News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by mgraczyk on Friday January 17, 2014 @09:51PM (#7079834)
I'm generally very skeptical of authors or papers that make claims about "quantum processes" and consciousness because they are generally written by people who know very little about neurology and even less about quantum physics. Ask them about quantum entanglement, and you'll generally get a misguided interpretation based on a decades old mistake in reasoning that has long since been corrected [1][2]. However, I decided to give this paper a try not because I expected there to be any actual content, but just to see why otherwise intelligent people would be drawn to what I consider to be obvious pseudoscience.

I didn't read the whole thing, but from what I know of quantum mechanics and QFT (standard undergraduate course load) I didn't see anything wildly misguided. This tells me that one of two things are true.

1. This paper describes a legitimate link between a non-classical process occurring in the brain that may "cause" consciousness. I do not know enough about the brain to rigorously evaluate the claims.

2 (more likely). Quantum physics is hard, even for scientists. Neither of the paper's author's are physicists, and neither have done any _recent_ meaningful work in any subfield of physics. I would expect that groundbreaking work in physics would require ideas beyond an undergraduate level, but I did not see any physics in the paper I didn't understand. It looks like at the very least, there is room for a false positive. What I mean by "false positive" is that sometimes not about A will cause you to reason that Q->C even when the truth is A->Q and A->C (correlation does not imply causation...). For example, it could be that the electrical signals of the brain that cause consciousnes + quantum effect, but if the same signals were running through a semiconductor we would instead see a different quantum effect (depletion zones, electron holes...). If our brains were made of 5nm CMOS transistors, a non-physicist might see quantum tunneling and conclude that it somehow caused consciousness.

I think the most important thing for non-physicists like me to remember about papers like this is that although sometimes scientists make important discoveries outside their fields we should allow specialists in the area to evaluate the non-physicists claims before believing them ourselves.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mysticism [2] http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/76036/how-does-qf...

EDIT

Penrose did important work on the nature of black holes ~40 years ago. At one point in time he was a real physicist.

Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by dnautics on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:19PM (#7079900)
I liked this: If I may add - my personal few cents -

1) I am filled with distaste when people treat quantum mechanics "like magic". In this case it's just taking an unexplained phenomenon (consciousness, or heck, even the weaker 'cognition') and pushing an explanation into a 'more obscure' corner, which I think is intellectually lazy.

2) Drop consciousness for a second, it's really quite amazing if microtubules have a role in cognition (penrose's 'weaker hypothesis' vs. penrose's 'strong thesis' which is that consciousness is QM). And people on hn should take note, because this has implications for a lot of machine learning, which sometimes is bio-mimetic (neural nets e.g.)

3) if we take 1 and 2 into consideration, it is possible that cognition and ML is feasible using LESS computational power, just that we're missing out on the correct architecture by attempting biomimicry - granted, biomimicry has served some fields well, like image processing and OCR.

edit: and then I realized that my 1) is your link [1].

Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by cscurmudgeon on Saturday January 18, 2014 @05:16AM (#7080684)
> 1) I am filled with distaste when people treat quantum mechanics "like magic". In this case it's just taking an unexplained phenomenon (consciousness, or heck, even the weaker 'cognition') and pushing an explanation into a 'more obscure' corner, which I think is intellectually lazy.

That is a quite beautiful straw man.

Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by pavelrub on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:30PM (#7079934)
This is very misleading even after your "correction". Penrose's theories on consciousness and QM might be eccentric, but he is one of the better known physicists of our time, with integral contributions to the mathematics of GR. He deserves more than being presented as "not a physicist" at first, and then as somebody who "did some work on back holes 40 years ago" later. He is also definitely a very real physicist.
Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by cscurmudgeon on Saturday January 18, 2014 @05:15AM (#7080681)
I like it when we dismiss papers without actually reading them. Makes it much more easier. Come on HN! Keep up with the pseudo-intellectual mid-brow dismissals.

> Penrose did important work on the nature of black holes ~40 years ago. At one point in time he was a real physicist.

> why otherwise intelligent people would be drawn to what I consider to be obvious pseudoscience.

> I didn't read the whole thing,

Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by tilt_error on Saturday January 18, 2014 @06:18AM (#7080758)
More so; Scientific papers have structure - reading them linearly from beginning to end, just that you skip the end, may not tell you anything about what the authors propose.

The beginning (like the introduction and method stuff) generally is a build-up where you connect the contribution with the contemporary knowledge, but it is only in the final discussion and conclusion parts that you will find the argumentation.

Picture yourself reading a Hercule Poirot story by Agatha Christie, but stop reading just as Hercule summons all the participants into the living room to wrap up the story. Would you then criticise Christie for writing a bad story :) Of course, the story could be bad with weak character narratives and a lousy plot, but would you not want to know whether the butler really did it before giving up?

Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by Dylan16807 on Saturday January 18, 2014 @12:54PM (#7081574)
The comment is explicitly not a dismissal. "I didn't read the whole thing, but from what I know of quantum mechanics and QFT (standard undergraduate course load) I didn't see anything wildly misguided."

And it taught me some valuable information about entanglement.

But go ahead, keep it up with criticizing the tone.

Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by waterlesscloud on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:00PM (#7079857)
Whatever you think of their theory, Roger Penrose is most definitely a physicist who has done meaningful work in various subfields of physics.
Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by nkvl on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:21PM (#7079905)
Here's an edge.org answer that briefly touches on this - from the other end, by another great physicist, Anton Zeilinger[0]: http://www.edge.org/response-detail/25548

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anton_Zeilinger

Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by mgraczyk on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:03PM (#7079868)
You are correct. However I don't know of anything he's done in recent years that could be considered legitimate physics.
Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by waterlesscloud on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:20PM (#7079902)
Alright, when we're to the point of saying Penrose is no longer a real physicist or doing legitimate physics and implying that he doesn't have a very deep understanding of quantum physics... Well, there's not much point in continuing.
Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by cscurmudgeon on Saturday January 18, 2014 @05:18AM (#7080687)
> real physicist

When people can't debate on facts, they search for things like this. There is no use in continuing.

Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T... by carbocation on Friday January 17, 2014 @09:58PM (#7079849)
Excellent post. When you say "false positive" you could substitute "confounding effect" to use a more specific term for what you've described, by the way.