News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by jcampbell1 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @02:37PM (#7467838)
It seems there are hypothetical scenarios where your taxes could exceed your net worth. If you mine a bitcoin worth $1000, and then it's value falls to $100, you could owe taxes on $1000, and the $900 capital loss would only carry forward to the next year.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by slg on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @02:53PM (#7468002)
You can use the $900 in capital losses to offset your income (up to $3000). According to the IRS, you would have only $100 in income ($1000 - $900). So in your example, you would have $100 cash and tax liabilities on $100 in income. You will only run into a problem when you exceed $3000 in capital losses, that is when you would have to rollover your losses to the next year.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by humanrebar on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:13PM (#7468188)
Still seems like a problem to me.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by slg on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:25PM (#7468285)
How so? These aren't new rules, just old rules that are newly applied to Bitcoin. As others have noted, this is how things work for employer issued stock. You only put yourself in danger if you are ignorant of the rules and don't take necessary precautions. If you are investing enough to open yourself up to a capital gains loss of more than $3000, you have no excuse to be ignorant.

Tax tip from a non-lawyer/non-accountant - Immediately sell a percentage of your newly mined bitcoin equal to your marginal tax rate. If your tax rate is 25%, sell 25% of your bitcoin as soon as it is mined. Those coins already belong to the US government. If you don't convert to cash immediately, you are basically leveraging the government's money to invest in Bitcoin speculation.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by humanrebar on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:41PM (#7468393)
> If you are investing enough to open yourself up to a capital gains loss of more than $3000, you have no excuse to be ignorant.

I disagree wholeheartedly. The tax code is needlessly complex. These are not laws of nature, they are arbitrary rules that have accumulated over time. Large capital gains happen naturally and it's silly for there to be gotchas like this.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by dasil003 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:00PM (#7468533)
When it comes to the IRS the prudent thing is to treat them as a force of nature.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by Tloewald on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @06:07PM (#7469497)
...so avoid them and move as far away as possible?
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by SilasX on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:32PM (#7468330)
The fact that "it's always been that way" is no refutation of the fact that "it's a problem" that you could lose money and yet still owe taxes as if you had gains because capital losses (hysteretically) saturate at $3000.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by jrockway on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:40PM (#7468799)
It's not a problem if you immediately sell a portion of the coin to cover your tax liability. This is how employer stock programs work; when shares vest, some are immediately sold to cover the income tax. Then, if the shares decrease in value and are sold, you have a normal capital loss to deduct. If they increase in value and are sold, you have normal capital gains.

This is money, not "do whatever you want".

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by molsongolden on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:09PM (#7468972)
It doesn't seem fair or correct to compare Bitcoin to employer stock programs. The IRS seems to be doing this as well. Stock and stock options are generally granted in exchange for work performed for an employer so you have earned those amounts but Bitcoins are created through mining not given by an employer.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by jrockway on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @06:05PM (#7469483)
I agree with you completely.

That said, it doesn't matter what is and is not "fair" when dealing with the IRS. Choice A is to do what they tell you to do. Choice B is to fight them in court.

This thread assumes you want to go with Choice A and that you want to limit your liability if something goes wrong. Like most risk-management techniques, it does decrease your returns.

(Tax lawyers might have some better advice. Perhaps you can mine into a blind trust, and pay income taxes in 5 years on the current value of the coins? Dunno, not a tax expert or a laywer. I would consult with one if I was mining a lot of Bitcoin.)

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by derekp7 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @08:43PM (#7470624)
So here's a question for everyone -- if I take a few hunks of wood, say worth 10 bucks, and use it to craft a musical instrument that can be sold for $100, does that count as $90 in income, even if I just leave it on a shelf?
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by molsongolden on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @09:42PM (#7470946)
Not at all. That is the way I was seeing it but gamblor956 explained the reasoning behind the IRS guidance in a response to one of my comments below:

"Bitcoins earned through mining are considered compensation for providing resources to the Bitcoin network to compute hashes verifying transactions."

When viewed as compensation then the treatment seems consistent with NSOs or barter transactions.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:16PM (#7469022)
This would be a problem if bitcoins were illiquid. They are not, so it's easily solved. The IRS simple rule is to treat all income as incurring tax on the moment it is received.

They make allowances for things that are not liquid.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by adventured on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:10PM (#7468606)
Capital gains (the losses) don't saturate at $3,000.

If I have accumulated $100,000 in capital losses over the prior ten years, I can wipe all of that out in one shot by producing a large enough capital gain in one year.

Capital losses saturate when applied to ordinary income.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by arg01 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @08:51PM (#7470688)
Is this a problem for anyone with money in MTGox?

i.e. would sales inside MTGox have counted towards this tax or isn't only with withdrawl/deposit into their ecosystem. I can imagine that if internal to MTGox interactions are treated this way then there are a lot of people who sustained a capital loss higher than that and had no option to withdrawl the money to pay taxes.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by RyJones on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @02:41PM (#7467877)
This is pretty much what happened to a lot of people in the valley during the dot-com bubble pop - your stock losses could be carried forward until the heat death of the universe, but you paid on 100% of the (illusory) gains.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @02:59PM (#7468059)
Mostly this happened to people that got bad advice (I really hope all of the entrepreneurs reading this site are smarter now).

For most, the issue was exercising their options. This is a tax event -- and the tax is owed on the difference in your strike price and the current price of the stock. If you find yourself in this situation -- immediately sell enough stock to cover the tax.

If you are given stock -- that is the tax event. You need to have enough cash to cover taxes on stock given to you -- if the stock is illiquid, and this is a bonus or something, then you should ask for part of the bonus to be in cash (to cover tax). If the stock is liquid, immediately sell enough to cover tax.

If you are a founder, and your stock just goes up in price, that is not a tax event.

Being given at-the-money options is not a tax event. You only owe <s>stock</s> tax once you exercise.

IANAA (not an accountant)

EDIT: replace "stock" with "tax" in the second to last paragraph

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by beagle3 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:30PM (#7469091)
It happens to people who got good advice too. I was an investor in a startup that sold for 3x (yay!), and the deal was less than 1 yr from my investment (35% short term capital gain rate + 13% NYC rate = 48% tax rate on the spot) but the deal was 45% cash, 55% stock. So I already had out-of-pocket expenses.

But I had to wait 6 months to sell any stock (SEC rule 144, applies to anyone whose shares were not bought), during which buying company share crashed 75% unrelated to this deal.

Now, since the deal happened to be in the first 6 months of the year, I was able to net it all, and a 3x exit was reduced to ~1.5x thanks to rule 144

If the deal had happened just 3 months later (any day after 1-jul), I would have lost money - not even full return of capital - on a successful exit, and had losses to carry till the end of the universe.

The tax laws are the problem. I have a good accountant, but wasn't in the driver seat for this deal, so I couldn't properly structure it.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by 0003 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:20PM (#7468237)
Whatever you do, do not ask for more illiquid stock to pay for the tax... :P
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by Anderkent on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:17PM (#7468223)
Doesnt selling stock immediately rather than after a year mean your tax rate on it is higher?
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by stevewilhelm on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:16PM (#7468644)
> Doesnt selling stock immediately rather than after a year mean your tax rate on it is higher?

This is the exact thinking that got many people in trouble during the dot.com bubble.

They exercised their options and neglected to sell and hold enough capital to pay their tax obligation.

Then the bubble burst and stock prices dropped, in some cases to nothing, within a year. The IRS still wanted the capital gains taxes on the difference between the option's grant price and the stock price on the day the options were exercised (aka the taxable event).

It was not uncommon to have people loose their houses and have their wages garnished to pay off their taxes.

Consider this a cautionary tale when speculatively trading Bitcoin.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by beagle3 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:44PM (#7469248)
But do see my other comments on SEC rule 144 - sometimes you are forbidden from selling in a way that exposes you to loss risk that cannot be mitigated without running afoul of security laws.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by stevewilhelm on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @09:19PM (#7470830)
You can purchase put options or employ other strategies to hedge against risk when one owns a large position in a single stock.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by beagle3 on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @03:19AM (#7472061)
There was specific language that explicitly said "this is illegal" until the latest revision. Now, it's implicit, and in inquiries to the SEC they have repeatedly said "that goes against regulation".

The general idea behind rule 144 very sane: It's supposed to limit pump-and-dump IPOs and M&As, by forcing anyone who did not pay for their shares outright to wait 6 months before they can gain anything (and legally, the SEC is only interested in the overall guarantee - e.g. put options that guarantee you don't lose are AGAINST the current spirit and the former letter of the law).

However, the laws apply equally to someone who owns 90% of the shares (who is in a position to abuse an IPO and M&A) and 0.1% of the shares (who is likely an employee receiving RSU or options, has zero control, and likely not even any finances to draw upon)

The tax law is insane, the security regulations are complicated, and their interplay is ludicrously insanely crazy.

Whenever you see people saying "oh, it's very simple - you just didn't get the right advice" you can be sure that they have no idea what they are talking about - either they didn't have to deal with it, or they weren't aware they were doing something illegal.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by tsotha on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:34AM (#7471796)
Not always. Sometimes that's against the rules, depending on exactly how the stock is awarded.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by ogreyonder on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:45PM (#7468425)
Yes; for people participating in an employee stock purchase program, it is called a Disqualifying Disposition. It puts you in the short-term capital gains bracket (with about 15% higher tax).

However, it's still a VERY good idea to do if you plan on holding stock.

I know stories of several people who were exercised options on 7 figures of stock, only to see the price collapse before they were able to sell. The taxes they owed because of that eclipsed their net worth several times over.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by beagle3 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:41PM (#7469211)
It's an excellent idea if you can do it - but sometimes you can't - e.g. If you are in the 6 month lockup period following an IPO or grant or other SEC rule 144 event. It runs afoul of said law to even hedge with options or on the open market.

It is crazy, but it is that way.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by thrownaway2424 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:40PM (#7468382)
No, because the exercise is taxed as income at the time of the exercise. If you sell it, there's not _more_ tax to be paid, because your gain after the exercise is zero. If you sell it after some, you'll pay long-term capital gains rates on the delta between your sale price and your exercise price.

Exercise-and-hold is a bad idea for most people in most cases.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by zpao on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:52PM (#7468476)
AFAIK You're taxed on receiving stock as if it were income. This is regardless of if you sell it today, tomorrow, or never.

After that you're only taxed on gains. If you sold on the day of reception, then your gains/losses are likely minimal. Eg, receive at 50 sell at 50 = 0 gains/losses. Sell at 51 and you have $1*N gains. Those gains are taxed at a higher rate until a year after the stock appeared in your account. I think the difference is ~10% (35 vs 25 or so).

So there are definite tradeoffs between holding for the year vs selling immediately. This part is no different than buying/selling on the stock market.

tldr; yes, but not exactly

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by Consultant32452 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:44PM (#7468423)
Generally, yes. Short term capital gains are taxed at a higher rate than long term capital gains.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by ChuckMcM on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @02:51PM (#7467979)
I was going to say this exact same thing. I was writing off 'losses' from stock losing value from 2001 to 2012 at $3,000 a year. It would have been longer except that you can, in some cases, offset gains made later against those losses. And yes, all under the auspices of 'alternative minimum tax' for which I have a special place of loathing in my heart for whomever thought that was a good idea.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:09PM (#7468158)
Do you know (remember) the mechanics of how the AMT affected this? Were you given stock that you didn't have a chance to sell? My understanding that only the initial grant of stock and the subsequent selling are taxable -- and didn't realize the AMT affected this.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by ChuckMcM on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:50PM (#7468459)
Note, the tax code changes every year and I'm not an accountant, just a victim :-)

Whenever I have exercised an option, my taxes have included an AMT calculation based on adding in the difference in value between exercise price, and market price, of those options as additional ordinary income. When the AMT tax calculation yields a 'tax owed' number that is larger than the non-AMT version (which it always did when exercising shares to make down payments) the IRS asked for the bigger number. Meaning that even if I had not sold the shares I exercised, the IRS wanted me to pretend that I had and pay tax on that money that I was pretending to have received. In exchange for doing that, the tax basis becomes the market price at the time of exercise.

If you don't actually sell the stock (because, for example, you are waiting for escrow to close), and the stock value goes down significantly, you can reach a point that the value of the stock drops below the tax liability you incurred by exercising the stock option in the first place. In some cases the stock can become worthless. (my best score has been $120/share stock going down to $0.52 share) If you realize this is going to happen before the tax year is over you can dump the stock take the loss and it all works out in the wash (loss cancels gain). If you cross over a tax year boundary then you owe the tax anyway (even though you don't have a way to pay it) and when you sell the stock in the following tax year you get a 'loss' but you don't have any gains to offset that against and you can't just take it out of the taxes owed. You can however write it off, $3,000 per year against your ordinary income.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:11PM (#7468997)
Ahh. By the time this information filtered to me in 2001/2, it became -- exercising options is always a taxable event. So that's the rule I live by and always make sure that there is a way to get cash simultaneously. I didn't realize it was because of the AMT.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by itbeho on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:46PM (#7468851)
How would you determine market price for stock options in a startup that's not public yet?
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by ChuckMcM on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:29PM (#7469088)
Periodically, the board of directors will go through a process for determining the value (aka the market price) for stock options. If you exercise your option and the exercise price is less than the current valuation price, then you will experience a 'taxable event.' I would guess that you'd be hit with the AMT in the US if computing the tax based on that exercise value was higher than your non-AMT computed tax. But you would want to check with your accountant.

Some companies allow you to file an 83b election, which is to exercise all your stock immediately, and as it is worth exactly what you are paying for it, no taxable event, and then take ownership of it as it vests. A person might choose to do that because in the event of going public or any time when the common stock becomes liquid, you would only pay long term capital gains rather than short term gains. The downside is that if the company exits where the common stock is worthless (not an uncommon occurrence for startups) then you would lose that money you paid originally. (but you could write off that loss, $3,000 a year, against future income :-)

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:06PM (#7468967)
It would not be prudent to exercise options that are not liquid. There is no benefit to doing that.

You don't, for example, usually get meaningful voting rights with those shares.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by sokoloff on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @07:37PM (#7470164)
You might want to exercise options before a new priced round (series B, C, D, etc) or before an S-1 filing. Yes, this exposes you to some adverse treatment (AMT for ISOs, and the risk of paying income tax on shares that later crash or become worthless), but it also establishes an ownership date (for the LTCG holding period) and a basis (which will presumably be higher in the next priced round or IPO, even though they're illiquid now.

(And as kalkin observes, if you're leaving the company with in-the-money options.)

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by kalkin on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:33PM (#7469112)
Well, it is not uncommon for options to expire after you leave a company if they are not exercised. So if you take a new job and don't want to throw away your options...
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @02:50PM (#7467972)
According the article this is not true. The tax event is turning the bitcoins into currency or spending them.

So, the issue could be you have $1,000,000 of bitcoin, and you spend it. You now owe capital gains on the difference in price between when you bought and sold. Now, even if you have the $x00,000 in bitcoin to cover this, you better convert it fast (like simultaneously).

Or, never spend bitcoin directly -- convert enough to dollars to buy and pay tax, then spend the dollars.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by jstalin on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @02:56PM (#7468030)
Actually, it says that you are taxed on their value at the time they are mined.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by SilasX on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:39PM (#7468381)
Strange. Why don't they treat the cost basis as your cost of production? That is, if you spend $X to mine the bitcoins, and sell them for $Y, why not tax you on $(Y-X) rather than Y minus "whatever the market said they were worth then"? $(Y-X) is your true dollar-denominated realized gain.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by pbreit on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:02PM (#7468539)
They do. You can report your costs as an expense.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:01PM (#7468073)
Miners are taxed at the time they are mined. This is probably consistent with diamonds.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by oijaf888 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:33PM (#7468752)
It seems pretty backwards compared to any other sort of creation. If I build a house, my basis is how much I spent building it, not how much my neighbor's house is worth.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:04PM (#7468953)
I don't think this has anything to do with basis. The difference is that mining the coin is considered a tax event -- so you pay tax on the mined value -- with the cost being deductible. This makes sense because the coin is liquid and can be sold in part without reducing the utility of the remainder.

That is not true of a house. It isn't as liquid and it's hard to sell part of the house to cover tax.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by tellmetwice on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @07:21PM (#7470062)
so if you mined gold you get taxed at the moment you caught sight of it and not when you take it to market?

And if you knew how mining pools worked it takes it on a totally different course with shelved shares, etc

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by FootballMuse on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:22PM (#7468254)
How does this work when mining in a pool is nearly continuous? You earn 0.000000x btc per share in a pool, and you might earn a share every few seconds.

What exchange do I use to determine the value of the btc?

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by jstalin on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:28PM (#7468309)
It's likely that the taxable event would occur when you can control the bitcoins. For instance, many pools have a minimum payout and you can't withdraw any until you meet that minimum. Based on other IRS rules, the taxable event would occur when you reach that withdrawal minimum.

As for the exchange to use for the value, it would probably be legitimate to use an average of a few exchanges, if the prices are wildly divergent.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by maxerickson on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:33PM (#7468336)
Should emphasize that whatever valuation will be expected to be reasonable and done consistently (so don't pick different exchanges for different payments or whatever, and probably don't pick Mt. Gox, and so on).
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by im3w1l on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:31PM (#7468742)
Well in the limit it would tend to an integral, and, assuming you have fixed hash power, approach the time and inverse network difficulty weighted average price.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by xur17 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:39PM (#7468797)
And then taxed again at the difference between that and their current value when you spend them?

Or can we use them to buy stuff, and avoid capital gains altogether?

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by faet on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @05:39PM (#7469190)
If you buy stuff you are taxed. If you buy 1 coin for 10$ and buy a $100 tv you owe 90$ in taxes.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by molsongolden on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:12PM (#7468623)
This seems insane. If I build 3 chairs I do not include the market price of 3 chairs on that day in my gross income, I sell the chairs and recognize the income generated by the sales.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by jedberg on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:17PM (#7468653)
That's not true. If you build 3 chairs and don't sell them by the end of the year, you pay inventory tax on the 3 chairs, i.e. you pay taxes on them without selling them.

This is why stores that sell physical goods to a blowout sale at the end of the year.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by molsongolden on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @04:26PM (#7468712)
I'm not sure what you mean by inventory tax.

If I haven't sold the chairs then I haven't recognized any income. Even if I had to value my inventory then I would value it at the lower of cost or market and in the case of Bitcoin that would be cost which would be computer depreciation and electricity, much less than the market value on the day of mining.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by gamblor956 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @07:51PM (#7470264)
Bitcoins earned through mining are considered compensation for providing resources to the Bitcoin network to compute hashes verifying transactions.

IOW, it's not at all analogous to building 3 chairs yourself.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by sokoloff on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @09:10PM (#7470784)
Should I file a Schedule F (income from farming) for my herb garden? I actually looked through the instructions for schedule F and I don't find any clear basis to allow me to not file it.

In practical terms, I'm not worried, as I suspect that I'd have a net loss, but assuming a net gain (that the fair market value of the parsley and sage I got from the herb garden exceeded my out-of-pocket costs to run the garden), I think I have to file a Schedule F per the regs.

For the record, it seems perfectly consistent to treat BTC as capital property; it doesn't seem reasonable to treat them as ordinary income.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by gamblor956 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @09:28PM (#7470870)
You should ask a tax lawyer or an accountant. But a "garden" is unlikely to be a "farm" within the meaning of the federal code, especially if it's just a hobby activity rather than a bona fide business intended to make money. (See http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p225.pdf, which notes that a farming business requires a profit intent.)

As for treating BTC as capital property--they are, under IRS decree--capital property for all US FIT. However, like all other capital property when received as compensation they are also income and get taxed like income. BTC doesn't get special rules just because it's digital.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by sokoloff on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @10:42PM (#7471220)
If I spend $10 buying a disposable planter and herbs, and over the course of the year, I harvest $20 FMV of herbs, I have made a profit. Profits from a hobby activity must be reported as income. Time permitting, I will ask my CPA/EA when we go over my taxes. (I'm quite certain that I spent more gardening than the value of the food I extracted, and hobby losses are not deductible, so I'm quite sure I'm clean...)

I'm not suggesting that BTC should have special rules because it's digital, but rather questioning whether mining BTC should be treated as compensation for personal labor (ordinary, active income), treated similarly to a dividend or interest payment, or treated as an outcome of a business activity (like raising beef cattle, food crops, or extracting energy from wind/solar). To my mind, the activity seems more closely aligned with the last group, and pretty far removed from compensation for personal efforts.

(None of this applies to me personally, as I've never owned a BTC, but these topics strike

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by gamblor956 on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:35PM (#7474941)
Ah gotcha. I see what you're missing now.

It is possible for compensation to also be business activity income. Compensation, tax-wise, simply refers to getting paid to provide labor or a service. Whether that service is a business activity of the service provider is a separate question. (Labor is generally not a business activity, and generally employees are treated as providing labor to their employer).

IOW, mining is compensation, but if it is a business activity of the miner, then they can deduct their losses/expenses against their mining gains. Someone who only mines as a hobby (i.e., they don't put much effort into it or attempt to maximize profits or minimize losses) doesn't get to do that even though they are also providing a service.

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by molsongolden on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @09:37PM (#7470918)
I don't know if I agree with taxing them as compensation but at least this view makes the IRS guidance appear logical. Thanks for the explanation.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by baddox on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:52PM (#7468468)
> It seems there are hypothetical scenarios where your taxes could exceed your net worth.

That's trivially true for traditional income tax and pretty much any other tax, right?

Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by wmf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @02:59PM (#7468058)
If you spent $900 in depreciation and electricity to mine $1,000 worth of BTC, would you owe taxes on $100 or $1,000?
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property by loumf on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:04PM (#7468104)
Taxes are typically paid on profit. BTC are not the only things with cost to acquire and carry (e.g. Cattle) -- and I believe those costs are taken into account.