Re:Pending Comments
by nodesocket on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:53AM
(#7447904)
I like the idea, but I think there should be simple logic like:
Threads that are older should be allowed to be commented on by anybody.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
>>It may be that bad comments tend to be concentrated on particular threads, and that the right way to implement pending comments is per-thread rather than site-wide.
So what about this? Here comments is a vector of all the scores of comments inside one particular thread.
----
(defn filter? [comments threshold]
(let [size (count comments)]
(if (< threshold (/ (reduce + comments) size)) false
true)))
;;user=> (filter? [1 2 3 4] 2);;false
;;user=> (filter? [1 2 3 4] 3)
;;true
I think there's a lot of value to this idea. Think of it as basic network effect/peer pressure/culture thing. Just as you want "more of the right people", you (probably) want to start out on a topic with "more of the interesting/right" comments. That will generally steer the discussion -- as readers adapt to what is being discussed.
This could/should probably be a/b tested (eg: on/off on odd/even numbered submissions or whatnot).