News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by 1stop on Friday March 28, 2014 @04:48AM (#7485986)
Sorry but screen width is a pretty dumb reason to drop a rich experience on larger screens.

It's just another media query.

Why can't 27 inch/high res/super duper screens get the awesome layout, and shitty "poor people" screens get the shitty layout?

Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by ntaso on Friday March 28, 2014 @04:52AM (#7485995)
But an inconsistent experience, if the page looks vastly different for some people than for others.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by danabramov on Friday March 28, 2014 @05:58AM (#7486198)
I don't get why you're downvoted.

Toggling between two completely different newsfeeds based on screen size is not responsive—it's inconsistent.

If you don't agree, check out how different the old and the new feed are.

Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by madeofpalk on Friday March 28, 2014 @07:39AM (#7486532)
what if... there's a middle ground?

If facebook was set on using media queries, im sure they would have kept the same general design but just optimised layout and spacing for different screen sizes.

Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by d23 on Friday March 28, 2014 @09:42AM (#7487122)
You guys are going down a pointless path of pedantry. The original attack suggested Facebook's sole reason for making the decision was advertising metrics. This person is saying that isn't true. I'm guessing the team running one of the top trafficked sites in the world is aware of media queries.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by madeofpalk on Friday March 28, 2014 @07:24PM (#7490604)
Yeah that was kind of my point... I got sucked in.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by 1stop on Friday March 28, 2014 @04:55AM (#7486005)
It doesn't have to look vastly different, it just has to look 'designed' for each screen size. This isn't a difficult problem... I'm wondering if responsive web design is a foreign concept within facebook. :\
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by spazmaster on Friday March 28, 2014 @05:09AM (#7486042)
Facebook.com isn't responsive (you'll see fixed width's, just check it out), so it does seem that responsive design is something they disregard purposefully.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by joshfraser on Saturday March 29, 2014 @12:44AM (#7491444)
Facebook cares too much about their performance to use responsive design.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by cliveowen on Friday March 28, 2014 @06:57AM (#7486386)
People are used to different experiences on different devices. You can argue that they expect mobile and desktop versions to differ, but I can also argue that a 10-inch netbook is a very different device from a Retina MacBook.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by makomk on Friday March 28, 2014 @10:29AM (#7487451)
Facebook already has an inconsistent experience. For instance, I've been viewing Facebook with this new design for a few days now, whereas other people are presumably still on the old one.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by jamesie on Friday March 28, 2014 @06:39PM (#7490408)
This is mostly a function of ramping up to Facebook scale and is a temporary inconsistency.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by calinet6 on Friday March 28, 2014 @07:53AM (#7486573)
As a UX designer, there are all kinds of reasons the design could have been unsuccessful, on small screens or just in general.

Media queries don't fix everything.

Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by 1stop on Friday March 28, 2014 @08:19AM (#7486688)
I'm sorry, but they fix EXACTLY that problem. If you need a UI to work at different sizes... that is what media queries are for.

The design can change quite drastically using media queries. I can look at facebook for about 2 minutes to see how they could improve at different sizes.

Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by calinet6 on Friday March 28, 2014 @08:35AM (#7486767)
They fix exactly what problem? The single problem of the sizing of components on the screen? Great!

I did not mention one problem—I alluded to many. What about the problem of people not clicking links? What about the problem of users not understanding how to navigate to events? How about lack of awareness of which of your friends are online? Etc. etc.

Media queries fix exactly one problem. The size and position of elements on different sized screens.

There are thousands of other things to evaluate in a design that have nothing to do with that. I realize you're focused on this specific issue, but Facebook has to worry about all of them at once.

Media queries don't fix everything.

Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by 1stop on Saturday March 29, 2014 @02:04AM (#7491586)
They could do both (like every other competent UX team does).

All of those problems are still their, I was responding to the point made in the post, that they couldn't ship the awesome design, because there are people with little screens... That is what responsive is for, meaning they could have shipped exactly what they shipped PLUS the awesome design (that they themselves, said was awesome).

So yes, media queries fix exactly their problem, as they had two designs that they liked, but one was only good for big screens, the other for little screens.

To put it more bluntly they had already solved all the other issues (and more) you talked about... just the screen size was the only problem (cited in that post!)

Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by witty_username on Friday March 28, 2014 @11:46AM (#7487922)
> shitty "poor people" You've offended billions.
Re:Whatever’s Best For The People, That’s What We Do by jacalata on Friday March 28, 2014 @08:39PM (#7490898)
in case you are serious: the full quote was 'shitty "poor people" screens' which parses not to 'shitty poor people' but to 'shitty screens for poor people' and is not really offensive.