I think the thing that killed me was that it was closed source.
The last thing I want in my professional career is ANOTHER thing trying to lock me in.
So I use emacs.
I don't really get all the IDE hype outside of what I consider to be the big 3 required ones (due to vendor restrictions or in AS's case, isn't Eclipse): VS, XCode, and Android Studio.
For the rest, it seems that vi and emacs do what would be needed, and work on everything. Why not just improve on those two products instead of making new ones that are simply short lived fads?
While I get why new editors pop up, and really, I'm glad we have people trying to innovate and introduce new ideas, I'm ultimately more interested in stuff like the Neovim project, for this reason.
I will say it's nice when someone creates a new product that has a killer feature or two, because some form of that seems to make it's way back to vim/emacs pretty often.
I'm sure people said the same thing about vi/emacs when they came out.
OTOH I don't know if that's the case for vim, which is what people seem to mean these days when they talk about vi.
vim also has a pretty horrible codebase. horrible not because bad developers are working on it. horrible because of historical reasons. but neovim is actually in the process of doing what everyone said nobody could do.
He didn't say it was vim. You took it as your opportunity to express your Opinion, since he mentioned something you care about, but just look like the kid in class raising his hand as high as he can yelling "Me! Me! Pick me!".
Pay attention.
The general population of HN seems to cares enough to upvote them (original post has 1300pts which is high) so either write an extension to block them or just ignore them and upvote other articles. GitHub has a lot of good will with people who read HN so of course articles about them will be popular. See: whenever GitHub goes down.
Same thing happens with bitcoins and pretty much any other popular topic.
With the risk of sounding like a prick, I share this sentiment. People who like to hack their editors already use vim/emacs. Those who don't, are happy with whatever they're using.
Sublime Text proved exactly how quick a closed source editor can fall out of favor with people. Its 3rd iteration wasn't even released, and you already hear as much complaint about it as praise.
Seriously though, the fact that:
It's closed source
It's Mac only
Written in Javascript
Painfully slow (compared to Vim)
probably don't matter much for many HN users. The things that do matter (powerful text manipulation, batch editing, block editing, multi-select, etc) are being handled by this editor. That's fine.Please don't show up and start saying "STOP LIKING THINGS I DON'T LIKE!!". It's not helping.
Have you read the article you are commenting on? It talks about the exact opposite:
> Compared to Atom the search [in Textmate] is blazing fast.
> Doing regex searches in vim on that file is instant. The memory barely moves. Searching for the character d takes almost 10 seconds in Atom, and significantly increases memory usage. When I say significantly, I'm talking 200 megs.
That doesn't mean powerful anything to me. Especially not text manipulation.
EDIT: Also, I don't care if people actually like things. What bothers me is blind fanboyism/praise for something people used for 2 days at the max.
For instance, I messed around with sublime text and I really dug how it handled multiple cursors. I'd never say something like vim couldn't do that, but sublime (for me) made multiple cursors seem intuitively powerful and useful, in that I could perform quick operations in seconds that I wouldn't have thought to perform in that way before.
I'd say it's similar to me if you were to compare regex find/replace with normal find/replace. It's a more powerful/flexible idea. Whether or not it's a good one is up for grabs.
That said, the speed does sound like it could be a problem. I just don't think power text manipulation is referencing processing efficiency.
I'm wondering how the efficiency of this setup is played out in stuff like Light Table and Brackets, which seem pretty similar (I think the front end on those is just html? I could be totally wrong). And like I said, so far I'm way more interested in neovim than any of the newer other browsers.
I'm playing around with React (and Om, Quiscient etc) at the moment and it's by far the nicest UI model I've ever encountered. If I could get Cassowary working reasonably fast too it would be miles ahead of anything else.
The only thing that I don't see improving soon is not having shared memory threads (or even zero-copy messaging). Webworkers are all well and good but sometimes the serialisation overhead is still enough to block the UI. thread.
Re: Web workers, this probably isn't news to you but you can use transferable objects [1] to eliminate the serialization hiccup. Of course, if you're really trying to share objects across threads in real time, rather than transfer data, parse, and fire events, you may have bigger issues.
1. https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Guide/Performan...
It's a pretty sad state of affairs when "painfully slow" doesn't matter.
I disagree. Speed is the biggest thing that matters to me, the reason I switched to SublimeText couple years ago and still am using it right now is because it's blazing fast (especially ST3).
Right there.
Ahh, the anachronistic JS attacks... Right there.
Everyone, stop talking about stuff I don't like. Since I'm so self-absorbed that I can't possibly comprehend someone not having the exact same opinions as me, this is obviously some kind of marketing hype machine at work.
Did it ever occur to you that people react to big things from big companies? No, of course it didn't, which is why you came on here and threw a tantrum.
How about this: go back to proggit and stop whining here.
JavaScript is a great language but it won't get Atom to Emacs for the same reason that SICP in JavaScript peters out in chapter 2. The design tradeoffs in the language come due. What is rather surprising about Atom is that the great advantage of Browser+JavaScript+html, ease of cross platform development, is nowhere to be found in the initial release. What is perhaps more surprising however is that the only version is for Mac rather than that hacker's favorite, Linux.
I don't have anything against Atom, but for me it doesn't inherit Github's awesome sauce.
and people seem to keep rehashing the same conversation surrounding it.
I'm not surprised he's exasperated, but I'd hardly call it a rant.
Are we still seriously discussing a closed source, non-free, Mac only Sublime Text clone that was written in Javascript and as it turns out, is painfully slow?
Say what you will about Proggit, but at least the discussion there isn't all "OMG I can switch from Sublime now!!!". Jesus Christ.