News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by jfasi on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:09PM (#7292747)
I disagree in terms of regulation: there is plenty of regulation on broadband internet, except it tends to discourage competition against broadband providers.

This isn't a problem that is going to be solved by placing regulations on the industry. Your example of past subsidies provides an excellent argument for this: given the political clout these entities hold and have in the past used to stilt legislation in their favor, what leads us to believe we're going to do any better with new regulations?

At the end of the day, the market is demanding better internet service. While telecommunications providers are certain to wage war against the injection against honest competition into their sector, things are actually looking pretty good in my mind. The FCC sees market demand and is working to tear down anti-competitive legislative barriers [1]. Smaller efforts such as Google Fiber are doing the hard work of convincing the public that better service is within reach.

http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/02/20/fcc_s_pla...

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by abvdasker on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:32PM (#7292878)
It's highly unlikely that the FCC will accomplish much in the way of enforcing net nutrality given that the agency has basically been captured by special interest.

Tom Wheeler, the new FCC Chairman, was a lobbyist and head of the NCTA for 5 years[1]. The idea that he will do anything to hurt the cable companies his old organization represents is ludicrous.

[1]http://www.nytimes.com/2013/05/02/business/tom-wheeler-telec...

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by klenwell on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:41PM (#7292955)
What leads me to believe we'll do better with new regulations? The belief, as chimeracoder suggests, that regulation can done right.

One point that caught my attention in an NPR report[1] on this dispute last week:

IHS's Broughton says there was a similar dispute in South Korea a few years ago, and it was ultimately arbitrated by the government.

I don't know the details of the South Korean dispute but I understand South Korea has pretty fast internet speeds.

http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2014/02/20/280255...

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by alexeisadeski3 on Monday February 24, 2014 @03:48PM (#7293341)
South Korea also has highly invasive internet censorship.

Would you like that as well?

Oh of course not. We want the great parts but to leave the bad parts. Sometimes it's a package deal. I'll take what we've got, thank you very much.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by brenschluss on Monday February 24, 2014 @03:52PM (#7293360)
South Korea's internet censorship has very little to do with their internet speeds. Saying "Well, if you want fast internet, it'll have to be censored" (as if our internet isn't fully monitored) is a false equivalence of the highest order.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by alexeisadeski3 on Monday February 24, 2014 @04:11PM (#7293433)
Monitoring =/ censorship

If the gov't views the internet as it's possession, then it can make sense for it to be both fast and censored.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by brenschluss on Monday February 24, 2014 @04:48PM (#7293626)
Well perhaps this may be the case in some scenarios, but that doesn't mean that the internet can't be censored when internet infrastructure is private, either. p = internet is public infrastructure q = censorship for some (but not all) p -> q for some (but not all) ¬p -> q q -> irrelevant

It's irrelevant to the question of fast internet.

To reiterate, you're saying that censorship and fast internet are a package deal, and if we want fast internet, we have to deal with censorship, amirite?

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by alexeisadeski3 on Monday February 24, 2014 @06:06PM (#7294025)
I'm saying that the political process which leads to things like gov't required fast internet may also lead to greater encroachment upon said internet.

It's an interesting way of thinking of things.

Yesterday I listened to a discussion comparing the less regulated and more stable banking system of Canada to the heavily regulated and crash prone US banking system. Everyone in the US says that they want Canada's banking system, it's a common refrain.

But do Americans want the political system which leads to such a banking system being implemented properly? As soon as you get to the Queen of England appointing US Senators, Americans tend to want to forget about the whole banking system thing.

I suppose the point is this: If you tell the US political system to implement Korea style fast and cheap internet, what you're going to end up with is something much different from what you wanted. The same political forces which got you to your current location will filter this legislation as well. And you may end up with something far worse than the status quo.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by reversi_online on Monday February 24, 2014 @11:51PM (#7295675)
Canada's banks were still under the equivalent of Glass-Steagall restrictions at the time, and the government had kept them on a very short leash in many other respects. Your analysis is 180 degrees removed fom reality.

I don't know where the heck you're getting the nonsense about the Queen from either, the Canadian Prime Minister selects senators at his own discretion and the royal involvment in the process is just ceremonial.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by alexeisadeski3 on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @06:04AM (#7296885)
Time for you to crack open our nation's history books!
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by reversi_online on Monday February 24, 2014 @04:21PM (#7293477)
Some things never change. I remember a article on South Korean broadband in Businessweek 15 years ago that ranted on about Seoul's paucity of elevators.

I'm guessing that package deal means we'll also be having to eat pickled cabbage and end our sentences with verbs if we want decent Internet speeds? I just hope we won't have to drink bubble tea, that stuff is gross.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by barrkel on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:21PM (#7292813)
You need to qualify your statements with "in the US", because regulation has been effective elsewhere.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by chimeracoder on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:36PM (#7292917)
> I disagree in terms of regulation: there is plenty of regulation on broadband internet, except it tends to discourage competition against broadband providers.

Well, yes - when I use the word "regulation", I'm implying the sort of regulation that we see with respect to Con Edison. They can't so much as change the way they itemize fees on my bill (!) without regulatory approval.

That certainly creates problems of another sort, but on the other hand, the actual service provided[0] and the pricing is pretty much a solved problem (as much as one can expect)[1].

I'm sure ConEd would like the sort of legislative protectionism that cable companies receive, with no requirements surrounding price or quality, but thankfully, they don't have that (and altering the status quo is always tough in general - in this case, inertia is on consumers' side).

Obviously regulation could be established to make things worse, but I think it's clear what kind of regulation we're looking for for the purposes of this discussion. And I'm intentionally deferring the question of how any of these policies would be enacted - I'm just comparing two alternatives states to the status quo.

[0] excluding customer service, which is going to be mediocre at best no matter what.

[1] Interestingly, pricing is partly "solved" due to the introduction of ESCOs, which are a way to privatize the supply chain (at the consumer's choice). "Free market" and "regulation" are not mutually exclusive - we could easily establish a regulated monopoly on last-mile copper wire while allowing multiple competing upstream providers.[2]