I feel like this lecturer is recognising that lecturers appear to add more value if they deliberately hinder students from accessing resources outside of their lectures. That's not a good thing.
All the conclusions seem bad if you set learning as the goal: I disagreed with the suggestions that the slides shouldn't make sense and that students shouldn't be able to read ahead.
If the students are reading ahead, they are better able to interact with the material ahead. That's a good thing.
The goal of the teacher is to help the students learn the subject matter: it's not right to think that they can only do that by paying close attention to your every entertaining word at the time you elect to say it.
When I held the course for Infosec 101, I made sure that everyone on the course knew two things on the first day:
1) slideware was NOT the study material, they were complementing the lectures and acted only as memory aids
2) the exam was deliberately designed and scored so that it could not be passed by merely trying to learn from the slideware
That gave the students two options. Either attend the lectures and read up on some of the external course material, or try to read all of the listed material and figure out what I'm going to emphasise in the exam. Most of them decided to attend. It probably helped that I was happily cultivating the legend of me being completely loose cannon and able to pull off pretty much any kind of stunt if it helped to make the material more memorable.
It worked too.
My goal was to actively discourage all kinds of rote learning, and require real understanding instead.
Or you could have just sent out an email stating what would be emphasized on the exam.
Confusing the two roles is the main problem with PowerPoints today.
The slideshow should act as a visual aid to great teaching, rather than trying to replace it. I liked the idea that the slideshow alone should be nonsensical.
The instructor-expert can add flavour and understanding to the slides, and expound upon the points being made, but the slides should also stand alone as a resource.
A lecturer should appreciate that it's impossible to absorb a complex topic during a lecture, and provide resources that later complement what they are saying.
No. that's the point. Slides have one purpose only - to help the student during the talk. Attempting to make them dual-purpose, namely....
>Students generally do refer to slides after lectures,
Is to end up with the worst of both worlds. If the lecturer wants to distribute notes or a transcript after the lecture, that'a what they should do.
> but the slides should also stand alone as a resource.
Nope
A lecturer should appreciate that it's impossible to absorb a complex topic during a lecture, and provide resources that later complement what they are saying.
> yes - just not in the for, of slides.
It's a difficult task to make one set to an adequate standard, so I was assuming you would use one set for both jobs (as seems to be the case in higher ed courses I'm familiar with).
Andrew Ng's Machine Learning lecture notes are world famous.
TL;DR: If you are making a slide-deck for an in-person presentation and also expect it to be a stand-in for you in your absence, then you are doing it wrong!
If you doubt that students need help to avoid poor choices, consider how common cheating is, and how much effort we put into making it less rewarding for them.
It's a fact that if you put all the class notes online, some students will not come to class, thus you did not do them a favour.
Is there a place between text notes for people who learn from text and live lectures for people who need interaction that is best filled with a video? Are there actually people in that place?
Neither does it provide the interaction of a live event nor the depth and individual pacing of the written word.
BEST CLASS EVER. I went to almost all of the lectures, but when I got home the video was usually already online - so if I missed something during the lecture, no worries, I could go back and rewatch it. IT WAS AWESOME.
Slides are terrible though - the problem is that it takes forever to make really good slides. I've seen it done before, and when it's done right it's a real piece of art, but 99% of the time slides are copied/made in haste and then the teacher just reads them off in class too quickly.
The only plus side to slides is you don't have to read the teacher's awful writing that is usually too small on a board that's too small for the giant room.
If I'd had videos, I could have watched them at 2x, paused when I needed to to go do some sketching or googling, and learned more in the same amount of time because I was directing my own learning and not limited to somebody else's linear encoding of ideas into words.
I could come up with a plausible scenario where everytime I try to learn from videos, pause and google something - I constantly receive mis-information and half-truths which confuse me further and cause me to google more random things. In this case I need to attend lectures so that I can interact with an established expert on the topic and ask questions 'live'.
We need both formats.
The medium is the message, if the medium is slides plus presenter, the lecture needs to be recorded.
We are at this amazing point in history where the avenues for communication currently outstrip our ability to use them. We should all be finding ways to fill that gap.
No, it would not. Making useless work where none is needed is wrong, so there is no reason to artificially constrain students to being present. If a student is able to learn perfectly from a textbook and notes and other resources, or better yet, a video recording of the lecture, and is able to pass the tests and do the homework to prove they are indeed learning successfully, then there is no problem.
If you have to force students to attend lectures for the sole purpose of justifying the existence of your job, then your job should not exist.