News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pending Comments by spiralganglion on Saturday March 22, 2014 @02:52AM (#7448080)
There is a large discussion on the subject here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7445761
Re:Pending Comments by sounds on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:52AM (#7448213)
I'm scratching my head about what the guidelines are around commenting and endorsing. Here's what I've gathered by looking through pg's comments: (in addition to what he originally posted)

• Parameters are loose (click link for more) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447668

  • You can post 5 pending comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447568
  • You can endorse at 500 karma https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447701
• Might get a showpending https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447613

• Might make it more AJAXy https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7447778

• Users can retract pending comments with the delete link https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7446490

• The HN feature suggestion thread is exempt https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7446395

• A code snippet showing how it works https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7446596

• in this thread: "turning it off for now"

Re:Pending Comments by sentenza on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:57AM (#7448341)
I find it interesting that the original description [1], if followed to the letter, will with a very high probability kill (all?) user contributions over time.

Here's why: It says that you can't post another comment when you have a comment pending. Let's assume that:

a) Most "good" contributors write comments of varying quality (maybe on average 90% good 10% not so good)

b) Most people, when they interrupt their work flow to participate in the HN community, write on average more than one comment (if they comment at all).

So inevitably, the average user will repeatedly bump into the "can't comment, have to wait" wall. Which is inconvenient and constitutes a blunt reminder of the "value asymmetry" between the site and the lowly user.

I'd say it is fairly reasonable to assume that being stopped and having to wait is rather off-putting to most HN users. So it hangs on how many repetitions of the wait cycle the average HN user can stand.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7445761

Re:Pending Comments by whatevsbro on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:43AM (#7448316)
Summary: Censorship by group-think. Unharmonious comments will just never be seen.
Re:Pending Comments by deveac on Saturday March 22, 2014 @10:32AM (#7449180)
Meh. Site has up and down votes as well, along with flags. This is just another effort to keep the crap level down and quality up. If you've got something to say, you can say it in a way that isn't inflammatory or low value. This is a privately held gathering place, and if the price for absolute lack of censorship is comments and rhetoric that incite, inflame, go off topic, or otherwise just make this gathering place worse, then they can be shown the door. No virtue in that with respect to a private space with high value conversation as one of its premier objectives IMHO.
Re:Pending Comments by wpietri on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:21AM (#7449357)
I think "inflammatory" is often situational, individual.

I'm not personally worried. I'm seen as an insider. As Louis CK says, "How many advantages can one person have?" [1]

But people who aren't part of the HN tribe already think they're treated unfairly here, and from what I read on Twitter, they're confident that this change will only increase the level of groupthink by making sure their comments never get even seen.

Personally, I think that comments that incite and inflame are often useful. I agree that there's plenty of pure dickishness here, and I'd love to see that go. But sometimes comments are upsetting because they contain uncomfortable truth. Sometimes we skate on by the polite statement when a passionate outburst will force to see things through someone else's eyes.

[1] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TG4f9zR5yzY

Re:Pending Comments by deveac on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:41AM (#7449442)
I understand your point, but for a long time the tougher nut to crack for online forums has been quality, staying on topic, and not derailing the discussion by being uncivil or hostile.

One of the nice things about HN is that users are rather blunt in their critiques. I think the gatekeepers (>1k karma) will generaly do a good job separating frankness from hostility.

At any rate, it's an interesting experiment and I'm truly curious to see how it plays out.

Re:Pending Comments by pbhjpbhj on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:21PM (#7450961)
Why do you need on-topic when you have threading. What you need is collapsible threads; thread OT _for you_ then collapse and move on.
Re:Pending Comments by crusso on Saturday March 22, 2014 @09:43AM (#7449002)
The guidelines don't mention anything about "unharmonious". They only recommend to avoid endorsing posts without content like "this" style comments, and comments that are made in an aggressive non-collegial way.

If that's group think, then awesome. Let the group think begin.

Re:Pending Comments by wpietri on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:31AM (#7449395)
Are you telling me that every truth you have ever recognized has been conveyed to you in the most collegial of ways?

I can recall a number of occasions where somebody told me something important and they might as well have started out with "Look, asshole". Deservedly so, because I was not just wrong but wrong in a way that was conveniently self-serving and harmful to them.

I would also like to see the dickishness taken down a notch or three here. But if it comes at the cost of making this more of an echo chamber, then it will be a Pyrrhic victory.

Re:Pending Comments by crusso on Saturday March 22, 2014 @01:46PM (#7450050)
There are plenty of places on the Internet where you can get your "truth" or whatever in a medium of abuse.

The people running this site have asked that this not be one of them.

I say this as a person who appreciates and uses sarcasm more than most... people can communicate just fine, often more effectively, without it.

Plus, it's more than just how something is said. If you read PG's short request, he's looking for a change in attitude in how points are even argued. Argue as colleagues coming to a solution together, not as adversaries trying to take each other down.

Re:Pending Comments by wpietri on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:22PM (#7450438)
I agree that we should stamp out abuse. And I'd love to see less king-of-the-argument-hill behavior around here.

However, you've created a false dichotomy; there are things in the world that are neither abusive nor particularly collegial.

The concern is that in getting rid of the abuse, Hacker News will also get rid of uncomfortable truth.

Re:Pending Comments by crusso on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:53AM (#7453541)
Point to a single place where the policy even implies that uncomfortable truths are not endorsable?

Like I said, I'm sarcastic - but I definitely have seen HN go downhill since I've been here over the last couple of years. I look at the need to say things more constructively as a learning and growth opportunity.

Re:Pending Comments by wpietri on Sunday March 23, 2014 @04:39PM (#7455043)
Uncomfortable truths are uncomfortable. People often confuse discomfort with wrongness.

The policy doesn't have to say that people shouldn't endorse uncomfortable truths for it to have that result. That people will misuse power to keep comfortable is something that you shouldn't have to have explained to you.

Re:Pending Comments by krapp on Saturday March 22, 2014 @09:40AM (#7448995)
maybe, maybe not?

There are enough 1k+ karma posters that, at least unless the karma bar is either raised or a lot of malcontents are culled, consensus on controversial topics is likely to be impossible. At least I hope so.

Re:Pending Comments by whatevsbro on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:13PM (#7450395)
> unless the karma bar is either raised or a lot of malcontents are culled, consensus on controversial topics is likely to be impossible

Well _of course_ consensus on controversial topics is impossible. That's kind of what makes them controversial topics. But how is that related to whether you never even see controversial posts because group-think has not resulted in uncensoring them?

Re:Pending Comments by krapp on Saturday March 22, 2014 @03:21PM (#7450432)
Because it's almost certain someone in that pool is going to be willing to endorse it. It's too fragile a system to allow for groupthink to be enforced.
Re:Pending Comments by riggins on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:31AM (#7449394)
there are a million websites with low quality, un-moderated discussion.

Personally I like the idea of pending comments.