The simple flaw in your argument is that you assume that these things are usually mutually exclusive. In fact, it is typically the opposite; they usually are one in the same. The things that are "best" for society also tend to make the most money. People pay for things because they want (or need [2])them, because it makes their lives better [1]. To extend this to investments, smart investments are investments to companies who will eventually make money, because their products are worth buying.
Investing money is an incredibly rewarding but very risky activity. Smart investments will make upwards of 100x ROI, bad ones will lose every penny. Having smart investors is an imperative to maximizing the usefulness of money. Just look at Solyndra ;)
1. since people are having trouble understanding how to interpret this sentence let me clarify. "Better" is completely subjective. For the purpose of making buying decisions, "better" is whatever the person making this buying decision defines as "better" for them. All in all the point of "better" not really being "better" is irrelevant (as it the distinction between want and need). If you want to make the argument that investors are investing in companies that actually make our lives worse, then the solution is typically banning those companies and products directly, not banning investments to those companies.
2. thanks to /u/revscat (yes I know this is not reddit)
When you have the money, you make the rules. That sums up the problem. Markets are not magical creatures, they exist within the context of social rules and norms. Selling human beings was once seen as rather profitable. Then society decided that selling human beings was wrong, even though it was profitable. You clearly understand this, we banned slavery, we didn't just ban investing in slavery-related businesses.
What I think you are missing is that there are a ton of things that are between "good for society" and something along the lines of slavery that is clearly a bad thing. The problem with these middle "bads" is that they aren't bad enough to be universally and energetically rejected.
This means that there is plenty of room for people with money to get these things made legal, or kept legal, and it is these things that often seem to be more profitable than other, more socially beneficial, activities (possibly because fewer people are morally willing and able to do them). I think of this sort of thing as "meta-competition" because it is competition among those with money to most efficiently turn their money into influence and power that can be used to allow them to make even more money.
As long as money can be converted to power, you can't assume, as you have done, that whatever is legal is socially beneficial (or at least not socially destructive).
More interestingly, society decided that slavery was wrong after it became unprofitable. The same goes for child labor.
Someone should really inform the human traffickers.
Modern human trafficking is prevalent in industries that are themselves illegal, so there isn't free market competition.
The problem with slave labor is considerable expense is necessary to guard them, and the slaves not only do as little as possible but they will actively sabotage the work.
Yes, the cost was huge - that's why stupid things like the Fugitive Slave Law and the Dred Scott Decision happened, leading to the failure of Whiggish Moderation and, well, you know the rest...
What drove slavery into the ... juggernaut it became was more that financial panics in the US ( and also even more globally ) destroyed so much cash value that slaves were all that was left of value when the tide went out.
I recommend the horribly-titled "A Nation of Deadbeats". It's narrative history, but wow its a good story. And at the same time, I bet financialization is completely critical to having the sort of standard of living we have now.
Child labor only became an issue when adult labor began to be idled.
The things that make the most money are the things most desired by the people with the most money to spend. That group of people can only be equated with "Society" if that group of people does in fact form the majority of the society. That's why a large middle class is so important, and why growing differences in income are so threatening.
People pay for things they want out of the choices they are aware of.
"Analysts" - politicians, Joe College, HN posters - tend to use an overly simplified economic model, based primarily on the "Turn Lemons into Lemonade" 3rd-grade economics primer they read as a child.
You can make an awful lot of money in the short term doing things that are horrible for society. Look at natural gas extraction by fracking - are we saying that polluting the water table, the air and ground in an is best?
Or look at the defense industry. The make a lot of money too. Is taking our great intelligence and devoting it to weapons and destruction best for society?
Best might be best for a small group, but is rarely best for society.
Yes, it's better than the alternatives. Cleaner and less CO2 than coal, cheaper than solar/wind/nuclear. It has never polluted the water table. For North American energy, what's better?
> Or look at the defense industry. Since the power WWII superpower era, death and destruction has gone way down. Overwhelming force and vastly superior weapons are making large scale wars a thing of the past. We are actually living in the most peaceful time of human history, from a bodycount perspective.
I agree too much money is spent on defense, but thats a political problem not a banking/investment problem.
Isn't that the opposite of things that are best for society making the most money, which was your original point? Wouldn't society be benefited almost infinitely more if it could harness an almost infinite supply of energy?
http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2014/01/05/some...
That's the first hit on a google search.
Your article simple says there are reports of pollution. Pollution != polluting the water table. All fossil fuel extraction creates pollution.
Hundreds of studies of been done, both public and private about fracking's risk of getting close to the water table. It's never proven to be true. The only study that suggests its possible is the Duke study, but it doesn't prove that it has happened.
This is a hot button issue around here. The water is monitored closely, there are no fracking chemicals showing up in the water tables.
More often than not, people pay for things because they must. Food is not optional, nor is clothing, shelter, or health care. For the majority of American population gasoline, auto insurance, and related transportation expenses are similarly non-optional. Similarly electricity and water. For much of the population you can add in child support or day care.
There is not much money, if any, left over for discretionary spending.
The point is that you seem to believe that all spending is voluntary. This is flatly not true, and smacks of willful ideological naïveté.
If you're interested in complex-systems theory, you can try out implementing various simple simulations yourself. It's actually pretty hard to come up with one, even with hilariously optimistic assumptions, where each agent individually optimizing actually leads to a globally optimal outcome! It's even pretty hard to come up with one that works in any reasonable sense at all: you quickly get swamped by system-endogenous effects and all sorts of weird oscillations and attractors that have nothing to do with the utility function. Fun times living in emergent-effects-land!
...when you don't have the mental apparatus necessary to perceive it. BTW, I'm not referring to intelligence.
(With apologies to Upton Sinclair)
2. (magic happens)
3. the greater good
What I've noticed is that two categories of people believe in such schemes: libertarians, and primary school children.
The "magic" is called "consumer surplus" and it's one of the few defensible things in macroeconomics. It's quite real.
The paradox is that explicitly trying to do things for the greater good very often backfires - although not always.
But as a "control law" - in the sense of running a distributed, massive system - self-interest produces measurably better results than Soviet-style central planning. This rests on information-theoretic foundations and it's early days yet. We're pathetic at macroeconomics, and it's a lot captured by both whim of the moment.
Of course, now we have a lot of hybrids, some that work much better than free markets, some that don't. That's quite new, assuming nothing bad happens to them.
Nope. I could really want a cigarette, bottle of alcohol, or a large cheese burger with 2 patties, doesn't mean it would make my life better. In fact, it's likely to make my life worse. So, really there isn't a flaw in grandparent post's argument, the things 'best' for society really don't tend to make the most money.
p.s. not actually, I should be working.
p.p.s see my note on my above comment for a proper response to this.
Stop right there. With jobs moving abroad and wage that is not going up, how would people pay for things they want.
There's a middle ground here. "Well-regulated market". Communists don't understand the market part (see Great Leap Forward) and Libertarians are idolators who think the market will automatically settle into the best thing for society if only we didn't have a government (see Somalia).
Amartya Sen has done a lot of research on this: the big factor that determines whether famines happen or not is less planning than it is democratic political structure.
I don't disagree with your conclusion about political structure, but if we're talking about pure collective planning with no reliance on private allocation of capital, that's never actually been done with a democratic political structure anyplace larger than a kibbutz. Democratic socialism, IMO, is much closer to well-regulated capitalism than it is to communism.
State-allocated capital without a private finance sector has failed miserably
It is completely wrong. It is a lie. You weren't obviously talking about a spectrum, you were talking crap.
The spectrum comment referred to the socialism/communism terminology, with socialism generally seen as involving a heavily-regulated free market and large public sector, as opposed to communism where the private sector is outlawed. A spectrum.
But food shortages aren't the same as famines, and in the famines (assuming we're talking about the famines of the early 30s), economic incompetence wasn't the primary driving factor, although this may be simply a case where we simply have different definitions of incompetence. Stalin explicitly wanted millions of Ukrainians to die as collective punishment for not being sufficiently red, and it's fair to say that he thought it was better to have a dead peasant than a peasant not part of a collective farm, where they and all their activities could be made easily legible to the Soviet State and placed under bodily control.
Those millions of deaths racked up could have been avoided if Stalin had wanted to, even within the rubric of central planning. It's really not even a matter of the famine being something that could've been "averted": the famine wasn't a natural occurrence but something engineered.
Central planning, particularly central planning under a dictatorship, being highly conducive to psychopaths killing millions of people is something I'd agree with, but it needs explicit argumentation.
I dunno; all the bright-line false alternative stuff doesn't work. Economic history is still interesting.
I believe it turns out that the regulation that got repealed probably would not have mattered much other than possibly setting up transparent exchanges for derivatives, and that seem speculative as well. YMMV, IMO, all that.
IM-uneducated-O their national decision makers currently do a better job than ours on economic policy (they actually invest in infrastructure and aren't in bankers' pockets on the plus side, a bit too cozy with leading industrial firms on the minus side), while local government there tends to be very corrupt by our standards.
You're aware that there's a healthy private sector in China currently, right? The name "Deng Xiaopeng" ringing any bells? They've had grains futures markets for 25 years now. Not state-allocated capital for food. Seems kinda implausible that you just missed that one.
I'd suggest reading a newspaper sometime. Maybe a history book or two.
I didn't claim that the existence of any state spending at all causes famine. That would be ridiculous to claim. Does US highway spending mean that we're undergoing a famine RIGHT NOW? I mean, the human race would be extinct if that claim held true, given that governments have generally existed most places.
What's your angle, here? What on earth are you trying to prove? To who?
...which companies and industries will shrink and which will grow.
If there's no demand for the product or service, where is the business and financial model?
The financiers don't determine what will turn a profit. They only predict what will return a profit. A market that signals growth and large profits will attract more investment. Investing in a market that doesn't return a profit is something financiers try to avoid. The market shapes the investors decisions, and the decisions shape the market.
Its about the unbearable amount of money they extract for the service they provide.
It may not have a single, "simple" solution, but it is always worth keeping in mind -- necessarily so, I would argue.
Recently, we've had an extreme emphasis, in much of our (U.S., "Western") rhetoric, on the individual and competition.
However, such emphasis, in the extreme, does not scale too well.
One might argue that we are failing at scale, for some fundamental reasons.
"Those who work in banking, venture capital, and other financial firms are
in charge of allocating the economy’s investment resources. They decide, in
a decentralized and competitive way, which companies and industries will
shrink and which will grow. It makes sense that a nation would allocate many
of its most talented and thus highly compensated individuals to the task."
This quote also stuck out to me to for two reason:(1) First, yes, it's true that these individuals collectively allocate the capital in our nation (and other nations), but at no point has anyone made a convincing case that this is the optimal (i.e. global maxima) for the overall good of society. There are myriad alternative ways in which society could organize itself to better allocate capital. What evidence out there actually supports the status quo as the best way, especially considering that we've never really given support to any plausible/promising alternatives.
(2) Second, it matters not if you are the "most talented" individuals for the task if you don't act impeccably ethically. The only thing worse them incompetent people with good intentions are competent people with ill intentions. Wall Street if full of the latter, ensuring that their talents are going towards doing a remarkably good job at extracting rent from any of society's productivity gains.
"Bloated and inefficient, the financial sector is focused on hooking up bankers with large bonuses rather than matching savings with investment."
I don't think the two goals—greed and making society better—are necessarily orthogonal, as you seem to be asserting. The incentive structure just isn't set up correctly.
(not to mention the brain drain on the labor markets, and the corrupting influence on politics, and the speculative instabilities, etc.)
The simple flaw with this idea is that wall street is squarely focused on making more money. Not making society better. Not allocating capital effectively. Not even on creating wealth(which is distinct from money). The single guiding equation for all deals and transactions is "how can we make as much money as possible with as little risk as possible and also stay out of jail".
That wall street occasionally invests in companies that actually do create wealth and allocate capital to the betterment of society is more a case of broken clock sometimes being right.