assumption about me, by the way, is entirely wrong. If you've brought a product to market, I'm sorry the experience turned you into a cynical curmudgeon. It only turned me into someone who had accomplished something hard. Things being hard is not a reason not to do them, a reason to act as if others won't do them, or to fail to look around and notice the advancements occurring all around us.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Sunday March 30, 2014 @08:47PM (#7498782)
My impression of you is that the letters "VR" have short circuited your brian and caused you to forget that things have to still fit within the constraints of physics. Today, or with any possible future advancement. Hand waiving and "advancement" won't ever surmount these constraints. Building towards a future that can't ever happen is not a useful thing to do.

Things being hard are not a reason not to do things, things being stupid or impossible are.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nknighthb on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:02PM (#7499323)
The letters "VR" aren't even relevant to a belief that two-way 3D video chat is practical today, and will become more practical in the future.

You've bound yourself by artificial limitations on your thought process. Please do not act as if people who do not share those boundaries must be idiots.

Edit: By the way, since you brought it up, I've never read Snow Crash. I really don't know anything about it other than a brief synopsis I read at some point years ago. It's unwise to assume anything about my opinions comes from pop culture, as I'm largely disconnected from it.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:31AM (#7499639)
Draw a diagram of how you think it will work.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nknighthb on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:38AM (#7499839)
How I think what will work? 3D video chat? You need a diagram for two cameras, a 3D monitor, and ordinary 3D glasses?

Or did you mean something else? Perhaps something you've been assuming I'm talking about because your response to abstract notions is hostility and arrogance, rather than a search for common ground and understanding? Perhaps you've assumed all this time that I've been saying a specific product, the Rift, could be used for face-to-face interaction, because you didn't ask, but instead called me a six-year-old idiot?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @12:34AM (#7506199)
And now you have changed the rules again. Don't pretend like you're looking for common ground when you keep changing the fundamentals of the discussion.

The discussion is, oculus rift, 3d chat. Diagram it.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by nknighthb on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @02:13AM (#7506457)
That may be what you want the discussion to be, because then you "win" according to some "rules" you wish existed, but it's not. Or wasn't, rather. The discussion is long over. It was over the moment you decided to be a dick.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:58AM (#7515521)
So no then. You can't. Because it doesn't make any sense and it's a bad idea. I'm sorry you had to be the person who had the idea and I'm sorry I had to be the person to call you on it.

Okay, to be honest, everybody has this idea about VR. In your mind you see a glorious 3d representation of person you are chatting with, if your imagination is powerful enough, you can even feel the frame of the headset on your face and the wash of the display glow against the contours of your nose. But everybody who ever thinks about this idea, and is in a position to try and do it, runs into the same fundamental problem. Because in their imagination and their dreams, they're never in the place of the person they're chatting with, to see what they're seeing and they never realize that what the other person must see is them with a headset on...and then they realize the person they first saw in their dreams must have one on as well and the entire illusion shatters. You can't achieve the kind of telepresence we all wish for today or anytime in the near future.

I know you're struggling with accepting this scenario, but I've watched this same scenario play out for 30 years. There's nothing new about the Rift except it's consumer cheap. I've personally used systems better than the Rift and the moment you get the headset on, you realize VR telepresence, via video, won't ever work.

Nobody wants to have that kind of chat experience, so the only other possible mode is to do it with avatars.

Guess what, that's what's currently being done.

https://developer.oculusvr.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=5...

http://www.worlds.com/index2.html

https://www.activeworlds.com/index.html

http://someyworks.com/vc/vc.html

http://www.vr-fun.net/

The experience is obviously not what you or I are talking about though, even the first link which actually uses a VR headset (the Rift). But there's a very long list of well known issues to surmount that haven't been solved yet for very good reasons. No amount of "let's suppose that..." will make some of those very hard things a reality. At least not with the goal of something the general public will accept in enough volume to make it worthwhile.

Sorry to be a dick, but there really are unworkable ideas. You're a consultant, you know that you sometimes have to break bad news to the people you work for when they simply can't do something because it's not possible. You might come across as an asshole when you do, and people's feelings might get hurt, but somebody has to break the bad news.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by sizzle on Sunday March 30, 2014 @05:15AM (#7495650)
well said, you have a way with words.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by threeseed on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:42PM (#7492827)
You could say the same thing about computers.

Nobody wants to sit in front of a screen just to communicate with other people. Yet billions of people do.

Up until now the technology simply hasn't been good enough to address the "presence" issue.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by honestcoyote on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:37PM (#7493360)
Sitting in front of a screen doesn't completely block your vision. I think there will be a certain level of discomfort, no matter how lightweight the goggles, at being completely blind to your surroundings. I have no idea if this will prevent mainstream acceptance of the technology, but I think it will have a serious effect.

Maybe the next generation of this tech will find a way to preserve peripheral vision, and/or provide some pass-through motion detection, while still remaining immersive.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:07PM (#7493938)
There's no reason. The problem with the acquisition is that FB could have been just one virtual experience among thousands for OVR, now it's likely to be the only one.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by samstave on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:56AM (#7492635)
If FB wanted anyone to believe they had some mighty vision in social gaming, then why didn't they buy out Zynga or other game companies like that that actually had massive userbase on their actual platform.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by kyleblarson on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:43AM (#7492579)
It's easy to take the moral high ground when you don't have a three comma offer sitting on the table in front of you.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by jader201 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:20PM (#7492975)
The point isn't that they made a bad/immoral decision.

The point is that they say this:

> Beyond our core community, we expected it would be positive.

Oculus are brilliant people -- how could they expect this would be received positively, even by those "beyond our core community"?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by adestefan on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:13PM (#7492712)
I'd sell out in a heart beat. However, I also wouldn't be shocked at the outrage.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by sirkneeland on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:18PM (#7492724)
Same. And I also would go do an interview claiming that I was.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by teacup50 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:12PM (#7492707)
"Greed is good"?

That isn't an argument for the moral low ground. It wasn't like the alternative was "or you get nothing".

The alternative was "or you get to pursue the vision you built the company on and potentially have a few more commas in front of you".