News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The problem is with the product by edtechdev on Saturday January 04, 2014 @11:49AM (#7011684)
Google is just researching and trying out new products that can potentially help their bottom line - so what if some may not explode in popularity.

Their bottom line is to get more exposure to their ads, and I'm not arguing if that's good or bad. Driverless cars would mean that passengers have more time to be exposed to web ads on their phones and tablets (I'm not saying that's the primary motivation or benefit, but it certainly is a factor in Google's involvement). Expanding Internet access in cities through Google Fiber means more people can be exposed to their ads. Sharing Android freely with anyone means increased access to the web and thus Google ads. It's not too difficult to see what the motivation for developing Google Glass is - you would potentially be exposed to ads all day long, not just when you whip out your phone or when you are using your computer.

Re:The problem is with the product by kkowalczyk on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:58PM (#7012375)
I doubt Google has as simplistic view of their business as you do.

Google's bottom line is the same as everyone else's: making money.

Currently, the ads are very lucrative for them and they use the money from ad business to both expand the ad business (like investing in YouTube or Android) AND try to find other sources of revenue (e.g. Google Fiber or Google Apps for enterprise).

You can't assume that Google is terminally stupid and can't see past their current business model.

Google Fiber is not free. If people use Comcast, they'll see as many ads from Google as if they were using Fiber. Google can estimate how much ADDITIONAL ad revenue they could expect per user from Fiber vs. Comcast usage and that's probably not much.

At $70 or $120/month, this can be very profitable business (long-term, of course, initial investment is huge). Outside of US, companies make good profit at lower prices.

Same goes for self-driving cars: transportation is a massive industry. Taxis alone are $10 billion industry. Personal car ownership and use is massive. If Google could get a piece of that business, it could be more profitable than their ad business.

Re:The problem is with the product by AceJohnny2 on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:57PM (#7012062)
I don't understand why you assume their only or main reason to develop Google Glass and self-driving cars is ads.

Their original product was a search engine. Their breakthrough money-making product was ads, indeed, and they've focused their business model on that, but I contest that it's in their DNA. Do you really think the only value they could derive out of self-driving cars is for more targeted ads?

Re:The problem is with the product by joelrunyon on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:25PM (#7012207)
Google is an advertising company. Everything they do is an attempt to protect their advertising revenue in the search vertical.

Read this article on all of google's besides search being a "moat."

http://techcrunch.com/2011/03/25/search-googles-castle-moat/

Re:The problem is with the product by amaks on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:51PM (#7012335)
This might be a case few years ago, but google is clearly trying to diversify its business with the high speed internet, self-driving cars, robotics. It's hard to justify these investments for the sake of ads.
Re:The problem is with the product by joelrunyon on Saturday January 04, 2014 @02:24PM (#7012467)
High Speed Internet --> To have more data & serve you more ads throughout your whole internet experience (not just google).

Cars --> Oh, have more time while you're not driving? Spend it on your tablet / computer / device & see more ads.

Robotics --> Time freed up around the house? Spend more time online. Need to have your robot run errands for you? Approve these coupon offers at nearby grocery stores & have your robot pick them up.

Glass --> Like the outfit that person is wearing? Here's a coupon to buy it right now.

Google is an ad company. They have cool tech - but they it comes back to ads.

Re:The problem is with the product by krisoft on Saturday January 04, 2014 @03:19PM (#7012716)
About self driving cars: I just want to know if you gave serious consideration to the idea of licensing the technology, and making piles of cash that way? If you did, then I assume you concluded that the advertisement possibility is an even bigger revenue source? Or you don't think that, but you believe that google has a company wide blind spot for that solution? I don't want to put words in your mouth, just want to understand deeper your reasoning.

So, could you please elaborate on why do you think self driving cars will be monetized through ads?

Re:The problem is with the product by joelrunyon on Saturday January 04, 2014 @03:39PM (#7012813)
They invested 258 million into Uber[1]. I doubt Google . Google's mission is to "organize the world's information." Given that's their MO, once they've figured out the textual information of the web, they're moving to mapping the world & taking typically "offline" data - online.

With a bunch of driverless cars roaming the streets - they could be collecting all sorts of contextual data on people / locations / businesses that I imagine many, many people would be willing to pay for. They might not be ads in the same way you think about typical "search" ads, but they're still ads nonetheless.

Google doesn't tend to like to build actual "paid" services. Rather they create free services that draw in people / eyeballs & use that information to push their index of information even further.

http://techcrunch.com/2013/08/22/google-ventures-puts-258m-i...

Re:The problem is with the product by gfodor on Saturday January 04, 2014 @04:12PM (#7012957)
Or, you know, they can just license the technology to literally every automotive company in the world, for tens (hundreds?) of billions of dollars of recurring annual revenue.

This is technology that is only possible through their insane lead in all the work on Google Street View. It will take years or decades for people to catch up. Then again, there is only one Google, so perhaps nobody ever will. They have all the PhDs and the patents. They have all the ground-level data about every nook and cranny on American roadways and beyond, and a system in place that keeps this up-to-date. They have a huge economic moat on this. Who else can do this? It's a $1t+ projected future cash flow imho. You think they really give a shit about the secondary increase in advertising revenue from people surfing their web in the car, enough to give the golden goose away for free?

What you say sounds clever but really it's pretty simple: Google will have a product that everyone wants, a product that will provide a massive ROI even at a high price, and nobody else will be able to duplicate it for a very long time, if ever. No need for higher dimensional chess here. If they pull it off it will eclipse anything you or I have lived through in terms of upside for a single company.

Re:The problem is with the product by giovannibajo1 on Saturday January 04, 2014 @06:33PM (#7013523)
I think that Google DNA is against making money out of licensing consumer software. They give out everything for free, they release lots of open source libraries, they even released the most important mobile operating system in the world for free, giving it out for free so that other companies can make companies selling mobiles. When they were forced to get into hardware with the Nexus line, they decided not to make a profit selling them, so that people can benefit from cheap top-tier phones.

Lots of people think of Google has some kind of hero of free software and free services for consumers and I think it kinds of match their DNA and their mission. They did started monetizing the B2B/power users services more aggressively (Google Apps doesn't have a free version anymore, Google Drive space raised three times prices now, GAE got lots more expensive, etc.), but consumer market is where scale is.

They want to organize the world information and making it freely and easily accessible. My feeling is that they won't patent and license driverless cars exactly for this reason. I think the business model they will choose for Google Glass will tell us more about this.

Re:The problem is with the product by gfodor on Saturday January 04, 2014 @07:04PM (#7013661)
I think this is just semantics. If Google's technology is powering my self-driving Honda Civic, someone has to pay for it. The hardware, the software, the service, all three of those are going to cost money. Google is not going to give away the hardware, someone will buy that, but that's not where the money is. They might give away/open source some of the software, that's irrelevant.

The big question is if the live navigation and driving service is going to be like Google Maps or Google Apps.

I don't think the division between paid vs ads has anything to do with consumer vs business. It has to do with if someone will pay for it, plain and simple, or if they have to monetize it through advertising (directly or downstream.) Android they had no choice and were willing to do anything to ensure they didn't miss the smartphone train. Here, they have all the leverage and no competition.

I'm pretty sure you'll see auto manufacturers paying for the service in a license-like fashion to put it in all their cars or consumers will pay directly for the service. I don't think anyone expects their car to drive itself around for free, and will be willing to pay for it, just like they don't expect free internet service and pay google for Google Fiber. I said "licensing" but what I meant really is "pay for the service directly."

edit: Oh, and even if it turns out consumers get a free ride (literally :)) you're still looking at absurd revenue from all the commercial entities that will have a need for this technology, both traditional ones (shippers, commercial transportation) and new ones we haven't thought of yet that become possible once the tech is available, like car-sharing services or micro-shipping. Google certainly isn't going to let them use it for free.

Re:The problem is with the product by joelrunyon on Sunday January 05, 2014 @01:35AM (#7014871)
> Google certainly isn't going to let them use it for free.

Why not? They let them people use almost every other service they offer for free.

Re:The problem is with the product by eonil on Saturday January 04, 2014 @02:58PM (#7012621)
I had a big expectation on Boston Dynamics, but not anymore because Google purchased them.
Re:The problem is with the product by crag on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:39PM (#7012276)
"I don't understand why you assume their only or main reason to develop Google Glass and self-driving cars is ads."

Because everything Google does is for serving ads. Every tech that Google releases is directly or in-directly related to ad revenue. Either serve ads or collect data to sell to advertisers.

Nothing wrong with this. Many companies rely on ad revenue (Facebook or example).

But I do know Google is desperately searching for other sources of revenue. It's just that they are addicted to ads. And social media (for ads). Which, IMHO is killing the company. Their total focus on Google + (and other social apps) is sucking the life out of other interesting projects; that might yield results that aren't dependent on ad revenue. But it's hard to think out-side the box. Sad.

Re:The problem is with the product by Confusion on Saturday January 04, 2014 @03:17PM (#7012706)
So your answer to the question "Why do you assume .. ads?" is "because everything .. ads". How do you not recognize that as begging the question?

And then a few sentences later you say "Google is desperately searching for other sources of revenue", which is utterly inconsistent with "because everything .. ads". Your comment does not make any sense at all.

Re:The problem is with the product by crag on Saturday January 04, 2014 @03:27PM (#7012756)
My point is that Google is searching in vain. It's running around in circles cause it keeps coming back to ads.

Confusing? So is Google. Know anyone who works there? Ask. Many there are just as confused. And that's Google's problem.

Re:The problem is with the product by corresation on Saturday January 04, 2014 @02:34PM (#7012509)
Their bottom line is to get more exposure to their ads

Anyone who says this or its many variants has no business acumen or creativity. It is the banal banter of the boring. This sounds harsh, but seriously it grows tiring watching people desperately try to stretch everything to fit some nonsensical hypothesis.

Google is a very large company and their product is technology. They happen to have entered the market at a time when advertising was literally the only way to make money online (they originally tried to use the web purely to sell business search appliances, but that didn't pan out), but assuming that their entire future business model is ads is the domain of simpletons.

And, as an aside, I see more ads on my iPad and iPod Touch than I do on my Nexus 5. Isn't that weird?

Re:The problem is with the product by rimantas on Saturday January 04, 2014 @02:36PM (#7012522)
So. please tell, what their future business model is? Google product is ads, plain and simple.
Re:The problem is with the product by corresation on Saturday January 04, 2014 @02:51PM (#7012585)
Google has amassed the most enormous, capable data system on the planet. They have more knowledge about the world, places, people and information than anyone. They have continually demonstrated a computer engineering excellence that is simply unmatched.

If you lack the creativity to understand the opportunity ahead of them (or how the lack of these things has hurt companies like Apple), you should disengage from the conversation. Simply trotting out the tired, nonsensical "hurp durp ads" rejoinder adds nothing to the conversation but demonstrates a bit of tiring flag waving.

And by your very analysis, what is DaringFireball's "product"? It is ad (and t-shirt) supported, therefore the product is ads and t-shirts?

Re:The problem is with the product by throwawaykf03 on Saturday January 04, 2014 @03:09PM (#7012670)
> Google has amassed the most enormous, capable data system on the planet. They have more knowledge about the world, places, people and information than anyone. They have continually demonstrated a computer engineering excellence that is simply unmatched.

I think the real criticism is that despite all this and all the potential opportunities ahead of them, pretty much all their revenue is from ads. Personally, I don't think of this as a cause for criticism, but I do view such a single point of failure as a significant weakness.

Re:The problem is with the product by dasil003 on Saturday January 04, 2014 @04:20PM (#7012987)
There's no pressure for them to earn money from anything besides ads. Maybe this is cause for criticism from some Wall Street bean counters, but I don't see how it can be seen as an inherent negative for a technology company. They do a ton of interesting future tech stuff over there, arguably more than any other company in existence.
Re:The problem is with the product by gfodor on Saturday January 04, 2014 @04:01PM (#7012908)
According to the OP, since Google makes most of its money from ads, they somehow only want to strategically pursue ad-based revenue. This is beyond stupid analysis. Literally every business on Earth would like to diversify their revenue stream if it were possible to do so.

Besides there are plenty of examples where Google earns revenue that isn't from ads. See: Google Apps, GAE, GCE, etc. etc. If "We Are An Advertising Company, You Are The Product (TM)" was Google's ethos and defined all the work that they do they would not have built those products.

Re:The problem is with the product by ddebernardy on Saturday January 04, 2014 @06:55PM (#7013620)
Odd... I was under the impression that Google was created over a decade ago, and that it still looked and quacked (?) like a one-trick pony for all intents and purposes.

But who knows... Perhaps, after purchasing a zombie business for $12 billion and multiplying its staff by nearly an order of magnitude in the process, it might learn another trick or three.

And yes, isn't it very weird that Google makes more from ads displayed on iDevices than it does from ads displayed on Android devices, in spite of the fact that the latter are reputably ahead in terms of market share?

How could we possibly explain that? Is it that Android devices are used as dumb phones? That Android tablets are gathering dust in drawers? That iDevices are so superior that users don't mind the extra ad annoyance? All of the latter? Other things? I honestly wonder... If you've a sane explanation, then please, do tell, because I'm at a loss to make any sense of this myself.

Re:The problem is with the product by corresation on Saturday January 04, 2014 @08:17PM (#7013936)
Wave that flag a little harder. Show the club how much you belong.

How embarrassing.

Re:The problem is with the product by enome on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:04PM (#7011761)
I never really understood the reason behind driverless cars until I saw that they create 3D models of the environment they drive through. If everybody would drive a google car that would mean google has the potential of mapping the outside world in 3D in real time or atleast any place where cars can be used. The possibilities with this kind of data are pretty crazy and also a little scary.
Re:The problem is with the product by praptak on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:09PM (#7012128)
< I never really understood the reason behind driverless cars

Really? It might sound crazy but I think people would just buy them because they are, you know, useful for getting places.

Re:The problem is with the product by robotresearcher on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:44PM (#7012298)
And will save perhaps 20,000 lives and many more serious injuries in the US alone every year.
Re:The problem is with the product by rcxdude on Saturday January 04, 2014 @07:00PM (#7013645)
Well, the cars that google are developing also (AFAIK) rely on an existing 3D map of the environment of similar detail to what they scan in.
Re:The problem is with the product by rhizome on Saturday January 04, 2014 @02:28PM (#7012487)
Keep in mind that from a business perspective, the main use of these vehicles might be military. Think of them as drones in car form.
Re:The problem is with the product by rafe33 on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:12PM (#7011804)
It's also a massively profitable industry. It would do for the car industry what android previously has done for them in mobile.
Re:The problem is with the product by gress on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:18PM (#7012166)
Android is loss making for Google, and has resulted in an industry with only two profitable players, both of whom view Google as a competitor.

I doubt that is the scenario that Google would like for the auto industry.

Re:The problem is with the product by jasonlotito on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:45PM (#7012307)
Nothing awesome can come without fear.
Re:The problem is with the product by mcphage on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:10PM (#7012132)
> Google is just researching and trying out new products that can potentially help their bottom line - so what if some may not explode in popularity.

That's all good. Where it's a problem is when they take a product that they haven't sufficiently researched—haven't finished, in other words—and then charge people real dollars for them. Lots of real dollars.

Re:The problem is with the product by pook1e on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:40PM (#7012281)
I don't see the problem. Google is letting people pay to beta test their product. They aren't forcing anyone to buy anything nor are they marketing it as a finished product.