News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by pc on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:38PM (#7116547)
Stripe cofounder here. Needless to say, this article contains many factual inaccuracies.

More broadly, articles like this are part of why we didn't announce our previous financings. If you don't also announce metrics, it's easy to write articles like this.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by mcarney7 on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:53PM (#7116661)
Hey Patrick, we'd be happy to include any numbers that you share publicly. We gave you that opportunity yesterday, but you declined. You guys have been fundraising and having M&A talks over the last 6+ mo, meaning your numbers are "out there." I find it hard to believe that everyone we spoke to is grossly inaccurate in the exact same ballpark. I'm happy to concede that the figures may be outdated, and we acknowledged that in the article. But we also compared you guys against competitors' metrics from the same period. Our goal is to be fair and accurate. The more you share, obviously, the better.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by sama on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:32PM (#7117289)
It does not work this way. You do not get to cite made up numbers with anonymous sources that clearly contradict some public info (e.g. the graph PG tweeted in November) and use that disinformation as an attempt at blackmail to get the company to release its numbers.

Flipped around, Stripe would not write a blog post about Pando saying all sorts of wildly wrong things and then say "well if you want to correct us and tell us that your traffic is not dwindling and you're not almost out of money, we'll give you that opportunity because our goal is to be fair and accurate".

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by pg on Friday January 24, 2014 @05:47PM (#7118727)
"Our goal is to be fair and accurate. The more you share, obviously, the better."

We wouldn't want you guys to get hurt. And unless you do what we want, I'm afraid we can't guarantee your safety.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by adamnemecek on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:06PM (#7116771)
Seems like a blackmail-y proposition.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by ivanca on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:13PM (#7116923)
>I'm happy to concede that the figures may be outdated

"Share your metrics or we are going to assume and publish your company as being today where it was many months ago" is pretty shady journalism.

>We gave you that opportunity yesterday

How generous of you.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by wdewind on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:18PM (#7117015)
No, they make it extremely clear that the numbers are old in the article, and then give a pretty generous extrapolated figure.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by ivanca on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:25PM (#7117202)
"Extremly clear" would have been to mention the time-period in the title. And "pretty generous" according to who? you?
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by throwawayun on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:12PM (#7116906)
> The more you share, obviously, the better.

Better for who?

They obviously have a strategy, and your comment is rude and presumptive. This is why people often hate the press.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by mcarney7 on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:17PM (#7117009)
We didn't write "stripe's metrics today are X." We wrote, "Stripe's metrics 6 months ago, when they were in fundraising and M&A talks were X...during the same period its competitors metrics were Y, Z." Seems fair and accurate.

Stripe doesn't need to share data if it doesn't want, but then criticizing us for being inaccurate is a bit ridiculous.

Also, it's not our job to tell Stripe's (or any company's) story as they want it told. It's to report on the ecosystem. Its better for the ecosystem – investors, competitors, customers, etc. – if they share transparent numbers.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by ivanca on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:24PM (#7117176)
>Stripe doesn't need to share data if it doesn't want, but then criticizing us for being inaccurate is a bit ridiculous.

Ridiculous is to making ANY present tense assertions when your using old data, like in the title you don't say "Memo for Stripe for where it was 6 months ago" or any other indication of the time period at hand.

Your magazine is the only thing here poisonous for the ecosystem.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by lotso on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:16PM (#7117657)
Writing articles on anonymous sources' information and criticizing a private company for not sharing their data, so you can write a new blog post is a bit ridiculous.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by kposehn on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:45PM (#7117423)
Four issues with the article:

#1: I understand the desire to do comparison in the market and look at Stripe's multiple vs. others, but PayPal and Stripe are not equal in forward looking growth. To try and apply Stripe's valuation multiple to PayPal's earnings assumes that PayPal is in the same sort of growth stage, which it clearly isn't. And most likely, Braintree was not either when they sold. Why sell if you're eating everyone's lunch?

#2: While numbers from six months ago may have been circulated and Pando apparently has those numbers, a lot can change in that timeframe. Large deals can be closed, growth can accelerate or very important technology can mature that has the potential to upset the status quo in Stripe's favor. General analysis of the market and knowing the habits of several of Stripe's investors makes me think that a key factor that is not public is in play. I expect a deal that gives them far better profit margin.

#3: "Stripe is a transaction-based business with a clear model — and one not growing particularly rapidly if it took two years to get to just $1.5 billion in annual payments volume our sources report as of six months ago." This is a bad assumption to make. As a rule, I never assume a company has a transparent business model as there are many aspects of technology and deal structure outsiders are not privy to. Who is to say Stripe doesn't have a new payments product on the way? Would it be so crazy for them to start snapping up downstream fulfillment companies with an $80mm war chest to maximize profit margin? Maybe so as they of course don't want to compete with customers, but who knows?

#4: Another issue with the assumption about payment volume is a linear growth curve. If you say "Braintree did $12bn in payment volume when it sold in late 2013, that means $2bn in volume growth per year, more than stripe with $500mm per year over 3 years of life". However, looking at articles that state Braintree's payment volume shows they were apparently doing only $3bn annually in 2011 at their $34mm Series-C (http://techcrunch.com/2011/06/29/accel-puts-34-million-in-on...). If Stripe is assumed to be making a rapid growth stride to make this raise, then they likely have a similar (or stronger) growth curve than Braintree did at that point (https://twitter.com/paulg/status/403183731449413632/photo/1)

The problem I have with the article is that you're making a series of assumptions and treating them as fact, or at least as highly likely. This is difficult to make stick with a company that is deliberately opaque, as is their right to be.

* I am of course analyzing this from a very-outside perspective and my assumptions should be taken with a grain of salt. Or ten.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by borski on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:55PM (#7119781)
"Why sell if you're eating everyone's lunch?"

Because $800M is success in anyone's book, and payments are hard.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by rgbrenner on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:00PM (#7117536)
Out of curiosity, why don't you release metrics?

I would like to use Stripe for one of my startups.. but wasn't able to find any numbers.. so since the company is young, and you get a small fraction of the total processed... with 30 employees at Stripe... I figure you have a huge burn rate.. and I'm hesitant to use it.. not when I'm already familiar with authnet, paypal, and others..

Stripe looks great, but no numbers means I can't be sure if you guys are doing well.. or if I'm going to be doing an integration with a different company in a year.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by pc on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:13PM (#7117635)
Want to drop me an email? [email protected]. Would be happy to describe our thinking and see if we can help out with your startup.

(Also -- we're now 85 people and have companies like Rackspace and Hubspot using Stripe in case that helps :-).)

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by dangrossman on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:26PM (#7117724)
> I can't be sure if you guys are doing well.. or if I'm going to be doing an integration with a different company in a year.

If you can spend a couple extra bucks, you might consider integrating with Spreedly instead of with any individual processor. They're a unified API for 55+ gateways, and a gateway-agnostic card vault. This is one of the worries using them eliminates; you can use Stripe no matter what your concerns are, because if they do disappear in a year, you can point your sites back at Authnet or whoever you prefer without changing any code. No interruption of service, no lost customer info to continue billing.

http://www.spreedly.com

You do have to trust Spreedly will still be around, but that's much easier than trusting in a new processor. Unlike a payment processor, they don't suffer from existential threats like a failure in their risk evaluation allowing a fraud event to wipe out a month's worth of profit at a time. Their business model basically prints money (run an API, keep a few pennies of each transaction) and they've been at it for years.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by zallarak on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:01PM (#7116718)
First off, congrats on the hard work and incredible progress you guys have made.

I'd just comment that you responding to this, along with a YC partner, only adds credibility to the story. If its BS, it should be totally ignored. The fact that both of you took time to attempt to discredit an article from a blog would make one question why you feel the need to do so.

Interestingly I got down-voted on this comment too.. Ironic because I am generally impressed with and love Stripe and its story. Just sayin' to not take an outlet like Pando too seriously.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by ivanca on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:17PM (#7117010)
So, when scientist take the time to point out why creationism is wrong it means that they believe creationism is correct? I call bullshit on you.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by zallarak on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:31PM (#7117282)
You make a good analogy but in my personal opinion, stretch it too far. The greatest scientists don't get caught up in squabbles about creationism with fools - they simply let their work prove it wrong. They are too busy to engage in petty debates with a blog. Why should founders of a billion dollar company care what a blog says? Now if it were a regulatory institution or a credible news organization that investors take seriously/Stripe was publicly traded, then its a different matter because media perception would have a material impact on the business. Debating Pando does no benefit for them, so it makes one wonder why they engaged.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by ChuckMcM on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:53PM (#7116666)
Shocking that PandoDaily got their facts wrong! :-) In a weird way, the press coverage feels more bubblish when the press can't figure out what is going on and do this sort of article (one presumes to draw out data they couldn't get in the first place). Of course it could just be to get the rage views.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by tomasien on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:40PM (#7116557)
Did they bother to check PG's Twitter account? I mean, do they think he's lying?
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by TheMakeA on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:41PM (#7116565)
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by dangrossman on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:51PM (#7116649)
That graph certainly makes the premise of the article seem entirely incorrect.
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by joshuaknox on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:08PM (#7116828)
That graph doesn't have labelled axes, so it's pretty hard to glean much of anything from it accurately.

Assuming blue is Nov 2012-Nov 2013, that means that the starting point for 6 months ago is roughly 2/3 of the way across the blue. Eyeballing it, the height roughly doubles during that period, which would be consistent with the article.

Disclosure: I work for Braintree.

Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by pbreit on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:30PM (#7117268)
If blue is 12 months then 6 months would be 1/2 across and it looks more like tripling (and accelerating, rapidly).
Re:Memo to Stripe: Winning the hearts of Valley startups is ... by rgbrenner on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:58PM (#7116697)
That graph contains no numbers and therefore does not have enough information to refute (or even disagree) the article