News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by Dn_Ab on Sunday January 19, 2014 @07:59PM (#7086906)
Sidenote: You can tell Woz is an amazing genuinely good person with no hint of pretension or self importance.

A lot can be discerned about famous personalities by who they choose to follow. For example, you can tell whether the person has little utility for social networks but maybe started out following a scattering of experts relevant to their interests.

Usually though, the personality is using their handful of followed people as an importance signalling factor. Often they will be following somewhere between -5e6 to 10 hugely important to unbelievably hugely important people; people with names like Larry Page, Jeff Bezos, Paris Hilton, Bono, Lord Vishnu and Kanye West.

On the other hand we have those like Steve Wozniak - following nearly 5000 people and deigning to reply to someone even the likes of HN commenter OGC is completely unaware of.

That is, in all seriousness, an incredible sign of sustained humility.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by wpietri on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:00PM (#7087477)
I volunteered at a conference series where Steve Wozniak was a regular attendee.

As anybody who has ever worked a generic job knows, some people treat you like people, and some treat you like a used tissue. This particular conference had an amazing volunteer crew that had been together for years, many of whom had serious day jobs: brilliant designers, high-tech executives, etc. Knowing that the volunteers were gems, I knew that how the famous conference speakers treated them was all about the speakers. I didn't think famous people would really do the, "Do you know who I am?" thing, but I saw it happen.

Anyhow, Wozniak was one of the best. Warm, friendly, genuine. I remember one year he showed us a magic-shop gizmo he had just acquired, delighted by the cool effect they had contrived. Since I had grown up hacking on my Apple ][+ and kinda idolizing him, it was both a pleasure and a relief to learn that he was just as swell to everybody as you'd expect him to be.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by sliverstorm on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:54PM (#7087654)
I've always wondered more about Woz than Jobs! We get plenty of shrewd businessmen; they aren't a dime-a-dozen, but they aren't an enigma either. Kind of an understood phenomenon. People like Woz (at least based on the myriad recountings; I have not met the man) seem to actually be rare. I wonder if there was an interesting aspect to his youth, or what. Maybe the same way that you can have a psychopath, you can have the opposite? Someone whose brain is hard-wired to be more empathetic than normal?
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by abalone on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:50AM (#7087818)
Jobs was more than a "shrewd businessman". Building Pixar over 10 years into one of the top movie studios was not some "shrewd" business decision. Ditto for NeXT, the early Mac, the iPod, the iPhone, the iPad.. It's more accurate to say he was a visionary who took a long term view.

It's only in retrospect that we have the luxury of looking on his track record as smart from a business standpoint. Woz even criticizes the early Mac for losing money. Says Scully saved the company. Which tells you a lot about what separates Woz from Jobs.

Folks like Woz were a big influence on Jobs. So were a bunch of other people. The idea that he just took other peoples' ideas and marketed them is the same old trope. He took the best raw, undeveloped ideas from the billions around him and fit them to together and refined them into something accessible to everyone. VERY FEW people can do that well. He proved he could do it, not just once, but countless times in multiple categories.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by wirrbel on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:53AM (#7088117)
Jobs is a designer. Using existing pieces to create a good product. While this is an important skill to have, it is nothing I would idolize someone for, moreover, Jobs only was capable of focussing on design because countless Wozniaks did the plumbing (and really awesome hacking). This is _division of labor_. You just cannot build products alone.

While Jobs did his job, he certainly was arrogant and a few times too often humbled those people making his products possible. This is not cool at all. I refuse the viewpoint that a manager has to be that way to implement his vision.

Since the era of Romanticism in the 19th century, we like to think in terms of "Geniuses" and look out for them to admire them. This is pretty sad, because it should be well known by now, that only with collaboration real products and inventions can be delivered.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by ghshephard on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:26AM (#7088933)
Anybody who worked anywhere near Jobs will observe he was one of the biggest assholes around. I know quite a few people who worked in, or near his sphere - and they are all pretty consistent on this point.

And yet, who else in modern history has driven as many companies to such such success, and lead the creation of so many great products?

We had a ton of the NeXT machines at my university, and I still believe they, more than anything, demonstrate the height of Steve's capability of creating a company and product. Anybody who used Sun's Desktop OS and associated applications 5 years later saw how far ahead of the market NeXT was. I thought it was a far superior product to the Macintosh, which, by 1993/1994, was starting to get long in the tooth, and by 1996/1997 had fallen behind Windows in platform power/flexibility, causing me (never particularly religious about the platform I worked on - best tool for the job and all) to leave the Mac behind and switch to Windows (Followed by a switch back in 2003 when OS X took the lead again)

Does anyone honestly think Apple would exist today (and certainly not in it's current dominance) were it not for this single individual?

And, is it really a coincidence that Pixar rose to the heights it did with Steve at the helm?

Sadly (speaking as one) - technologists are for the most part fungible, you can swap out one for another. Designers/Architects are somewhat more rare, but they can be identified, recruited, and hired.

But Geniuses/Leaders - they come but once in a lifetime, and we admire them for that uniqueness.

Certainly doesn't mean we have to like them as people though.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by wpietri on Monday January 20, 2014 @10:38AM (#7089991)
I don't totally disagree, but I think this is excessively sunny.

As somebody who was an early NeRD (NeXT Registered Developer) and helped start one of the NeXT User Groups, I don't think I would call NeXT a successful company. It created some great technology for its day, but it was an ongoing commercial failure. Nobody would buy the hardware, so they killed that early. By the end they were killing off the OS and going in the direction of being a set of Windows development tools.

It was only that Apple wanted Jobs that saved them, that and Steve's enormous ego, which demanded he bring NeXT along. At the time, Apple could have bought Be and I expect it would have gone as well or better. Remember, it took them 3 years to get a new OS out the door, which is a long time in market-land. And really, the NeXT stuff didn't make a giant difference; it wasn't until the iPod that Apple really took off.

It's worth noting that Steve Jobs's major skill, aside from yelling at people until they designed something that he liked, was marketing. Jobs was incredibly good at selling himself. When weighing his "genius", I think it's worth looking at the extent to which his public image has been shaped by his own skill in self-promotion, and the fact that his company made something that a lot of people directly use and love.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by pjbrunet on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @12:43AM (#7093687)
I agree about the iPod, before that Apple was a sad story. They just rebranded the Diamond PMP for the Napster crowd, which was pretty smart. Nobody knew what an MP3 player was till Napster came along:

Diamond Rio MP3 player - 1998

Napster - 1999

iPod - 2001

After that, everything they made was a minimal white box with rounded corners and the rest is history. LOL.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by hexagonc on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @09:21AM (#7095329)
If I recall correctly, Apple didn't really take off until they released a Windows compatible iPod. That singular decision to leap out of the Apple-only ecosystem is what set the stage for the iPhone and the iPad and all other success thereafter. I wonder what world we would be in if Apple had continued to insist on people switching to OSX hardware before enjoying the benefits of the iPod. I suspect that most of the huge market for Windows users would have turned to the Zune, which the few people who actually own them seemed to like. Image a world where the Zune had won the music player wars.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by impeachgod on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:48PM (#7090741)
Fortunately for us, Apple acquiring NeXT instead of Be means that we get to program iOS and OS X in Objective-C instead of C++.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by ekianjo on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @12:07AM (#7093588)
There's a lot of things to say against Objective-C, as far as I know.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by kenrikm on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @12:47PM (#7096876)
And there's a lot to say against C++ as well, AFAIK.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by impeachgod on Wednesday January 29, 2014 @03:12AM (#7142653)
But much less than against C++.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by hahainternet on Monday January 20, 2014 @08:39AM (#7089403)
> But Geniuses/Leaders - they come but once in a lifetime, and we admire them for that uniqueness.

Oh please. There are 7 billion people in this world. This hero worship has got to stop. By your own admission he was a complete arsehole. His 'vision' was who he could exploit. Look at how he treated Woz. That's not the actions of a visionary, that's the actions of an egomaniac who discovered a route to power.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by Tyrannosaurs on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:37AM (#7089686)
With respect that's as blinkered a view in the opposite direction. Neither the "Jobs was a genius" nor the "Jobs was an asshole" narratives are incorrect, but neither are complete and as such neither is particularly helpful or enlightening on it's own.

To me at least, what makes Jobs most interesting is what he achieved despite being an asshole and how that played out. He undoubtedly was a thoroughly unpleasant individual and people who worked with him will queue around the block to tell you that, but he also, coming from a pretty low baseline, turned Apple into the largest company in the world by getting many of those same people who will tell you he's an asshole to build genuinely great products.

The most interesting people are rarely one thing or the other - that's what makes them interesting.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by soperj on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:20PM (#7090955)
I don't know what the big deal about Apple being the "largest company in the world" is. Who was the company that they passed. Exxon Mobile? Shell? They create great products used by billions around the world. No one romanticizes their CEOs, and they're all assholes too.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by mwfunk on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:44PM (#7091946)
It's not who they passed on the way up, it's the fact that they did it in 12 years starting from when their company was 60 days from bankruptcy after spending the preceding decade in a seemingly endless death spiral with no future. Do you not remember Apple in 1996? Blackberry right now looks positively bursting with potential by comparison.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by soperj on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:47PM (#7091970)
Blackberry isn't getting a big influx of cash & business software from a competitor.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by Tyrannosaurs on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @06:55AM (#7094709)
And with good reason.

Bill Gates didn't do that as some sort of goodwill gesture, he did it because he felt it was right for MS.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by BugBrother on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @11:12AM (#7096121)
Huh?

Wasn't the money put into Apple part of a deal after Microsoft was found with source code for Quicktime getting into their own video software?

The "Microsoft believes in Apple" from that might be more Job's reality distortion field. :-)

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by Tyrannosaurs on Wednesday January 22, 2014 @08:11AM (#7102357)
Oooo, I didn't know that.

But going back to the original point, if that's true you could say that Apple was in a slightly better state than it might have appeared (in that it had leverage over MS that it could use that might not have been obvious at the time) but I don't think it significantly undermines the idea that Jobs did a fairly remarkable job in turning Apple around.

After all, MS and many other companies had far more resources than Apple even with the settlement and none of them had the same level of success Apple enjoyed during that period (or since).

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by ghshephard on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:32AM (#7089662)
Who says that visionaries can't be egomaniacs? And, in the case of Jobs, who says that he could have been an effective visionary without being an egomaniac?

I don't think I worship Steve Jobs, nor do I think he's a hero. But I don't think anybody can second guess what he accomplished in his many careers. If it had just been the Apple, we could have ascribed that to Woz. Or the Macintosh, we could have suggested Raskin was the key, Or Next was all about Avie Tevanian, or Pixar was all about Lassiter, Or iMacs all about Jonie Ives, or iPod all about Fadell, or Apple 2.0s resurgence all about Tim Cook, iOS was all about Forstall, or the iPhone/iPad...

But, there's a common thread to all of those creations - and yes, behind all of them were massive collaborations of incredibly talented people, lead by inordinately brilliant designers, engineers, and architects - but in the center, unreasonably demanding and pushing, was Jobs.

That's all I think we need to give him credit for, but no less.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by Geee on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:55PM (#7091442)
I think most companies fail because of the 'culture of mediocrity', especially when they grow. A leader who is unconditionally asshole with a good taste is exactly what keeps the culture fresh and inspired. That's who Jobs was.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by nbouscal on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:26AM (#7089629)
> Sadly (speaking as one) - technologists are for the most part fungible, you can swap out one for another.

The willingness of members of our profession to believe and repeat this bit of absolute nonsense is one of the primary reasons our industry is such a shitshow.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by ghshephard on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:54AM (#7089762)
There is always room for differentiation at the top, either as an architect, or leader - but (speaking of my own profession) - I've never actually seen an environment where any particularly network engineer wasn't replaceable. In fact, one of the hallmarks of a first class network engineer is that they leave behind an environment that is well documented, designed to industry standards, and is pretty much resistant outages as a results of single points of failure.

A Network engineer who is a 'Hero' and can never go on vacation, is worth much less than a network engineer who has built an environment that any random Taos CCIE can come in and manage with a couple days cross training.

Ironically, from that perspective, the more fungible [1] a network engineer is, the more valuable they are.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fungibility

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by wpietri on Monday January 20, 2014 @10:25AM (#7089908)
You seem to be contradicting his point, but as far as I can tell you're proving it.

The fact that you see such a stark difference between a first-class network engineer and the work of lesser mortals is proof that they aren't fungible.

I'll also point out that you have, perhaps unintentionally, changed the topic from design to maintenance. We're talking about product creation. Some people like to pretend that all the design happens in the head of the person with "designer" on their business cards. But anybody who has spent time in a team making great products knows that everybody is involved in design. It can't be otherwise, because design happens at the intersection of desire and possibility, and the technologists know the possibility space more deeply than anybody else can.

That a well-designed network can be easily maintained is demonstrates the great design skills of that first-class network engineer. That there are long periods in a network's life when design skills aren't needed isn't proof that technologists are interchangeable; it's proof that they aren't.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by gutnor on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:58PM (#7091151)
I'm not sure why you don't apply that reasoning to managers. You do not need continuous guidance from the CEO.

A great CEO, after he has built a good team and a good strategy can just let the company sailing along for a decade. He is just as fungible as the network engineer. I mean, Jobs died and Apple didn't immediately go bankrupt, another CEO just stepped in, and either cruise along ( or picked up where Jobs left of, future will tell )

The big difference between the 2 is the immediate impact and that's more a cultural thing than anything. If you look at it from an engineering point of view, you avoid at all cost to design anything with such a fragile, expensive and exposed element as is the CEO role in a business the size of Apple.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by scardine on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:57PM (#7090810)
I left the field because it is a pretty inglorious role: nobody congratulates you when the network withstand the load under the worst circumstances, but everybody point you a finger for the minimal glitch - when it is not your fault you have to prove it.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by hboon on Monday January 20, 2014 @08:32AM (#7089368)
I mostly agree, but just one nit: Pixar was mostly John Lasseter, Ed Catmull, and many wonderful folks including many animators. While Jobs personally funded the company for a long time (10 years or so? That's really quite a vision), he wasn't really running it.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by ghshephard on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:24AM (#7089620)
I've spent a few hours reading the history of Pixar (it's controversial as to what role Jobs had, particularly around the "founding" - which he really wasn't) - and while I've come to the conclusion that Steve Jobs had very little (if any) role in actually running Pixar, he appears to have had some "catalyzing" effect - Issacson never really dived into that aspect of Job's personality - it might be his negotiating skill (which was epic), or his reality distortion field (which I think even Jobs fell under the influence of) - but from the very start of Apple, he just believed in a series of realities, and did whatever he could to change things so they came true.

Now, he didn't always win (most memorably in his ejection from Apple by the board), and sometimes this egomania had catastrophic effects - from his personal life, and most likely to his own health, where he refused to accept other people's opinion of what the best course of action was. You can argue and shape some people minds, but ultimately you can't win an argument with nature.

It may very well have been the case, that without the bad, there could never have been the good - they were inexorably linked.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by pjmorris on Monday January 20, 2014 @10:45AM (#7090029)
> It may very well have been the case, that without the bad, there could never have been the good - they were inexorably linked.

I think there's something important to this notion. I once read a biography of Churchill that suggested Churchill's distrust of Hitler in the 1930's partly sprang from Churchill being the kind of egomaniac who could recognize an egomaniac. I'm sure I've done neither Churchill nor the book justice in this description, but I think there's support for the notion that personality doesn't simply or easily decompose into good parts and bad parts.

[1] 'The Last Lion: Winston Spencer Churchill: Alone, 1932-1940', William Manchester

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by markdennehy on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @07:50AM (#7094907)
Churchill's an interesting example to bring up in what has become a thread about hero worship. The man was revered during the war and in all the gosh-wasn't-it-a-romantic-age reminiscences since; so much so that they gloss over things like his having proposed the Battle of Gallipoli and being sacked from the cabinet for that; his being the first person to push using gas on the Kurds (beating Saddam to it by quite a few years); and him being the only wartime leader to be ousted by a landslide majority before the war ended (and thus getting himself chucked out of cabinet in both world wars -- I don't think anyone else managed to do that either).

It does rather support the idea that hero worship is a really bad waste of time at best, and downright dangerous at worst...

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by talmand on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:11PM (#7090528)
From what I've read Jobs wanted a completely different future for Pixar (something like 3D rendering software for the masses) than what Lasseter, Catmull, and others wanted. It was their pushing for the future they saw and desired that's the reason behind the success of Pixar as we know it today. Jobs was supposedly looking to sell off Pixar and viewed it as a failure until Disney showed up.

Putting Pixar's success on Jobs alone is a huge disservice to the true believers that actually built Pixar.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by markdennehy on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @07:39AM (#7094867)
> And yet, who else in modern history has driven as many companies to such such success, and lead the creation of so many great products?

On the former, it's a fairly modern phenomenon for anyone to start multiple companies that succeed and grow to a large size (unless you look at historical periods now recognised as having been infamously financially unstable, like the Dutch tulip boom years). Those who were equally if not more successful than Jobs just didn't bounce from company to company, but invested their efforts in one place.

As to the latter question, I think you'll find that there are quite a few people who could lay equal claim to (a) producing that many great products, and (b) having created the products Jobs is credited with.

Personally, I think you're all overlooking something. The people who work in our industry are by and large professionals. And a professional does what the boss says because that's what the salary is for. It's not like we get the salary anyway and then do what the boss says if we feel like doing it or think he's inspiring enough!

So, to give an anecdotal example, when the iPad prototype comes to Jobs and he does that fish tank routine and says "aha- air bubbles, therefore you can still squash it down more", that's just being an arsehole to people who work for you. What, you think they had a dozen prototypes just so the boss could dunk one in water, destroying it? They're paid so that if he says "squash it more please", they go do it. That's what engineers do. The teenage drama queen nonsense isn't required.

And if you believe the arsehole-ness is a necessary thing to be a genius and get things done, you have been watching far too much House for your own good.

Honestly, the more you learn about Jobs, the less you see that you'd hold up to your kids as a role model; whereas the more you learn about Wozniak, the more you see that you'd hold up.

And we're still only talking about the technical work; nobody's commented yet on the moral issues surrounding the actual manufacture of products like the iPhone. Lovely device; but is that worth the human abuse it takes to manufacture it?

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by angularly on Monday January 20, 2014 @06:41AM (#7088990)
I did the exact same thing, because of similar views (using the best tool for the job). I also switched to Windows in 1995 or so, and switched back to Mac in 2004.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by bestdayever on Monday January 20, 2014 @11:41AM (#7090356)
>And yet, who else in modern history has driven as many companies to such such success, and lead the creation of so many great products?

Elon musk?

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by crusso on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:03PM (#7090850)
Top contender, but has a way to go before he achieves near Jobs-level success.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by eftpotrm on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:11PM (#7091221)
Hmm, I'd put Jobs lower and Musk higher; I'd suggest we're overscoring Steve Jobs still. Paypal is clearly already a big success though, and both Tesla and SpaceX have the potential to become so in the coming years.

For me, we're still under Jobs' reality distortion field. I mean, which companies did he build? NeXT which did interesting technology but basically died in the market. Pixar where there's significant dispute about his level of involvement and he may have been more an angel investor.

And Apple. Huge, sure. But he was kicked out the first time round for focusing exclusively on a product that was losing money hand over fist, was both more expensive and less capable than rival products, and which was never more than a minor niche player (albeit stably so), squandering the Apple II's early work. When he returned it was some years before they regained serious success, and that was largely with iOS. Which, by the time of his death, was already losing market position in both phones and tablets, a trend which is showing no sign of abating and every likelihood of levelling out in much the same position the Mac ultimately did, for similar reasons - one manufacturer and a few devices simply can't innovate as fast as a whole army of rivals cooperating. He built great products, but a great company to live for a lifetime?

Now, don't get me wrong. I'd love to have even 0.1% of Steve Jobs' success. He was a visionary, a brilliant marketer and an excellent communicator. But I'd suggest his personal single-minded obsession interfered with his ability to hear the market reaction to his products, and the consequence of that was not companies that last a lifetime.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by crusso on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:43PM (#7091391)
Paypal is interesting and a niche success, but wasn't deeply visionary. SpaceX and Tesla are cool, and may even end up being market successes - but they still have a ways to go before proving themselves.

I'm a Musk fan, but Jobs had a huge body of work in fantastic products/movies that his enterprises created under his leadership.

a trend which is showing no sign of abating and every likelihood of levelling out in much the same position the Mac ultimately did

There's your problem right there. You're somehow equating number of clone devices out there to Jobs's visionary ability to create entirely new markets with products and services that were then copied endlessly.

Number of cheap clone devices out there produced by third party manufactures was never Jobs' goal. How is IBM doing with that whole computer clone business, by the way?

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by peterjancelis on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @12:17AM (#7093622)
Paypal was much more than a niche success - "payments on the internet" is huge. You can argue Paypal didn't materialize its vision, but the vision was there.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by nickstinemates on Monday January 20, 2014 @10:32PM (#7093266)
IBM isn't hip, but it's still a meaningful company that's thriving.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by nknighthb on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @06:43AM (#7094663)
That's because IBM-the-company has always been a multi-headed beast with a lot of other -- and far more successful -- businesses both before and after the IBM PC business existed. crusso is not talking about the company, but the business, which IBM got out of in 2004/2005 after years of losing money on it.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by VLM on Monday January 20, 2014 @08:48AM (#7089443)
"Jobs only was capable of focussing on design because countless Wozniaks did the plumbing"

As an EE-type dude Woz's design work was pretty impressive. He's in no danger of being worshipped like a Williams, Pease, or Widlar (much less a Tesla) but he's at most only one tier down. Lets say he's in the top ten, or in serious competition to be in that class. Multiple independent people repeatedly come up with the phrase "elegant" to describe his electrical design work.

So calling a highly skilled stuffed suit the designer and the guy who did all the good design work a mere plumber is somewhat historically revisionist. For that matter I don't think either of them would have gotten as far as they did without teaming up, so other than some desire to dominate, there's not much point in placing one higher than the other.

What it is, is a highly effective social commentary. A genius grade stuffed suit gets all the credit. A genius grade designer is a mere plumber to be used as a resource by the really important person, that being the stuffed suit. In other words, it sucks.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by crusso on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:52PM (#7091427)
"social commentary" implies that there's something nonsensical about it or only understandable in a cultural idiosyncratic way - but is it at all surprising that the genius communicator, marketing, salesperson has a much better communicated, marketed, and sold reputation?
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by gurkendoktor on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:02PM (#7091718)
> A genius grade stuffed suit gets all the credit. A genius grade designer is a mere plumber to be used as a resource by the really important person, that being the stuffed suit.

I don't think that's a general rule though, compare Tim Cook and Jony Ive. (Maybe I'm reading too much MacRumors for my own good, though...)

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by codyb on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:50PM (#7091663)
I think in the end it sounds like they both had very different skill sets.

Woz seems in his comment and from comments in this topic to have wonderful integrity, and empathy. He builds cool things because he can and because he wants to help others. He had incredible intellectual power and expertise in a newly developing field and worked in almost all aspects of it.

Jobs on the other hand had an incredible business sense. He lacked the empathy that Woz had but had the drive which actually put certain products out to market where they reached millions and millions of people.

I think this is very much a case of comparing apples to oranges.

Who would you rather hang out with and have as your lead engineer? Woz. Of course. No brainer.

Who would you rather have as your lead business man, innovator, and idea man? Jobs. No brainer.

Are there things both can probably be faulted for? Sure. Are there things that both can be idolized for? Sure. You don't have to idolize an entirety of a person. Just like no one things you idolize wife beaters for liking Rick James music, or idolize pedophiles for liking Michael Jacksons. The list of people who've done incredible things but had terrible sides to them is tremendous. And the list of terrible things is incredibly subjective in a lot of cases. Is being an asshole manager who accomplishes amazing things a bad thing? Yes to some and no to others. It's a very gray area I believe.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by neilk on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:22PM (#7091827)
When Jobs designs things, sometimes you get an extreme focus on simplicity ("Why can't this CD burner have just one button that says 'burn CD'?") and sometimes you get skeuomorphic atrocities like Game Center.

I don't think Jobs was a designer per se. He set ambitious goals for other designers to accomplish, maybe.

Jobs was great at recognizing talent, motivating talent, browbeating talent until it quit, and then taking credit for whatever that talent accomplished.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by justin66 on Monday January 20, 2014 @08:32PM (#7092831)
> Woz even criticizes the early Mac for losing money. Says Scully saved the company.

It looks like you're trying to be critical of Woz but it's worth noting that he is totally correct here. The company would not have continued without the Apple II revenue Sculley was focused on keeping. In the same vein, Gil Amelio and Fred Thompson later saved the company from bankruptcy by selling Apple debt at remarkably favorable terms. Jobs liked to make fun of Amelio, which always struck me as a little ridiculous.

People like to latch on to Jobs's personality quirks as being strange, wonderful advantages but I can't help but wonder how much more successful he might have been if he'd actually developed a better ability to work with and persuade people like John Sculley and his board. The world could have been pretty different if he'd had the people skills to hang in there at Apple. NeXT being developed within Apple might have meant big early success, which might have meant things going a pretty different way in the nineties...

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by abalone on Monday January 20, 2014 @11:47PM (#7093511)
"I can't help but wonder how much more successful he might have been..."

I just. Wow. Jobs was maybe more successful than anyone else in the history of the industry, ever, plus there was that movie studio thing.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by justin66 on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @12:37AM (#7093678)
I'm not the one who voted you down, although "I just. Wow." isn't what I'd call a thoughtful response.

To reiterate: visualize a computing world where Jobs managed to make his peace with Sculley and the board and used all the resources of Apple to make the NeXT technology happen a lot more swiftly and completely. He might then have brought Mach kernel people into Apple and high-end workstation tech might have began being commoditized and non-suckified and merged with the PC space in the late eighties.

If you don't see how that might have made him quite a bit more successful (and changed the shape of the world to come pretty drastically) I'm not sure what else to say about it.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by abalone on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @12:58AM (#7093722)
Pardon my momentary astonishment there, but you are talking about one of the most successful people in the industry. That alone should give you cause for pause in your analysis, which you seem especially confident of ("totally correct").

You seem to discount the possibility that Sculley et al were the problem.

Let's look at the history: While they may have temporarily boosted revenues at first, uncontroversially the "sales guys" ran Apple into the ground in the 90s. Drove it almost bankrupt. Jobs came back and indisputably saved the company from the brink of disaster, not by trying to play the same game as Microsoft, but again by pursuing visionary projects.

Jobs' refusal to compromise and "work with" the sales guys who ran Apple into the ground... is maybe, just possibly, one of the reasons he ended up being one of the most successful guys in the history of the computing industry.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by hyp0 on Monday January 20, 2014 @09:01AM (#7089494)
Ed Catmull said the best thing Jobs did for Pixar was stay out of the way. Literally, not interfering and instead letting Catmull and Lasseter get on with it; yet providing support when needed (via introductions and so one). He was more VC than founder.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by kabouseng on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:20AM (#7087885)
And then take all the credit for the ideas, saying it came to him in a dream...pffft (touch interface for the iPhone).
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by gnaffle on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:52AM (#7088580)
When did he say that?
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by kabouseng on Monday January 20, 2014 @07:39AM (#7089166)
I'll have to go search for a link. But it was during the keynote unveiling of the original iPhone if I remember correctly, where actually two of the engineers came to him to demonstrate the capacitive touch screens or panels that were only just beginning to receive main stream attention.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by gnaffle on Monday January 20, 2014 @08:39AM (#7089402)
I've watched that keynote, and it certainly wasn't there. While Jobs had a tendency to claim ideas as his own internally (often after dismissing it initially), to the public he never seemed to like to claim ideas as his own, but rather make a point of how the products were a result of teamwork.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by Eye_of_Mordor on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:30AM (#7088472)
Shame he didn't learn empathy from Woz - arguably the greatest flaw in his character and possibly the biggest need he had as a human being.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by ClementM on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:02PM (#7091721)
I have tried to research whether Steve Jobs was 'suffering' from narcissistic personality disorder http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narcissistic_personality_disord... without finding much more than speculations. But if you look at the 'symptoms' list, and compare to the various reports from people having worked with him, it looks like it. Lack of empathy is a typical symptom.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by sliverstorm on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:06AM (#7087999)
I wasn't making any particular assertion about what Jobs was. Call him a businessman, call him a visionary, call him whatever you like. Unfortunately, no matter what I call him, someone will object.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by rquantz on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:47PM (#7091404)
I guess you just have to call him "Steve Jobs"
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by gbhn on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:01PM (#7090833)
By "countless" I think you mean "half a dozen, with perhaps a 25% success rate." Its important that we realize that the upper end of the impact scale isn't an endless string of success, but "a few." One is really hard, and failure is common.

By the same token, a few successes are truly impressive. It takes a lot of execution and judgment to avoid many, many pitfalls.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by dhruval on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:09AM (#7087699)
"Maybe the same way that you can have a psychopath, you can have the opposite? Someone whose brain is hard-wired to be more empathetic than normal?"

Something like this maybe:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highly_sensitive_person

Even more interesting, is this model that describes how some of the negative stuff (shyness, nervousness) related to having high sensitivity can be overcome by the subset of that population that go on to accomplish great things:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Positive_Disintegration

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by andrewtbham on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:14AM (#7087710)
He wrote a book called iWoz. It's definitely worth a read if you're interested in him. He was obsessed with building his own computer from a young age.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by lsh on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:22AM (#7088430)
I read that book and while I can recommend it, I felt Woz didn't dwell particularly long on any single aspect - it was just a nice long polished story, like something he had told many times before but this time collected into a book. I don't think I was looking for secrets or drama, but the man has done some amazing things and he puts so little emphasis on them in the book. Does a Wozniak biography exist that is not an auto-biography?
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by pjbrunet on Tuesday January 21, 2014 @12:50AM (#7093706)
http://www.stevenlevy.com/index.php/books/hackers

Not sure how much it has changed (revisions) but my old copy has a few chapters on Woz.

Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by JeremyMorgan on Monday January 20, 2014 @12:28AM (#7087759)
Yup. Far better than the Jobs autobiography, though both were fascinating people I think Woz resonates with the average person much better, though his skills and intellect are far above average.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by oskarth on Monday January 20, 2014 @07:50AM (#7089200)
Or maybe they follow few people because of limited resources. You can't infer someone's humility bases on the amount of people they follow on twitter. Why do they follow "big" people? Maybe because they are friends, someone they look up to or just someone they want to keep track off. In other words, the exact same reason you follow someone.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by gokulk on Sunday January 19, 2014 @08:28PM (#7086993)
Lord Vishnu ?
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by hobs on Sunday January 19, 2014 @10:02PM (#7087289)
Hindu god. "the all-pervading essence of all beings, the master of—and beyond—the past, present and future, the creator and destroyer of all existences, one who supports, preserves, sustains and governs the universe and originates and develops all elements within. Though he is usually depicted as blue, some other depictions of Vishnu exist as green-bodied, and in the Kurma Purana he is described as colorless and with red eyes.[1]" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vishnu
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by gokulk on Monday January 20, 2014 @01:30AM (#7087912)
I am Hindu. I was just suprised Lord Vishnu has a social media account.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by sliverstorm on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:07AM (#7088001)
You think technology is beyond Vishnu?
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by lsh on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:23AM (#7088437)
just made my day ;)
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by elwell on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:41PM (#7087614)
I like how Kanye is listed after Lord Vishnu.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by saraid216 on Monday January 20, 2014 @03:55AM (#7088306)
Turns out there are like... 5 Lord Vishnus on Google Plus.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by darklajid on Monday January 20, 2014 @05:04AM (#7088629)
All using their Real Name™, of course.
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me” by wwweston on Monday January 20, 2014 @11:58PM (#7093552)
Only 5? That'd seemingly leave another 4 incarnations unaccounted for.