News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pending Comments by pg on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:17AM (#7447790)
I'm turning off pending comments for now, because I'm going to bed and I don't like the idea of something this new running without me being able to watch it.

One thing I noticed while it was turned on was that the comments were actually pretty good. It may be that bad comments tend to be concentrated on particular threads, and that the right way to implement pending comments is per-thread rather than site-wide. That was actually the original plan, but it was simpler to implement site-wide, and I usually try to do the simplest thing first, in case it works.

Re:Pending Comments by obituary_latte on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:24AM (#7447998)
What's "it"? What is the problem that you all are trying to solve? I have showdead on, and maybe 2% of the comments I see are unreadable-grey.

Pending what? Approval? By whom? Sounds scary. Perhaps I missed the tps report. If so, sorry. But as an outsider who spends a lot of time here (work; analogue; fortuitous), I can't wait to have the comments here that I've come to love be editorialized by some cabal of power users.

Simple indeed.

Re:Pending Comments by spiralganglion on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:52AM (#7448080)
There is a large discussion on the subject here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7445761
Re:Pending Comments by sounds on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:52AM (#7448213)
I'm scratching my head about what the guidelines are around commenting and endorsing. Here's what I've gathered by looking through pg's comments: (in addition to what he originally posted)

• Parameters are loose (click link for more) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447668

  • You can post 5 pending comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447568
  • You can endorse at 500 karma https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447701
• Might get a showpending https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447613

• Might make it more AJAXy https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447778

• Users can retract pending comments with the delete link https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7446490

• The HN feature suggestion thread is exempt https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7446395

• A code snippet showing how it works https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7446596

• in this thread: "turning it off for now"

Re:Pending Comments by sentenza on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:57AM (#7448341)
I find it interesting that the original description [1], if followed to the letter, will with a very high probability kill (all?) user contributions over time.

Here's why: It says that you can't post another comment when you have a comment pending. Let's assume that:

a) Most "good" contributors write comments of varying quality (maybe on average 90% good 10% not so good)

b) Most people, when they interrupt their work flow to participate in the HN community, write on average more than one comment (if they comment at all).

So inevitably, the average user will repeatedly bump into the "can't comment, have to wait" wall. Which is inconvenient and constitutes a blunt reminder of the "value asymmetry" between the site and the lowly user.

I'd say it is fairly reasonable to assume that being stopped and having to wait is rather off-putting to most HN users. So it hangs on how many repetitions of the wait cycle the average HN user can stand.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7445761

Re:Pending Comments by whatevsbro on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:43AM (#7448316)
Summary: Censorship by group-think. Unharmonious comments will just never be seen.
Re:Pending Comments by deveac on Saturday March 22, 2014 @10:32AM (#7449180)
Meh. Site has up and down votes as well, along with flags. This is just another effort to keep the crap level down and quality up. If you've got something to say, you can say it in a way that isn't inflammatory or low value. This is a privately held gathering place, and if the price for absolute lack of censorship is comments and rhetoric that incite, inflame, go off topic, or otherwise just make this gathering place worse, then they can be shown the door. No virtue in that with respect to a private space with high value conversation as one of its premier objectives IMHO.
Re:Pending Comments by wpietri on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:21AM (#7449357)
I think "inflammatory" is often situational, individual.

I'm not personally worried. I'm seen as an insider. As Louis CK says, "How many advantages can one person have?" [1]

But people who aren't part of the HN tribe already think they're treated unfairly here, and from what I read on Twitter, they're confident that this change will only increase the level of groupthink by making sure their comments never get even seen.

Personally, I think that comments that incite and inflame are often useful. I agree that there's plenty of pure dickishness here, and I'd love to see that go. But sometimes comments are upsetting because they contain uncomfortable truth. Sometimes we skate on by the polite statement when a passionate outburst will force to see things through someone else's eyes.

[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TG4f9zR5yzY

Re:Pending Comments by deveac on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:41AM (#7449442)
I understand your point, but for a long time the tougher nut to crack for online forums has been quality, staying on topic, and not derailing the discussion by being uncivil or hostile.

One of the nice things about HN is that users are rather blunt in their critiques. I think the gatekeepers (>1k karma) will generaly do a good job separating frankness from hostility.

At any rate, it's an interesting experiment and I'm truly curious to see how it plays out.

Re:Pending Comments by pbhjpbhj on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:21PM (#7450961)
Why do you need on-topic when you have threading. What you need is collapsible threads; thread OT _for you_ then collapse and move on.
Re:Pending Comments by crusso on Saturday March 22, 2014 @09:43AM (#7449002)
The guidelines don't mention anything about "unharmonious". They only recommend to avoid endorsing posts without content like "this" style comments, and comments that are made in an aggressive non-collegial way.

If that's group think, then awesome. Let the group think begin.

Re:Pending Comments by wpietri on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:31AM (#7449395)
Are you telling me that every truth you have ever recognized has been conveyed to you in the most collegial of ways?

I can recall a number of occasions where somebody told me something important and they might as well have started out with "Look, asshole". Deservedly so, because I was not just wrong but wrong in a way that was conveniently self-serving and harmful to them.

I would also like to see the dickishness taken down a notch or three here. But if it comes at the cost of making this more of an echo chamber, then it will be a Pyrrhic victory.

Re:Pending Comments by crusso on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:46PM (#7450050)
There are plenty of places on the Internet where you can get your "truth" or whatever in a medium of abuse.

The people running this site have asked that this not be one of them.

I say this as a person who appreciates and uses sarcasm more than most... people can communicate just fine, often more effectively, without it.

Plus, it's more than just how something is said. If you read PG's short request, he's looking for a change in attitude in how points are even argued. Argue as colleagues coming to a solution together, not as adversaries trying to take each other down.

Re:Pending Comments by wpietri on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:22PM (#7450438)
I agree that we should stamp out abuse. And I'd love to see less king-of-the-argument-hill behavior around here.

However, you've created a false dichotomy; there are things in the world that are neither abusive nor particularly collegial.

The concern is that in getting rid of the abuse, Hacker News will also get rid of uncomfortable truth.

Re:Pending Comments by crusso on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:53AM (#7453541)
Point to a single place where the policy even implies that uncomfortable truths are not endorsable?

Like I said, I'm sarcastic - but I definitely have seen HN go downhill since I've been here over the last couple of years. I look at the need to say things more constructively as a learning and growth opportunity.

Re:Pending Comments by wpietri on Sunday March 23, 2014 @04:39PM (#7455043)
Uncomfortable truths are uncomfortable. People often confuse discomfort with wrongness.

The policy doesn't have to say that people shouldn't endorse uncomfortable truths for it to have that result. That people will misuse power to keep comfortable is something that you shouldn't have to have explained to you.

Re:Pending Comments by krapp on Saturday March 22, 2014 @09:40AM (#7448995)
maybe, maybe not?

There are enough 1k+ karma posters that, at least unless the karma bar is either raised or a lot of malcontents are culled, consensus on controversial topics is likely to be impossible. At least I hope so.

Re:Pending Comments by whatevsbro on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:13PM (#7450395)
> unless the karma bar is either raised or a lot of malcontents are culled, consensus on controversial topics is likely to be impossible

Well _of course_ consensus on controversial topics is impossible. That's kind of what makes them controversial topics. But how is that related to whether you never even see controversial posts because group-think has not resulted in uncensoring them?

Re:Pending Comments by krapp on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:21PM (#7450432)
Because it's almost certain someone in that pool is going to be willing to endorse it. It's too fragile a system to allow for groupthink to be enforced.
Re:Pending Comments by riggins on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:31AM (#7449394)
there are a million websites with low quality, un-moderated discussion.

Personally I like the idea of pending comments.

Re:Pending Comments by edmccard on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:37AM (#7448045)
>maybe 2% of the comments I see are unreadable-grey.

Maybe that's the problem? That is, maybe bad comments are, to paraphrase Mark Twain, like the weather; everyone talks about them but nobody bothers to downvote them to unreadable greyness.

(either that, or there are voting rings that devote themselves to upvoting greyed-out comments).

Re:Pending Comments by prawn on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:48AM (#7448325)
Any dodgy comment with reasonable age seems to be slammed by the time I get to it. Someone must be down voting them. And I can't recall seeing evidence of groups up voting junk comments, only stories. Everything seemed to be working OK to me. I find the quality of comments on HN to be very good and don't think this new feature is necessary.
Re:Pending Comments by mercer on Saturday March 22, 2014 @10:04AM (#7449092)
While I agree that generally the quality is high, I do feel that over the past two years (or so) that I've been active here, I've been seeing more and more reddit-like puns or empty comments. They're not overwhelming, and generally harmless enough, content-wise, but I do find them annoying. I welcome this attempt to fix the situation before it becomes too bad.
Re:Pending Comments by prawn on Sunday March 23, 2014 @06:24PM (#7455508)
I down vote them when I see them. I figure that will discourage people from repeating that style of comment and a few of them here and there won't wreck anything.
Re:Pending Comments by Udo on Saturday March 22, 2014 @06:04AM (#7448477)
Being in a different time zone I missed out on the trial, bummer. I'm looking forward to actually trying it out. Going back to the original discussion it seems this is a measure designed to weed out comments that are nasty and low in content.

The potential issue I see is that this feature adds a layer of complication and indirection to solve a cultural problem.

There are two classes of low-grade comments: the "normal" ones which quickly sink to the bottom because they're downvoted into oblivion, and the "crafty" ones that get a lot of upvotes even though they're cheap, inflammatory, personal, repetitive, or just generally trollish (like for example the maneuver where someone posts a reply disagreeing with an imaginary point that was never made in the parent).

The existing voting system is pretty good at filtering out the normal trash, but it fails to address the crafty pieces - so I assume the Pending Feature is designed to address those. I'm not sure it can though, because the crafty trolls seem to have a lot of fans and the same people who upvote these things today are just going to endorse them in the future.

Sorry for spit-balling from the cheap seats, I'm actually excited to find out how the new system works in practice. It intuitively it feels like a layer of complexity with dubious benefits, but that said: addressing the underlying problem is a worthy cause.

Re:Pending Comments by protomyth on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:16AM (#7447978)
"I'm turning off pending comments for now, because I'm going to bed and I don't like the idea of something this new running without me being able to watch it."

Sage advise for every developer and the fervent wish of every system admin. Goodnight sir.

Re:Pending Comments by vacri on Saturday March 22, 2014 @06:11AM (#7448499)
At my last job, the (rather dedicated) developers would often push code to production at 1am, give or take an hour.

As support, I would ask them "Please don't do that. You don't watch to make sure it works okay"

They would respond 'It's okay, because we'll be back online at 8am'.

"Yes, but our primary customers are farmers, who check our SaaS at 6am to plan their day. It's the point of our software."

'It's okay, because we'll be back online at 8am'

"I don't think you understand how this works..."

Re:Pending Comments by noir_lord on Saturday March 22, 2014 @07:38AM (#7448655)
It's an interesting problem to optimise for.

When is the best time to push new changes to production based on probability they will fall over, usage patterns and day of the week.

I'm relatively lucky as the stuff I do is mostly for businesses so the (obvious to me) push point is 8am Saturday morning, that gives me two days to sort out any problems and there is always some low level usage.

Re:Pending Comments by protomyth on Saturday March 22, 2014 @12:18PM (#7449622)
I think vacri hit it with the knowing your audience and what times they are active. If you run a true 24-hour global service then you need to think hard, but a lot of systems have a very select audience that can be properly scheduled. I would imagine midwest farmers would accept updates done Sunday mornings during church hours maybe slipping later into the afternoon during sports.
Re:Pending Comments by crusso on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:52PM (#7450075)
Sounds like a support organization that should have had the developers' home phone numbers.
Re:Pending Comments by ElDiablo666 on Saturday March 22, 2014 @07:17AM (#7448611)
Except in those cases we would hope they implement the feature in question and in this case we can only hope he has the good sense to leave it off.
Re:Pending Comments by nodesocket on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:53AM (#7447904)
I like the idea, but I think there should be simple logic like:

   if post.created > 10 hours {
       comments.pending(false);
   }
Threads that are older should be allowed to be commented on by anybody.
Re:Pending Comments by jw2013 on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:25AM (#7448003)
>>It may be that bad comments tend to be concentrated on particular threads, and that the right way to implement pending comments is per-thread rather than site-wide.

So what about this? Here comments is a vector of all the scores of comments inside one particular thread.

----

(defn filter? [comments threshold]

  (let [size (count comments)]

    (if (< threshold (/ (reduce + comments) size)) false

       true)))
;;user=> (filter? [1 2 3 4] 2)

;;false

;;user=> (filter? [1 2 3 4] 3)

;;true

Re:Pending Comments by e12e on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:37AM (#7448047)
I think there's a lot of value to this idea. Think of it as basic network effect/peer pressure/culture thing. Just as you want "more of the right people", you (probably) want to start out on a topic with "more of the interesting/right" comments. That will generally steer the discussion -- as readers adapt to what is being discussed.

This could/should probably be a/b tested (eg: on/off on odd/even numbered submissions or whatnot).

Re:Pending Comments by minimaxir on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:32AM (#7447834)
The comments are good because it's a Friday night and the only people now on Hacker News are the people who care about it too much. :P
Re:Pending Comments by Ecio78 on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:33AM (#7448030)
it' Friday night in the US ...
Re:Pending Comments by sturmeh on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:29AM (#7448154)
Indeed, Saturday night here!
Re:Pending Comments by sev on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:33AM (#7448032)
I think we need control, but not this much control. Moderation is key in everything. No pun intended.

If this becomes reality, I see a future where we have no bad comments, a lot of decent/good comments from the same people and therefore turning into an elitist society (more-so than it already sort-of is). I feel this will push new users away, and therefore slow our knowledge diversification.

Re:Pending Comments by yaur on Saturday March 22, 2014 @06:42AM (#7448550)
"Punditocracy" is that a thing? If not it seems like a good term for it and something that is pretty antithetical of a site site that calls its self "hacker news".
Re:Pending Comments by tripzilch on Sunday March 23, 2014 @03:32PM (#7454699)
For one beautiful moment, I imagined you meant we should get the comments with the best puns to rise to the top.
Re:Pending Comments by vl on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:37AM (#7448435)
I'm convinced that "intelligent" auto-folding will improve quality of experience. It will naturally reduce depth of branches on the earliest (which are often top) comments and promote more top-level comments. In a sense my feeling is that there is no need to penalize people for unpopular opinions, the view should be such that unpopular comments are discoverable only by most dedicated readers.

I'm afraid that current change will increase mono-culture.

Re:Pending Comments by thatthatis on Saturday March 22, 2014 @12:18PM (#7449625)
Have to agree with you. Reddit solved this problem elegantly with auto folding ages ago.
Re:Pending Comments by mbrameld on Saturday March 22, 2014 @09:52AM (#7449039)
This has such potential for abuse and it's obvious it hasn't been very well thought-out. I hope that in order for an overseer to put the kibosh on a comment he or she will have to enter an explanation. Also, all comments that don't meet the group-think criteria should be viewable by everyone along with who censored it and why. I hate to see another website I love go down the drain.
Re:Pending Comments by dangrossman on Saturday March 22, 2014 @12:33PM (#7449705)
There is no active censoring; you can only "put the kibosh" on a comment by having several thousand people all independently decide not to click its "endorse" link. Nobody can individually kill a comment.
Re:Pending Comments by matt_heimer on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:53AM (#7447905)
When you say "the comments were actually pretty good" is that subjective or was the average karma per post higher?
Re:Pending Comments by mcgwiz on Saturday March 22, 2014 @12:28PM (#7449676)
The word "endorse" mischaracterizes the aims of this program, and counter-productively provokes groupthink. Renaming the "endorse" link to "tolerable" (where it becomes a kind of flag) would go a long way to mitigating that risk.

Details in my comment on "Coming Soon...": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7449597

Re:Pending Comments by Alex3917 on Saturday March 22, 2014 @08:23AM (#7448765)
If it's easy you could set it so that it's only turned on after the thread has 10 comments or whatever. That way there is a universal rule but it cuts down on unnecessary moderation work.
Re:Pending Comments by ajro on Saturday March 22, 2014 @06:16AM (#7448512)
Could we please have the way to unlock someones abilty to post comment (delete comment, wait for timeout etc.) described in the FAQ?