News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by Geee on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:12AM (#7492475)
Don't you see it? Facebook can't currently monetize face-to-face interactions, but in virtual reality they can.

The purchase makes a lot of sense for Facebook. Facebook's business model is to monetize human interactions. Today, most of human interaction happens over the Internet (with messages and images), and in the future, it will happen in virtual environments. VR will be the ultimate platform, and Facebook wants to own that platform.

Virtual reality is not about gaming. Would you describe Matrix as a game? Facebook's wants to put everyone in the Matrix, so they can monetize us.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by dragontamer on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:16AM (#7492496)
This is what people fear from Facebook.

Selling out to Microsoft or Sony would have been "monetize by making awesome games". Selling out to Facebook means virtual reality ads will penetrate everywhere you walk.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by freshyill on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:26PM (#7493284)
Just like on Instagram! Wait.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by danabramov on Saturday March 29, 2014 @11:45AM (#7492589)
Do you seriously believe this? Then there will be competitors without ads.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by Geee on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:05PM (#7492676)
You can't compete with 'without ads' business model. Look around: Google search, Youtube, Facebook etc. They all had first mover advantage and there's no way someone can compete with these. These services (and companies) operate around the idea of giving away free candy and locking everyone in with network effects. This is what will happen to VR as well under Facebook's control.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by Turing_Machine on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:39PM (#7492817)
"Look around: Google search, Youtube, Facebook etc. They all had first mover advantage and there's no way someone can compete with these."

They did? What about Yahoo, Alta Vista, WebCrawler, MySpace, Friendster...?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by evan_ on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:17PM (#7492722)
Maybe it's harder to be #1 without being free but there are many video sites competing with YouTube that do pretty well. Vimeo, Netflix, Amazon Instant Video, etc- they're not FREE but they're still very popular. There's no reason to believe that Facebook's VR network will be the only one.

Also, none of the products you listed had first mover advantage. They're all excellent examples of things that upset a formerly dominant major player.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by rayiner on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:23PM (#7492751)
For movie distribution, network lock in doesn't matter so much. But for video sharing they do, and for VR they really will. Competing with Netflix is a lot easier than competing with Facebook or YouTube for that reason.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:23PM (#7492753)
> You can't compete with 'without ads' business model. Look around: Google search, Youtube, Facebook etc. They all had first mover advantage and there's no way someone can compete with these.

Nonsense, there are dozens of very expensive data providers and search companies out there who do very well for themselves thank you very much.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:28PM (#7493008)
Could you name three? (I fully expect that you can, but it'll make your argument that much more convincing).

Of the top of my head, I think of DuckDuckGo, which does not spy, but it still have ads.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:50PM (#7493110)
LexisNexis

VersusLaw

various legal, bio, tech, IP, etc. sites.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:33PM (#7494075)
doesn't let me edit, but Merck also has an entire slew of searchable information as does places like Bloomberg or other financial data companies.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by dragontamer on Sunday March 30, 2014 @11:21AM (#7496394)
And therefore, Oculus Rift has "sold out".

We are now looking for more legitimate competitors, and are pissed off at the Oculus.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by randunel on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:12PM (#7492705)
There are ad-less video sharing websites, yet youtube is #1. Same will happen with Oculus, targeted ads in vr.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by superuser2 on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:27PM (#7492763)
Other businesses that are about monetizing human interaction: telephony (pay us to talk to people), restaurants (pay us for a venue to have a conversation/date, show off your wealth), clothing (pay us to increase your apparent status/attractiveness), theater and movies (pay us to have an activity with your friends/date), beyond-low-end housing (pay us so you can entertain and impress and be in a city with lots of humans to interact with).

You say this like it's a dirty, disgusting thing to do, but is Facebook really that different from all of these industries in terms of wanting to monetize human interaction?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by freshhawk on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:05PM (#7492926)
All your examples are charging the user for facilitating interaction rather than monetizing on information gleaned from surveilling the interaction. That's a substantial difference.

I would say that the walled garden aspect also makes it pretty substantially different from those industries. I think we all agree that if there was only one restaurant chain or one movie theatre chain it would be a pretty awful experience in comparison to our current reality. It would make financial sense to degrade the experience quite a bit for a relatively small increase in profit per customer. In telephony this experiment was already run and the answer was, yes, it was substantially worse.

So yes, Facebook really is that different from your example industries.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by silentOpen on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:08PM (#7492937)
Yes. With the exception of telephony, each of those industries also delivers material/entertainment/comfort value. Telephony is just voice communication and benefits from a network effect and natural monopoly. Facebook has a far more sophisticated model of communication but is most similar to telephony.

The difference between Facebook and telephony is striking. You pay for a telephone connection. Other people pay for your Facebook experience to be mediated to their wishes. Telephony is p2p and we typically frown on operator intervention and worry about excessive centralization. Facebook could be p2p but is centralized and has heavy operator intervention.

Offering communications services for free and then attempting to 'monetize' the interactions that you mediate is distasteful.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by Geee on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:00PM (#7492895)
There's the obvious difference that there's no platform lock-in with these, and therefore there's choice and competition. Telephony, Internet, are open technologies without locking you in as a customer for any company.

Think back when we lived in caves. We shared stories, we shared cave paintings, we shared music by singing together, we had fun together, we explored and shared our curiosity, we created new things together. Most technology today is still just tools to do these same fundamental things, but in novel ways. Facebook wants to be the middleman in this. They didn't invent 'social', they brought it into digital world, they want to own it, and they want to monetize it.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by loup-vaillant on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:24PM (#7492995)
> Telephony, Internet, are open technologies without locking you in as a customer for any company.

No, they are natural local monopolies. It takes explicit effort in policy making to avoid actual monopolies. The result is mixed: while it is possible to change your provider, it is much less convenient than changing the theatre you will go to next time. Switching costs aren't negligible. And in the US, I hear you have only two provider at any given place: the DSL provider, and the cable provider.

As you suggest, there is nothing wrong with Facebook wanting to monetize human interactions. The problem is how they do it. If they charged their user for the service, and didn't bother them with ads and constant spying, that would be fine. Heck, they could even prevent most spying and cut down the server costs by selling little servers you could plug into your home, have them talk peer-to-peer, and charge for updates or something.

But no, they had to violate our most intimate conversations constantly. Okay, maybe not the most intimate (those actually go through Gmail), but you get the idea. That is what's wrong with Facebook (and Google, and Apple…). Not charging for the service, but the hidden costs, the spying, and other totalitarian artefacts.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:44PM (#7492840)
No FB is exactly the same. They monetize interactions. So what kind of interactions will you be having with an OVR strapped to your face that they'll now be monetizing?

I upvoted you because I thought your comment didn't deserve the downvoting it was getting

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:06PM (#7492684)
How will you do a face to face interaction when you are both wearing VR goggles ?
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by corysama on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:28PM (#7492772)
You and I can be in different locations. But, with the goggles on, we can be face to face inside VR.
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Saturday March 29, 2014 @05:04PM (#7493926)
Looking at some avatar that distinctly isn't you I presume?

Because a video (no matter how good) of you wearing a pair of displays on your face is decidedly not as good as just video chatting.

What specific experience is benefited by communicating in this way over just video or voice chat?

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Sunday March 30, 2014 @06:44AM (#7495795)
It is ridiculous beyond belief, it's getting to Kurzweil levels of "woooo, the future"
Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Sunday March 30, 2014 @12:54PM (#7496799)
Here's a reply to another thread.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7496786

TIL one of the buzzwords that makes people really lose grasp of reality is VR.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Sunday March 30, 2014 @02:45PM (#7497289)
That sums up my sentiments exactly.

But just to add, I've already owned a VR headset 20 years ago. Ok the screens were 320x240 but the resolution wasn't the downside, it was the neckache from wearing the damn things.

I've also got some NVidia 3d shutter glasses. You can play any OpenGL or DirectX game with them. They are great fun and really enhance a game. I've already played Everquest in 3D. (Although Dungeon Keeper 2 is my favourite, you can go into first person mode as a fly was wander round your dungeon - I've spent hours doing that).

3D porn is great also, I can recommend that.

I've not tried an Oculus but it looks like a neckache device to me.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by bane on Sunday March 30, 2014 @07:45PM (#7498506)
I'm not sure what it is about VR that short circuits people's brains and they lose all concept about how things still have to work in the physical world.

I mean, can you really see a fashion conscious teenager coming home to chat with their friends looking like this? http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/images/manampli...

There's lots of issues with VR, it's definitely got some cool potential, and I've seen some really nice applications of it over the years.

One of the problems I remember from the 90s was the disembodiment problem. You can't see where your hands and arms are (even if proprioception informs you where they should be). Some versions tried to map your virtual body to your real body, but it's never the same and the illusion breaks. Other cases just ignored it, but then you're left fumbling for control surfaces you can't see. It's an uncanny valley you can't overcome unless you track every part of every limb and map it to a realistic simulacrum in the virtual space.

Haptics and feedback then become the next problem and on and on and on, there's a very long stream of issues that need resolution before it comes close to what people think they are fantasizing about in their heads. 3d head tracking goggles are the simplest problem to solve in this equation.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Monday March 31, 2014 @03:38AM (#7500168)
The goggles I had were head tracking which I found worse than the shutter glasses for the reasons you allude to. In RL when I look to the left I don't just move my head, I move my body, chang emy feet, move the weight of myself around ready to act. I've now to move my control equipment to orientate myself ready for action. It just doesn't work.

It's why Wii games are not FPS shooters, they are stand and slash and they only have control to deal with.

Re:Oculus Says They Didn't Expect Such Negative Reactions to... by SixSigma on Saturday March 29, 2014 @01:23PM (#7492987)
An incredible waste of effort and talent for gee-whiz nonsense.