It's likely that the taxable event would occur when you can control the bitcoins. For instance, many pools have a minimum payout and you can't withdraw any until you meet that minimum. Based on other IRS rules, the taxable event would occur when you reach that withdrawal minimum.
As for the exchange to use for the value, it would probably be legitimate to use an average of a few exchanges, if the prices are wildly divergent.
Re:IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property
by maxerickson on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @03:33PM
(#7468336)
Should emphasize that whatever valuation will be expected to be reasonable and done consistently (so don't pick different exchanges for different payments or whatever, and probably don't pick Mt. Gox, and so on).
What exchange do I use to determine the value of the btc?