News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rent Is Too Damn High: The Enormous Cost of Letting F... by jbooth on Thursday February 20, 2014 @04:46PM (#7273851)
There's a spectrum, obviously, but the post I was responding to, as phrased, seemed to be oversimplifying and basically arguing against letting the invisible hand, defined as a bunch of selfish a-holes creating market forces, work at all. (The poster clarified downthread that that's not what they meant, don't want to misrepresent them here.)

I don't disagree with your conclusion about political structure, but if we're talking about pure collective planning with no reliance on private allocation of capital, that's never actually been done with a democratic political structure anyplace larger than a kibbutz. Democratic socialism, IMO, is much closer to well-regulated capitalism than it is to communism.

Re:The Rent Is Too Damn High: The Enormous Cost of Letting F... by mattmanser on Thursday February 20, 2014 @05:48PM (#7274229)
Obviously? This was your assertion:

State-allocated capital without a private finance sector has failed miserably

It is completely wrong. It is a lie. You weren't obviously talking about a spectrum, you were talking crap.

Re:The Rent Is Too Damn High: The Enormous Cost of Letting F... by jbooth on Thursday February 20, 2014 @05:52PM (#7274244)
Can you show me any success stories of absolute communist states with no private sector? Just one, maybe? Who's lying?

The spectrum comment referred to the socialism/communism terminology, with socialism generally seen as involving a heavily-regulated free market and large public sector, as opposed to communism where the private sector is outlawed. A spectrum.

Re:The Rent Is Too Damn High: The Enormous Cost of Letting F... by dkuntz2 on Thursday February 20, 2014 @07:36PM (#7274695)
Can you show me any success stories of absolute capitalist states with no market regulation? Just one, maybe?
Re:The Rent Is Too Damn High: The Enormous Cost of Letting F... by jbooth on Thursday February 20, 2014 @08:39PM (#7274912)
Of course not. My whole point was about middle ground, a "well-regulated market".
Re:The Rent Is Too Damn High: The Enormous Cost of Letting F... by Florin_Andrei on Thursday February 20, 2014 @06:51PM (#7274497)
I believe it is necessary at this point to emphasize that this is a discussion between real people, where logic is a bit fuzzy, and metaphor is sometimes employed. It is not a computer code that would fail to compile if even one detail was not true in a literal fashion.