News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by epicureanideal on Friday January 17, 2014 @09:40PM (#7079805)
Although I generally agree with the sentiment of the article, I strongly disagree that we need specifically "affordable" housing. State-subsidized "below market rate" housing that enables people with low salaries to occupy highly-demanded space is incredibly inefficient and also likely doesn't serve the interests of the people it is supposed to help.

I don't see why the ability to live in San Francisco is any different than the ability to afford a BMW or a Tesla. Should the government subsidize "below market rate" luxury cars too? What would be the incentive to get an education or work hard? Personally I feel somewhat offended when there are dozens of below market rate units available and I'm actually excluded from attempting to buy them because I earn too much money. Meanwhile there are hardly any homes available for people who can afford the houses without subsidies and we bid up the houses to obscene prices due to lack of supply.

Also, if the people who work in SF or other high income areas cannot afford to live there at current wages, there should be pressure on them to leave and work elsewhere. This would increase demand for their labor and drive prices up, all else being equal. (I know, there are other factors here, but those should be dealt with separately, not by adding more layers of complexity to the problem.)

Further, if those workers cannot afford to rent or buy, lowering the cost of renting or buying also reduces the pressure on employers to raise their wages.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by scoofy on Friday January 17, 2014 @09:54PM (#7079845)
As a recent nyc -> sf transplant, i think the best short term solution to making living in the bay area more affordable is to run one track of bart back and forth from 12am - 4am. SF needs a brooklyn, a real brooklyn, that you can get to when your shift at the restaurant/bar/other-service-job ends at 1am.

Public infrastructure is a public good, and service industry workers can't be expected to cab it to oakland when their shifts end. Heck, the bikelane on the new bay bridge segment ends before treasure island. I could NEVER have lived in brooklyn if the non-auto infrastructure was the way it is between sf and oakland.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by lsc on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:07PM (#7079877)
>As a recent nyc -> sf transplant, i think the best short term solution to making living in the bay area more affordable is to run one track of bart back and forth from 12am - 4am. SF needs a brooklyn, a real brooklyn, that you can get to when your shift at the restaurant/bar/other-service-job ends at 1am.

That... sounds pretty great. As a bonus, it would make public transit usable for recreational use, and probably keep a bunch of drunks off the road.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by silencio on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:53PM (#7079992)
The biggest reason why I avoided buying a restaurant in SF is because there is no answer to the problem you outline, yet. Hiring and keeping employees was a clusterfuck. A lot of them lived in East Bay or Daly City, and this was a problem I saw something like 2-3 years ago. It's probably worse now.

I have a restaurant in East Bay and I have employees on the same side of the bay that will walk 15 more minutes to save 35 cents on BART fares. I pay them more than minimum wage plus overtime and meals, and I offer to pay the 70 cent difference every day since I don't want any of them walking alone too late at night. They just pocket the 70 cents and keep on walking. Compared to my day job and my fiancé's day job and how we'll uber instead of walking 15 minutes...

It's not just improving BART service, it's also about improving public transit in general I think - including to the point that fares drop. My cousin from Seoul completely flipped out on me shortly after coming to the US. He realized that he was spending ~$10 and a couple of hours every day to get to his school in downtown SF from Alameda. Incredibly rude awakening if you're used to one of the busiest and best subway systems in the world, I guess.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by fishtoaster on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:50PM (#7079985)
From what I understand, Bart needs that 12-4 timeslot for track maintenance.

> Unlike some public transit systems with multiple sets of tracks on the same routes, BART doesn't have the duplication that would allow us to run trains on one set while performing maintenance on another. Third-rail power has to be shut down for maintenance crews to be able to operate safely and do the work that keeps the system safe and reliable. And the trains can’t run when the power is down.

- http://www.bart.gov/guide/latenight

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by _delirium on Saturday January 18, 2014 @09:16AM (#7081041)
It doesn't actually require extra tracks to run a 24/7 metro and also do maintenance. A very common solution is single-tracking. BART has two tracks, one for trains in each direction. What some systems do is just close one side for maintenance, and then run trains on the other side in both directions. For low-frequency service (e.g. hourly night service) it can just be a single train shuttling back and forth end-to-end. For higher-frequency service a few other options are possible. You can split the route into smaller segments (say, in half) and have one train shuttling back-and-forth on each segment. Customers change trains at segment boundaries if they want to go further. Alternately, some systems can run trains fully in opposite directions, if there is a siding somewhere along the route that can be used for passing.

The Copenhagen metro is a 24/7 system, without extra tracks, that uses this method. On maintenance nights a usual pattern is a brief complete-service shutdown 1:00-1:30am to switch from regular operation to single-tracking. One track is taken out of service and powered down, and service at ~20-minute headways resumes on the remaining track. The Atlanta subway also uses this method for longer weekend maintenance sometimes, going to single-track mode all weekend (they don't do 24/7 operation, though, I would guess due to budget issues).

It's possible BART can't do maintenance with single-track operation due to how it's set up, but their message implies it's physically impossible without having spare tracks, which is not true in other systems.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by scoofy on Sunday January 19, 2014 @05:04PM (#7086225)
This is exactly what they did with the G train in brooklyn on the weekends. It's 2 track only, and they would shutdown one side, transfer to the other side at Bedford-Nostram. Was it a pain in the ass? Yes. Was it way better than no service... absolutely!
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by alexeisadeski3 on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:38PM (#7079953)
Alternatively, SF could just legalize privately owned buses.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by _delirium on Saturday January 18, 2014 @09:47AM (#7081096)
Aren't they already legal? Here's a story about a private bus service, which SFMTA seems to have reacted positively to (see the quote at the end): http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/05/29/leap-transit_n_3354...

The biggest controversy seems to be over where private buses that don't have their own private loading/unloading infrastructure can stop and load/unload. Some cities tolerate unofficial use of public bus stops, or look the other way when buses load/unload in a blatantly illegal way (by just stopping in a lane of traffic and blocking it, as "Chinatown buses" typically do). Other cities are less tolerant of that. But when private buses actually pay for their own private loading/unloading facilities on land they either own or properly rent, like Greyhound does, then there's no problem.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by alexeisadeski3 on Saturday January 18, 2014 @09:54AM (#7081107)
No, they are not legal: "To fit under CPUC's regulatory rebric, charter party carries can't just pick passengers up on the street, like taxis or traditional buses do, which is why Leap rides need to be ordered ahead of time through the company's iPhone app."

Cities don't allow private busses to obtain curb rights in the first place.

Greyhound is intercity, not intracity. Useless for this purpose.

The only controversy stems from taxis & muni busses protecting their turf.

You may know them as Jitneys: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Share_taxi

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by hyperlexic on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:09PM (#7080038)
I'm curious how Brooklyn dealt/deals with the issue of crime and public safety. I lived in West Oakland for while, and this seems to be the general region where a 'Brooklyn' type of spot is trying to emerge. BART station is right there, and it's close to the bridge for all-night bus lines and bikers too. But it's just such a friggin dangerous place to be (at any hour of the day or night) that I wonder if it's even possible.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by scoofy on Sunday January 19, 2014 @05:09PM (#7086249)
There are a couple places you just don't get off the train in brooklyn: east new york and brownsville, but on the whole, even areas below the JMZ: east williamsburg/bed stuy/bushwick aren't nearly as dangerous as they may seem by looking at them.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by hyperlexic on Sunday January 26, 2014 @12:24AM (#7124003)
Yeah unfortunately today there really is no area in Oakland near a BART station where I would want to be walking around with a pocket full of cash/tip money late at night. There's a lot of investment and excitement happening in West Oakland, and it's interesting to watch the process. But until they get the public safety issues to a somewhat reasonable level, I don't see it. What I see are young hip people moving in, getting robbed or worse and going back to the City to live in a shared closet for 2k a month.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by lukejduncan on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:29PM (#7079932)
I'm really interested in the NYC comparison.

I don't know anything about city planning or the history of it, but places like New York must have gone through similar transitions. What worked, what didn't? I feel like there has to be a lot of history to learn from on the topic.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by rayiner on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:01PM (#7080016)
Things that don't work: rent control, historical preservation restrictions, burdensome light air and view restrictions.

Things that do work: letting rich people move in, letting developers build what they want, and using that massive tax base to build high-quality public transit.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by Khaine on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:42PM (#7080108)
Letting developers do whatever they please is a horrible idea. Most developers are crooks and do whatever they can to make the most amount of money, which is why most cities have city plans and zones to prevent developers from shitting on everything.

Secondly, historical preservation makes a city what it is. Would Paris be the same without the Eiffel Tower? Good historical preservation enhances and defines the city.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by mc32 on Saturday January 18, 2014 @01:10PM (#7081635)
On the other hand you have Tokyo where buildings are built for a 25-year lifespan. I would not call Tokyo a boring city, it's just different. It has its own modern character. Also, Paris was planned post WWii, unlike London which is more haphazard in configuration. The Eiffel Tower was nearly demolished after the expo. It's only now that people think of that Iron monstrosity as emblematic of the city. Sometimes a blight does take on its own charm, such as the Eiffel tower, or Tokyo (radio) tower.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by epicureanideal on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:09PM (#7079883)
I also wouldn't mind if they would add some extra cars so it isn't standing room only during commute hours. How hard is it to add an extra car to an existing train? Raise my fare, I'll pay not to have to be packed in like cattle.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by encoderer on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:38PM (#7079950)
If only it worked this way. Fares are already set years in advance and BART management seems to have their own ideas on how they want to spend the limited resources they have.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by sologoub on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:38PM (#7079952)
I'd imagine the length of the train is limited to the shortest platform it has to support. Not from SF, so not sure if there really is room for expansion.

Frequency might be another answer - run the trains closer together, but again there are limits there too.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by prodigal_erik on Sunday January 19, 2014 @04:51AM (#7083984)
I've never seen a BART station shorter than ten cars, though many rush hour trains only use eight or nine.

I seem to remember that BART has an outdated and overwhelmed computer system which requires greater spacing between trains (and sometimes fails all the way down to manual control). At least new cars will have three doors instead of two, which should get a train out of a station faster.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by hkmurakami on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:56PM (#7079998)
I think I've been on trains in Japan (albeit not in Tokyo) where the first two cars didn't fit on the platform, and passengers were alerted to switch cars if getting off at that station.

Not sure how well it'd work given commuter congestion, but it warrants some consideration.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by kcorbitt on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:04PM (#7080025)
When I lived in Barcelona there were some low-traffic platforms shorter than the trains that went through them. I think the cars at the end of the train had big warning signs that they wouldn't open at station [X].
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by steveklabnik on Friday January 17, 2014 @09:59PM (#7079852)
You're ignoring the crux of the issue here.

The issue is not "I want to move to San Francisco", the issue is "I've lived in this neighborhood my entire life, and now I can't afford to any longer." Let's not even get into how expensive it is to actually move, all of the complication and complexity involved in moving a family with children to a different school district, all of the paperwork that needs updated... it's nontrivial.

You shouldn't be surprised when people who are currently being colonized against their will and having their entire lives thrown into upheaval without any upside are a little bit upset about it.

(I live in the Mission.)

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by epicureanideal on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:02PM (#7079865)
Perhaps the person should have bought a house instead of rented? If they're renting (I still rent) they should understand that rents go up and they may not be able to afford to live there.

Let's say they can't buy. I am not indifferent to their problem, but I don't see why having lived in a place for a given length of time should mean that person has a right to live permanently in a place they can no longer afford. And I don't see why it should deny someone who can afford to live there the ability to do so.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by steveklabnik on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:07PM (#7079876)
> Perhaps the person should have bought a house instead of rented?

Choices like these aren't even open to people who are affected by gentrification.

> And I don't see why it should deny someone who can afford to live there the ability to do so.

I, personally, don't feel that those with money should be able to run roughshod over those who don't.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by epicureanideal on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:13PM (#7079892)
> I, personally, don't feel that those with money should be able to run roughshod over those who don't.

What other method of allocating scarce resources did you have in mind? Random selection seems less fair than high income, because income is at least somewhat correlated with producing value. I mean, if you disagree with this, you basically disagree with the free market. I agree our current market is imperfect but I don't think randomly gifting scarce housing space to people is better.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by steveklabnik on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:16PM (#7079896)
> I mean, if you disagree with this, you basically disagree with the free market.

I do disagree with the notion that a free market (not that such a thing has ever or will ever exist) always leads to socially optimal outcomes, yes.

> I don't think randomly gifting scarce housing space to people is better.

Nobody is suggesting random gifting.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by argonaut on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:47PM (#7079981)
Whether or not free markets are the best way to allocate housing is another debate in of itself. I think they are, but the question for you is what specific method of allocating housing would be better? The beauty of free markets is that they are often, given time, self-correcting (not in all situations, which is one reason we have regulation in general). In any other market, rising housing prices would stimulate developers to build more housing; the problem is that in SF, local govt regulation stymies expansion, both vertical and horizontal.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by _delirium on Saturday January 18, 2014 @10:01AM (#7081120)
> In any other market, rising housing prices would stimulate developers to build more housing

It's not clear to me that this would actually bring down prices, and existing empirical evidence of how development increases in urban cores affects prices is pretty mixed. If all else were held equal, adding supply would bring down prices. However all else tends not to be equal, and development sprees seem to often generate their own upward-spiraling demand, which sometimes actually increases prices above what they previously were, by attracting more demand than the newly added supply satisfies. Some of the concern over gentrification (though often poorly investigated) is about what those mechanisms are. One pattern is upgrading of housing stock, e.g. replacement of 100 mid-range old housing units with 200 high-end new housing units, which often has the effect of increasing all three quantities: price, supply, and demand. That can then lead to some circular migration, as wealthier people move in to the city and poorer people move to formerly-well-off suburbs which as the houses age and deteriorate, become poorer (common in "inner-ring" suburbs of American cities).

That can be good for other reasons, if you see more dense housing as a good in itself. Even if SF ends up more expensive than before, you might prefer an SF with 1 million people over one with 825k. However other people disagree that this shuffling around of rich/poor people is a net improvement. That's something of a subjective debate. However on the more objective question of whether redeveloping SF will solve the specific problem of housing costs, I'm skeptical: I suspect redevelopment of SF will not have much impact on its affordability.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by argonaut on Saturday January 18, 2014 @09:45PM (#7083181)
I'd be really interested in reading studies that have examined the effect of real estate development on prices. Any links?
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by username223 on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:25PM (#7079918)
> What other method of allocating scarce resources did you have in mind?

I've always been a fan of allocation based on who had bigger muscles and was better with a club or other blunt weapon. To each his own.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by encoderer on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:35PM (#7079943)
This is a tough one. No doubt about it. No easy answers here.

I just bought a house in Berkeley (used to rent in Glen Park). I'm curious what you think about rent control laws. I know a lot of landlords are abusing Ellis Act evictions but outside of those, rent control laws do a fair job at protecting the types of renters you mention.

The city budget is flush with revenue driven from the tech boom. I am not against them using a portion of this to help with housing issues. But it seems mostly to be a lack of ideas that's stopping that from happening.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by kunle on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:24PM (#7079913)
Government subsidizes all sorts of things in all sorts of ways: Teslas/Priuses with credits, home loans with the mortgage deduction, student loans, Twitter moving to SF, and so on. Not saying these are good or bad, just indicating that subsidies are a pretty core part of our society and a case could be made for justifying or denying each.

Some rationales for subsidizing affordable homes specifically: fewer slums, greater social mobility for low income families (expensive areas also tend to have good schools), more stability for the elderly (who make up an astonishingly large proportion of low income folks as they can often no longer work).

A society where the raw effects of market forces were allowed to act on people would be really unpleasant (I grew up in one and have been to several) - free markets are a fantastic way to generate wealth but a poor way to ensure balanced social outcomes.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by rayiner on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:03PM (#7080020)
> greater social mobility for low income families (expensive areas also tend to have good schools)

This is an argument for subsidizing housing out in Santa Clara county. None of the public schools in San Francisco are particularly great.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by encoderer on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:47PM (#7079980)
If we follow your logic to its conclusion, San Francisco becomes a city of the uber rich, with the rest of the rabble scattering across the bay area.

So, what would that look like.. Some thoughts..

Good luck staffing jobs at the current SF minimum wage. You want baristas and servers and bar backs? And you want them to commute into the city? You'll get some (as you do now) but enough to run all of the cities establishments? We're talking a massive number of jobs. Sure, people will do it, for the right wage. So you're seeing wage inflation that will hurt small business owners a great deal.

Ethnic diversity would take a big hit. You'd see asian american and caucausions pushing out other groups that are on balance less affluent.

You can easily see NIMBY taken to an even further extreme that it currently is.

Commercial rents would presumably follow residential rents, further reducing low-margin businesses (like restaurants) in favor of high end retail and similar. (See: the Grove in Marina closing for this very reason).

I could go on, and certainly I am not listing the positive consequences of such a transformation. But I see strength through diversification and so I can't shake the feeling that this would be a weaker, less desirable San Francisco.

And if that were the case, if it truly did make it a less desirable place, well, now you have the positive feedback loop moving in the opposite direction, leading people OUT of the city until an equilibrium is found.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by rayiner on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:58PM (#7080006)
Your concerns are really unfounded. Manhattan is basically already the way you hypothesize (with lower-income people commuting in from the other boroughs), and it works just fine.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by dougmccune on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:12PM (#7080049)
as people have pointed out elsewhere in this discussion, the transit situation in NY is an order of magnitude better than SF. I agree with the SF is to Manhattan what the greater Bay Area is to the boroughs of New York analogy. But there's a pretty massive difference when it comes to public transit.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by rayiner on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:13PM (#7080051)
Okay, so build better transit instead of playing stupid games to "combat gentrification."
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by TheEzEzz on Friday January 17, 2014 @09:48PM (#7079826)
> Should the government subsidize "below market rate" luxury cars too?

People have families and lives built around geographic locations, not cars. I'm not saying we should or shouldn't subsidize housing (I lean libertarian personally), but it's disingenuous to suggest this is like the car market. What's at stake for many people is a foundational part of their lives.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by epicureanideal on Friday January 17, 2014 @09:59PM (#7079854)
They can build families and lives somewhere else if they can't afford to live here, right? Do people have a fundamental right to raise a family in San Francisco rather than Omaha or Austin? Are other places so horrible that we should use taxpayer money to ensure that the largest number of people possible can live in SF? And we should make it easier for the moderately low income to live here rather than people with higher income because ... why? Because people who work in technology don't deserve to raise their families here? Because despite education and hard work we really should make the ability to raise a family in a great area a random selection?

I actually think the car analogy is useful. Not subsidizing housing in San Francisco does not deny people the ability to start families. They can still start them in many other fine places that they can afford. Not driving a BMW or Tesla doesn't deny people the ability to get to work. A Honda or Toyota does that just as well.

NOTE: "Affordable housing" does not apply exclusively to people who have lived in the area for N years previously as far as I know, and even if it did I don't see why that would be fair. If you rent, you rent. When your lease is up, if the price goes up, that's how rent works. Also, there are already rent control policies that would serve this purpose.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by sophacles on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:54PM (#7079993)
It doesn't apply so well. It's not just about the kids you raise. It's about the fact that people's parents and grandparents and uncles and cousins live nearby. It's about friendships built over years. It's about community. What you're saying is this:

Fuck those people - they don't deserve community nor the benefits of it they worked for, because they can't afford the prices you are willing to pay to kick them out (despite most of them being decent citizens with jobs and everything).

It's kinda messed up. Not saying I have a solution, just pointing out a real problem.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by epicureanideal on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:22PM (#7080062)
So the ability to live in San Francisco should become an inherited right? Or at least being first in line for housing? Oh, I see, your parents lived here Mr. X, so even though Mr. Y is offering more money, I'll cast that newcomer aside. He isn't one of "us", who belong here.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by sophacles on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:35PM (#7080090)
Getting a little hostile aren't you? I actually flat out said I don't have a solution, so whatever the heck you are reacting to your own insecurity at something. I merely pointed out that what you propose has problems. And that your attitude is simply: anyone who can't afford it deserves to not have their lives considered.

Honestly, you are saying that the only consideration people should have for one another is net worth and that interpersonal relationships are of no value, yet you are angry that your lack of those same things could be used to keep you from spending your money (suggesting value). This is a pretty strange.

I do think that perhaps some consideration besides "number of dollars" should be taken in situations like this, because I don't really think a group of people should be able to so fundamentally fuck over another group because they can afford to. But those are my ethics - I value respecting people on more than money.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by TheEzEzz on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:05PM (#7079872)
You can decide to build a family anyway. It's harder to move a family, especially an extended family.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by malandrew on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:31PM (#7087582)
Fully agree. I've had front-row seats to the shenanigans that are BMR housing units because my girlfriend qualifies for and has been trying to get, and the only conclusion that I can come to is that:

(1) It's a "squeaky wheel gets the grease" policy (2) They are just sticking fingers in the cracks in a dam that is leaking everywhere to plug a few holes.

The biggest problem with mollifying a large segment of the population with a lottery system is that it legitimizes a solution that never really solves the problem.

BMR housing is typically accessible to people with 70-110% of the area's median income. For every unit, there are 100+ applicants, and those are just the ones that are aware of the program's existence. The program is also riddled with fraud, with many applicants misrepresenting their income to be eligible or adding family members to the application even when that family member isn't going to live with them in the unit.

The worst effect though is that it removes many people from becoming advocates for re-zoning and building of new units. Each of those 100 people per unit now directs their time and attention towards a lottery system instead of demanding real changes from their representatives in local government. Removing those people leaves the very rich and very poor. The poor know they don't have a chance and are living hand to mouth so they won't participate at all. The rich are either well off enough to be insulated from the issue so they complain but never do anything, or the rich are the property owners extracting rent. Ultimately the only people really participating in numbers are the landlords.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by yapcguy on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:24PM (#7079915)
> Should the government subsidize...

I don't see why a poorly run bank which has made bad investments in toxic assets should be bailed out with taxpayer's money when it should be allowed to fail, with good banks picking up clients and assets and growth in market share...

My point is there are few markets which are truly allowed to operate freely. If housing markets were not regulated, the uber rich would buy up every piece of real estate and then we'd all be stuffed.

> we bid up the houses to obscene prices due to lack of supply.

People can only bid what they can afford, and what they can afford is driven by loose lending and cheap credit. Tighten bank lending and housing prices will start falling.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by epicureanideal on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:29PM (#7080074)
I also wanted to say, this is really not a conflict between the rich and the poor. What ends up happening is the truly rich can afford to live in SF easily with or without subsidies. The lower and lower-middle class end up with "affordable" (subsidized) housing. The upper-middle and upper-but-not rich get stuck in the middle with no assistance and maybe being able to afford to live in the area if they save in every other area and work themselves to poor health.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by epicureanideal on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:26PM (#7080068)
I agree with you about the toxic assets and about cheap credit, but I don't see how those interventions would encourage us to add even more interventions.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by pmiller2 on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:27PM (#7080070)
>Also, if the people who work in SF or other high income areas cannot afford to live there at current wages, there should be pressure on them to leave and work elsewhere.

The problem is that people who can't afford to live where they currently live also can't afford to move.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by prodigal_erik on Sunday January 19, 2014 @03:56AM (#7083896)
How does that happen? We used to have a lot of stuff, but hiring movers never cost anywhere near even one month's rent. Are these the same people who are half a paycheck away from disaster all the time?
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by devindotcom on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:50PM (#7079986)
Wow! You are really out of touch!
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by kunle on Friday January 17, 2014 @08:24PM (#7079608)
The most striking figure in here is this one:

"The hard truth is that the Bay Area's housing and transit systems are bursting at the seams. According to the San Francisco Apartment Association, last year the city added 68,000 new jobs and just 120 new housing units. Silicon Valley's rental vacancy rates are even lower than the city's."

That's math that just undeniable.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by rayiner on Friday January 17, 2014 @09:50PM (#7079831)
For comparison, Chicago, a city that isn't growing like SF, added 1,150 housing units in 2012 and had 3,050 units under construction for delivery in 2013-2014 as of September 2012: http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2012-09-13/classified/ct-....
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by nb13 on Friday January 17, 2014 @08:36PM (#7079640)
This one really jumped out at me too. I haven't read this anywhere before:

"research from the Bay Area Council Economic Institute showed that each of these tech jobs had an astounding effect of creating an additional 4.3 jobs in the local economy."

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by kunle on Friday January 17, 2014 @08:47PM (#7079662)
Yeah I thought that was striking as well. I'm generally skeptical of stats like this but I'd love to see the paper and see the structure of those gigs (eg which industries, where geographically are they concentrated etc)
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by nb13 on Friday January 17, 2014 @08:54PM (#7079684)
I found it. It's mentioned on page 5 in the executive summary. I don't have enough time to read through the whole report right now.

http://www.bayareaeconomy.org/media/files/pdf/TechReport.pdf

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by timr on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:43PM (#7079965)
So, first off, it needs to be acknowledged that this was written by the "Bay Area Council", which is a PR machine for a dues-paying group of bay area corporations, including Facebook and Google [1]. Consider the source.

Second, while I'm the first to acknowledge that SF needs to build up, it's clearly absurd to say that the tech boom is "not the cause" of the city's housing problems -- that's like saying that skiing isn't the cause of Aspen's housing prices. Nonsense. It's plain that tech is the proximal cause, even if you believe that the boom has brought both positive and negative consequences to the city (as I do).

Fair debate on this topic has to begin with the acknowledgement that the tech companies' policies are indirectly driving a displacement of non-tech workers from the city. It's dishonest to claim otherwise.

[1] http://www.bayareacouncil.org/about-us/member-companies/

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by surrealize on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:38PM (#7080096)
> It's plain that tech is the proximal cause

It's half of the proximal cause. Housing prices have increased because of the interaction of supply and demand. Blaming the tech boom focuses only on the demand side, but the supply constraints (height limits, zoning density limits, etc.) are just as important.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by timr on Saturday January 18, 2014 @12:01AM (#7080146)
The supply didn't decrease. The demand increased. That's the proximal cause.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by malandrew on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:41PM (#7087611)
The demand has been increasing for like forever. The supply has never reacted to the increase in demand. The complete paralysis when it comes to rezoning is an equally valid proximal cause. The Bay Area hasn't been constructing housing to meet the demand caused by job growth, tech or otherwise, for 30-40 years now.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by surrealize on Saturday January 18, 2014 @12:10PM (#7081423)
If you like. The policy levers are all on the supply side, though (unless you want to start kicking out major employers or something). So it's pointless to complain about demand side changes.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by timr on Saturday January 18, 2014 @07:22PM (#7082867)
"The policy levers are all on the supply side, though"

Are you kidding? Remember the big white buses that everyone is mad about? They play a role here.

The valley tech companies have mitigated the natural barrier that would ordinarily limit the number of tech employees living in the city -- the pain of commuting. So rather than staying close to work and building communities where they live, they use the city as a glorified suburb, but with cushy private transportation. There are a variety of things wrong with this, not the least of which is the fact that they reduce housing supply for the natives.

Econ 101 theories about supply and demand don't apply when large external forces are subsidizing the demand side of the equation. One can quite reasonably argue that instead of "building up" (which is expensive and disruptive) SF should just ban the private buses -- it would be cheaper, more natural, and would solve the same problem.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by surrealize on Sunday January 19, 2014 @03:32AM (#7083857)
Ban private buses? You mean, like, prevent people from operating private buses entirely? No greyhound? You can't mean that, because it's ridiculous, but I'm not sure exactly what you do mean.

A huge number of people employed on the peninsula would absolutely live close to work and build communities there, if those peninsula cities weren't so hell-bent on preventing dense development. There just isn't the supply there.

And what the f do you mean by "natives", anyway? Native Americans? Everyone else is an immigrant. If you moved here a year before I did, do you have some more legitimate claim to live here? I don't think so.

Of course supply and demand applies to the situation. Your suggestion of banning private buses, while ridiculous, is specifically an attempt to influence demand. Your own suggested solution assumes that the "Econ 101" theory applies.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by malandrew on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:42PM (#7087618)
Once enough of the employees are commuting, I would imagine that any smart business would look at the situation and think "Time to move the office to the city or at least build a satellite office there."
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by malandrew on Sunday January 19, 2014 @11:38PM (#7087598)
True, but one of the comments on the article is especially telling:

    "The title of this piece expresses a false choice. It's not 
    meaningful to consider the development of industry separately 
    from the development of housing for the workers in industry. We 
    chose in the early 1950s to develop industry in the Bay Area 
    without regard for where the workers in the new workplaces 
    would live. Long before the current wave of tech immigrants 
    reached San Francisco there were people commuting to the Bay 
    Area from Manteca and Mountain Home and Santa Rosa and Santa 
    Cruz. Silicon Valley activists raised alarms in the early 1970s 
    that four new jobs were being created for each new housing unit 
    that was built. It shows an astonishing nearsightedness that 
    the people and the governments of Bay Area cities are only now 
    realizing that this is problematic."
It's observations like that that further support my views that San Francisco (and the Bay Area in general) is managed by children and has been for an incredibly long time. Considering how many people in the Bay Area are inventing the future, the local government here exhibits a level of shortsightedness that I have previously only witnessed in developing countries.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by radley on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:35PM (#7079945)
"tech's shuttles are a godsend, eliminating 327,000 cars"

That doesn't seem accurate. Over a third of San Francisco's population leaves town on tech buses?

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by cloudwalking on Friday January 17, 2014 @10:46PM (#7079974)
"tech's shuttles are a godsend, eliminating 327,000 cars and 10,000 tons of carbon every year at no cost to the taxpayer"

I presume this means 327,000 car trips per year.

Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by sethhochberg on Saturday January 18, 2014 @12:42AM (#7080238)
That seems much more reasonable - assuming 260 work days a year and 2 trips per day, we'd be looking at just under 450 cars off the roads due to shuttles.
Re:Bay Area tech boom not cause of region's problems by wpietri on Friday January 17, 2014 @11:03PM (#7080024)
This just in: young PR guy for for business lobby group thinks business is awesome.