News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by zedshaw on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:26PM (#7234956)
"they simply don't believe in a monopoly of laws and law enforcers"

Ahahahahaah! That's the same as not having laws! And even then, what you're saying is they believe someone should bring this guy to justice...and then do nothing to him. Then it's not justice. You're killing me my friends. Just killing me here.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by btilly on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:51PM (#7235183)
I've been having conversations on this topic recently with a libertarian who grew up in the Soviet Union. Let's just say, when you've seen laws and law enforcers monopolized by villains, it becomes quite hard to accept that justice is whatever the government and courts say it should be.

While I personally like law and order, when the choice is mob justice or a police state, there are some definite advantages to mob justice.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:54PM (#7235223)
That actually alludes to something I noticed recently: Libertarians tend to come from countries with shitty governments, which makes sense. You're likely to be far more suspicious of the idea of government regulation if your government has a history of incompetence and malice than if you come from a country whose government, while imperfect, mostly just works.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by iopq on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:47PM (#7236981)
That's true, I'm a libertarian from a country with a shitty government (United States)
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:27AM (#7237250)
And you rarely see libertarians here in Canada. For all its warts, our government mostly works: healthcare is pretty good, education is pretty good, regulations are generally not onerous, taxes are pretty low, crime is pretty low, etc. It's a solid B- government, and that seems to apply regardless of who's in power. So while you get disagreements on what government should or should not do, you don't really get disagreements about whether or not government is good: it's mostly ok.

I agree, the American government (on all levels) seems to be particularly dysfunctional, so it makes sense that many Americans would look at it and conclude that government writ large is bad. Combined with the American propensity for introspection and self-criticism, the very real observation that American government is bad leads to the (imho erroneous) conclusion that all government is bad, ignoring the fact that most western governments, while flawed, are nowhere near as flawed as yours is.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by einhverfr on Friday February 14, 2014 @03:11AM (#7237502)
> And you rarely see libertarians here in Canada.

I think that is because your provinces have actual positive jurisdictions of sovereignty, as opposed to the very weak protections our states have.

> For all its warts, our government mostly works: healthcare is pretty good, education is pretty good, regulations are generally not onerous, taxes are pretty low, crime is pretty low, etc.

For example, there is no "Canadian Health Care System." Rather there is some federal money that goes to provinces as long as they don't do anything horribly out of line, and the provinces get to set up their own systems.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Friday February 14, 2014 @11:35AM (#7239377)
Provinces have far less power than states do, at least on paper. The reason education and healthcare is run at the provincial level is because the federal government decided to do it that way as a cost-saving measure. If they decided to change it back, the provinces would just have to suck it up and go along for the ride. Just look at equalization payments for an indication of how little power provinces have.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by mlvljr on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:29PM (#7235846)
Local libertarians (I am coming from Russia) are indeed mostly crazy to the point of advocating social Darwinism and Ayn-Randianism as a means to a perfect future of the humanity (??), I was quite puzzled to know the "original" libertarians are quite different from that :)

Just my two commie copeikas...

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jerf on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:04PM (#7236066)
In a nutshell, in every country there's some number of political positions that have a certain amount of broad political popularity, and these will be captured and represented by some set of political parties. ("Captured" is a bit more aggressive than I really want here, but it really is sort of like a territory thing; positions are malleable and can move between parties over time.) In anything with a voting system that matters, these parties will tend to grab the vast majority of the middle ground. (In the US, the two parties actually play the part of multiple parties in a proportional representation system as in much of Europe; the popular positions are still all covered, but you do get some really bizarre pairings under one tent sometimes.)

Consequently, the ones who are left out of the resulting parties are nearly by definition outliers. If one studies statistics, one of the things you'll learn is that in anything that has even a faint resemblance to a Gaussian distribution, the outliers are always more diverse than the main body. So on those fringes, you can always find some real nutcakes, along with a group of people whom you may merely find eccentric but forever bear the burden of being tarred by association with the loonies.

(It isn't necessarily the best plan to judge a fringe belief by an even more fringe set of loonies; for every stone you might be inclined to toss at the "other side", it's worth bearing in mind you've got a matched loonie on your side. Naturally, the loonies are the loudest, everywhere.)

I claim to be libertarian, but probably even more accurate would be call me a Classical Liberal - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_liberalism (Albeit not every bit of that; 18th century Classical Liberalism can not be simply blindly applied today, but I think it's closer than later philosophies, or, perhaps, ironically more appropriate for the 21st century than the philosophies of the 20th, which I think were too greatly influenced by the accidents of the Industrial Revolution, which fade as we continue through the Information Revolution.) Anyways, following through that on Wikipedia would probably give a helpful perspective on the general ideas, moreso than a loud loonie. There is an actual respectable intellectual tradition here, even if it is not the one currently in favor.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by steveklabnik on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:45PM (#7235941)
"Original" libertarians were French anarchists. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarianism#Etymology

> The use of the word libertarian to describe a new set of political positions has been traced to the French cognate, libertaire, coined in a scathing letter French libertarian communist Joseph Déjacque wrote to mutualist Pierre-Joseph Proudhon in 1857, castigating him for his sexist political views.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by JohnBooty on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:50PM (#7235169)
"Ahahahahaah! That's the same as not having laws!"

I'm nearly as far away from libertarian as one can be, but no - it's not the same as not having laws.

Example: Old (American) West-style "frontier justice" where a bunch of townspeople form a posse or a lynch mob or whatever to right some (real or perceived) wrong.

(edit: I do understand that this is only one possible scenario, and not what all or even many libertarians want)

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by brnstz on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:12PM (#7235359)
Mob justice is not law.

For an illustration of this, check out the very first scene of the TV series Deadwood. There's a lynch mob outside the sheriff's office, and they want to kill the person in the jail. The sheriff fends them off so he can legally hang him instead.

The creator originally wanted to do a series on ancient Rome, about the birthplace of civilization. The studio wanted a Western. He said, oh, perfect, that works, too.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by shpxnvz on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:28PM (#7235474)
And yet mob justice is exactly what we have in US, though sometimes with a legislative session's worth of delay. A constitutional republic protects against mob justice through individual guarantees of property and liberty, and further through strict limitations on the state's power. Our government, of course, has long since managed to rid itself of most of these limitations.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by brnstz on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:01PM (#7235672)
Laws are not perfect. Sometimes you need a revolution (i.e., a mob).
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by MrZongle2 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:23PM (#7235429)
Perhaps citing a television show is not the most credible evidence one can bring to a discussion?

Edit (since I cannot reply directly, apparently): why is it not credible?

Can I start citing the X-Files or Star Trek? How about a broadcast of the Nancy Grace show?

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by brnstz on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:53PM (#7235635)
Why is it not credible? That scene illustrates a point even more abstract than the one we are discussing.

If the result is the same (the prisoner dies), does it matter whether a legal authority performs the killing, or whether a mob does? I think it does.

You may not agree with the legal authority's process or laws, but at the very least it is written down.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by thaumasiotes on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:49PM (#7235612)
To illustrate a concept? Fictional media are ideal, as they can have the facts go however they want. What difference are you hallucinating between citing a philosophical paper discussing a thought experiment, and citing a television show?
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by dinkumthinkum on Friday February 14, 2014 @12:45AM (#7237140)
You really have trouble with this kind of discussion? I'm not sure what would fix this thinking ... Maybe you should read books or learn thought experiments or just start with basic metaphors ... hrrmphh! I'm stumped!
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by steveklabnik on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:43PM (#7235929)
> (since I cannot reply directly, apparently)

HN hides these links to prevent very quick back-and-forth. Either wait a few minutes or click the 'link' link.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by MrZongle2 on Friday February 14, 2014 @11:48AM (#7239434)
Thank you. I wasn't aware of that.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by mpyne on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:39PM (#7235545)
The thing to keep in mind is that the whole idea of a state is that it is the organizational entity (call it a posse if you like) that has the legitimacy to use force in the first place.

If multiple such groups have the "right" then you have either a coalition state or tribes with warlords, but even that only really changes the level of jurisdiction.

It seems to me that some libertarians try to claim theoretical victory by defining their legal enforcement to be a private contractor or somesuch, but as soon as they do that they've simply re-defined the government to be that private contractor (or whoever is controlling them) instead. There's still a state and still governance, whatever you happen to call that particular rose.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by muteh on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:58PM (#7235655)
You just said "lynch mob" like it was a good thing. Try again.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by arg01 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:36PM (#7235531)
I'd have to say that the law looks like a monopoly to me. If the only way I can avoid being subject to the local law is to move a large distance and that's the only way to opt out how is this not a monopoly, or rather how is it any less the case than it is now?
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:52PM (#7235192)
>Ahahahahaah!... You're killing me my friends. Just killing me here.

You can make the same argument without being an ass about it.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by Crito on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:09PM (#7235343)
If he were the sort of person that were capable of making this argument without being an ass about it, then this entire thread of discussion would not have been started in the first place. Whether you are a libertarian bitcoin drug dealer, a communist bitcoin drug dealer, or a politically apathetic cold-hard-cash drug dealer, governments don't enter the "I got ripped off, what are my options?" equation. That's just the reality of the business.

Politics is a rather uninteresting tangent here, brought up really only to start a flamewar.

Seriously, who gives a shit about the political opinions of drug dealers? I don't know where my dealer stands on economics, taxation, or civil rights, and I don't have any reason to care.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by lurkinggrue on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:40PM (#7235553)
There is quite a bit anarcho capitalist bent to a portion of the Bitcoin community and a number of people are going to be prone to pointing and laughing when something like this happens.

Not sure if that makes it right but people will be people.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by Crito on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:54PM (#7235637)
Sure, anarcho-capitalists are more prevalent in the bitcoin community than in society in general (and I think you correctly identify it as anarcho-capitalist, not libertarian; several commenters here do not seem to understand that there is a difference), but ultimately drug dealers seeking justice outside of the legal system is nothing new at all. The only unique thing that is going on here, as opposed to traditional drug dealing, is that the request is made publicly.

If you rip off drug dealers, you should expect them to call for heads. Using this as the basis for a political flamewar is just straight-up trolling.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by baddox on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:58PM (#7235255)
Probably not, because it's not a very good argument.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by locusm on Thursday February 13, 2014 @10:12PM (#7236637)
You are far too easily offended if that's being an ass.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by Kequc on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:59PM (#7235265)
I dunno man. I agree with you on that, of course you're right. But, people have limits not everyone wants to talk at length to a libertarian so mockery is employed.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by janardanyri on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:46PM (#7235587)
In a public general-interest Internet conversation, when you reach the limit of your willingness to productively engage, it may be prudent to cease engaging.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by sabbatic13 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:05PM (#7235704)
I wouldn't write off mockery as unproductive. It's been an element of perfectly productive political discourse since the beginning of recorded political discourse. If done well and in an informed fashion, it ends up dispelling the illusion that any ignorant bit of pseudo-theory someone can conjure up is worthy of the public sphere.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by zedshaw on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:24PM (#7235809)
It's funny how me pointing out the stupidity and bullshit of a group of criminals makes me an asshole...

But a guy who has actually lost people's money, put them at risk of reprisal from drug dealers, helped people (potentially young people) commit major crimes, enabled future addicts, and potentially is lying about the security flaw to steal all this money while spouting hypocritical contradictory statements...is a fucking hero.

Bravo! You win the ultimate hypocrite award of the century!

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:54PM (#7236345)
How did "stop being a jackass" turn into "I support the guy who stole the money"?

Zed, I want to make myself clear, here: I have absolutely nothing to say whatsoever about whatever substantive claims you might be making. I'm just telling you to stop being a asshole about it.

But fuck it, I told you pretty much the exact same thing[1] almost 3 years ago, and you haven't changed since then. It's not your message that turns people off, it's your delivery. I still suspect it's a calculated ploy for pageviews and name recognition.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2605957

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by milkshakes on Thursday February 13, 2014 @09:20PM (#7236423)
> Zed, I want to make myself clear, here: I have absolutely nothing to say whatsoever about whatever substantive claims you might be making. I'm just telling you to stop being a asshole about it.

For what it's worth, this is Responding to Tone, or DH2[#]

#: http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @09:45PM (#7236528)
Only if I were disagreeing with some substantive point he made, which I'm not (I'm not agreeing, either). The substantive issue of my comment was his tone. I'm not disagreeing with him or trying to convince others that he's wrong; I'm just calling him out for being a jackass.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by milkshakes on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:34PM (#7236938)
> Only if I were disagreeing with some substantive point he made, which I'm not (I'm not agreeing, either). The substantive issue of my comment was his tone. I'm not disagreeing with him or trying to convince others that he's wrong

FTA: So if the worst thing you can say about something is to criticize its tone, you're not saying much. Is the author flippant, but correct? Better that than grave and wrong. And if the author is incorrect somewhere, say where.

> I'm just calling him out for being a jackass.

This is actually DH0, Name Calling.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by Floegipoky on Friday February 14, 2014 @12:53AM (#7237158)
You can't (reasonably) apply the hierarchy of disagreement to someone who is not actually disagreeing. He's not saying this to contribute to the debate, he's trying to encourage the community to express itself in an appropriate manner. Zed has made it pretty clear that he has no interest in factual debate. Multiple people have tried to point out the misunderstandings expressed in his posts and have been met with accusations of hypocrisy and/or avoidance of the actual points raised. He's firmly in the range of DH0-3. I'll admit I'm pretty new here, but this seems to me like behavior that the community should try to discourage.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:06AM (#7237195)
"You're being a jackass" != "You're a jackass"

I'm criticizing the behaviour, not the person. If you can't call out poor behaviour, you can't expect civil communication.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by milkshakes on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:39AM (#7237286)
> I'm criticizing the behaviour, not the person.

What you're doing is kidding yourself. You already know that zed shaw, being zed shaw, could care less about what the fun police has to say about the way he expresses himself.

> If you can't call out poor behaviour, you can't expect civil communication.

This news forum provides a mechanism that allows users to collectively rank posts by voting on them. Zed's comment on this article happens to be the top ranked one. Respectfully, I would submit that the majority of people who have seen it value the information content of his post more than they are offended by the way that he delivered it.

Could he have expressed himself in a more PG13 fashion? Sure he could have. Could he have made his point more politely? I don't think anyone would argue against that. But that's not Zed.

Frankly, I think it's a bit presumptuous of you to appoint yourself the civility police and harass people for the way they say things without actually engaging with what they are trying to say. Luckily for us, Zed doesn't actually care what you think. But I don't believe that it is either constructive or in the spirit of this venue to encourage an environment that attacks people for how they say things, rather than what they say. I think that the losses from such an overly sensitive environment, given the diverse range of cultures and personalities this board attracts, would far outweigh the gains.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:58AM (#7237332)
I respectfully disagree. Nothing is lost by tailoring the tone of your comments to your audience; you're doing so right now through your choice of words. On Youtube, you might have said, "stop being such a fucking pussy", and it would have fit within the expected norms of conversation there.

>I think it's a bit presumptuous of you to appoint yourself the civility police

I've done no such thing. By claiming I'm not allowed to criticize someone's behaviour, you're doing the exact same thing you're condemning me for.

>and harass people for the way they say things

Telling someone to stop being an asshole when they're being an asshole isn't harassment by any reasonable definition of the word.

>without actually engaging with what they are trying to say.

I don't care what he's trying to say, and I'm explicitly not engaging in that facet of the discussion. If somebody was standing on the street corner grabbing passerby and shaking them while shouting, "don't take on more debt than you can pay!", I'd tell them to stop being an asshole, too.

> I don't believe that it is either constructive or in the spirit of this venue to encourage an environment that attacks people for how they say things, rather than what they say.

You're quite simply wrong. Look at any of the low-value, one-line comments that get downvoted to oblivion for saying something along the lines of, "this sucks". You can say, "this sucks" in a way that adds value, and you can say it in a way that detracts value. Saying, "this sucks because of xyz" is simply more valuable than saying "this sucks because of xyz and you're all a bunch of morons for disagreeing".

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by milkshakes on Friday February 14, 2014 @02:37AM (#7237425)
> By claiming I'm not allowed to criticize someone's behaviour, you're doing the exact same thing you're condemning me for.

What I am criticizing you for is failing to understand that, at least in this specific case, your sensitivities do not in fact align with those of the community. And also for name calling someone who has contributed more to the hacker community in this past year than you have in your life.

Zed Shaw's comment is at the top of this thread. That is data, that you cannot continue to ignore while still claiming to speak for the community. Hacker News has a very effective system for burying comments that the community deems offensive and inappropriate. If the community was truly offended, then this post would be buried, or dead, not at the top.

> Telling someone to stop being an asshole when they're being an asshole isn't harassment by any reasonable definition of the word.

You mentioned upthread that this is not the first time you have had this discussion with Zed. And you continue to emphasize that you are not interested in what he says, but just criticizing him for how he says it. How many times do you have to repeat the same conversation for it to constitute harassment? How many self-righteously morally outraged people like you do you following him around and littering his threads with meaningless ad hominem criticism think it will take before he decides it's not worth it and just leaves? Do you really think Hacker News would be a better place without Zed Shaw?

> If somebody was standing on the street corner grabbing passerby and shaking them while shouting, "don't take on more debt than you can pay!", I'd tell them to stop being an asshole, too.

What I'm trying to explain to you is that, in this case, you're the person on the street corner, Zed is the passerby, and I still think it would be rude to call you an asshole, though I will continue to point out that if your attempts are genuinely in an effort to better our community, it would be worth carefully considering whether they are in fact in the community's best interest.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:47PM (#7240212)
I don't think this discussion is going anywhere productive. If it's alright with you, I'd rather just leave it as is.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jacobtracey on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:30PM (#7235851)
It's the condescending way you write that makes you seem like an asshole... i.e saying "Hahahahah" all the time - I don't particularly disagree with your points but the insulting tone is unnecessary, don't you think?
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by julie1 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:16PM (#7236881)
At one point, I wish I could shout like him. There are stuffs that are obvious: it is simple ideas. You speak about it nicely and you get scorned. Then, you doubt, you persist and you discover that you were right: it is now obvious, and still they laugh at you. So maybe, nervously, you laugh even louder.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by zedshaw on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:57PM (#7236022)
First off, only my mother gets to tell me to "watch my tone". Random jackoffs online can go fuck themselves if they think they've earned my respect by default, especially if those same jackoffs use political rhetoric to harm and steal from others.

My tone is simply a reaction to the tone of arrogance and superiority most objectivists and commenters take. If you don't want to be ridiculed, then don't write like a arrogant douchebag with zero self-awareness. Those kinds of people are due a large dose of insulting and "tone".

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jacobtracey on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:10PM (#7236105)
redthrowaway's comment:

> You can make the same argument without being an ass about it.

Your reply:

> It's funny how me pointing out the stupidity and bullshit of a group of criminals makes me an asshole...

You completely missed their point, how you can't see that is beyond me.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by wtallis on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:42PM (#7236281)
Careful, now. It looks like you're saying that calling something stupid bullshit is being an asshole. Some of us happen to believe that stupid bullshit is a real thing and that there are circumstances where calling something stupid bullshit may be entirely fair and justified.

Try defending against the accusation itself instead of taking the stance that the accusation is always automatically invalid.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jacobtracey on Thursday February 13, 2014 @09:41PM (#7236516)
Yeah, I wasn't saying that at all.

I was attempting to show that his response was a strawman.

After further reading I'm guessing his entire online personality is an act though so the topic seems to be worthless discussing.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by redthrowaway on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:19AM (#7237227)
>It looks like you're saying that calling something stupid bullshit is being an asshole.

No, being an asshole while calling something bullshit is being an asshole. A ^ B |- A. You can say something's bullshit without ridiculing people. Zed's problem isn't that he says unpopular things, it's that he seems to try to be as rude as possible in saying them.

Saying something's bullshit isn't necessarily rude. Saying something's bullshit and anyone who disagrees with you is an idiot|hypocrite|moron|asshole is.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by wtallis on Friday February 14, 2014 @11:30AM (#7239357)
> "Saying something's bullshit and anyone who disagrees with you is an idiot|hypocrite|moron|asshole is."

The truth of that statement still depends on what the issue is. There are some beliefs you really do have to be stupid or disingenuous to espouse.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by rhizome on Thursday February 13, 2014 @09:26PM (#7236454)
So is it actually your point that the floor is now littered with fee-fees over the difference between "ass" and "asshole?"
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by amagumori on Thursday February 13, 2014 @10:22PM (#7236677)
in the immortal words of The Dude - you're not wrong, zed, you're just an asshole. escalating discussions into flamewars by being unnecessarily inflammatory hurts the quality of the discussion for everyone.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by spikels on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:14PM (#7236128)
But wait Zed you certainly come out "looking like an asshole" quite often. You admit it yourself[1]. It seems to have something to do with your strident polarizing style. Just saying...

BTW - Love your L?THW books. Thanks

[1] http://zedshaw.com/essays/master_and_expert.html

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by 300bps on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:44PM (#7235935)
There's no need for the tone you're taking.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by bmelton on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:11PM (#7235356)
All due respect, you're missing the point.

The 'monopoly of laws' to which the parent refers are the ones like those against home distillers -- such that you're allowed to buy a distillation device, you're allowed to buy corn, you're allowed to buy sugar, yeast, etc., but you're not allowed to put them altogether to make whiskey, despite that you're allowed to buy whiskey.

Another example is the Lacey act, which, if construed narrowly enough, might make it illegal to eat a steak, or to fish, or to hike through the woods.

Even the most staunch of minarchists wouldn't generally repeal the 'base' laws, which are those laws that, if violated, infringe upon the rights of others. Libertarians do not, for example, suggest that murder should be legal -- everyone has the right to life.

Gun control is the nearest example I can think of, so pardon me if it doesn't fit the archetype 100%, but there are literally more than 20,000 laws on the books pertaining to guns, despite the fact that each of those are just derivatives of laws already on the books. Using a gun to steal is expressly against the law, and may carry a different penalty in many jurisdictions than just 'stealing'. Why? Stealing is already illegal, and the manner in which it's done carrying a different penalty likely is just a scheme to enforce mandatory minimums to fill the prisons.

Alternately, laws which are predicated upon arbitrary distinctions, such that a person with 9 ounces of pot gets away scot free, while a guy with 10 ounces of pot must serve an obligatory 5 year prison term.

You're of course welcome to hate libertarianism as much as you like, but if you're original post was sincere, you're woefully ill-informed on the subject.

Edit: Re-reading, I completely misinterpreted the OP's use of 'monopoly of force', and ended up making an altogether unrelated argument. That said, I consider my point both salient and well-researched, so I'll let it stand.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by mpyne on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:46PM (#7235589)
> Even the most staunch of minarchists wouldn't generally repeal the 'base' laws, which are those laws that, if violated, infringe upon the rights of others. Libertarians do not, for example, suggest that murder should be legal -- everyone has the right to life.

The set of laws is not really the problem then. Literally everyone agrees that "government should be as small as possible", the problem is that no one ever agrees as to how small that can possibly be.

As soon as you're accepted the state, the "men with guns" whom the libertarians trot out as their boogeyman, the existence of a judicial system and police, etc. then the libertarians are suddenly not that far different in practice from many other parties and are even closer in theory (since apparently everyone agrees that courts and police are OK now...)

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by novalis78 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @10:10PM (#7236630)
"literally everyone agrees that 'government should be as small as possible". Coming from Europe, that strikes me as a fascinating American (I presume) statement. From countless conversations I (Libertarian leaning - something which I just discovered in the last few years, did not even know that such a thing existed before that) had in the past in various European countries I found that the size of government was usually completely irrelevant for most people and in fact the majority was in favor of laws, ideas, concepts, movements etc, that de facto would lead to more government and more laws. Sorry for the OT, just fascinated :-)
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by mpyne on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:31PM (#7236928)
The concept comes out of something akin to the sibling reply to my comment.

That there are legal concepts/ideas/etc. that would allow government to regulate something is usually a given, especially in our globalized world where you might buy something online made 3 states away (so that the Federal government is clearly in the lead).

The conceit is that just because government can get involved doesn't mean it's a good idea for government to get involved. In fact it's practically axiomatic here that the 'proper' level of government involvement in laws, regulation, etc. is the minimum needed to do the job and that government interaction beyond that level is actively harmful. Even the Democrats tend to toe this line, their disagreement generally comes at the level of "minimum needed" (e.g. there was a push for single-payer option before ObamaCare was finalized as that was felt to be the only way to really meet the goals intended).

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by einhverfr on Thursday February 13, 2014 @10:55PM (#7236791)
And yet, having been owner and operator of businesses in both the US and UK, the UK government is far friendlier to small businesses than the US government is. Part of the US problem is that government has scaled up so far demographically and geographically that the government does need to be as small as possible at least on a federal level.

A way to look at this from a European perspective might be the role of the European Union: should the EU government be as powerful as possible? Or should virtually all of the lawmaking power reside with the member states?

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by bmelton on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:50PM (#7235617)
I don't necessarily disagree. It wasn't an attempt to assert that libertarianism is or isn't great, just that if Zed genuinely thinks that most libertarians don't consider 'theft' a crime, then he is badly mistaken.

How close or far away Libertarianism is from more statist methodologies is outside the scope of the point I was trying to make, but if I were making a point, it's that yes, they are closer together than his lawless society (which couldn't be further apart) suggests.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by mpyne on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:11PM (#7235738)
Well I know it's hard to pin a single definition but I will say I've encountered "libertarians" who were really essentially an/caps and actually did envision a nearly lawless society running on some sort of free market (oh, and strong property rights, always strong property rights).

It's getting to the point that when one says they're a libertarian I'm not even sure what that means at first. :-/

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by bmelton on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:26PM (#7235828)
I've had that same discussion recently with my wife, when I think we were discussing Chomsky. In short, I agree, the 'libertarian' umbrella is a broad one, but I think it's as unfair to suggest that libertarianism seriously espouses lawlessness as it is to suggest that democrats espouse NSA spying. Sure, some democrats undoubtedly do, but it's by no means a core policy position.

As for the 'strong property rights' comment, you clearly haven't yet met a libertarian socialist[1]. ;-)

[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarian_socialism

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by pekk on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:44PM (#7236292)
'crime' is not equivalent to 'cause for revenge through the security agency of your choice'.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by toolz on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:48PM (#7235162)
..and this my friends is what political discussion looks like.

You know, even if you were/are/will become right, laughing at someone else's ideals benefits no one. It just deepens the abyss that separates logic from political differences.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by banachtarski on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:55PM (#7235236)
This guy is an asshole. Just move along guys nothing to see here.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by nbody on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:56PM (#7235241)
Your comment seems more appropriate for YouTube than HN.

Anyway, I guess the point is that Libertarianism has some different views but the main takeaway is about having more choices and a more lightweight state.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by baddox on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:57PM (#7235250)
It's not the same thing as not having laws. That's like saying that a competitive market for food is the same thing as having no food.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by pekk on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:37PM (#7236261)
a war of all against all is not law.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by dtsygankov on Thursday February 13, 2014 @09:11PM (#7236400)
"But without the government, people would immediately start killing each other, and the last person remaining would commit suicide. Heck, I would gladly kill you right now if no one would be watching." - that is your argument, essentially. No, I don't think that would happen. Most people are not evil enough to willingly hurt other people, and most of the evil ones are not courageous enough to willingly hurt other people and risk being shot.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by gweinberg on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:58PM (#7236360)
It's also something that has never existed outside Hobbes' imagination
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by mpyne on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:44PM (#7236969)
It's rather the opposite, Hobbes's treatise explains why you didn't witness it throughout recorded history. Once a population group got large enough to have to worry about silly things like common property it ended up having leaders/warlords (either homegrown or due to conquest from abroad).

But even so, you certainly saw it in recorded history when government was weaker. "Highwayman" used to connote a very scary idea, something that is most relevant in modern history to those driving in convoys in Afghanistan or Iraq.

Another very good example was the actions of the FLN in French-run Algeria starting in the 1950s, where they actually more or less incited that "war of all against all", and did so from an organization that was not very centralized at all.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by einhverfr on Friday February 14, 2014 @03:07AM (#7237491)
> It's rather the opposite, Hobbes's treatise explains why you didn't witness it throughout recorded history. Once a population group got large enough to have to worry about silly things like common property it ended up having leaders/warlords (either homegrown or due to conquest from abroad).

Is there any evidence that humans ever weren't large enough to worry about common property? I mean populations evolve, not individuals, right? And even families have common property within the household, right? If humans are social creatures, then it seems to me that this view of history can't be right because humans have always formed governments as required by our social nature.

> But even so, you certainly saw it in recorded history when government was weaker. "Highwayman" used to connote a very scary idea, something that is most relevant in modern history to those driving in convoys in Afghanistan or Iraq.

But bandits have almost always been a reaction to the formation (often by distinct government policies) of a destitute class. You see a major increase in banditry following the confiscation of the Monasteries under Henry VIII, for example, because this was instrumental in creating the destitute masses that would power the English Industrial Revolution.

The FLN is a good example of the use of a war of all against all as a tactic to weaken governments. I don't think it is a good example of what happens without strong government though. A much better example would be blood feuds in medieval Iceland, or in weak government areas today.

Blood feuds though are complex institutions. They don't really form a war of all against all. Rather they form a way for bad behavior to be punished. If a man in Papua feels that his wife has dishonored him and kills her, her brothers will likely do the same to him. This will spin around until everyone gets tired of it and decides to reconcile with some sort of settlement.

As Jesse Byock has pointed out, one can see significant evidence that in medieval Iceland, the blood feud was an institution which provided a similar form of social control and stabilization to what we might think of as law and order. In short, blood feuds are law and order by a different means.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by mpyne on Friday February 14, 2014 @05:58PM (#7241639)
> Is there any evidence that humans ever weren't large enough to worry about common property?

Well, yes, as long as you keep going back in the geological record (I won't say historical record since written language would seem to have required a dense-enough population).

> If humans are social creatures, then it seems to me that this view of history can't be right because humans have always formed governments as required by our social nature.

Well even at the family unit level you mention, there would be government (by head-of-household, whoever that was). In areas with multiple families you'd likely have common property which would need it's own form of government (warlord, popular tribal chief, what-have-you). But that's getting back to my original argument.

I think we might actually be in agreement; the key to me seems to be that the Hobbesian nightmare doesn't occur when a populace and its government are organically grown. There's no reason you'd see all-vs.-all in history simply because there was always some form of government.

Hobbes's nightmare seems to come from the collapse of government among a mass of people, and its subsequent power vacuum, which results in subsequent in-fighting (or invasion from abroad). There are multiple examples of this in recorded history as well.

> But bandits have almost always been a reaction to the formation (often by distinct government policies) of a destitute class.

I don't think anyone would argue that destitution increases crime and violence against the weak. It's easier to have morals when you don't have to die of hunger due to your principles.

Likewise I think your point about blood feuds is spot on, but then we need to recognize that it has become government (as you say, law and order by a different means).

The idea that the "war of all vs. all" would be transient (until some form of stable governance sets up) is probably the thing which keeps Hobbes from being as much of a nightmare. But it also wouldn't really make those who live through the transient feel any better about it.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by iguana on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:58PM (#7235256)
zedshaw being an asshole. I'm shocked, shocked!
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jrockway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:27PM (#7235468)
How is he being an asshole? He is exactly right.

Watching Bitcoin from a detached and neutral position is absolutely pure entertainment.

"Hey y'all, let's make a web page for transferring money and drugs!"

"But I'm not very good at programming."

"No worries, there's CRYPTO!!!!!"

"Oh excellent, we'll sure screw over our oppressive government now! Down with the rule of law!!"

<time passes>

"Uh boss, someone just untraceably and anonymously stole all of our untraceable and anonymous money!"

If you're not rolling on the floor laughing, you're missing out on life.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by TeMPOraL on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:19PM (#7235785)
Well, he might be right here and there, but he's still being an assohle, and it's not the first time we see him acting as one (I'd wager it's his most recognizable trait).

Being right and/or smart and/or recognized doesn't, and shouldn't, give one an excuse to be a dick.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jrockway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:40PM (#7236272)
I don't think he's being an asshole, he just has the gift of being able to phrase his opinion in a way that makes people that disagree with him feel really bad.

It's not being an asshole to tell someone they're being stupid when they do something stupid. These guys just lost several million dollars via their illicit drug-trading website. They don't need a pat on the back from zedshaw.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by TeMPOraL on Friday February 14, 2014 @05:31AM (#7237839)
> These guys just lost several million dollars via their illicit drug-trading website. They don't need a pat on the back from zedshaw.

I'd agree if he limited his mockery to those people, but his comments are full of broad generalizations and target also honest people with ideas different than zed's.

I don't even say I agree with those ideas, though I find the concept of crowdsourcing law worth serious exploring instead of dismissing outright (there are some serious people, like Robin Hanson, discussing this [0]). It's easy to laugh off things you don't understand.

To be honest, I'm yet to see a single case of a person who truly understands an idea and then proceeds to sneer. For me, seeing one laughing at other peoples' ideas is a clear sign that the person doesn't know shit.

[0] - http://hanson.gmu.edu/regprivlaw.html

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by __--__ on Friday February 14, 2014 @04:42PM (#7241167)
and he should give a damn about whether you agree or not because... ??
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by lurkinggrue on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:42PM (#7235564)
I'm finding it quite funny and saw this coming a mile away.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by Claudus on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:20PM (#7235791)
Theft can happen under any form of government, I'm not sure why you would think otherwise.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jrockway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:17PM (#7236145)
Yeah, my bank loses all my money all the time. If by all the time I mean "not once ever".
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by tolmasky on Thursday February 13, 2014 @10:15PM (#7236645)
This is an astounding comment post-2008.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by eropple on Thursday February 13, 2014 @10:33PM (#7236716)
Mutual funds and stock portfolios aren't banks.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by smtddr on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:58PM (#7235658)
>>How is he being an a__h___? He is exactly right.

Being a a__h___ and being right aren't mutually exclusive. :)

Sidenote: BTW, now that we're talking, if you have a coworker at Google who can get this comment[1] removed from my channel, I'd appreciate it. I reported it as hate-speech like a month ago or something.

1. https://www.youtube.com/user/SMTDDR/discussion

For posterity's sake - http://i.imgur.com/6kpYvcM.png

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jrockway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:18PM (#7236151)
That's pretty bad. I'll look into it.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by smtddr on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:24PM (#7236186)
Thanks!

I'm sure Google gets like a million of these a day. I'm probably in some queue somewhere.... and I've never dated a white girl. ;-)

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by jrockway on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:27PM (#7236205)
Also take a look at this:

https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2802268

It seems like you should be able to just delete the comment and block that asshole. If you've tried that and it doesn't work, I'll escalate.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by smtddr on Thursday February 13, 2014 @08:39PM (#7236268)
http://i.imgur.com/zIWLiyr.png

For some reason, I'm only allowed to report it. =/

EDIT: I was able to block the user, but the comment remains it seems.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by joyeuse6701 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:37PM (#7235532)
Fools always laugh the hardest.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by steveklabnik on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:46PM (#7235951)
A witty saying proves nothing.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by Floegipoky on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:30AM (#7237259)
Is that recursive irony?
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by steveklabnik on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:39PM (#7240150)
Yes.
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by joe_the_user on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:51PM (#7235184)
Oh, I think the libertarians want something like the old posses that once went around stringing-up cattle thieves, so they would do something to the thieves if they caught them - unless fear of the state prevented this (why they think the state is unjust).

Not that there aren't multitudes of other problems in their schemes.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by TeMPOraL on Friday February 14, 2014 @05:35AM (#7237853)
Zed, I'm sorry, but at this point your comment has jumped the shark. You're full of crap, that's all.

I'm yet to see a person who truly understands an idea and then proceeds to laugh it off just like that. For me, it's a good indicator that the person laughing doesn't know shit, and doesn't even try. It's easier to make people you disagree with feel bad about themselves than to actually engage with their arguments.

(note I'm not referring to the drug dealers who lost money, but to the off-hand dismissal of ideas many honest people hold)

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by abueesp on Friday February 14, 2014 @12:02AM (#7237030)
Polycentric Law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polycentric_law

+

Wealth of the networks (instead of monopolistic centralism base upon territory, population and gov 300years old model Wealth of the Nations/States).

Move forward. Even it is not possible eventually to have a complete monopoly of the law, except in the case of a dystopian totalitarism.

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by dinkumthinkum on Friday February 14, 2014 @12:39AM (#7237128)
No, it's more like you use your money and you get your own police force and set of laws and I'll use my own and get the same and then we'll figure out our grievances ourselves. Sounds like a workable system. :)
Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by fredgrott on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:50PM (#7235621)
ah the Frank Zappa method..

for those that do not know the story..

Frank Zappa disarmed someone that tried to shoot him and than refused to call the cops

Re:Silk Road 2 Hacked, All Bitcoins Stolen by RankingMember on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:47PM (#7235954)
I think that's a Zappa myth. It's been told various ways, including yours, but also another in which he encourages the attacker to walk with the group Zappa's with to a lake, wherein they then throw their belongings into it, including the gun.