News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by gfodor on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:17AM (#7055687)
...and soon robotics.

I'm a huge Apple fanboy but they really need to get their shit together on the web services front. Siri still sucks almost unbelievably bad. It never works. Maps still leads me to random streets and goes in circles.

As we move towards smaller and smaller devices one has to assume more of the work is going to be happening in the data center. Not good news for Apple unless they start making some real strategic acquisitions stat. (They've started at least.)

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by striglia on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:26AM (#7055854)
You're comparing them on uneven terms. Show me one company besides Google that can even stack up to what Apple's done in Maps or with Siri. There's none. That's because both require amazing amount of expertise, money, and data to deploy properly. Apple has correctly done what they had to (break off the data flow from iOS to Google) even where it may have reduced the experience for their customers. That's a long term play.

Funny how Google is continuing to corner the data market via acquisitions like Nest. Almost feels...anti-competitive, no? I wonder how long until we start talking about Google the way we still talk about 1990s Microsoft.

Is it plausible that a new company, starting from scratch in the Maps/Search/Personal Assistant/etc. field could actually compete with Google? Or would they just get crushed under the personalizing power of Google's raw data and computational advantage?

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by magicalist on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:42AM (#7055894)
> Show me one company besides Google that can even stack up to what Apple's done in Maps or with Siri

Well Microsoft, easily, if they had the will. I guess the pieces are actually all there, but they aren't as direct with posing it as a "personal assistant" or whatever.

If you consider the products separately: there are several major mapping companies, though there have been a ton of confusing mergers and splits in the last 5 years, not to mention OSM. As for Siri, it was a tiny team at Siri, Inc that created the foundations of Siri. Apple has done a ton with it (though I was hoping for more by now), but you can easily imagine a next-gen Siri coming out of a startup.

> Funny how Google is continuing to corner the data market via acquisitions like Nest. Almost feels...anti-competitive, no?

This becomes a little farcical, honestly. First, you can get far more information from a phone, and there are like 3 orders of magnitude more Android phones out there than there are Nest devices.

But more importantly, if we're going to talk about the "data market" -- as if that's some sort of thing -- virtually any acquisition that has customers would help them corner it. But that also means any other company with customers also has a stake in that "market", in which case, no, it does not feel anti-competitive.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by striglia on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:07AM (#7056077)
I think you underestimate the importance of context in all of this. You can't build any of these products well without knowing (deeply and certainly) users' patterns. Microsoft has no realistic way of knowing when it routes you to the wrong place...no continuous training data to let it feed and refine a personal assistant. Data products can be cool demos (see Siri) from a startup, but without both the starting dataset and the continuous feedback that you get by deploying these against real users and capturing the resulting behavior, I think they are quite limited. Continuous adaptation and learning is as important as the initial algorithm.

And while I certainly am looking into the future when I talk about cornering the market, I think it's an interesting question to ask how you compete against a company like Google that starts with this much user context. How can you build better experiences when they have the advantage in data, ML expertise, and the raw computational power? The incremental acquisitions of data and companies are not the issue...it's the web of connections that is valuable. And Google is not only trouncing Apple, their only meaningful competitor, in that race...Google is pulling even further ahead.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by product50 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:40AM (#7056169)
Microsoft search share is around 18% in US and a number of those searches are local (Apple has none of those). Additionally, they have a growing number of Windows 8 devices which they will be using for local/maps and train their models. I have used Bing maps and though it is not as good as Google Maps, it definitely holds up against Apple Maps.

To your initial question that if there is any company which could have built Maps or Siri, Microsoft is more than a good answer. You can try to get really nitpicky on this but it is what it is.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by latch on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:15AM (#7056259)
Whenever I see a comparison to Microsoft's anti-competitive behavior, I wonder whether people don't understand antitrust law, what Microsoft did, or both.

From a competition point of view, antitrust isn't concerned about where you are, but rather how you got there. As Sherman put it:

"[a person] who merely by superior skill and intelligence...got the whole business because nobody could do it as well as he could was not a monopolist"

As far as we know, Google is doing nothing to prevent other companies, like Apple or Microsoft from making similar acquisitions and/or capitalising on the acquisitions they have made.

Microsoft told OEMs that if they sold more than X computers without Windows, their licensing cost would go up by Y. There's also their embrace, extend and extinguish (their own words) which describes their strategy to adopt a standard (Java), add custom behavior (J/Direct) and thus breaking the standard and weakening the product. And this isn't all of it, and they also did some stupid stuff in court (submitting faked videos and getting caught).

As long as Google's behavior doesn't hurt consumers nor does it unfairly disadvantage competition (and being too good and too big isn't enough, they need to actively undermine them), the comparison is absolutely and totally flawed.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by pmelendez on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:35AM (#7056890)
"as well as he could was not a monopolist"

This sounds very strange to me given the fact that by definition a monopoly is the control of a market by one entity, it doesn't have anything to do with how it gets there.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by freehunter on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:46AM (#7056956)
Having a monopoly is not illegal. Abusing that monopoly to gain unfair advantage in another market is illegal. People use the term "monopoly" to interchangeably mean "legal monopoly" and "illegal monopoly", which does get confusing.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by pmelendez on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:46AM (#7057584)
>"Having a monopoly is not illegal."

Well that depends on the country. In some countries monopolies are illegal and the government is the only one that can perform ones.

Also, questionable practices are not necessarily illegal. For instance, no that long ago (well 20 years or so is not that long for me), having privileged information on wall street wasn't illegal, but questionable.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by saturdaysaint on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:56AM (#7057018)
As someone that uses both platforms extensively, I find claims of Siri and Maps inferiority utterly mind-boggling. On an iPhone, I can get directions to anywhere or call anyone or create calendar events while barely looking at my phone. Google Now is nice in some respects but almost always requires an off-putting degree of annoying manual manipulation to accomplish actions as simple as calling someone.

For me, Maps gives me eerily accurate drivetime estimates whereas Google's times are utterly useless. And I consider the UI patently inferior. I feel like a need two hands and a full minute to do things that require a few quick taps in iOS. Google seems to need to ping their server to get my search history or home address, whereas iOS calls it up in milliseconds. I would also kill to have navigation on the lockscreen as in iOS - it always requires a janky series of button presses and swipes on my Android phone.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by smackfu on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @09:28AM (#7057197)
>For me, Maps gives me eerily accurate drivetime estimates whereas Google's times are utterly useless.

Fascinating. Apple Maps is always wrong for me, with the estimated time of arrival constantly changing as I drive, while Google (and Waze) are spot on.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by micampe on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:18AM (#7057462)
Well of course the ETA changes while you are driving, that seems obvious. It's an estimate, it depends on current conditions, it can't be correct from the start.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by smackfu on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:53AM (#7057624)
For instance, just now I pulled up directions to the place I drove on Sunday. Apple Maps gives three routes, ranging from 35-40 minutes. Google Maps gives three routes, ranging from 29-33 minutes. In my experience, it will take closer to the time Google says, so if I'm using Apple Maps, the ETA will start out at 35 minute from now, and by the time I get there, it will be 5 minutes sooner. The only "current condition" it is depending on is that I'm driving faster over the route than it expects.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by micampe on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:59AM (#7058098)
The estimate also depends on current traffic conditions.

I won't debate the accuracy of either case since it can only be an anecdotal and unproductive conversation. You were disputing the value changing over time, not it being inaccurate. Google does seem to give more optimistic estimates in general.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by epmatsw on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:05AM (#7057387)
It's heavily dependent on the city you're in as far as I can tell. Google Maps is awful in Madison, but I've had better results with it in Atlanta.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by ansimionescu on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:30AM (#7057512)
As people often say, it might have something to where you're using these services. E.g. in York, UK both Apple and Google Maps work perfectly fine.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by adolph on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:27AM (#7057500)
The back and forth of claims regarding Siri seem to indicate an uneven level of service. My own experience is that it works great just enough to fail frustratingly.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by saturdaysaint on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:12AM (#7057757)
It's not perfect, but I would kill to have it on my daily driver Android. Siri consistently nails daily things like "Directions home" or "Call [girlfriend]" or "set an alarm for 10 minutes" or "Show movies near me", all manual tasks when I'm in Android.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by mvgoogler on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @05:02PM (#7060111)
Interesting. On my Nexus 5 all of those examples work perfectly without touching the phone. Since around the time of the Nexus 4 the voice recognition has been really good (for me at least).

Not trying to argue - it's just interesting how much variation there is for different people (for both Siri and Android apparently).

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by morganherlocker on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:41AM (#7057567)
Maps works well for me and I can think of few times when I have found it lacking. Siri, on the other hand, gives me a timeout ~15% of the time.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by saturdaysaint on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @11:17AM (#7057788)
Well Android requires me to stop what I'm doing and fiddle with my phone to get directions home or call my girlfriend or get movie times %100 of the time. I'll take the occasional timeout since Siri seamlessly routes me to my house with a single button press/voice command.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by morganherlocker on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:22PM (#7059820)
Does Google Now not do this? (not an Android user)
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by saturdaysaint on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:58PM (#7060071)
I'd say it almost does this. But there are enough fit and finish issues (like, a few orders of magnitude beyond Siri's supposedly showstopping "occasional internet timeouts when in spotty network coverage") to make it functionally useless.

Just initiating the voice commands is a pretty telling comparison.

iPhone: hold down ergonomically placed home button until it beeps, say what you want (eg "directions home"). Siri waits a well-timed beat and launches maps.

Android: press unlock button (semi-awkwardly placed on upper right corner), do weird home button motion only used to launch Google now (drag the soft "home" button up). Say "OK Google" to initiate voice detection, say what you want. Then there's a poorly calibrated lag to make sure Now is doing what you want, a hair over 5 seconds maybe.

Then there are weird fit/finish issues. Android seems to do weird things when headphones w/ a mic are connected, so it takes several seconds longer to be able to say "OK Google" after launching. If you use headphones a lot, it's basically a dealbreaker. And I find a lot of fit and finish issues when Google actually performs the action.

I'd be curious to try the Moto X to see if its "always listening" mode mitigates some of these issues.

tl;dr Now is great as a morning homepage, but an abysmal failure as a Siri-like assistant

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by Angostura on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:27AM (#7056440)
I've found that the data in Maps has been significantly improved (in the UK) over the last couple of months, its now actually possible to find businesses on it (road data has always been reasonable).

The more concerning thing to me, is Apple's apparent usability weakness when it comes to iCloud, syncing and its devices. I've worked it out now, more or less, but the potential for confusion is tremendous. If I turn on syncing, I expect syncing. If I turn off syncing, I expect syncing to stop, I do not expect warnings about documents being deleted from various devices.

Similar with calendars. Turn on iCloud and suddenly you have calendars 'On My Mac' and in iCloud. All the calendars are duplicated. Horribly confusing behaviour for someone who is new to it.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by statictype on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:54AM (#7056999)
If I turn off syncing, I expect syncing to stop, I do not expect warnings about documents being deleted from various devices.

This has been a problem with iTunes syncing as well. Constantly warning me about deleting apps and photos when I check or uncheck a box. Does anyone ever want to say yes to any of those questions? Very user hostile behavior.

There's still no easy way to randomly get photos from a computer onto my ipad. I have to use some 3rd party app or frickin mail them to myself. The photo syncing feature is useless.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by xutopia on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @09:57AM (#7057345)
In Quebec, Canada I find it leads me to impossible places. Even hospitals have the wrong address.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by IBM on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:20AM (#7055833)
Do you actually use Siri or Maps? Because I find your complaints about them absurd, I use both of these services every day and they work marvelously.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by x0x0 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:27AM (#7055857)
Do you? apple maps just led us 18 minutes out of the way just this weekend. It's apparently incapable of leading people to restaurants just off 80 in Auburn, CA. When we gave up and used decent software -- ie google maps -- it got us straight there.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by freehunter on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:49AM (#7056971)
And other times, Google Maps leads me astray or takes me down inappropriate roads while Bing Maps/Nokia Maps works just fine. It's almost like they're all getting their mapping data independently and as such have their own unique strengths and weaknesses.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by lostlogin on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:56AM (#7056058)
I had that issue with google maps. The problem is that this is all anecdata. We need someone perverse enough to trial both. What a chore.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by hackaflocka on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:30AM (#7055862)
The name of the local university is wrong in Apple Maps. It's using the 30 year old name. I've sent them corrections (via the maps app) a couple of times, over 1.5 years ago. No change.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by eshvk on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @09:09AM (#7057078)
To be fair, I have sent corrections to Google Maps and it took them two years and talking to a friend in Maps before they corrected it. Also, this was for Google telling me to take a left where no left existed when driving from the South Bay into San Francisco.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by lostlogin on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:58AM (#7056063)
Try again. I fid the same, with no luck. However my recent flags have been actioned.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by Spiritus on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:01AM (#7055940)
It doesn't even get my home address right, and I live in the middle of Sweden's fourth largest city.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by catshirt on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:22AM (#7055836)
for what it's worth, i stopped actually using them because they both suck terribly even before you compare them to their Google alternatives.

maps has notoriously bad data.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by natevancouver on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:47AM (#7056188)
There is mapping data, and then there is place data (where a business is located).

Google and Apple must use the same mapping data, because I see the same errors in both apps. Of course with Google, after I report the error it gets fixed. I can’t say the same for Apple. And Navteq* has more detailed and accurate data than either of them.

What Google has is superb place data. Apple has… Yelp.

*Assuming you have recent Navteq data. Not the nav system in your car that hasn’t been updated in 2 years.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by Angostura on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @06:28AM (#7056447)
Something's happened with Apple place data in the UK in the last month or two - it's suddenly become... OK. It was a laughable joke before.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by IBM on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:26AM (#7055852)
Better start giving it a look again with the trend Google's services are heading in.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by smackfu on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @09:21AM (#7057156)
You never run into the "I'm really sorry but I can't handle your request right now" message for Siri? That is just a total killer to that service, because it takes 15-20 seconds just to error out. And sometimes when you try again, it happens again. And then you ask yourself, "why am I using Siri anyways?"
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by gfodor on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:52PM (#7059265)
Yes, I'd say about 20-30% of the time I use Siri it times out or hangs either when it parses what I say or trying to resolve it. A few weeks ago Maps lead me to a parking lot when getting directions to a restaurant. In Mountain View.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by vvhn on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:37AM (#7056906)
They work in the US ( and perhaps some other "first world" countries ) but in places like India, data for even big cities is practically non existent while Google Maps has everything ( and up to date ).
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by rmason on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:46AM (#7055746)
Can someone explain to me why Apple didn't acquire Nest?

He's a known quantity at Apple and he's doing hardware that would expand their market. I know they don't do a lot of acquisitions but this would seem to be a no-brainer for them.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by nairteashop on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:24AM (#7055840)
Apple's MO has always been to do a few things, and do them well. Perhaps home automation is not on their radar. Google, on the other hand, is used to running a million different unrelated projects, so they are better setup for something like this.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by bluthru on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:53AM (#7055770)
Getting a return on 3.2bn seems like a risky bet for Apple. Google has the incentive to bring in Tony Fadell, but his disciples have already shipped many products at Apple.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by bedhead on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @10:20AM (#7057472)
I would speculate that it's because Nest's products aren't scalable in the way most of Apple's other products are. The appeal is too narrow, appealing primarily to ultra-techy folks or people building/redoing their home. Phones and mp3 players and computers are owned by almost everyone. I just don't see smoke detectors and thermostats having that same kind of broad appeal.

Nest is neat. I don't have one but my neighbor does and it's a fine product. I'm as "gadgety" as the next guy here, but even after playing with Nest and being impressed I still wasn't compelled to buy one. I dunno, maybe one day.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by smackfu on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @08:10AM (#7056770)
Apple makes acquisitions to improve their existing products. If the people at Nest wanted to improve Apple products, they wouldn't have left Apple and formed Nest in the first place.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by laureny on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:47AM (#7055753)
> Can someone explain to me why Apple didn't acquire Nest?

I'm guessing that to them, it's all or nothing: either they invent and market the product, or they're not interested.

Unsustainable hubris, if you ask me.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by cowsandmilk on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @07:24AM (#7056609)
> Unsustainable hubris, if you ask me.

Or the opposite of hubris. They want to stay focused on their product line. They're happy to put connected home products in their stores, as they've done with nest; but they recognize they are already spread thin, so they do not actually want to make products in that space. Apple's acquisitions tend to be targeted improving their existing product line, not rapid expansions into new products.

I would bet Apple could make a good washer and dryer, but no one is claiming Apple is not out there courting the best washer/dryer company due to hubris.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by snom380 on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:57AM (#7055783)
My guess from the kind of companies they buy, is that their products really need to fit with Apples area of focus. If not, they buy the company for the talent or technology (like FingerWorks).
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by rmason on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:27AM (#7055991)
So the only reason that they'd buy a company is if purchasing the company's technology lets them get a product to market sooner than if it were built in house? Or by doing an acqui-hire they can get a team at at the right price to fast forward a new product?

So you're saying that they've become a 'not invented here' kind of company?

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by iand on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @04:31AM (#7056144)
Unlikely. Siri was an acquisition for example.
Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by bitserf on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @01:57AM (#7055784)
Are they capable of shifting from device centric thinking?

Feels like Google has a lock on the talent that could help Apple build out their capability here.

They'd need to take services seriously as well, for starters.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by erichocean on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @02:12AM (#7055812)
Are they capable of shifting from device centric thinking?

Sadly, no. I doubt even Jobs would have made that shift were he still alive, but I'm certain Tim Cook won't.

Re:On Google's Acquisition of Nest by 001sky on Tuesday January 14, 2014 @03:03AM (#7055947)
Apple owns identity. Google not so much. Yet. Once they are in your glasses, car, and thermostat...things will be different.