Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly
by saosebastiao on Monday February 24, 2014 @04:32PM
(#7293531)
Your use of statistics is meaningless because average density is meaningless. It suffers from the same resolution problem as the coastline paradox [1]. I'm an example of this: If you measure density by the block, I live in a density of 120,000 persons/km2, but if you measure density by the city, I live in a density of 1720 persons/km2, and if you measure density by the MSA, I live in a density of 168 persons/km2. I have gigabit, and the fact that I live in an MSA with 168 persons/km2 is in no way a refutation of the fact that density matters for infrastructure costs.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly
by brenschluss on Monday February 24, 2014 @04:52PM
(#7293654)
Saying average density is meaningless is like saying, because of the coastline paradox, even a small island's coastline is the same length as a large continent's coastline -- they're both infinite!
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly
by saosebastiao on Monday February 24, 2014 @08:07PM
(#7294512)
Correct. However, if you can define a level of resolution to measure the coastline/density, then then it can be compared. Average density/coastline is meaningless without context.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly
by brenschluss on Wednesday February 26, 2014 @02:34PM
(#7307073)
Great point.
This is a commonly repeated argument in favor of the status-quo in the US, and I'm just trying to refute it whenever possible.