News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by skywhopper on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @09:51AM (#7177696)
I hope the new CEO has the courage and the power to set out a vision and stick to it for more than just a few years in a row.

Microsoft under Ballmer has been a study in short attention span. Changing themes, names, and directions every three to five years. When I was a Windows sysadmin back in the day, it was incredibly frustrating to build anything on the Microsoft platform because by the time you wrapped your brain around the new way of doing things, the next server OS release would change everything. From what I've seen since I moved on to a different career, that pattern hasn't changed.

Apple's success has come from a laser focus and constant improvement for the past 17 years. Microsoft used to be similarly focused. Remember the old adage that Microsoft would get it right by Version Three, and wipe out the competition? Well, they haven't stuck to any particular plan for long enough to come up with a version three of anything in 15 years.

Hell, Microsoft pioneered tablet computers, but after some promising early models and some decent push into the innovation required, they kind of just let that project wither on the vine until Apple came up with a workable model. Then MS desperately tried to pivot and turn everything, even the server OS, into a tablet-and-desktop-friendly mess.

Remember Zune? Remember Live? Remember the Kin??

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by javajosh on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:43AM (#7178094)
> Remember Zune? Remember Live? Remember the Kin??

We should be very careful about criticizing others for their failed products. The side-effect of experimentation and innovation is that some of the experiments will result in failure to find market fit. Market fit failure isn't a good thing for a company, but it's much worse to not experiment at all.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by danieldk on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @11:01AM (#7178234)
Moreover, it's surprising that the grandparent evokes Apple as a counter-example, since it discontinued iTools, MobileMe (or perhaps more importantly iDisk), Ping, Xserve, etc. With the exception of Ping, products that a large group of people relied on.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by skywhopper on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @06:01PM (#7180844)
I guess I failed to make my point clearly. These were not necessarily bad ideas. The Kin got pushed out too early and too sloppily. It would have been better to kill the project before launch than what happened.

Zune could have been a good brand but rather than sticking to their guns, they abandoned it. Live was another unifying brand that they gave up on too quickly in favor of new rebrandings -- Bing, Office365, etc.

My point is that the constant jumping from idea to idea and rebranding instead of sticking with good ideas and revising until they're successful is a pattern of the Ballmer years that is a big part of Microsoft's lack of impact in the computing world over the past 5-10 years as Apple and Google and Amazon have risen to the forefront.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by hga on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @11:11AM (#7178292)
I'm most familiar with the example of the Kin, and it was not an example of "experimentation and innovation", but a case study in how Microsoft has largely lost its ability to execute on a proven concept.

For that matter, the Zune was a (late) iPod clone; sure, it had some experimental features (that didn't pan out, but, hey, they tried), but it was hardly seriously innovative.

It also was yet another example in how you'd best not trust Microsoft, as part of it they threw their PlaysForSure ecosystem under the bus.

Hmmm, getting whole sectors of the world to trust Microsoft in the future is going to be a tall order for the next CEO, assuming he doesn't just punt on many of them, which might be the wisest thing to do.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by dublinben on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @01:09PM (#7179162)
Both the Zune Pass and Zune Share were much more innovative than anything beyond the first iPod.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by r00fus on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @01:31PM (#7179327)
Execution matters. Zune Pass died a few months ago. I can still use account credit I put on my AppleID from 10 years ago (in fact I still have a few bucks on one of my early accounts).

A small startup that gets squished by larger competition has an excuse as to why it shut down services and let down it's customers. Microsoft has no such excuse. They failed to compete, then the failed their customers. Innovation is wasted if it's improperly handled.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by Elepsis on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @03:45PM (#7180123)
Zune Pass transparently got rebranded to Xbox Music and still works just fine.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by rlpb on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @12:35PM (#7178918)
> When I was a Windows sysadmin back in the day, it was incredibly frustrating to build anything on the Microsoft platform because by the time you wrapped your brain around the new way of doing things, the next server OS release would change everything.

[...]

> Apple's success has come from a laser focus and constant improvement for the past 17 years.

Really? OS 9, OS X, iOS? Sure, it's not quite the same number of platforms as Microsoft have done in that time. But I don't think that they're on polar opposites of the spectrum here as you suggest (nor do I think that being at one end of this spectrum is necessarily good).

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by skywhopper on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @05:49PM (#7180788)
I'm not sure I totally understand what you're saying, but I'll try to respond:

When Apple bought NeXT and Steve Jobs took over as CEO, the OSX project was born at that moment. Before that Apple had been stabbing wildly in the dark for a solution to their outdated OS, with a bunch of failed efforts at a rewrite. Yes, they updated the old MacOS a couple of times, which needed to happen, but as soon as OSX was ready for prime timee, they made the switch.

iOS is to some extent based on the same internals as OSX, but even if it were a completely different architecture, I'd say it's actually a good example of Apple's focus. Rather than forcing crossover and synergy where it doesn't make sense (ie, forcing the Metro interface onto the desktop and server, without actually providing Metro interfaces to their most popular desktop apps or server tools), Apple created separate OSes for devices that have completely different roles.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by jimbokun on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @12:41PM (#7178966)
OS X and iOS share the same core. OS 9 was a stop gap while getting NextStep ready to replace Mac OS.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by arethuza on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @11:11AM (#7178291)
"Microsoft pioneered tablet computers"

I always thought that was GO http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GO_Corp.

Although I suspect more people know about GO from Jerry Kaplan's book Startup than from their products.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by pjspycha on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:48AM (#7178127)
Microsoft is often being thumbed as being thickheaded and stubborn as well as unable to be flexible and quick enough to change with the market. "Short attention span" is definitely something new.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by cmelbye on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @11:50AM (#7178558)
Are those mutually exclusive? Couldn't they miss a trend and then eventually bring it to market late, and then change their minds about it shortly afterwards?
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by lotso on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @01:53PM (#7179483)
The Zune is at the foundation of Microsoft's Metro design language.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by skywhopper on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @05:54PM (#7180816)
Right, my point is that they didn't have the guts to stick with that product or the brand. It didn't do well after a couple of revisions, and they dropped it for the newest unified marketing idea.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by MartinCron on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @03:18PM (#7179989)
Yeah, Zune was a market failure, but it was a really great product that was totally underrated.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by BlackDeath3 on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @04:58PM (#7180531)
I tried to buy one not long ago and was sad that they had been discontinued. I don't know if this is still the case today (or even relevant in the world of smartphones) but I could not for the life of me find an MP3 player with an FM tuner in it. But the Zune had one, did it not?
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by tanzam75 on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @05:59PM (#7180835)
> I tried to buy one not long ago and was sad that they had been discontinued. I don't know if this is still the case today (or even relevant in the world of smartphones) but I could not for the life of me find an MP3 player with an FM tuner in it. But the Zune had one, did it not?

A Nokia Lumia 520 is dirt-cheap and has an FM tuner.

All you have to do is to pretend that it isn't also a phone.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by BlackDeath3 on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @06:07PM (#7180863)
Does it function poorly as a phone?
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by tanzam75 on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:07PM (#7181098)
No, it functions fine as a phone.

You said you were looking for an MP3 player with FM radio, and couldn't find one. I just meant that you could've found what you needed by expanding your search to include phones.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by BlackDeath3 on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @07:10PM (#7181113)
I have considered phones, hence the smartphone comment above in my post. Before this time last year, I'd never owned a smartphone before, and hence they weren't on my radar too much when I was looking for a device that included an FM tuner.

Either way, thanks for the suggestion.

Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by MartinCron on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @05:30PM (#7180703)
I'm pretty sure it did have an FM tuner in it. Also, the new iPod Nano has FM, if you're still in the market. http://www.apple.com/ipod-nano/
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by BlackDeath3 on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @05:38PM (#7180741)
Very cool. Thanks for the link!
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by kvb on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:16AM (#7177900)
I'm not sure this is a helpful diagnosis - Microsoft didn't have a short attention when it came to tablets (as you say, they pioneered them, and they haven't abandoned them), they just didn't get the form factor right, and many of the Live services have just been rebranded. Likewise, Apple has also demonstrated a short attention span at times. Remember Ping?
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by marknutter on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:26AM (#7177978)
It's not that they didn't get the form factor right, it's that they didn't align as a company to make sure it was a success. To my knowledge, in-fighting between different divisions in Microsoft lead to the Tablet PC's ultimate demise and as an early adopter myself I definitely felt the pain of it. Tablet pen functionality in Office was a pathetic, tacked-on afterthought, for instance.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by kvb on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @10:48AM (#7178130)
Good point - there were several problems with Microsoft's tablet approach, and you're certainly right that application software is one of them. The main thing I wanted to say is that "short attention span" and "abandonment" don't accurately describe what went wrong.
Re:Satya Nadella – Microsoft's CEO by fumar on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @01:06PM (#7179149)
In those early iterations the stylus support was pathetic. In contrast, Today's stylus hardware/software integration on their Surface Pro line is great.

I look forward to Microsoft finding their own perspective not only in hardware, but in software/search as well.