Re:Quantum Vibrations Inside Brain Corroborate 20-Year-Old T...
by cscurmudgeon on Saturday January 18, 2014 @05:16AM
(#7080684)
> 1) I am filled with distaste when people treat quantum mechanics "like magic". In this case it's just taking an unexplained phenomenon (consciousness, or heck, even the weaker 'cognition') and pushing an explanation into a 'more obscure' corner, which I think is intellectually lazy.
That is a quite beautiful straw man.
1) I am filled with distaste when people treat quantum mechanics "like magic". In this case it's just taking an unexplained phenomenon (consciousness, or heck, even the weaker 'cognition') and pushing an explanation into a 'more obscure' corner, which I think is intellectually lazy.
2) Drop consciousness for a second, it's really quite amazing if microtubules have a role in cognition (penrose's 'weaker hypothesis' vs. penrose's 'strong thesis' which is that consciousness is QM). And people on hn should take note, because this has implications for a lot of machine learning, which sometimes is bio-mimetic (neural nets e.g.)
3) if we take 1 and 2 into consideration, it is possible that cognition and ML is feasible using LESS computational power, just that we're missing out on the correct architecture by attempting biomimicry - granted, biomimicry has served some fields well, like image processing and OCR.
edit: and then I realized that my 1) is your link [1].