Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me”
by crusso on Monday January 20, 2014 @02:52PM
(#7091427)
"social commentary" implies that there's something nonsensical about it or only understandable in a cultural idiosyncratic way - but is it at all surprising that the genius communicator, marketing, salesperson has a much better communicated, marketed, and sold reputation?
Re:Wozniak: “Actually, the movie was largely a lie about me”
by gurkendoktor on Monday January 20, 2014 @04:02PM
(#7091718)
> A genius grade stuffed suit gets all the credit. A genius grade designer is a mere plumber to be used as a resource by the really important person, that being the stuffed suit.
I don't think that's a general rule though, compare Tim Cook and Jony Ive. (Maybe I'm reading too much MacRumors for my own good, though...)
As an EE-type dude Woz's design work was pretty impressive. He's in no danger of being worshipped like a Williams, Pease, or Widlar (much less a Tesla) but he's at most only one tier down. Lets say he's in the top ten, or in serious competition to be in that class. Multiple independent people repeatedly come up with the phrase "elegant" to describe his electrical design work.
So calling a highly skilled stuffed suit the designer and the guy who did all the good design work a mere plumber is somewhat historically revisionist. For that matter I don't think either of them would have gotten as far as they did without teaming up, so other than some desire to dominate, there's not much point in placing one higher than the other.
What it is, is a highly effective social commentary. A genius grade stuffed suit gets all the credit. A genius grade designer is a mere plumber to be used as a resource by the really important person, that being the stuffed suit. In other words, it sucks.