News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by patio11 on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:40AM (#7157498)
I would strongly consider not running a money transmitter as a side business. If you do not understand that you are running a money transmitter, I will be happy to elaborate.

I would also mention, on the assumption you're not aware of it, that you are offering fairly effective money laundering for credit card thieves at below-market rates for that service, and you can expect heavy dedicated adversarial interest. I rather expect you are receiving it already and are as-yet unaware of it. Feel free to ask for more elaboration if you do not understand the mechanics of how this works, or why it will quickly dominate the pool of people willing to receive $50 in consideration for $100 of Starbucks cards.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by brd on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:43AM (#7157518)
This is exactly why I am horrified by the number of bitcoin companies cropping up. I can only assume many of them have no idea what they are potentially exposing themselves to from a legal perspective.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by humanrebar on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:57AM (#7157595)
> I can only assume many of them have no idea what they are potentially exposing themselves to from a legal perspective.

Or an ethical perspective even.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by logfromblammo on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:53PM (#7157950)
I'm not entirely convinced that money laundering is unethical in its own right. Certainly, profiting from unethical activity is only once removed from unethical. That would make obfuscating the taint on unethical-once-removed funds an act that is unethical-twice-removed.

Clearly, there has to be some point at which we can no longer care, because I'm not certain that (metaphorically) there is a coin circulating that hasn't been dipped in blood at least once. Otherwise, the farmer who sells a hog to the butcher that sells sliced ham to the mafia capo's wife also shares the taint.

And even that presumes that the money to be laundered is profit from an unethical act, rather than one merely prohibited by government edict. I personally do not find marijuana-based commerce to be unethical. Therefore, I don't particularly feel as though a seller of sinsemilla on Silk Road should feel bad about wanting to be able to spend his profits without getting pinched, even if it means a murderer-for-hire could theoretically also prevent someone from following his money.

It isn't the money that's dirty or clean. It's the person holding it. Thus, I believe the criminalization of money laundering practices is simply an effort by the governments to solidify their control over the financial sectors, and to make their efforts at fighting crime less labor-intensive.

Even if all money were perfectly untraceable, police could still solve crimes by examining the evidence of the crime, rather than the evidence that someone got paid for it.

Of course, states seem to think that is rather a useful tool to have, so I expect that this business will be raided and shut down sooner or later. My advice is to cash out (in actual cash, no less) on the unexpected success as soon as possible, and then exit the business entirely before someone decides to make an example of it.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by notahacker on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:12PM (#7158542)
Ethically, there's a difference between profiting incidentally from criminal activity because a fraction of your customers happen to be criminals, and having a business model which is viable largely due to criminal activity.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by logfromblammo on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:41PM (#7159059)
That difference being directly attributable to the criminal activity. If your business model is killing people and taking their wallets, you are unethical because you murder and steal, not because you have more money in your pocket after you do it.

There was an idea floated a while back about why 51% of the miners couldn't just disavow the Bitcoin that FBI seized from Silk Road users. The answer was that it would completely unravel the currency, and impose an ethical obligation on everyone to examine the source of coins before accepting a transaction.

Gold has no smell. If it did, it would all stink. Attaching ethical considerations to money itself places an additional transaction burden in commerce, such that even a tiny cost can grind everything to a halt, in much the way that a pinch of sand in your oil pan can destroy your engine.

Think about the ethical consequences of currency that is not completely ethically neutral, and compare with the consequences of one that is. In the one case, money laundering happens, and you cannot reasonably prevent it. In the other, black markets flourish as white markets fail, because currency can flow only between them in only one direction.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by notahacker on Saturday February 01, 2014 @09:04AM (#7161651)
I'd argue that running a business providing services which are attractive primarily to criminals, like anonymously converting one means of payment to another for a 50% margin, is unethical even though money transmission per se isn't. YMMV
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by work_account_1 on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:03PM (#7158459)
Money laundering is an act of assisting someone in getting away with a crime. If you inadvertently do so, you're not guilty of money laundering. The intent has to be there.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by conductr on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:30PM (#7158648)
Maybe that's the way you feel it should be, but it's not that way in the US. It's more a form of negligence. If you don't follow AML rules, you are negligent thus guilty.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by dmm on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:46PM (#7158355)
Money laundering is not unethical. It wasn't even illegal in the US until 1986. At the time the law was passed we were promised it would only be used against organized crime that couldn't be stopped any other way.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by riter on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:42PM (#7158734)
Laws against anonymizing sources of income (Money laundering) are primarily enforced for tax evasion purposes. It's the catch all for even the most brilliant of enterprising "criminals".
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by work_account_1 on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:01PM (#7158452)
How exactly is money laundering not unethical? What's so ethical about assisting someone in getting away with a crime?
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by canvia on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:49PM (#7159099)
Just because something is illegal doesn't mean it is wrong. There are a lot of sociopath control freaks that want to dictate morality to the world, or to have power and control over others. There are many "crimes" that one might participate in that are perfectly valid business transactions such as consumption of controlled substances and prostitution. Right and wrong transcend words written on paper. One might argue that enabling the freedom to participate in these markets safely is extremely ethical and those attempting to restrict these markets are the criminals.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by lprubin on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:23PM (#7158607)
I think you need to explain why money laundering is unethical. Because there are plenty of laws passed by various governments that many people feel would be unethical to follow.

To use an extreme example, was it unethical to hide jews from the Nazi's?

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by mdpopescu on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:18PM (#7158933)
Always replace Hitler with Stalin or Mao or you'll be swamped by the idiots quoting Godwin's Law.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by rtpg on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:35PM (#7159029)
Money laundering happens to avoid paying taxes

hiding Jews from the Nazis was to avoid them getting shipped off to death camps.

The question is thus do you think that taxes are unethical? I don't think so but a lot of bitcoin fans seem to think so.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by tolmasky on Friday January 31, 2014 @04:04PM (#7159166)
It can be more complex than that. An extreme pacifist could have no problem with taxes per se but feel that paying taxes today implicates him in war crimes (drones strikes, etc.)
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by riter on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:38PM (#7158702)
Godwin's Law much?
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by dnsco on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:38PM (#7158692)
This conversation is officially over http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godwin's_law
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by Zidewinder on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:16PM (#7158922)
Fuck off. So he used an extreme example, doesn't mean his point is invalid. Godwin's Law is not supposed to be used as an excuse to shut down uncomfortable conversations.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:46PM (#7159084)
Godwin's law makes the money laundering law attractive in comparison.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by fnordfnordfnord on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:19PM (#7158936)
Who says that everyone who wants privacy necessarily wants it for criminal purposes?
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by blakeweb on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:24PM (#7158616)
I'm guessing the intent is to say that anonymizing the source of money per se doesn't seem to do anyone any harm, much like accepting cash as a form of payment. The problem is when people use such channels to avoid detection of crimes by law enforcement. We have to decide as a society which conveniences or defenses of privacy (anonymizing the source of money being one) are worth sacrificing to enable better law enforcement.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by jbigelow76 on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:38PM (#7157864)
Can you expand on this? Because the way I'm reading it it sounds like since it "could" be a tool for money laundering the OP shouldn't be doing it. But by that logic a car "could" be used to facilitate a bank robbery and therefore the salesman needs to consider those ethical ramifications.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by orik on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:46PM (#7157905)
There's a huge difference between this and a car salesman.

A car salesman goes through all sorts of paperwork and meets with the person they are selling the car too, and they hand the keys over.

This is much more similar to the service where you take a photo of a Key and you get mailed a copy of it for 5$; except it's semi-anonymous with bitcoin.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by maxerickson on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:50PM (#7157928)
Cars are probably one of the worst possible examples, since most transactions require the title.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by fnordfnordfnord on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:41PM (#7158309)
Are you proposing that a car salesman might refuse to sell someone a car on the chance that the buyer could be a criminal of some sort?
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by ygjb on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:44PM (#7158748)
No, just that the paper trail generated by purchasing a car from a dealership is undesirable for a criminal. This is why conventional financial institutions and services are undesirable for most criminals.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by fnordfnordfnord on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:12PM (#7158895)
Bitcoin transactions go in a public ledger. Although there are methods to obfuscate transaction history.

>This is why conventional financial institutions and services are undesirable for most criminals.

I think reality is in disagreement with you, as counter-intuitive as that may seem.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:12PM (#7158102)
I think he's asking about ethics. Just because this could be used for money laundering doesn't mean it must be used for money laundering.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by deeths on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:08PM (#7158505)
The difference is that government regulators (in the US at least, but presumably in many other countries soon) have stated that they consider bitcoin exchanges to be money transmitters and therefore regulate them in ways that prevent money laundering (http://blogs.reuters.com/financial-regulatory-forum/2014/01/...).

I suspect most lawyers/regulators would consider changing bitcoin into gift cards is legally like transmitting to cash.

Cars are regulated also, for instance to post a license plate that can be used to identify the owner's name and address, in part because they can be used in crimes.

This isn't _just_ an issue of if the seller is being ethical; it's an issue of whether they're following the law.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by jasonlotito on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:19PM (#7158575)
It's all about due diligence. Selling gift cards for bitcoins isn't illegal. However, you need to be aware that it can be easily exploited for money laundering, and you need to take steps to prevent that. And don't think money laundering is something that just happens in the movies. It's a very real problem, and deserves being attended to.

As for your car example, I'll leave that to the other comments already rebutting it.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by humanrebar on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:11PM (#7158095)
Just because someone can do something (technically and legally), it doesn't mean he should do it. I was trying to comment on the course of the discussion here -- there are a lot of comments about regulations and criminal liability but not many about ethical responsibility.

Clearly the most important issue is the factual one... whether there is more than incidental money laundering happening here.

If I had an ad placement business that only placed scammy ads or if I developed software that allowed people to be oppressed, I would also have issues. I would think that enabling criminal behavior is in the same broad category.

As far as cars, there's no issue selling a car. However, if your cars had armor plating and hidden compartment for guns, you have an ethical responsibility to find out if your customers are generally up to no good. If there is still a business to be made from legitimate customers, then maybe there's a way to ensure they're the only ones you do business with.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by redthrowaway on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:18PM (#7158148)
It's far more akin to a guy who sells guns out of his trunk in a dark alley. Chances are, it's being used for crime, even if there are legitimate uses for it.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by logfromblammo on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:58PM (#7158430)
One marked advantage to buying a gun for cash in a private sale is that the state won't know that you have it.

While I don't necessarily believe that would lead to acts of malice such as confiscation raids, it has already led to bonehead moves such as publishing over the public network the names and addresses of all registered gun owners in an area.

Also, people buy illegal moonshine when legit liquor stores are available. People buy cigarettes sold in the wrong state or from a tribal reservation. Buying a gun from an alley is a possible choice for someone who would otherwise prefer to bypass taxes, paperwork, and bureaucracy--illegal, of course, but not necessarily a prelude to a different crime.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by pc86 on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:44PM (#7158332)
No, because selling guns out of your trunk is a crime more often than not. This is a poor analogy.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by bradleysmith on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:39PM (#7158712)
Actually, it is not a crime in most US states. Person-to-person firearm sales are a wonderful example of a seller choosing to assess the intention of the buyer, and the moral ambiguity that this represents. A person can legally sell firearms out of his trunk in a great many places asking for nothing more than proof of age of the buyer.

This method of sale represents ~40% of all gun sales in the US. It would be safe to assume that the majority of guns purchased with the intention to commit crime are purchased person-to-person. There's a good breakdown of nationwide person-to-person regulations here[1].

[1] - http://smartgunlaws.org/private-sales-policy-summary/

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by dragonwriter on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:06PM (#7158485)
> No, because selling guns out of your trunk is a crime more often than not.

So is operating an unlicensed money transmission business -- in the US, this is likely to be both a state and federal crime -- or a licensed money transmission business without adhering to appropriate anti-money-laundering controls.

> This is a poor analogy.

Seems to be a spot-on analogy.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by clavalle on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:49PM (#7158780)
Not usually. Private sales of firearms are cash and carry most of the time. Thus the debate over gun show sales.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by ultramancool on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:08PM (#7157671)
For most of them it's no problem, they're just selling their product or service in an additional way.

However, something like this is scary as it's basically one hit easy money laundering. Not a bad idea if you're running the service anonymously. You'll make a good profit for sure. Otherwise there could be substantial risks and it may be better off to shut it down before feds get involved.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by daeyun on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:29PM (#7157812)
> Not a bad idea if you're running the service anonymously. Isn't running an anonymous (or unregistered) money transmitting service itself illegal?
[deleted]
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by celticninja on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:46PM (#7158357)
I think the issue here is that you could use a stolen card to buy Starbucks cards and sell them to this guy for btc. This guy is then going to swallow the loss when the fraud is detected. Credit card thief gets away with bitcoin.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by jorganisak on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:05PM (#7157640)
So goes disruption.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by mhluongo on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:54AM (#7157580)
I've been hand-verifying the transactions so far to try to keep abreast of fraud. I've also taken some automated steps (that I'm improving now).

I've been reading quite a bit about the money transmitter stuff, but I'd appreciate your take on why this would be categorized.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by patio11 on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:02PM (#7157625)
You should know that being a money transmitter is an exceptionally risky and time-intensive business to be in even if one is not "categorized as" a money transmitter. Even if the government ignores you, criminals will not. You are currently betting that your fraud prevention expertise is better than every criminal's fraud execution expertise. You will likely not win that bet. Do you understand that your adversary here has twenty people who are smarter than you and have years of experience on his payroll? I am not exaggerating in the slightest. Breaking your system wide open will not be his side project. It is his core line of business. You will just be a juicy target of opportunity, to the extent that you have worthwhile volumes. Note that four figures is already worthwhile.

As for the regulatory side of things, I'll pull you the exact citations when I get back from (ironically) a coffee run.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by mhluongo on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:10PM (#7157697)
Ha, thanks, I'm looking forward to the docs.

Re: fraud I've definitely been disillusioned that I can handle the tide myself, but OTOH I imagine fraud prevention is a lot like security- make sure the wall is higher than the water. I'll just have to figure out how to do that in a way that's safe, economical, and keeps the core idea behind the service working. It will almost certainly involve hiring people, or cutting off the influx of business down to- say- 5 cards a day.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by patio11 on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:48PM (#7157912)
Here you go:

http://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?c=ecfr&sid=d5570d7646c5...

[(5) Money transmitter (i) In general. (A) A person that provides money transmission services. The term “money transmission services” means the acceptance of currency, funds, or other value that substitutes for currency from one person and the transmission of currency, funds, or other value that substitutes for currency to another location or person by any means. “Any means” includes, but is not limited to, through a financial agency or institution; a Federal Reserve Bank or other facility of one or more Federal Reserve Banks, the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, or both; an electronic funds transfer network; or an informal value transfer system; or

(B) Any other person engaged in the transfer of funds.]

You unambiguously accept other value which substitutes for currency from one person. You equally unambiguously transfer value to another location or person, under multiple legal theories: a) the Starbucks card is one location, the Bitcoin account is another, b) the person holding the card and the bitcoin account may be different parties, c) your business operates as a transport layer between your customers and the company which you are unloading thousands of dollars of Starbucks cards on, and as those are different persons, that means you are transmitting that value.

You might think "But wait, FinCEN narrowed the regulations a bit for 'sellers of prepaid access' specifically to avoid overburdening them." Great news for Starbucks, bad news for you. You are not a seller of prepaid access, which you can verify by reading pg 45403 on of the Federal Register.

http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2011-07-29/pdf/2011-19116.pd...

You are, instead, using Starbucks cards and Bitcoins as a transport layer for value. The government is astoundingly non-neutral about that choice of business.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:25PM (#7158207)
But this is so general that lots of business would fit.

A bitcoin pool ambiguously, perhaps, transfers value too.

Why are they so non-neutral about this, and does it help us that they are?

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by domdip on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:45PM (#7158340)
It's not about transferring value - it's about substituting currency-equivalent value. What's the substitution going on in a mining pool? (And don't say electricity for coin, electricity is not valued similarly to a currency. Similarly 'claim on mining output'.)
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:29PM (#7158998)
Well it's a step up from electricity at least.

The currency equivalent value is securing the chain of BTC transactions and discovering new blocks, making the system work at all. New blocks have a currency equivalent value and doing transactions has a currency equivalent value too.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by dreamdu5t on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:45PM (#7158342)
Lots of businesses fit, but only ones with cash to take or political points to score will be targeted.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by gamblor956 on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:38PM (#7158696)
Politics and money has nothing to do with it.

Patio11 only posted an excerpt of the rules. Most businesses which fit this excerpt are excluded by portions of the rules not posted here but which are contained in the link. For example, those exceptions are why retailers who sell gift cards are not treated as money transmitters.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by 0xdeadbeefbabe on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:40PM (#7159052)
It reassuring to hear the rules make sense when you put them all together, but I still wonder if they are good rules. What is your take on it?
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by mhluongo on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:50PM (#7158375)
Thanks. In touch with a couple lawyers now.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by Pyramids on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:05PM (#7158475)
I can't give you any input on the legal side of things, however I commented on a thread about 6 months ago regarding gift card fraud[1] and the assumption that it's a new phenomenon.

With gift cards, especially Starbucks gift cards, it's almost (if not literally) impossible to verify legitimacy. Generally, almost anyone attempting this type of fraud, even at the lower levels will:

- Mask the fact that funds are loaded with credit cards in the transaction log by purchasing gift cards with gift cards.

- Use services[2] which sell residential IP's by location (infected systems) as proxies

Unfortunately for the service your offering, Starbucks has an internal chain-disable feature which deactivates any gift cards "downline" of a fraudulently loaded card, hence it's entirely possible that after conducting a card transfer, even one fraudulent transfer could put the entire balance of your legitimate holding account at jeopardy, and the average Starbucks call center representative will be unable to help you.

Services like Cardpool (also offered in-store at Safeway locations) verify individuals identities prior to cash-in, however even with that the amount of fraud they experience is staggering. To give you an idea, the rate of successful, fraudulent transactions experienced by Cardpool in Safeway stores for 2012 was over 20%, compare to the average chargeback rate on an adult site, which is between 0.5 and 2%

I think you've made a smart move to put your project on hold until you have a better grasp of the entire situation.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6175294

[2] http://5socks.net/

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:10PM (#7157694)
Your adversaries have experience making illicit transactions appear benign to trained eyes.

Assume money laundering will happen on your platform. Your priorities are (1) being in compliance with all applicable money transfer laws, e.g. registration and (2) working, within the confines of those laws and industry best practice, to minimise its frequency.

Today, if your service were to be used to launder money I believe you would be looking at asset forfeiture and jail time. That said, I think this business can be run profitably in a compliant way - it just takes planning and some expertise.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by gamblor956 on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:14PM (#7157729)
You need to talk to a lawyer ASAP. Patio11's cites can help you with the background, but if your business is taking off, you need to square it with the legal side of things before the feds come knocking.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by mhluongo on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:25PM (#7157796)
I'm definitely just wanting background- I don't think I'm a lawyer.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by ekanes on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:13PM (#7158104)
patio11 is right, you're about to have a major problem with gift cards going bad, which were bought with stolen credit cards. Happy to give more advice, you can reach me via my HN profile. Source: In a similar business for 16 months. (We sell gift cards for $ or BTC, but don't buy gift cards with bitcoin)
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by ashray on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:08PM (#7158500)
How do you handle compliance for your business (the bitcoin->giftcard one). From this discussion it seems like a total minefield. Do you ask your customers for their ID Proof/Address Proof ? (KYC/AML style) I know fraud isn't an issue for you at all because the bitcoin payments would be irreversible.

I took a look through your site and there are some really great deals (7% cheaper! wow!), great work btw!

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by ekanes on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:37PM (#7158689)
Thanks! In a nutshell, the higher the dollar amount, the more care we put into transactions and relationships.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by wcummings on Friday January 31, 2014 @02:53PM (#7158806)
I'm confused, isn't he selling cards for BTC. How does credit card fraud enter into this?

EDIT: OH HE'S BUYING THE CARDS THIS IS A REALLY BAD IDEA

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by rwhitman on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:52AM (#7157563)
Agreed, I wouldn't be surprised if his runaway success is due to people leveraging the money laundering possibilities en masse. Thats a hell of a risky business to be in
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by axefrog on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:51AM (#7157555)
How is he a money transmitter? His business is buying a product (Starbucks gift cards) and paying for them with Bitcoin. By your definition, a used car dealership that buys cars from the public and pays for them with cash is also a money transmitter.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:54AM (#7157577)
Gift cards are more like cash than goods. That is why "Federal tax law does not view giving an employee a turkey or a ham as the equivalent of giving an employee a gift card to purchase a turkey or a ham" [1].

[1] http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-tege/p_4090_fed_0305_text.pdf

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by gamblor956 on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:16PM (#7157740)
His definition isn't what's relevant--it's the legal definition of "money transmitter" that matters. Under the legal definition, the money transmitter rules can apply to businesses that exchange cash or cash-equivalent goods like gift cards.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by rwhitman on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:58AM (#7157603)
Starbucks gift cards are relatively anonymous, can store varying amounts of money without being suspicious and are easily transferred and sold. They are a fantastic vector for transfering dirty cash
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by anovikov on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:28PM (#7157809)
Anyway why worry? If bitcoin is anonymous, just host in 3rd world and work through ToR.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by rmc on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:38PM (#7157868)
Yeah because the "third world" has better legal protection than the USA....
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by jstalin on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:58AM (#7157602)
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by panarky on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:54PM (#7157958)
That link is for "virtual currencies" and here's one for "prepaid access".

http://www.fincen.gov/statutes_regs/frn/pdf/Prepaid_Final_7-...

In summary, in the US you must know your customer, have anti-money-laundering procedures, file suspicious activity reports, keep records for law enforcement, etc. Highly regulated.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by mhluongo on Friday January 31, 2014 @11:55AM (#7157585)
That was my thought too, but this is a common reaction so I'm definitely seeking clarification.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by brianbarker on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:48PM (#7159089)
How about this for everyone: regardless what you think about money laundering, if a financial institution in the US doesn't have the proper Anti-Money Laundering (AML) checks in place there are HUGE fines and legal trouble. Ask any bank or broker. Once groups start using your cards as a way to send money to their people inside, you'll have all kinds of new friends in the government.

At that point, your ethics are no longer up for debate and the law is coming for you.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by foobarqux on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:35PM (#7157853)
Do you have any good references on money transmission and how to operate one? What does and does not qualify, approaches to deal with the regulations as an upstart, etc.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by andrewfong on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:55PM (#7157963)
The short answer is (in California at least) it's a huge pain in the ass to comply with money transmission laws. You definitely need a lawyer. You might need a large amount of capital to backstop the business. You should also keep in mind that there is some uncertainty over what the law entails right now (hence the need for a lawyer), especially with respect to bitcoin. There is at least one ongoing lawsuit over California's money transmission laws.

California info: http://www.dbo.ca.gov/Licensees/money_transmitters/

Other states will have their own requirements. Depending on the nature of the business, you may have to interact with the SEC and FINRA. Again, get a lawyer.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by foobarqux on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:00PM (#7158005)
Are there any small companies that may superficially appear to be money transmitters but are not?
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by andrewfong on Friday January 31, 2014 @01:24PM (#7158196)
The law here is uncertain and differs between states. Until we get some definitive court rulings or clarification from regulatory agencies, it's hard to say.

There is one reading of California's law where practically anything that takes money from A and gives money to B is a money transmitter. Therefore, Uber (which takes money from passengers and gives it to drivers) or iTunes (which takes money from customers and gives it to artists) could be money transmitters. This is probably not the case (or at least, the law isn't being enforced that way), but it's far from settled. See http://www.businessinsider.com/california-rethinks-money-tra....

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by lifeisstillgood on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:25PM (#7158972)
Can I check my logic:

Our OP has acquired BTC through thrift and hard CPU pounding. And has a desire to drink much caffeine. So he realises that he can pour dollars held in starbucks cards out of person A's card and onto (his starbucks card?/his bank account? Not sure how that works as not got a starbucks card)

Anyway, he thinks he is onto a good deal, getting a latte at 30% off. However 10,000 dollars worth of latte requests later, and our OP smells a rat? Someone has bought starbucks gift cards with stolen CC details and then found a BTC owner willing to swap those gift cards for nice anonymous BTC.

I think that starbucks here is at least one money transmitter - they are taking payment at the NY branch, and guaranteeing the funds to our OP when he gets the card number.

However, there are a number of betwix and between issues - how do you buy a starbucks card with a stolen CC number? Is this a walk round the stores process? I would assume no-one saw his site and then went shopping, which implies that quite a large amount of starbuck's float will come from stolen CC - can anyone verify that?

But this one looks like everyone is in breach of some law some where. Starbucks, the OP, the credit card thieves. Unless Starbucks has a license as a money transmitter (transfer service for us in the UK)

There is a nice idea here - if you can automate throwing 5 bucks from one Starbucks gift card to another, you can invite someone to have a virtual coffee. How did you do that?

edit:

The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) of the U.S. Treasury Department requires MSBs to register.[9] It is also a felony to engage in money transmission without a license in any state that requires a license to operate.[10] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Money_transmitter

I would give those guys a call - but probably after calling your own lawyer. IANAL, but this is a sticky situation, and probably unique to date. Hope all goes well.

I expect intention will count for a lot here.

Edit: according to random site on inter web (http://qz.com/166193/why-a-start-up-coffee-company-is-now-ac...) Starbucks cards can only transfer balance to another Starbucks card, and be redeemed at Starbucks for goods. So I think they still need to be considered a money transmitter. Anyway the upshot is that about 4bn is put on these cards yearly and 650m was left as cash on the cards at end of last year. Which is nice for Starbucks.

And I think the "have a coffee on me" idea is quite workable - I could happily sip a latte and join a webinar if you paid for the latte. maybe not - sounds a bit cheap.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by anovikov on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:25PM (#7157795)
How a bitcoin which is anonymous can be laundering? A bitcoin in my understanding is black by default, it is like cash. If i was that guy i'd be happy (of course taking some protective measures as working through tor and having hosting in a 3rd world, but this is something i suggest everyone who does any e-business).
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by rgbrenner on Friday January 31, 2014 @03:19PM (#7158940)
The chain is:

stolen credit card or cash > starbucks gift cards > mhluongo's service > bitcoins > back to cash

so useful for laundering, and easily converting your stolen credit cards into cash before starbucks receives the chargebacks.

Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by jacalata on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:28PM (#7157806)
You know you can launder cash, right?
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by hueving on Friday January 31, 2014 @12:39PM (#7157876)
Cash IS what people launder.
Re:Ask HN: Bitcoin business unexpectedly taking off, help! by anovikov on Saturday February 01, 2014 @09:12AM (#7161672)
Yes sorry, my mistake came from that i forgot that money laundering in west vs third world means opposite things. There is no money laundering in U.S. understanding of the term say, in Russia (because there is no need for it), and what's called money laundering is a completely different business, that escaped my attention, so i completely agree my comment was nonsense.