I'm not going to get all conspiratorial on you, but to pretend like someone blogging on the Internet is being completely candid about their work? C'mon.
It's just another media query.
Why can't 27 inch/high res/super duper screens get the awesome layout, and shitty "poor people" screens get the shitty layout?
Toggling between two completely different newsfeeds based on screen size is not responsive—it's inconsistent.
If you don't agree, check out how different the old and the new feed are.
If facebook was set on using media queries, im sure they would have kept the same general design but just optimised layout and spacing for different screen sizes.
Media queries don't fix everything.
The design can change quite drastically using media queries. I can look at facebook for about 2 minutes to see how they could improve at different sizes.
I did not mention one problem—I alluded to many. What about the problem of people not clicking links? What about the problem of users not understanding how to navigate to events? How about lack of awareness of which of your friends are online? Etc. etc.
Media queries fix exactly one problem. The size and position of elements on different sized screens.
There are thousands of other things to evaluate in a design that have nothing to do with that. I realize you're focused on this specific issue, but Facebook has to worry about all of them at once.
Media queries don't fix everything.
All of those problems are still their, I was responding to the point made in the post, that they couldn't ship the awesome design, because there are people with little screens... That is what responsive is for, meaning they could have shipped exactly what they shipped PLUS the awesome design (that they themselves, said was awesome).
So yes, media queries fix exactly their problem, as they had two designs that they liked, but one was only good for big screens, the other for little screens.
To put it more bluntly they had already solved all the other issues (and more) you talked about... just the screen size was the only problem (cited in that post!)
How do you know? She's a director, and by definition totally in bed with the leadership. Would she publicly admit to decisions made in favor of ad revenue and against what's best for the user? Why didn't she, as Product Design Director, or anyone else at Facebook argue for defaulting to stronger rather than weaker privacy settings, or object to the undermining or even ignoring of previously made privacy choices under the guise of new feature releases? And if she or anyone did, and they were shot down, would she tell us?
So many people trusted Colin Powell, including much of the world after his U.N. testimony. Look where that got us. (What Colin Powell Knew and What He Said: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jonathan-schwarz/colin-powell-...) [And no, waterlesscloud, I'm not comparing "the design of the Facebook newsfeed to the Iraq War," I'm making a point about trusting people with a conflict of interest and/or loyal to the party under question.]
Dial it down a bit, please.
This is what's wrong with society today. Assumptions that are both wrong and sexist. Good job sir.
However it is a really unfortunate phrase to use where the group is mixed gender. Especially so when it's an imbalanced mix, such as very few women.
(I think everyone should get a small stack of "Yikes did I really say that?" chips. Only after someone runs out of their chips should we bring out the pitchforks and enjoy ourselves a nice cathartic public shaming spree.)
low end Android and Nokia handsets cost less than the cheapest PCs and Laptops.
Is it a org-wide policy at Facebook that the relevant product / operations head respond to criticism leveled at Facebook in private forums?
Are employees required to proactively defend their decisions, on private / public forums?
Is this the raison d'être for PMs at Facebook?
The reason I'm curious is that I have never seen a Facebook employee ever admit a flub here on HN. They mostly surface here to reaffirm the company position.
I don't know if the employees realize it or not but for the most part, this kind of spineless defending - and I have observed it on more than one occasion - appears to outsiders as virtue-less boot-licking.
I hope that the Facebook employees know that they are allowed to have differing and contrasting opinions.
Just because their founder doles out hundreds of millions of dollars to nameless causes and charities with unaccountable outcomes, does not mean that his every strategic move is unimpeachably virtuous, made with the best intentions of the user-base in mind.
Forsaking their reputation to salvage their founder's self-serving acquisitions might seem great now.
But these kinds of self-inflicted character-assassinations are bound to haunt the careers of the employees, in the long run.
I would advise Ms.Zhuo to think twice before coming to the defense of her founder especially in such nakedly crony-corporate-land-grab decisions, especially when she knows full well this kind of thing is indefensible and not in the interest of the public.
Also, Dustin Curtis seems to forget (or not understand) that Facebook is the same company that made a decision to implement AJAX at the expense of pageviews, at a time when that decision was highly controversial (the era of the Empire of MySpace). You can ding the management at Facebook for a lot of things, but this really isn't one of them.
The bigger story, really, is that poor people use Facebook on a computer, and thus that is where web-based experience optimization is focused. If you don't have a smartphone, or your smartphone sucks, you're going to be on the web; otherwise, why aren't you using your iPhone or iPad? (And remember, that's where Facebook derives a majority of their revenue -- so if there's going to be a conspiracy, it's going to be a conspiracy to get you to stop using the website, and to buy a high-ad-revenue-generating iPhone). Welcome to the wacky user landscape of 2014, where the Web is for nerds and poor people.
I like that Julie used Medium for her thoughts, rather than a Facebook post. Experimentation with others' products and services is super cool.