I don't disagree with your comment, but your argument would seem to apply to the rest of the world, whereas in fact the US is in a fairly unique situation among developed countries.
Most of the current situation can be explained by the fact that broadband is currently the only unregulated public utility.
In NYC, I don't really pay much attention to electricity, gas, and water. ConEd kind of sucks, and I wish they were better, but really, they work well enough most of the time, and I'm not sure that I could name anybody else who would do it better.
The problem is that we sold off monopoly rights to broadband without attaching any strings of regulation, etc. Why should they bother to upgrade their infrastructure? Heck, we literally paid the cable companies billions of dollars of government money to do exactly that, and because we failed to enforce that with any real teeth, they just took the money and ran. Of course they're not going to listen when consumers say they "want gigabit". It would make no business sense to do otherwise, especially when 80% of your customers are unable to vote with their wallet and use a competing service[0].
There's a case to be made for either a free-market approach to broadband, or a more "socialized", regulated monopoly. Unfortunately, what we currently have is a hybrid of both, and it happens to hit upon the worst of both worlds.
[0] There's a South Park clip that does a great job of describing this relationship. I won't link to it here, because it's rather crude and possibly (?) a bit NSFW, but searching "south park cable" on Youtube should lead you to it if you want to laugh, sigh, and cry all at the same time.
This isn't a problem that is going to be solved by placing regulations on the industry. Your example of past subsidies provides an excellent argument for this: given the political clout these entities hold and have in the past used to stilt legislation in their favor, what leads us to believe we're going to do any better with new regulations?
At the end of the day, the market is demanding better internet service. While telecommunications providers are certain to wage war against the injection against honest competition into their sector, things are actually looking pretty good in my mind. The FCC sees market demand and is working to tear down anti-competitive legislative barriers [1]. Smaller efforts such as Google Fiber are doing the hard work of convincing the public that better service is within reach.
http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/02/20/fcc_s_pla...
Tom Wheeler, the new FCC Chairman, was a lobbyist and head of the NCTA for 5 years[1]. The idea that he will do anything to hurt the cable companies his old organization represents is ludicrous.
[1]http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/02/business/tom-wheeler-telec...
One point that caught my attention in an NPR report[1] on this dispute last week:
IHS's Broughton says there was a similar dispute in South Korea a few years ago, and it was ultimately arbitrated by the government.
I don't know the details of the South Korean dispute but I understand South Korea has pretty fast internet speeds.
http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2014/02/20/280255...
Would you like that as well?
Oh of course not. We want the great parts but to leave the bad parts. Sometimes it's a package deal. I'll take what we've got, thank you very much.
If the gov't views the internet as it's possession, then it can make sense for it to be both fast and censored.
It's irrelevant to the question of fast internet.
To reiterate, you're saying that censorship and fast internet are a package deal, and if we want fast internet, we have to deal with censorship, amirite?
It's an interesting way of thinking of things.
Yesterday I listened to a discussion comparing the less regulated and more stable banking system of Canada to the heavily regulated and crash prone US banking system. Everyone in the US says that they want Canada's banking system, it's a common refrain.
But do Americans want the political system which leads to such a banking system being implemented properly? As soon as you get to the Queen of England appointing US Senators, Americans tend to want to forget about the whole banking system thing.
I suppose the point is this: If you tell the US political system to implement Korea style fast and cheap internet, what you're going to end up with is something much different from what you wanted. The same political forces which got you to your current location will filter this legislation as well. And you may end up with something far worse than the status quo.
I don't know where the heck you're getting the nonsense about the Queen from either, the Canadian Prime Minister selects senators at his own discretion and the royal involvment in the process is just ceremonial.
I'm guessing that package deal means we'll also be having to eat pickled cabbage and end our sentences with verbs if we want decent Internet speeds? I just hope we won't have to drink bubble tea, that stuff is gross.
Well, yes - when I use the word "regulation", I'm implying the sort of regulation that we see with respect to Con Edison. They can't so much as change the way they itemize fees on my bill (!) without regulatory approval.
That certainly creates problems of another sort, but on the other hand, the actual service provided[0] and the pricing is pretty much a solved problem (as much as one can expect)[1].
I'm sure ConEd would like the sort of legislative protectionism that cable companies receive, with no requirements surrounding price or quality, but thankfully, they don't have that (and altering the status quo is always tough in general - in this case, inertia is on consumers' side).
Obviously regulation could be established to make things worse, but I think it's clear what kind of regulation we're looking for for the purposes of this discussion. And I'm intentionally deferring the question of how any of these policies would be enacted - I'm just comparing two alternatives states to the status quo.
[0] excluding customer service, which is going to be mediocre at best no matter what.
[1] Interestingly, pricing is partly "solved" due to the introduction of ESCOs, which are a way to privatize the supply chain (at the consumer's choice). "Free market" and "regulation" are not mutually exclusive - we could easily establish a regulated monopoly on last-mile copper wire while allowing multiple competing upstream providers.[2]
There are also other problems with your post. For example, we didn't sell off monopoly rights. Its been illegal for municipalities to grant exclusive franchises since 1992. Also, franchises don't come without strings attached. Here in Phila, Comcast has to run cable to a bunch of poor neighborhoods and charge $13 per month for service. Distribution requirements and regulated rates exist in the cable world.
[1] At the end if the day, if Google bought TWC instead, Google's average profit margin would go down.
I recently had Google Fiber installed. Every single person I've talked to about it has responded with something similar to "Oh man, I wish I had that!" (That includes my tech-illiterate mom and the guy who came to install it who lives in a different city.) Of course consumers want faster, cheaper Internet connectivity.
"They want somebody else to build the fat pipes crucial to their business. That's why Google fiber is a marketing and lobbying tool and not a real business."
So, Google actually does the thing you said they don't want to do, and your response is, "well sure, but they don't really mean it?"
From the FCC: "The United States is 26th out of 32 countries in the 15-25 Mbps speed tier (advertised) with an average stand-alone broadband plan price of $56.50. The lowest advertised price for stand-alone services is in Slovakia at $18, while the highest charges are found in Switzerland at $180"
Although they don't summarize the findings above 25 Mbps the story looks much worse.
With respect to availability: There is a world of difference between 1Gps@$1000/mth and 1Gps@$50/mth though both qualify as 1Gbps availability.
Finally >10Mbps is pretty broad bin today and fails to meaningfully differentiate "very" high speed services.
Instead, wired net connectivity has been overtaken by puny LTE...
And don't forget: The telegraph industry! Neal Stephenson writes about it in "Mother Earth, Mother Board:" http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/4.12/ffglass_pr.html , which is fascinating and worth reading.
On one side there are irritated customers wondering why their service is so poor and why their bills are so high
One other "don't forget": a lot of people who pay attention are unhappy about franchise agreements and telco efforts to prohibit local utility fiber deployments by outlawing them at the state level (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7271044). Local municipalities that say, "Fuck it, we're going to roll our own" often find themselves forbidden because of successful lobbying at the state level.
In this new world, internet access is the new road. Good internet access will generate new services/goods and encourage consumption by consumers. This will inevitably lead to snowball effect of creating more wealth for the society.
US shouldn't be held hostage by a few people in an executive suite in Philadelphia who want to make a few bucks so they can own a few extra mansions and a private jet or 2. US is a greater country than that.
Furthermore, afaik many small towns even in eastern europe(while making great strides, no particularly huge cities) boast 100 mbit connections.
Assuming both of those statements are true, It doesn't seem to me like the economies of scale argument is valid here.
EDIT: 100 mbit/$20, 500 mbit/$30, checked my ISP.
One of the first deployments of gigabit fiber in the U.S. was in Chatanooga TN, with a population density of 471.9/km2. New York City has a population density of 10,640/km2. Romania's third largest city, Timișoara, with population density of only 2,446.58/km2 is considered the city with the fastest internet in the world.
http://www.romania-insider.com/romanian-city-comes-out-first...
Everybody talks about the last mile being the most expensive part of infrastructure, but if the last meter is 90% of the cost of the last mile (I don't know what the exact proportion is, but it is definitely close), then 100 houses in 10 sq km census block is going to be in a cost category that is orders of magnitude higher than 100 apartments in a tower with a 9.9 sq km park around it.
It sure as heck doesn't explain why there's no gigabit FTTH in Manhattan proper--by your reckoning the borough should have a residential density even higher than its overall average would suggest by virtue of Central Park taking up so much of the upper half.
Unless you're saying that urban and suburban America each lack FTTH for their own wholly unrelated reasons, an explanation that seems rather lacking in parsimony.
This is a commonly repeated argument in favor of the status-quo in the US, and I'm just trying to refute it whenever possible.
It depends on where you are. Two different apartment buildings in DC or NYC could differn, one getting FIOS and the other on a congested cable network or low-speed phone company DSL circuit.
But don't get the idea that the internet is generally terrible in the USA. I'd imagine my situation is similar to most others - I live in a smaller town (population < 50,000) and about 90 miles from the nearest 'big' city (Detroit), but for $39.99 I get 30mb cable internet which I'm more than happy with. They offer 60mb and 100mb packages but I don't see the sense in spending any more.
The old NYC infrastructure and all of the physical work (and permits, contracts, everything else) means a huge overhaul would most likely not be worth doing in dense and already wired places like these.
Also rayiner pointed out in another thread that according to Akamai the US already is pretty high up in the list of overall bandwidth. Also I think the HN / Reddit / tech echo chamber overplays the demand for gigabit internet. Most of America has no need for this, nor the willingness to pay for a connection this fast. 10-25 Mb is fine for most people. Browse Facebook, surf the web, stream a couple of movies, play games.
As for the remainder--well of course they're not making use of a service that they have no way to buy in the first place...and your insinuations remind me of the people in the early 19th century who howled that the first locomotives' 10 mph crusing speed was far faster than any sane person would ever want to travel.
And I haven't noticed the U.S. public rallying in horrified opposition to faster internet speeds in a big way. Or at all, really.
This is a common misconception. When it comes to actually using technology, the Japanese are at least a decade behind the West, thanks to their aging, collectivist, and risk-averse society. Fax machines continue to be widely used[0].
The primary difference is that in Japan, the government nationalized the last mile, resulting in a ton of competition. You can pick between a dozen ISPs in Tokyo.
0: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/14/world/asia/in-japan-the-fa...
Of course, I'm with Cablevision - when most of the city is limited to TWC.
It's not that I want/need gigabit, it's that the only thing I can get in some locations is unusable. I'm looking at you, 1.5mb/768k DSL lines. It's barely enough for web surfing and useless for streaming video or doing things like gaming, video conferencing....
Trouble is, this business model severely discourages new development (witness the "No one wants gigabit" rationale). Why interrupt your twenty year plan just to extend its life a year or two into the future? This isn't a bad thing if your industry is basically a utility industry, where technological changes move at a glacial pace. God help you if you enter into the technology industry armed only with the economic and managerial tools of a utility juggernaut.
So we've got ourselves a conflict. On one side there are irritated customers wondering why their service is so poor and why their bills are so high. On the other there are communications utilities providers: while they have a legitimate business need to keep their networks profitable, they are paying the price for committing the gravest sin possible in the technology world: complacency.