News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by georgemcbay on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:13PM (#7357203)
While I do feel bad for this guy's current situation (he clearly doesn't want any attention... sort of like the bitcoin Satoshi...hmm!), I really don't understand why so many people are jumping to the conclusion that this story is wrong/fake/some sort of conspiracy or whatever.

If there were a reasonable way to settle it for sure, I'd bet a substantial amount of money that this is the bitcoin Satoshi Nakamoto. The pieces laid out fit pretty well. I think there's a lot of weird denial going on because people built up this crazy fantasy of an assumed identity, highly advanced mathematician guy and learning the dude's real name is actually Satoshi Nakamoto and he's a pretty regular joe (for a near recluse) is causing a cognitive dissonance.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by VMG on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:18PM (#7357226)
If you look at the internet comments of Dorian Nakamoto, it is obvious that he is not the same person that wrote the whitepaper or participated in the bitcoin forums: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1zpuer/the_newsweek...

His skill level is completely different.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by Phlarp on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:27PM (#7357278)
Some of those links show him speaking in broken english with obvious misspellings, others are well structured and make him seem very obviously technically adept and attentive to at least hobbyist standards.

"Hi Nilayam,

1. Which wheels have spokes and how many spokes for each wheel? My UK built Pearse's 2-6-4 in 15mm/ft (1/20.3 scale) has all the wheels as solid disc (no spokes) and I'm wondering if this is true on the real prototype's Kitson locomotives of the same class, such as the 4-8-4 shown in your photos.

2. What were the thickness of the tyres? I think the thickness should be 4.5" or 4.75" for a 2ft 6inch gauge track with 5" diam. axles?

If you can get close up photos of the wheels, that'll be great. The L&M's truck wheels were 1 ft 11 inches and the drivers were 2 ft 6 inches I believe.

Dorian Nakamoto USA"

While these differences in writing style aren't conclusive in either direction; it does indicate that he is at least aware of how he conveys information online.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by Steko on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:27PM (#7357274)
The idea that these reddit links are some kind of smoking gun is a bad case of rationalizing.

FWIW, my Father in law is a first generation Asian immigrant who is an engineer and for whom English is a second language.

His emails to my wife are like the one above - broken English, poor grammar.

But I've seen some documents that he's written for work - the early stages of patent applications, for instance - and they read like someone else wrote them, even though my FIL is the one who wrote them as they'd yet to have been submitted internally. Proper grammar, more formal prose. There is, every now and then, a phrase or word that seems out of place and not something a natural speaker would say, but the difference between in grammar between work and personal emails is night and day.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by VMG on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:33PM (#7357313)
the burden of proof is on those who make the extremely unlikely claim that the person who painstakingly tried to hide his identity used his real name, communicates in native-level english on the Bitcoin forums and purposefully communicates in low-level English on all other internet forums.

Does not make any sense at all.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by georgemcbay on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:37PM (#7357329)
From where I'm sitting the burden of proof is on those who claim he ever painstakingly tried to hide his identity. To me it looks like someone who doesn't like a lot of personal attention (something I can certainly relate to) creating something to scratch an intellectual itch and that thing grew far larger than he imagined, so he bowed out.

I see no proof that he is someone who was planning complete anonymity from the start, that seems to me like a bolted on rationalization from people confused by his partial disappearing act.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by VMG on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:48PM (#7357371)
The newsweek article itself claims that Satoshi tried to hide his identity.

He never posted any personal information and used an anonymous japanese registration service for the bitcoin.org domain, payment in cash. An unlikely effort for somebody who doesn't care about anonymity.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by georgemcbay on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:12PM (#7357497)
The article quotes Gavin Andresen as saying "He went to great lengths to protect his anonymity.", but other than that doesn't offer anything to show that he actually was actively trying to hide his identity or was ever using a pseudonym.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by VMG on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:30PM (#7357592)
In that case, why is there no track record of a programmer named Satoshi Nakamoto on the internet?

All we have is a track record of a model train hobbyist Dorian Nakamoto.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by gwern on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:44PM (#7357667)
If it helps a bit: Satoshi Nakamoto sent all emails over Tor, connected to Bitcointalk over Tor, and paid through the nose for bitcoin.org registrar & hosting services on Anonymousspeech.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by Steko on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:41PM (#7357340)
Somehow you've mistaken life for a courtroom where we all need to meet the same standard of proof. I don't care what your burden of proof is, the preponderance of the evidence to me says that this is the guy. Now if Newsweek comes out and retracts the fairly unambiguous quotes we saw earlier I'm more than happy to change my views.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by georgemcbay on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:31PM (#7357305)
There is substantial variation in those samples themselves let alone between those samples and the bitcoin whitepaper. Some of them are written like bad text messages and some are perfect but awkwardly formal, and some are perfectly conversational. If those posts were consistent and at odds with his bitcoin writing (on the forums -- including the whitepaper is silly, virtually everyone writes differently for 'formal' papers) maybe they'd be decent proof, but they are all over the map.

Also, how about adding this link to this list:

https://www.national-preservation.com/threads/preserved-bars...

Another Dorian post on trains which is in a lot of ways remarkably similar to the bitcoin guy's writing.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by sktrdie on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:28PM (#7357282)
This other comment by the same Dorian shows that he's capable of writing better english: https://www.national-preservation.com/threads/preserved-bars...
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by hnha on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:24PM (#7357258)
or he just manages multiple online identities? It's not hard, especially if you are smart...
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by krick on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:59PM (#7357438)
Well, yes, of course it causes cognitive dissonance. It is 2014 year now and buzz around his personality is going for a pretty long time already. Both virtual and that one Satoshi-s are said to be worried about anonimity, using VPN to send emails, etc. And yet it is said he used his real name all this time. And being discovered only now by some journalist. Seriously, it is weird just by itself, not mentioning all these little discrepancies in their appearing personalities.

And both "Satoshi" and "Nakamoto" are fairly common japanese name and surname by the way, so I doubt if this one is really the only programmer Satoshi Nakamoto.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by georgemcbay on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:07PM (#7357470)
I think it is only being discovered now because nobody really looked before, at least not in the sense of actual research and journalism as opposed to googling some shit and doing a blog post.

I wouldn't be surprised if there are other programmers named Satoshi Nakamoto. McBay is a fairly uncommon name and I'm not even the only programmer named George McBay and the other one (who as far as I know isn't directly related in any way) is from Japan! Small world!

But that aside it isn't just the tech/math background, it is the total picture as laid out in the article. Unless the article is totally fabricated, which I have no reason to believe it is, the case it makes is pretty compelling.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by krick on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:31PM (#7357599)
Nobody looked before, really? Speculation about "who is Satoshi Nakamoto" has been around for years now, except previous Satoshi-s weren't called that and were suspected based on their deeds in field of cryptography. Wikipedia [1] mentions 6 of them and I've heard of more.

And "journalism" (professional one) usually makes me suspect making up random stuff much more than anything else. They are paid to make scandalous articles, you know.

To be fair, I don't personally claim it is fake. I say it is weird and makes me easily accept someone claiming it is fake.

[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satoshi_Nakamoto

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by DennisP on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:36PM (#7357618)
I don't really have an opinion on Satoshi, but I don't think it's all that hard to cherrypick details from someone's life to give whatever overall impression you want.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by kkwok on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:22PM (#7357243)
It's very possible it is him.

That said, I don't think the cognitive dissonance is because of some crazy fantasy however. The creator of bitcoin clearly went to some great lengths to avoid people knowing his actual identity. Given this, it seems very odd for them to have used their real name in all communication.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by argumentum on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:49PM (#7357381)
How can I take you up on that bet?

This is the first time I've seen reddit (since it's become a mainstream phenomenon) be more reasonable than hacker news.

http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1zpuer/the_newsweek...

> The pieces laid out fit pretty well.

What pieces? That he's kind of odd, according to his family? (if you were to take my family, which is fairly normal, 1/2 of us think the other 1/2 are odd). Who doesn't have an odd, reclusive uncle or two?

That he made a vague, difficult to interpret statement (and proceeded afterwards to completely deny any connection between himself and bitcoin)?

That he's "libertarian" according to his estranged daughter (though the following quote doesn't sound libertarian at all to me):

> Then Dorian also wrote about “being tired” about another issue: “I’m really tired of having the JACL, et al. requesting or getting $100K to millions in government funds for Japanese American monuments, about the camps or any other issue. Those money should be send on the JA’s practical needs and growth for the new generations. More dollars should be funded for startup businesses, business education, nursing services (yes, forget Keiro with high self salaries) and all they talk about is executive orders, camps, never about the betterment of JAs on their current living conditions or betterment of young ones going out to the world of business, competitions, financial education, etc.

That it was written in Newsweek? Here is an actual quote from the article:

> Of course, there is also the chance "Satoshi Nakamoto" is a pseudonym, but that raises the question why someone who wishes to remain anonymous would choose such a distinctive name.

What a shoddy piece of journalism. The authors of the Federalist Papers (Madison, Hamilton and Jay) used the pseudonym Publius. At least that name is really distinctive, in that no one was actually named that, unlike "Satoshi Nakamoto" seems like a common enough name for (also according to the article) there to be "several" living "Satoshi Nakamotos".

EDIT: I expect to get a lot of up votes now thanks to this :) :

In an exclusive two-hour interview with The Associated Press Dorian S. Nakamoto, 64, said he had never heard of Bitcoin until his son told him he had been contacted by a reporter three weeks ago.

Reached at his home in Temple City, Calif., Nakamoto acknowledged that many of the details in Newsweek's report are correct, including that he once worked for a defense contractor. But he strongly disputes the magazine's assertion that he is "the face behind Bitcoin." http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/U/US_BITCOIN_FOUNDER_DE...

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by Hieroglyph on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:18PM (#7357534)
> How can I take you up on that bet?

Creating the bet with Counterpartyǂ.

Step 1. Establishing 'Dorian Prentice Satoshi Nakamoto' trustless P2P betting feed

    counterpartyd broadcast --help
    counterpartyd broadcast --source='SOURCE_ADDRESS' \
                            --text='[BINARY] Dorian Prentice Satoshi Nakamoto is Satoshi Nakamoto, the creator of Bitcoin, by his own admission or indisputable evidence on or before June 21, 2014' \
                            --value='1' \
                            --fee-fraction='0.1'
Step 2. Placing bets

    counterpartyd bet --source='SOURCE_ADDRESS' \
                      --feed-address='FEED_ADDRESS' \
                      --bet-type='Equal/NotEqual' \
                      --wager='10' \
                      --counterwager='10' \
                      --target-value='1' \
                      --leverage='5040' \
                      --deadline='6,21,2014'
[ǂ]: https://counterparty.co
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by meowface on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:23PM (#7357555)
Unfortunately it may be very hard, or take a very long time, to either confirm or deny this claim. What is the standard of evidence for the bet to be won or lost?

For the record I strongly believe Newsweek got it wrong, and that he's the wrong guy.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by Steko on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:59PM (#7357437)
"What a shoddy piece of journalism."

You base this conclusion on one line of speculation in the article? Did you miss the part where the journalist flew out, went to the person's house and spoke to them to confirm it was really him before running the story? Sounds like excellent journalism to me.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by argumentum on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:05PM (#7357459)
Yeah I did miss that part. From what I read, the journalist spoke to him for about 15 seconds, within which he didn't really say anything at all, and was then shown the metaphorical door.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by Steko on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:48PM (#7357688)
> didn't really say anything at all

I guess we've reached the point in the argument where you've decided to go Flat Earth Society on us. For the record:

"I am no longer involved in that and I cannot discuss it," he says, dismissing all further queries with a swat of his left hand. "It's been turned over to other people. They are in charge of it now. I no longer have any connection."

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by VMG on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:58PM (#7357751)
Some more records:

In an exclusive two-hour interview with The Associated Press Dorian S. Nakamoto, 64, said he had never heard of Bitcoin until his son told him he had been contacted by a reporter three weeks ago.

http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/U/US_BITCOIN_FOUNDER_DE...

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by Steko on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:27PM (#7358157)
I don't deny he's now saying this. That's the substantial difference: argumentum is saying he earlier "didn't really say anything at all" which is frankly baloney.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by argumentum on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:31PM (#7358170)
Funny you read "Dorian S."'s earlier quote and see something, I read it and see nothing. Or actually, not nothing, just not something that means anything.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by krick on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:20PM (#7357541)
That part about "distinctive name" actually sound like shoddy piece of journalism. It's like calling "John Smith" distinctive. But while "John Smith" means nothing for native speaker, Satoshi (if written like 聡) can be interesting pen-name, meaning "wise" (google translate won't help you this time, so check http://jisho.org/kanji/details/%E8%81%A1 ).
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by mahranch on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:48PM (#7357691)
That doesn't mean much though. Every Japanese kanji used in a name means something on its own. Since they're used in names, they all are technicially "interesting". When people tell other people their names in Japan, they will often say how it's written in Kanji specifically to point out those distinctive meanings.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by krick on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:07PM (#7357793)
I know every kanji means something ("meaning something" is something kanji are made for, you know) and Satoshi (the Satoshi, I mean) never wrote his name in kanji by the way. But 中本聡 is something more "bitcoin-ish" than some 山本ヒロト, don't you think? So that name isn't really something unlikely to make up. I'd say randomly making it up is really really more likely than being the Satoshi's real name.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by joesmo on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:05PM (#7358059)
Missed the part that doesn't exist? Yes.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by gamblor956 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:59PM (#7357436)
The linguistic analysis actually holds up pretty well (both his writing style and his coding style), and the totality of the circumstances wherein Satoshi matches Bitcoin Satoshi makes it very unlikely that this is a "shoddy piece of journalism."

Also, you must not have read the part of the article where the journalist runs through and describes why the other Satoshis are not the Bitcoin Satoshi.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by argumentum on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:23PM (#7357556)
What "linguistic analysis"? What "coding style"? Was any actual code written by "Dorian S. Nakamoto" presented?

Where is some evidence he even knows how to program?

From the links on Reddit, which are the only pieces of writing that can be confirmed for "Dorian", I see absolutely no similarity with the style of the bitcoin paper. None, at all.

> describes why the other Satoshis are not the Bitcoin Satoshi

Where is this? She says "Dorian" was the only plausible Satoshi, and proceeds to use interviews and the absence of any hard evidence as evidence. It's like a creationist saying "how come there are no fossils of the missing link"?

Here's why it's shoddy journalism:

The process also requires a good amount of math, something at which Nakamoto - and his entire family - excels. The eldest of three brothers who all work in engineering and technical fields,

The only "evidence" that the family "excels" in math is that they work in engineering or technical fields. No papers published, nothing except that a couple of them worked at Hughes aircraft (including Dorian S.).

My mom is actually an engineer at Raytheon and before that Hughes. She had to get national security clearance and her work there can be described similarly. I'm sure many HN users have had to get security clearance. It's not that big a deal. Though my whole family consists of engineers, and even some professors, I would not particularly describe us as "excelling" in math. That is probably true for a lot of HN users as well.

And even if you were to make such a claim, it is in and of itself no evidence that this Satoshi is the Satoshi. On the other hand, if he had been publishing cryptography papers or game theory papers or even CS papers for a while, or even demonstrated any interest at all in cryptography similar to his interest in model trains ..

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by VMG on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:11PM (#7357492)
If this person is the Real Satoshi, why are all forum posts except the ones bitcointalk.org about model trains and Royal Danish Cookies?

Not a single post in any programming forum, not a single stackoverflow question, zero online participation in anything related to cryptography or programming.

If we are to believe that the developer of Bitcoin didn't mind using his real name online, what's the explanation for this?

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by gwern on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:43PM (#7357662)
> If this person is the Real Satoshi, why are all forum posts except the ones bitcointalk.org about model trains and Royal Danish Cookies?

Dorian seems to have fragmented his online activity under a variety of nicknames: so far people've found "ShtenDoji", "schten", "Schten Dohkji", "WagumaBher", and "ssshupring" (and I'm not sure if that's a complete collation of Redditor findings). Most of them have been linked either by him forthrightly mentioning Satoshi, or are variants of others. We could easily have missed years of programming activity. So it's not yet a strong argument from silence.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by wpietri on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:54PM (#7358005)
> How can I take you up on that bet?

Might I suggest http://longbets.org/ for this? To make it legal in the US, the money ends up going to a charity of your choice, but it's a great way to put something on the record.

Note: Shameless promotion for something I wrote code for.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by argumentum on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:12PM (#7358084)
I actually saw your website earlier, after reading tlb* 's predictions on his website which linked to yours.

Always thought it was a great idea, because I always make predictions and wish I could prove I did so to friends/enemies ;)

* trevor blackwell, yc founder/partner

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by joe_the_user on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:14PM (#7357510)
Oh god,

The worst thing is that this could be a ploy to force the real bitcoin founder to show himself/herself - implicitly their threatening to keep screwing-up random people's lives.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by lotsofmangos on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:03PM (#7357451)
You are betting against something like the chance of there being a Satoshi Nakamoto who is not involved in writing bitcoin, but may have done something else using bitcoin that makes him not want to talk to the press enough to spook a newsweek reporter.

I don't think I know enough either way to make a good bet and I'm not sure that reporter does either.

Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by joesmo on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:03PM (#7358054)
The denial going on is because there is no proof (thus your invitation to a bet). I find it hard to believe (read impossible) that Newsweek was the first person to have thought of looking through public records to find him.
Re:Alleged Bitcoin Creator Satoshi Nakamoto Denies Bitcoin I... by InclinedPlane on Thursday March 06, 2014 @07:58PM (#7357750)
This right here is like a case study in why a "Computer Science" education doesn't make one a "scientist".

The only thing here is coincidence, allegation, and innuendo: There's not the slightest hint of proof. This is shitty journalism and shitty investigative rigor. What it comes down to is a name and being smart.

Maybe he is the actual bitcoin Satoshi. But there is not one piece of positive evidence that is the case. Everything is circumstancial to the highest degree. Personally I think the standard of evidence for something this important should be higher.