News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by there on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:27PM (#742082)
from the comments:

You do realize that a large portion of people that are using IE6 are at work where they have NO control over the browser...

i hear this every time the ie6 argument comes up, and yet, i've never heard from someone that actually works in one of these IT departments that can vouch for this.

who are these unsympathetic robots who, while ironically working in an IT department, are so out of touch with technology that they fail to understand their users are stuck using insecure, out-of-date software that is now increasingly being blocked? are these users still using 500mhz machines with windows 98, too?

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by aichcon on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:38PM (#742114)
The problem is internal legacy applications that only work in IE6. If they upgrade browsers the apps break, so in order to support these apps they keep IE 6. The question for them is 'do we spend time and money to update all of our applications to upgrade a browser, or just leave things the way they are for now?'
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by pavel_lishin on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:11PM (#742205)
Sometimes the question isn't even "do we spend time and money to update our applications", because sometimes the code for the applications is long gone, along with the company that wrote it, and all they have left is the compiled code running on some server in a back closet.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by nostrademons on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:32PM (#742252)
This was the reasoning that led to Java's ascendancy in the enterprise and the 1996-2000 tech boom. Companies were stuck with Y2K-incompliant COBOL software that they no longer had the expertise (or sometimes even the source code) for, and they had a hard constraint of Jan 1, 2000 that they had to hit. So many of them threw away their existing software entirely and rewrote it all in Java. The resulting IT spending fueled the tech boom of the late 1990s, led to the rise of the Indian outsourcing industry, and resulted in widespread adoption of Java EE.

We're in a recession now. There're a bunch of unemployed web developers. Let's simply ban the use of IE6 and kill two birds with one stone! Break some windows and burn those diskpacks, baby!

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by palish on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:42PM (#742274)
Oh nostrademons... You always know exactly how to fuel the fire.

Maybe we should organize "ie6aholics annonymous"?

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:24PM (#742239)
Couldn't they install Firefox, then, and use IE6 for legacy apps?
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by riffic on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:21PM (#742341)
hell, back when I used to work for more restrictive companies I was still able to download the zip version of firefox, unzip it into ~mydocuments, and run it from there.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by lurkinggrue on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:31PM (#742248)
How about Virtual Box to run IE6?
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by jodrellblank on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @07:52PM (#742455)
How about the cost of a Windows license?
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by robin_reala on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @07:22AM (#743183)
How about Ubuntu and IEs4linux? Nothing like a few more layers of abstraction.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by aardvark on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:55PM (#742168)
That's exactly the situation we had at the place I used to work. Management believed it was better to deal with the limitations of legacy software than with the expense of modernizing it. As of 2006, when I left, they were even still using Windows 98 on a handful of PCs because there was no reliable way to get all the data out of one of the applications and the software vendor had gone out of business.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:44PM (#742134)
Same reply here as below: "Sorry, that's not an excuse. IE 8 comes with a "compatibility mode" feature where any site can choose to use the IE 6 rendering engine by setting headers or meta tags appropriately."
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by eli on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:09PM (#742200)
Nope.. that compatibility mode is for IE7, not IE6. (And my understanding is that it's not even a perfect emulation of IE7.)

Microsoft's official recommendation for developers is to install IE6 in a VM if you need to test compatibility. It's that bad.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:19PM (#742226)
Hmm, you're right. Somehow that didn't make it into the final release. What a shame.

Either way, our perspective is still that the more people that complain about IE 6, the more pressure IT departments will have to upgrade their systems.

Starting with Firefox for a modern browsing experience wouldn't be a bad idea :)

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by jodrellblank on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @08:10PM (#742483)
And an antediluvian management experience. Official MSIs with transforms and group policy templates for configuration please.

(e.g. group policy configure location and size of cache, proxy settings, location of profile folder, restrictions on plugin installation, items to add to favourites, home page configuration, default plugins to install, disable update checking if they wont have rights to install them, etc).

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by 100k on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:17PM (#742221)
Speaking of which, do you know where I can find IE 6 so I can install it in a VM and test our site?

MultipleIE doesn't work on Windows 7, which is what I'm using.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by eli on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:20PM (#742231)
Dunno about Win7 compatibility, but this is the official VPC image: http://www.microsoft.com/Downloads/details.aspx?FamilyID=21e...

Personally, I'd probably just use a VMWare image of XP or Win98 and download IE6 from here http://www.microsoft.com/Downloads/details.aspx?familyid=1E1...

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by Quiark on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:00PM (#742300)
Some compatibility problems don't regard HTML, so this compatibility mode is irrelevant - for instance in COM apps using the IE browser control, upgrades to IE7/8 are known to cause problems.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by nbhat on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @02:07AM (#742933)
I agree and I face this problem. Generally I circumvent this by firebugs capabilities to edit the HTML dynamically, but it has to be done too frequently end up uninstalling IE8. and installing it again at a later point. IT department thinks that IE7 does not make the security cut .. I dont know the specifics of security cut.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by webwright on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:18PM (#742335)
http://blog.digg.com/?p=878 <==== Data

Digg surveyed IE6 users. 76% of those surveyed DO NOT HAVE THE POWER/AUTHORITY/ABILITY to upgrade.

"Giving them a message saying, “Hey! Upgrade!” in this case is not only pointless; it’s sadistic.

We’re committed to developing to Web standards and building new ways to help you discover the best of the Web. Keeping an eye on what technologies folks use and why they’re being used is a big part of it."

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:31PM (#742360)
The Digg survey shows that 70% of IE6 users are corporate, but there's no indication how representative that is of the web as a whole.

Either way, this initiative is targeted straight at those users. We've heard from several sources that many corporate IT departments don't feel any need or urgency to upgrade, and receive very few complaints. We see this as a start -- the more complaints the IT department gets (especially from on top), the more pressure they'll feel to upgrade. Even if they can't upgrade IE 6 due to legacy applications, they could always install a version of Firefox side-by-side and only use IE 6 for the legacy apps.

For the other subset of IE6 users (moms, grandmothers, etc), this will be a great notice to let them know that their web experience is seriously degraded, and that they should strongly consider upgrading their web browser.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by webwright on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @08:17PM (#742493)
Unfortunately, IT departments receiving complaints isn't going to do it, unless those complaints are "I can't do my job with IE6 any more"... So you need to hit core web apps for those businesses. If the choice is "we could fix our 78 different custom web apps to work on Firefox" or "we could upgrade to IE8 or FF", the choice is pretty clear for a cash-crunched business with an understaffed IT department. It's a cost-benefit thing.

For what it's worth, we don't support IE6 (or if we do, it's accidental!) and we're pretty squarely aimed at businesses and "prosumers". So count us in!

Having consulted to big companies in a former life, I just don't think it'll do much good. :-(

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @08:57PM (#742565)
It's as good a place to start as any. Once we can get the percentage of users using IE 6 down a little bit more, we'll be able to ditch support completely.

Also, there's no reason the browser decision has to be binary: custom legacy apps could use IE 6, with Firefox as the main web browser.

BTW: Shoot me an email when you've implemented some kind of notice and I'll throw your logo up!

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by zmimon on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @11:00PM (#742746)
There's a slight problem with this (and I'm only half tongue in cheek here): corporate IT admins probably see it as an actual positive if their staff can't access their favorite social networking web sites or anything else not explicitly required for work. The only thing that will convince them to move is if critical business infrastructure they depend on starts breaking and that isn't very likely to happen soon.

I think one of key things that will make businesses move will be when Microsoft itself phases out mainstream support. Sadly, their policy is that IE lifecycles follow that of the OS they were released with, so if I read it right, we are looking at IE6 being supported right through to 2014 before security updates disappear. That means we'll probably be stuck with some reasonable percentage of IE6 users for a few years yet. With luck Win7 will be good enough to entice a lot of companies that held back through vista to upgrade and that will kill off a goodly number over the next year or two.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by irrelative on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:49PM (#742384)
Really not trying to be snarky here, but I don't think too many grandmothers are using weebly or reading reddit.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @07:03PM (#742399)
Sorry, there may not be too many grandmothers reading reddit, but our userbase is very much non-technical.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by qeorge on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:22PM (#742343)
I posted an eerily similar comment 2 minutes after yours (minus the yelling). I also found the digg survey quite revealing.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by czstrong on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:43PM (#742130)
I'm currently an intern at a large biotech company which employs over 25,000 people world-wide and all the machines come with IE6.

I'm an intern at their headquarters in a section of the IT department that doesn't deal with maintaining the software on the computers. However, there was one larger meeting where I remember someone asking about upgrading IE, and the response was something like, "Uhh, I've been pretty busy, I'll get around to it eventually." Everyone just laughed and I could tell it was a kind of ongoing joke. I think the general attitude is that no one here really cares enough to go through the work of upgrading everyone. I don't think they get many complaints, and their job isn't in jeopardy, so they just sit on it until something or someone really big makes them act.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:48PM (#742144)
That's what we figure -- the more complaints coming through the door, the more pressure will be put on the IT department to upgrade.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by jmcannon on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:34PM (#742106)
IE6 is still very prevalent in the American school system (don't know about elsewhere). We used to sell a web product to schools and you wouldn't believe the number of districts using IE6 for "compatibility" with their network software or because they don't consider upgrading a priority.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by mnemonicsloth on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:44PM (#742133)
One of my co-founders has been a public school teacher for the last 20 years or so. She says that the school system's primary function is to give America's least competent individuals a way to stay in the middle class.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by krakensden on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:49PM (#742383)
While that's true, it's beside the point. All the public schools I've been to do not have an `IT Department', the computers there were just installed in a fire-and-forget manner. Often the school district has some people who are supposed to be in charge of it, but they don't come around very often, and honestly don't have the time, money, or manpower to set up something sane.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by j2d2 on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:30PM (#742092)
These unsympathetic robots are all the people that are using Windows 2000. I've seen people in firms that refuse to update their version of windows. They all seem to hate this and don't expect much of a browsing experience from these machines anyway...
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by Bluem00 on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:58PM (#742175)
Here's an anecdote from my experience:

The majority of the users of my company's web application use IE6 on Windows 2000. Additionally, many of these computers have Vista stickers on them, and are quite powerful. Their IT groups already have established practices to support the machines, and they are used almost exclusively to surf the web and run software that was purchased 5 years ago. Our users aren't even unhappy, as their work does not center around a computer; thus, the corporate IT infrastructure has no motivation to upgrade them.

That said, we still pressure them to upgrade, and I'll be extremely happy when they eventually do.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by there on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:33PM (#742101)
so is the refusal coming from the IT person or the end-user?

perhaps instead of all these silly campaigns to try to force users to upgrade, they should make a simple questionnaire that asks the user why they are still using ie6, and then publish the results. i have a feeling the leading reason will not be "because some jerk in IT won't let me".

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by run4yourlives on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:05PM (#742311)
Actually I think the response would be, "What's a browser?"
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:40PM (#742122)
Our perspective is that the more people that are prompted about their outdated browsing experience, the more pressure the IT department will be getting to get their ass in gear and upgrade their decade old computer systems. You can bet that if the volume of complaints triples, it will start to become a major priority -- especially if the complaints are coming from the top.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by johns on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:34PM (#742107)
See the digg survey link below (or here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=742057)
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by soldarnal on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:41PM (#742270)
Being as my desktop at home still runs Windows 2000, I used to assume this was the case as well. But the OS/browser stats on w3schools, at least, show only 1% usage of W2K as compared to 14% IE6 usage, which, if my math is right, seems to mean that a large number of IE6 users are on XP.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by ironkeith on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:37PM (#742112)
I know from extremely unpleasant experience that many large Canadian government organizations are still using IE6+XP. Further, I know of at least one large health region still on IE6+XP.

Change takes a while in these monolithic bureaucracies; especially when they have to ensure that any upgrades to software have no negative effects to any other software installed on the system (a lot of which can be equal parts shoddy and proprietary).

As an aside, I've been working with a large government client for 2.5 years now, and I still haven't been able to get their IT dept. to add Flash to their image to support the streaming video site they paid my company to build (hooray for Windows Media Player).

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by tedunangst on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:21PM (#742232)
Were you actually expecting to hear from an IE6 IT shop on HN? The people living in that world don't often post here.

Next you'll say that nobody ever calls their computer case the CPU because you haven't seen anybody do it here.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by jodrellblank on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @08:04PM (#742474)
i've never heard from someone that actually works in one of these IT departments

Hi!

who are these unsympathetic robots who, while ironically working in an IT department, are so out of touch with technology

The same people who get emails from vendors warning us off upgrading to IE7 or certain programs will break. The same people who have had such pain from flakey apps for all sorts of reasons that we just don't dare upgrade. The same people who use anti-virus, non-administrator accounts and gateway HTTP, FTP and SMTP proxies with scanners to reduce the risks.

The same people who've learned to beat their inner geek into submission to the principle of 'if it's not broken, and you don't want it broken, leave it alone. Companies want sameness, predictability and uptime, not features, novelty, CSS compliance or security'.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by robin_reala on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @07:28AM (#743189)
By choosing the easy path for yourself you’re choosing the hard path for web developers. Sooner rather than later this tension will become too much and you’ll find that websites simply stop supporting your browser of choice.

But, like someone already mentioned in this thread it’s not a binary choice. Install Firefox (or an equivalent up-to-date browser) for normal browsing and leave IE6 on the machines for legacy apps.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by sepa on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:42PM (#742128)
I am currently working at one of the largest beverage corporations of the world, and not only they continue to use IE6 but also they methodically inspect every Windows OS update, even if its a security patch, it can be months until they decide to update the network with such patches and updates.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by sjs382 on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:53PM (#742160)
At my day job we have some (unpatched?) Windows 2000 machine (no service packs) running IE 5.5 (I think?). I carry around a flash drive with a Portable Firefox (among other apps) install on it for browsing at work.

They're 2.0 gHz P4 Dell machines if you're really interested in the specs. :p

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by run4yourlives on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @06:00PM (#742301)
The official browser at my office is IE6. Of course I have chrome, firefox and safari installed, but most employees here don't have local admin access.

>who are these unsympathetic robots who

The enterprise IT department that's who.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by Dobbs on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:04PM (#742189)
GM requires the use of IE6, or it at least did when my father last worked there (about a year and a half, two years ago). It could have changed by now but considering they were just moving from 95 to 98 when he left I doubt it.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by Jem on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @05:02AM (#743075)
I don't now, but have worked in 3 different locations where IE6 was forced on its users. All education.

They have different financial priorities than spending time on upgrading software that "just works".

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by alextp on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:54PM (#742164)
Well, a couple of years ago I was forced to use IE6 on a 500mhz machine running windows2000 in a project in the local government.

It was not pretty, although I managed to install XEmacs and survive.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by alaskamiller on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:29PM (#742089)
Not even the US military subject itself to the stupidity that is IE6.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by sachinag on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:39PM (#742116)
The U.S. State Department, however, does.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by otto on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:59PM (#742176)
As of how recent?

As far as I know all government machines are running FDCC(Federal Desktop Core Configuration) and the machines I've seen run IE7 with many IT departments recommending Firefox.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by fname on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @09:31PM (#742625)
The FDCC only applies to XP and Vista. Additionally, there's no forced method to specifically upgrade those platforms to IE7 or above.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by sachinag on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:15PM (#742217)
Fair - the town hall question referred to IE in general; it may very well be IE7 that they have at Foggy Bottom.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by hassy on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:30PM (#742247)
As does Britain's Ministry of Defence as well as many other departments in the British government. Moreover, they don't even have upgrade plans in place either.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by robin_reala on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @07:31AM (#743192)
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by jadence on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @05:28PM (#742245)
I know employees at Cost Plus World Market headquarters are stuck using IE6.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by bmelton on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @09:04PM (#742579)
In a lot of cases (including mine), IT operators are working with zero budget. While there's the obvious argument that upgrading from a free browser to another free browser doesn't cost any money, it does cost time; I work at a federal agency in which their web applications HAVE to work, and unfortunately, many of them were written for IE6. Rewriting those applications to support a new browser isn't free either.

In addition that that, there is time spent securing the installation. In the case of IE it's a little easier as I can manage it with policies, but it is absolutely critical that we're following DOD stigs regarding security, and setting up a central policy isn't free.

Regarding the PC comment, the laptop I replaced a month ago was a 1.0Ghz Pentium with 512M RAM. This was the upgraded laptop at the time, that I needed for java development. Compiling code with 512M on XP was adventurous. For the last 8 months I had it, the internal LCD had died, most of the keys didn't work, the WiFi radio was completely dead, and the power button would only work if I wiggled the frame and monitor. I made sure to use it on a plugged-in (ethernet network) to bypass the WiFi, plugged into an external monitor to get around the LCD, grabbed an external keyboard to type on, and wiggled it every day to power it on.

Before deeming it dead, they replaced the motherboard 3 times and the hard drive twice. I kept using the decrepit old machine because frankly, it was the nicest laptop anyone had on the team. They're refreshing the machines now, but we've only had IE7 in the environment for about a month. I am lucky in that I can use Firefox, but only within the firewall, and not at all to browse any external sites.

Sorry, I kind of got off on a tangent here, but it's perfectly reasonable to understand that there ARE in fact reasons why it takes a long time to get off of IE6.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by cakesy on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @10:38PM (#742716)
I have worked at a place like this. You clearly have never worked for a large bank, or financial institution. Or a company that has a lot of internal processes designed for ie6/active-x. It is great, like stepping back into the past, but not the good past of dinosaurs or gladiators, but the shit past of 6 years ago, when we didn't know any better. You no longer want to use a computer at home, since you are constantly reminded of the shit you are using at work.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by clistctrl on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:39PM (#742119)
They're people who work in firms that have intranet applications that were written specifically for IE6. Its cheaper to keep the browser than update some very badly written software.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:41PM (#742124)
Sorry, that's not an excuse. IE 8 comes with a "compatibility mode" feature where any site can choose to use the IE 6 rendering engine by setting headers or meta tags appropriately.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by dmm on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @08:27PM (#742514)
That feature was taken out of IE8 before release.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by jmtulloss on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @04:49PM (#742149)
That was an excuse until fairly recently. IE8 is pretty new to the scene, and hopefully this feature will allow corporations to upgrade.
Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by jodrellblank on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @08:18PM (#742495)
Sorry, that's not an excuse

I wasn't aware that companies needed an 'excuse' for not putting time and effort into a project they don't care about.

Re:YC startups unite to drive nail into the coffin of Intern... by drusenko on Tuesday August 04, 2009 @08:59PM (#742567)
They don't -- we're trying to give them a reason to care.