News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by sillysaurus2 on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:36AM (#7114597)
Smartphones are powerful now, yet games that manage to match the quality and depth of an SNES-era game are basically non-existent. After seeing the success of Rovio, Zynga and King, I don't think they will be made sadly.

It's important to realize that our tastes aren't necessarily representative of people's tastes in general. Most people probably wouldn't enjoy Chrono Trigger or FF3 compared to Candy Crush. The evidence is that Final Fantasy games have been available for smartphones for a long time now, but they just aren't selling. The storytelling experience is the same, but people aren't as into them.

It's easy to label the industry as "low confidence" but reality is more along the lines of "acts on hard data." It's wise to be cautious when it only takes one or two mistakes to kill your company.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by simias on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:58AM (#7114675)
I think the reason is not so much the taste of the people but rather the fact that a smartphone is not a NES. It's not the same use case.

Most successful games on phones are extremely casual, meant to be played for 5 minutes at a time while waiting for something else. The games you cited were meant to be played hours at a time.

That lowers people expectations as well as the price they're willing to pay for the games on phones.

Also, the fact that almost all interactions have to be done through the touchscreen makes many game types impractical.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by oneeyedpigeon on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:26AM (#7114773)
Settlers on the iPad is brilliant. The touchscreen interface is perfect for such a game, and I’ve certainly played it for hours at a time. Not sure how well it would translate to phone screen size, or if it’s even available.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by zimpenfish on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:25AM (#7114963)
You can get it on the iPhone and it's a bit fiddly. Definitely playable though.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Karunamon on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:04AM (#7114868)
They may not be selling because Square is selling their SNES-era games for tens of dollars. In a marketplace where $5.99 is considered a premium/high price, it's just plain insulting.

20ish year old games with minor graphical enhancements are not worth $15.99

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by xauronx on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:11AM (#7114897)
"Insulting" might be the wrong word there. I would think it's more insulting to tell someone how to value their work. Perhaps, it's an unwise price if they're looking for millions of downloads, but I don't know. I think that in order to keep pushing the iPhone toward a real gaming platform instead these ADHD spin offs and in app purchases, we need more of the big boys to price things at a sustainable price tag.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Karunamon on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:13AM (#7114907)
There's nothing reasonable or sustainable about $16 for a 20 year old game. My immediate reaction is "Are these people serious?" followed by "What do they think they're going to sell me that a SNES emulator can't provide?"

It feels like they're insulting my intelligence, in other words.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by untog on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:58AM (#7115126)
I'm not sure why the age would affect the value. Either it's a good game or it isn't. I paid for Grand Theft Auto 3 on my phone - is that too old to have value or is it still in the value zone? I'm confused.

Now, SNES emulators are something else. It's worth pointing out that downloading ROMs is not technically legal. And (at least on the iPhone) you can't use one without jailbreaking your phone.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Karunamon on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:25AM (#7115679)
Pong is a good game. It cost about $100 when it first came out.

Would you pay even half that for a mobile implementation?

As to the legality of roms, let's say I own a rather extensive SNES library (including every SE game available on Android). As far as I'm concerned, my conscience is clear. Nothing wrong with format shifting.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by vinkelhake on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:52PM (#7116236)
Games do age. Something that was looked impressive 20 years ago will probably look very dated by current standards.

Great games or not, trying to sell them at a price that is two or three times that of a "premium" game like Grand Theft Auto is ludicrous. The market has been conditioned to expect mobile games to sell for a dollar or two.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by p_e_n_g_u_i_n on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:56AM (#7115899)
You don't need to jailbreak; although MacBuildServer is down now, there are still a few websites that will exploit the Enterprise License for you. This will be "fixed" in iOS 7.1 though. SiOS (https://github.com/lmmenge/SiOS) is a good SNES emu for iPhone, I did a custom build but that isn't necessary.

I have no problem with downloading a ROM for a game I already own. Plus, you can't even prove I did it if I download it through a VPN and deleted it off my phone afterwards.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Dysiode on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:30AM (#7115310)
A touch interface, for one. Emulates are find and all but I find their inaccuracy frustrating more often than not. Further, it's not just a 20 year old game on an emulator. Somebody has to port it, make graphics (for what they are worth), probably localize it. Sure it's not necessarily as hard as making a game from scratch (though that could be debated), but that doesn't mean the costs aren't similar.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Adirael on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:49AM (#7115436)
Are they actually ported? I've played Sonic games on iOS that were just emulators (awfully done emulators).
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by pawn on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:26AM (#7115687)
I have Final Fantasy 1 for my Nokia, and it's actually a port rather than an emulation. I haven't looked up the differences, but what I've found so far are: The interface supports tapping on characters rather than selecting them with the 'directional-pad' which appears on the map when walking around. There's at least one new area to explore. The magic system is more like later games, using MP. Graphics have been improved

I'm not sure how many of these are ports from the DS version, though. Possibly all of them.

Based on the screenshots of FF3 for Windows, it appears to be a port of the DS re-make rather than the Famicom original

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by e_proxus on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:19AM (#7115629)
I think they're mostly just ported. I've bought a few of the Square games on iOS and they were just the normal games with touch capabilities added on top of the old menus. No usability changes at all to accomodate modern touch patterns. There are many "click" needed to navigate some menus, which would just have been one touch or drag in a modern app. Scrolling was also laggy and glitchy.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by logfromblammo on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:52AM (#7115870)
They're not really insulting your intelligence. They are insulting your first sale rights, and your decision to buy the original game and not re-sell it later.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by kcbanner on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:59PM (#7119082)
Well, they are selling you the legal right to own and run the game.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by mcdougle on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:24AM (#7114954)
Do we really expect the iPhone to become a real gaming platform? I'm not being rude, it's an honest question.

I don't see it ever becoming more, as a gaming platform, than it is now -- something to do to kill time while waiting in line or whatever else. I feel like the people who want a real gaming platform are, for the most part, more likely to go out and buy a full computer, an XBox, a Playstation, etc.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Cthulhu_ on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:47AM (#7115080)
It /is/ a real gaming platform, and companies like King.com make a killing off of the platform(s); not in the traditional sense of the word like the AAA games of PC and consoles, but in a novel fashion with addictive games, microtransactions and buying ratings and downloads for promotional purposes.

And it's a very real gaming platform for the millions of people that play and enjoy casual games like Angry Birds and Candy Crush. No it probably won't apply to people that were into gaming before it was mainstream, or to gamers that look for something with a bit more content, but for a lot of people it's awesome. Or addictive. Or both.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by mcdougle on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:46AM (#7115425)
Haha, I think we're arguing semantics here. Yes, I agree it's a real gaming platform, but not in the sense the guy above me was talking about.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by sambeau on Sunday January 26, 2014 @05:39AM (#7124691)
What makes a 'real' gaming platform? What does a 'real' gamer look like? How often does a 'real' gamer game?

All surveys of gamers over the last 5 years show that the average gamer is female, late twenties to thirty, and puts in gaming hours way above anything your average FPS gamer would. (and the figures from before that were badly skewed by having the 'hearts' players removed for not being 'real gamers' (and some even removed commercial casual games), despite being the overwhelmingly largest group of gamers (arguably, if they'd included them, we might have seen the rise in casual gaming sooner))

The iPhone is the biggest gaming platform in the world. It is also where the main gamers are playing the most hours of games. Isn't that 'real' enough for you?

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by timje1 on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:58AM (#7115127)
You might be onto a winner here. I've got chrono trigger and the monkey island on my phone and don't touch them - it's vastly more comfortable to play them for hours on my PC or emulators.

Phones need a different input device and a different display before they can be comfortable to game on for extended periods of time.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by RandallBrown on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:48PM (#7117900)
It really depends on the game. Somehow, I was able to get better at Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 2 on my iPhone than I was on the N64 version I played as a kid.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Goladus on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:46AM (#7115072)
Or a portable game system (Whatever the most recent DS/PSP thing is).

On the one hand it sucks to carry two devices on the other hand, many of the really good games are designed to be played with D-pads and buttons, not a touch screen and softkeyboard.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by mcdougle on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:52AM (#7115451)
Actually, that's a good point. Maybe, for a smartphone to become a "real" gaming platform as stated above, it's not game titles we need first, but hardware.

I know there have been Android phones introduced designed for gaming, and I think they flopped pretty hard (I didn't hear much about them for long). But maybe instead of a whole phone, a company could produce and sell a gamepad that plugs into the phone? Then they ("they" being the producer of the gamepad, and any companies that it enables to sell bigger titles) could target the DS/PSP/portable console market.

Interesting thought.....

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by ANTSANTS on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:10PM (#7118847)
To be fair, most people use their 3DS/DS/Vita/PSP/whatever more like a tablet than like a phone. They're meant for curling up on the couch on a lazy afternoon (or, uh, as something to keep you occupied on the toilet...), not for whipping out in public while you're waiting in a queue. The low battery life of the newer handhelds seems relevant: iirc the 3DS's is around 3 hours, and the Vita's is comparable.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Goladus on Saturday January 25, 2014 @11:15PM (#7123861)
I see people using portable game systems on the subway. But then whipping it out in public for 5 minutes at a time is not particularly conducive to the kind of deep games that we're talking about.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by ANTSANTS on Sunday January 26, 2014 @11:08PM (#7128742)
You're right, I should have mentioned long commutes in public transportation as the other main usage scenario of portables (especially in their country of origin), but that's not as relevant a consideration to (what I'm assuming is the average HN user) Americans living in areas with poor or nonexistent public transportation.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by jaegerpicker on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:21AM (#7114938)
I'd gladly pay $16 for a NEW game of that quality but wrapping up an old game as a new product and trying to get that out of it? No, thanks. I love mobile gaming and I'm working on trying to build a company out of it but repackaging up old games for the new platforms does not advance them in the least.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by yebyen on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:14AM (#7115208)
We used to pay $50 for every new game, why do you want a new game for $16?

I get it, most of the games are from $1 to $4, but I don't understand why. Either you pay $1-4 for a dumb little game with no depth, or you pay $16 for a quality of game that used to cost $50, when hardware was less advanced. Why?

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Karunamon on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:28AM (#7115699)
Because it's not a new game. There is not $16 worth of value there. There is no new content. It is a straight port job with bad touch controls grafted on.

I could have a superior experience with a SNES emulator.

Further, depth of a game has nothing to do with price. False dichotomy. The choice isn't between cheap games with no depth and expensive games with depth, the choice is between high value and low value.

There isn't a $16 value in what SE is putting out. There's not even a $5 value.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by yebyen on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:39PM (#7116159)
> I'd gladly pay $16 for a NEW game

This is what you wrote. I haven't been a gamer for a long time, other than some $2 and $5 games, so I'm on your side.

I'm trying to understand why we're not interested in paying $50 for a game anymore. I have a stack of them at home, I paid $50 in 1990's and 2000's money for them.

I agree that you shouldn't pay $50 for a rehash of some old game that was never designed for touch, on a platform that doesn't provide really any other options for input control.

I'm just trying to understand why nobody is putting out NEW games that you would pay $50 for. Nobody is even targeting this price point. Is it because distribution channels are so much cheaper, and there aren't as many middle-men trying to take a cut? Is there some deficiency in the platform to explain why they /can't/ sell us games at the $50 price?

I'm not talking about Candy Crush Saga. The consoles are still successful at selling new games for $50+. Nobody is doing it for Android or iOS as far as I can tell. Are we waiting for NVidia Shield and Ouya, or is there some other reason why nobody is producing for this platform any new, original games of high quality that you would pay $50 for?

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by eropple on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:03PM (#7116303)
Nobody's selling them because the few people who've tried to target an upmarket price point have failed miserably and the sort of investment needed to make a game "worth" $50 in the world of mobile games (filled with insane players who seem to think a dozen hours of gameplay isn't worth $3) would be a massive, massive risk. The only people able to actually move units at a price point over $10 seems to be Square themselves, and even they're not doing a great job of it with that mind-boggling back catalog of games and name recognition to use to their advantage.

I'm making a 2D JRPG right now - first wave of platforms being PC/Mac/maybe-Linux, second wave being mobile and tablet devices. The PC version will be priced between $15 and $20; the mobile one will by necessity end up around $8-$10 because that is the ceiling that people seem willing to pay for games (and not a lot of them at that).

From where I sit, the mobile market is largely quality-inelastic (unless you measure quality on 'reactivity of your Skinner box') and while I'm porting my game, I wouldn't bother otherwise if it wasn't solely a learning experience for me. Even if I was at an AAA shop I certainly couldn't justify spending the sort of money necessary to "validate" the existence of a $50 title on iOS.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by chc on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:19PM (#7116411)
Besides market issues, it is just really hard to make a very sophisticated game on a touchscreen. The controls are inherently imprecise and require you to cover up a third of the screen anytime you're interacting. The SNES game landscape would have looked very different if it had a control scheme with those properties. The popular sorts of games for mobile are the sorts of games that actually work well with the limitations of the phone hardware.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by jaegerpicker on Saturday January 25, 2014 @10:38AM (#7121055)
I'm not sure I'd pay $50 for a game unless it's one I REALLY wanted because friends were playing. I buy a medium amount of games but they are almost all are $20 and under. I tend to not like the big AAA production type of games except for a few exceptions (Mass effect, Uncharted, Skyrim but that's about all) but I love super meat boy, spelunky, bastion, banner saga, and tons of other indie games like them. To me it seems a better business model pay a smaller price from a digital delivery platform (Steam, iOS app store, google play store etc...) that a much larger chunk goes to the actual devs.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by yebyen on Friday January 24, 2014 @06:49PM (#7119032)
Issues responding to a new poster who is some other person than GP... sorry

I see now that's not what you wrote at all, but that was the point that drove my response.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by zeidrich on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:05PM (#7116758)
Because there are many games, and there is a bigger market of people buying those games.

Since there is more people buying those games, a popular game can be profitable at a lower price now than a popular game could have been profitable at in the past. There is also no mark-up through as many distribution channels. There's no physical shelf space necessary, there's not the same sort of publisher relationships needed. A team (of any size) can create a game and publish it directly.

So because of changes in distribution and an increased market, the price should go down due to reduced expenses. But the other side is that many of these changes also reduce the barrier to entry of new developers. This means that there's more competition which means that the price will go down due to reduced margins from competition.

It's not so much that it's $1-4 for a dumb game and $16 for a quality game. It's that people sell quality games for less than 5 dollars and still make money. It's also the perception that "this game was already made". Chances are the people who are buying it have already played it because these rereleases are generally for fans of the game. So you're paying again for a game that's 20 years old. Does it make sense to pay more than a new game?

That said I'm in total agreement that the biggest thing about it is form factor. People don't buy SNES rpgs on the phone because phones aren't the best way to play SNES rpgs.

Phones have a small screen, long term playing on such a small screen causes eye strain, phones have touch screens, which are great for angry birds, because it's a very intuitive use for touch. Touch screen gamepads are not intuitive, and occlude the screen. Phones are always on you which is very handy for games that you want to pick up or put down, but not so important for marathon sessions. Phones have batteries which need to be considered, so again, you want to avoid the marathon gaming sessions.

The reason we have so many casual games on the phone is because the phone is the ideal target for casual games. Games that you can pick up and put down. Go and play a level of candy crush saga on the toilet. Go and shoot some angry birds waiting for the train. I've tried to play some RPGs this way and you might get through a minor segment of a story line or some plot exposition on the can before your legs start to get numb.

You often find $60 PC games for sale. We haven't moved to a point where games are all $1-4. We just have moved to a point where casual games are $1-4, and bigger games demand a different delivery method than a little phone screen and substandard (compared with the alternatives of a console or PC) hardware. If you're going to pay $60 for a game, you're probably planning on putting some real time aside for it, which means sitting at your desk or on the couch. When you get an app for the phone instead, you do it because you might get some use out of it when you can't spend the time to sit at a desk or on the couch.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by yebyen on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:36PM (#7117804)
I must be overestimating the market for tablet gamers. It seems like we used to pay $200-400 for console game systems that didn't include a TV or stereo sound (sure, we all had TVs). I've spent around and below the low end of that range on half a dozen tablets, some as gifts, and the price of this kind of hardware is going down while hardware quality goes up.

Now many people are shelling out just as much for tablets and phones (or through subsidy plans, eventually paying as much as for TV consoles). Today, I have a Wii Mini which was $99, pay extra for more controllers, $10-30 a game since mostly all Wii games are used, or at least are priced as used... and I couldn't be happier that there's no way to hook it up to the internet and Pay-to-Play.

I wish that some of the games were more casual, but from a small sample, the Lego LOTR game is engaging, multiplayer, and really just couldn't be done at all on a small screen with a touch interface. Same goes for Just Dance, or Michael Jackson Experience. Still I can't help feeling like the makers of games for iOS and Android are sandbagging the market. It is about depth for me, and I honestly can't say that I've seen a lot of Android games competing on a much higher level than even the crappiest Wii games that I got for under $10.

Then again, I haven't paid more than $7 for any Android game.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by NDizzle on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:48PM (#7116211)
Check out Zenonia - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zenonia

I played Zenonia 2 on my iPad when I first got it and it was pretty solid.

They've now released a few more Zenonia games for several platforms at this point.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by entelechy0 on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:31PM (#7117761)
Too much "pay to win" shit. That stuff is literally killing mobile game potential.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by scardine on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:15AM (#7115606)
Value and price are distinct things. The value of anything is not the price the author think he is entitled to charge nor the manufacturing cost + a fair profit, it is the price people is willing to pay.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by DanBC on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:58AM (#7114673)
I don't care about people liking Candy Crush. Match 3 is a huge genre.

It's just sad that there isn't a clone that costs $4.99 to buy and doesn't need more purchases. It's even sadder that even if the clone did exist few people would buy it.

I really miss the Doom model of give away a few levels cor free and buy the rest.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by officemonkey on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:53AM (#7114844)
I don't understand why people think Candy Crush is bad. I've played Candy Crush for close to a year (I'm on level 153) and I haven't spent a dime.

Sure, I've played the same level for weeks on end, but I haven't bought anything.

Of course I've been tempted to push the button, spend 99 cents and bypass the level, but I have something called willpower and a certain amount of pride that every level I've beaten is legit.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by jader201 on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:21AM (#7115249)
> I don't understand why people think Candy Crush is bad.

> ...but I have something called willpower

This is why people think Candy Crush is bad -- because most people don't have this willpower, and it plays on this weakness, almost to an exact science.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by elliottcarlson on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:08AM (#7115181)
I've been somewhat addicted to Candy Crush for the last few months (at level 305 now - long commutes give me way too much free time) and I haven't spent a dime either. What was surprising to hear was that some co-workers have paid at every "world" change - and they didn't know there was a way to get through to the next world without paying. It seems, when it is hooked up to your Facebook account, you don't have the option to play the three bonus levels over the course of 24 hours each - only nagging FB friends and paying. The trick is to just sign-out of FB in-game, play the three levels and then connect it back up if you wanted to.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by jlees on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:37AM (#7115364)
Yes, I only realised this recently. I got into the habit of paying (although via FB, as the cost to unlock new levels is 2 credits - 20c - rather than $0.99).

However, I'm actually quite happy to pay for the content directly. Developers don't work for free, and they're constantly adding to the game. I like to support them (and other devs) as so many people expect to get hundreds of hours of gameplay for free these days.

I don't see an issue with paying for content gates in such a fashion -- but I do dislike the "Pay $0.99 to get 5 more moves, you've nearly done it!" mechanic, and others like it, so I don't pay for those.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by officemonkey on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:17PM (#7116402)
I've never signed in to FB, so I never knew the bonus level option disappeared.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by GaveUp on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:51AM (#7115867)
My biggest gripe is that the game is designed in a way to extract as much money as possible to the detriment of the game itself.

There are several levels you'll play where you have absolutely zero chance of winning (particularly the later levels where you need X of this and Y of that) because the colors just don't come up. Yeah, that's down to randomness, but it's one of those things that could be resolved. Also, when playing if you receive a call or switch to some other app in the middle of a game you lose your game and that life. Yet another way to pluck more money out of people. Then you have the arbitrary play limits (3 days to unlock another pack via bonus levels, 30 minute waits for lives, etc).

I'd have much less of a problem with the game if each level had a solvable method to it. Then you can make it pay to pass or skill to win.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by xixi77 on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:37PM (#7116538)
I'm not sure -- I think it just a patience vs. money trade off.

Which levels are you talking about? Definitely there are levels where it all comes down to luck, but even with 0.5% of winning, you'll probably get there after a couple hundred games. I'm not even sure it's a good business decision for them, more like poor design imo -- I suspect there are more people who get frustrated and quit than those who actually pay...

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by GaveUp on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:44PM (#7117419)
The levels I'm thinking of are the ones that require 200 green or multiple combos of special candies. Add in the chocolate things and the tornadoes and it just gets worse.

I don't know if it was poor design or purposeful to get more money out of people, but I tend to think the latter because of just how many places it begs to buy things.

People probably do get frustrated and quit. I know that's what I end up doing. Especially when my gaming habits are 30 minutes here and there. I just want a short session, not play for 5 minutes and have to pay more or wait 30 minutes to play more.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by mbreese on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:07AM (#7115555)
I'm in the same boat as you - played for a while, high level, never paid.

But, I wonder if all of the levels actually are beatable. I haven't been able to figure out if some of the levels are random or not. It seems like there are definite patterns for some levels, but not all.

This is what bothers me. I want to know that any given board can be beaten. If it can't and then they charge you to keep playing, that would be dishonest.

I just haven't figured out it that was the case or not.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by xixi77 on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:33PM (#7116514)
I am pretty sure there are people out there who have completed all levels without powerups/extensions/etc, so I think yes. And with the wheel of fortune thing, you don't even have to pay for powerups.

The only one I've had a problem with so far was 417 (which is basically a lottery level), but if I didn't have enough free powerups in storage, I am quite sure I would get lucky one time...

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Ygg2 on Saturday January 25, 2014 @08:57AM (#7120764)
Great, so instead of spending willpower on something useful, you spend it on avoiding temptations of Candy Crush.

http://seriouspony.com/blog/2013/7/24/your-app-makes-me-fat

The fact that people are playing it regardless of whether they are paying or not helps king.com make profit to demolish games like Banner Saga (note: this is a game I backed).

You might wonder how - but it's rather simple. Even if you pay zilch to play and you get to level 153, your friend brother, mom, sister, father or acquaintance will see this and try it out, and perhaps get hooked (if it's someone that would pay money to 'compete' in levels with you, even better).

It's a numbers game. Games like that depend on few gamers that spend in the thousands (aka 'whales'), and to get to them they need to wade through a sea of people that spend 0$ but are connected to the so called 'whales' .

So yes, thanks again for helping King.com ruin The Banner Saga for me...

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by p_e_n_g_u_i_n on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:19AM (#7114748)
> I really miss the Doom model of give away a few levels cor free and buy the rest.

Sadly, things like this get tons of hate in the reviews... People would rather be annoyed with stupid social media and IAP crap than pay a dollar for the rest of the game. The only way to really make it work is (from my experience) make an ad-supported, shortened lite version, so people can test it out before buying it. That's a real pain because now you have two malls to manage, update, and promote. At least that's how it works on iOS.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by interpol_p on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:42AM (#7114824)
I don't find this to be the case at all, we produced a game which was free and had a single purchase for the rest of the levels. People didn't complain any more than normal, conversion was good.

I also believe this model is executed well on the App Store — I personally play and purchase Tell Tale's episodic games, the Layton Brothers Mystery Room game, Phoenix Wright, Ghost Trick, and so on. All of them use this sales model.

One of the biggest, most loved games ever also used this model: Letterpress. It is free and offers a single purchase for unlimited multiplayer opponents. People love it.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by GFischer on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:49AM (#7115437)
A bit offtopic: where can I get recommendations for good mobile games? Geared towards a HN-like crowd :)

I've read about more interesting Android games on this article's comments (didn't know there were Layton games for Android) than in several unsuccesful searches. And all the "most popular" Android games the Play store shows me are not for me.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by xsmasher on Friday January 24, 2014 @02:33PM (#7117300)
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by GFischer on Friday January 24, 2014 @07:46PM (#7119285)
Thank you :)
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by DanBC on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:45PM (#7116601)
Did you do Crabitron?

http://twolivesleft.com/Crabitron/

A blog post about what happens when Yogscast briefly mentions your game would (I hope) be appreciated by HN.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by interpol_p on Saturday January 25, 2014 @02:58AM (#7120219)
We did do Crabitron.

We post all our sales (including what happened after Yogscast) on our "Crabstarter" page: http://www.crabstarter.com

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by Crito on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:15PM (#7116026)
This scheme didn't hurt Doom though, far from it, so what is the difference?

Is the change in platform somehow making the difference? Is it that Doom was perceived as technically advanced, while these smartphone games are not? Has the audience just gotten less mature, and more entitled?

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by sh4na on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:39AM (#7114815)
Who needs clones when you can have Ron Gilbert's Scurvy Scallywags! https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/scurvy-scallywags/id59329984...

I'm a huge fan of Match 3 games and I can honestly say there's plenty enough choice in that genre without having to rely on Candy Crush.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by zimpenfish on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:13AM (#7115206)
Seconded (although the permadeath-style reset when you completely die annoyed me greatly.)
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by girvo on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:28AM (#7114978)
I love match 3. I owned a legit copy of Bejwelled 2 on Windows Mobile (heh), Android, and now my iPad and iPhone. I love that game.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by sleepyK on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:13AM (#7114722)
Lots of games do that, and that seems to be the only respectable way to monetize.... that and in-game item sales.... but those tend to go too far and then cripple gameplay.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by osxrand on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:08AM (#7115563)
The Doom model wouldn't work on me anymore, unless the game was spectacular.

Once I've played the first x levels, I've usually satisfied my curiosity about the game and, if there is a pay wall, move on.

I do appreciate the chance to try before I buy, but maybe because I'm not 'investing' in the game (either by paying money upfront or time investment in a free game), it's easy to move on to one of the hundreds of other good games out here.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by smackfu on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:15AM (#7114917)
>It's just sad that there isn't a clone that costs $4.99 to buy and doesn't need more purchases.

Practically speaking, a lot of these freemium games just have a lot of money to spend on creating content. It's usually a better more polished game even if you don't spend money on it. That $5 clone has to come up with all the development budget up front, while the freemium version has constant cash flow.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by GFischer on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:12AM (#7114718)
There are free Match 3 games, at least on Android, I have downloaded and played several :) .

Example - JewelsStar

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.game.Jewel...

However, I'd pay for a polished experience like a PopCap made game (Bejeweled).

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by prawks on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:37AM (#7115366)
Final Fantasy is a poor example, I think.

Games like Castlevania, Mario, Zelda, Metroid which have simple but well-executed mechanics have basically gone out of flavor because the broader populace... I originally said this is because they do not enjoy difficult or lengthy games, however I think that may be incorrect. I think the wider populace craves achievement, and being able to show something for the time they've sunk into the game (as well as probably being put off by games with difficult learning curves). Games like Farmville, Candycrush, and most MMORPGs, while time consuming, award "something" the player can "show off" afterwards.

I think games like Spelunky are more along the lines of games the OP and many people I speak with miss. The indie game community on PC and XBLA have done wonders as of late. It's a shame it's not quite gone so well for mobile, but PC and mobile gaming are two massively different audiences. Quality games are far, far, FAR from dead, you just need to look to places where people with like-minded interests from you are.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by schnevets on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:31AM (#7115718)
Seems to me like it has less to do with the tastes of kids these days and more to do with the interface and features of the device. 2D platformers are damn hard to play on a touch screen and require a lot more attention than the typical puzzler/social game. The genres of Zynga and Rovio thrived organically in mobile environments. Meanwhile, the more "hardcore" gaming companies are trying their damndest to force existing game mechanics into an environment that doesn't sustain them.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by DanBC on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:43AM (#7115805)
Blocky Roads and similar could be the 2d platformers for the phone generation.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by GFischer on Friday January 24, 2014 @08:11AM (#7114716)
I have one of the Final Fantasy games on my cell phone, and the user experience is really not good for a cell phone game.

One kind of game I expected to do really well and I'm still waiting, is graphic adventure games.

In either case, I think the problem is recognizing that smartphone games are similar but different to handheld consoles, I'm sure there are plenty of insights to be had - maybe game sessions of 5-15 minutes instead of whatever handhelds have

This article says they're equal, but maybe it's a chicken and egg problem :)

http://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/iphone-gaming-sessions...

"traditional mobile games are played for around six minutes at a time"

"with Rolando .. the average play session is 22 minutes"

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by jaegerpicker on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:27AM (#7114974)
There some really REALLY good graphic adventure games for iOS, like the tell tale games for instance. The walking dead series is one of the best iOS games I've ever played.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by GFischer on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:45AM (#7115417)
I've heard about that, and I've played one Sam & Max game by Telltale :) .

I don't have and don't plan on owning any Apple devices - not useful and too expensive in my country, the local ecosystem uses Android, so I hope they release more games for Android :) I thought they hadn't released, any but apparently they just did !!! Should show them some support by buying it :)

www.slimgamer.com/16504/telltales-the-walking-dead-season-one-finally-comes-to-android/

should I watch the TV series before?

Thank you for pointing me to that game :)

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by foldor on Friday January 24, 2014 @03:03PM (#7117556)
The Telltale Walking Dead game is actually based on the comic book universe, which is distinct from the TV show. Also, the game features a completely separate story, with only a few character references for fans to catch.

So no, you don't need to watch the show or read the comic to enjoy the game, but as with all license properties it never hurts.

Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by mikestew on Friday January 24, 2014 @12:13PM (#7116010)
I'd show support by buying it if it ran on something other than an Amazon Kindle Fire DX. :-( Rumor has it that one can side-load it, but I'm not going to hassle with that only to find out it has issues on a Galaxy Note 3.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by girvo on Friday January 24, 2014 @09:30AM (#7114985)
I just played the first episode of The Walking Dead on my iPad. Please, give it a try... It's mind blowingly good.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by GFischer on Friday January 24, 2014 @10:47AM (#7115433)
Thanks, will do if I get it to work on a Google Nexus :)
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by etler on Friday January 24, 2014 @01:04PM (#7116311)
Beyond that, there's a very limited range of games smartphones can support. Because of the lack of dedicated physical buttons, most action game just do not work. The action games that do well are runners, because they remove nearly all the controls except for dodge. Because the screen is a touch screen you inherently cover the screen as you control the game. It's the reason the DS has two screens, so you can cover up part of the second screen without blocking the main action above.
Re:King.com, makers of Candy Crush Saga – Trademark Trolls w... by bkurtz13 on Friday January 24, 2014 @11:02AM (#7115523)
How do you know they aren't selling? It would be nice to have actual data before making blanket statements that conveniently support your point.