News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by dbecker on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @08:56AM (#6959340)
The real problem is: This additional freedom you can buy with money means less freedom for somebody else.

This assumes that wealth is a zero-sum game, so it can be traded around but not created.

It's hard to reconcile that view with the fact that standards-of-living have been growing, more or less worldwide , for the two centuries.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by ashray on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @10:22AM (#6959668)
Is the standard of living really growing for everyone? Or are there more people now (%wise) in poverty ?

This is an honest question as several people have mentioned the standard of living argument before on HN. I've read however that the rich-poor divide is growing and thus am just wondering about this..

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by joshuahedlund on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:17AM (#6959913)
Not only have both absolute and percentage numbers of people living in poverty dropped in the last two decades[0], but global inequality (unlike some intra-country inequality) is falling as well[1].

[0]http://www.economist.com/node/21548963 [1]http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/12/13/a...

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by snowwrestler on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @10:31AM (#6959699)
It's growing for most people in the world. The exceptions would probably be those who live in areas that are experiencing war or failed governments.

I don't have time to dig up sources but it's not hard to research. Wikipedia is a good place to start.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_reduction

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by randallsquared on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @10:30AM (#6959696)
Both can be true at once. The richest are farther ahead than the richest were, in monetary terms, but the poor have made huge strides in absolute wealth as well: it's possible to live a 1950s upper middle class lifestyle on almost the same dollar amount in 2013. Our idea of what a middle-class lifestyle entails, though, is now far above that.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by coldtea on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:38AM (#6960021)
Well, there are also intangibles that nobody cares to measure, that matter a lot.

A 2013 "middle class lifestyle" might be far ahead a 1950 "middle class lifestyle" in pocessions, access to products, etc, but there are important differences too.

For example, in all likely the 1950 "middle class" family could get all they needed by only one person working. And that person work an 8 hour day, with benefits and security. He was also quite sure that'd he keep his job if he was half decent at it permanently. He rarely was in debt.

Today's middle class starts of with a large debt (college loans), both in the couple have to work their asses of, and are not very far from falling off middle class, should anything bad happen (from a market crash to a medical emergency).

As for the increased luxuries and such (compared to 1950), those don't mean nothing to them, as they are the assumed zero-level for all middle class in their time.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by humanrebar on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @04:58PM (#6961281)
I believe your assertions about the 1950s need substantiation. I'd like to see some empirical data about things like poverty levels, life expectancy, job security, bankruptcy, and so on.

Keep in mind that this is only a couple of decades (at most) from the Great Depression. Even if the 1950s were clearly better, it's a rather cherry-picked data point considering how much worse the 1930s clearly were.

That being said, I'm not too excited about the intangibles of the 1950s. The Korean War was in the 1950s and Jim Crow was in full swing. Life expectancy was much lower. Just about any consumer good from today is clearly superior to the 1950s equivalent.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by Crito on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @06:12PM (#6961499)
Just for starters, he is almost certainly warping his perception of the 1950s by only considering what movies and television showed the 1950s being like for white men in suburbia America.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by coldtea on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @07:02PM (#6961647)
Which doesn't matter much, because I can also do the exact same comparison to the same group in today's suburbia America.

And no, it's not "movies and television". There are numerous books studying the decline of the middle class since the seventies.

Heck, there's even an accepted term "Great Prosperity" (as opposed to the "Great Depression" that describes the era after World War II for the USA and the West in general.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post%E2%80%93World_War_II_econo...

Here are some factoids:

Back in 1980, less than 30% of all jobs in the United States were low income jobs. Today, more than 40% of all jobs in the United States are low income jobs.

According to one study, between 1969 and 2009 the median wages earned by American men between the ages of 30 and 50 declined by 27 percent after you account for inflation.

Back in the year 2000, more than 64 percent of all working age Americans had a job. Today, only 58.7 percent of all working age Americans have a job.

The home ownership rate in the United States is the lowest that it has been in 18 years.

In 1989, the debt to income ratio of the average American family was about 58 percent. Today it is up to 154 percent.

Consumer debt in the United States has risen by a whopping 1700% since 1971, and 46% of all Americans carry a credit card balance from month to month.

Back in the 1970s, about one out of every 50 Americans was on food stamps. Today, about one out of every 6.5 Americans is on food stamps.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by Crito on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @09:04PM (#6961924)
> Which doesn't matter much, because I can also do the exact same comparison to the same group in today's suburbia America.

Compare the lives of minorities and women in America 60 years ago to their lives now. Quality of life for the majority of Americans has undeniably improved. You have massive tunnel vision if you cannot recognize this.

Remember that white American men are a plurality, not a majority.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:47AM (#6962533)
I'm not too excited about the intangibles of the 1950s.

It actually was a pretty good time, if you were American and white. The post-war boom was in full swing, American economic growth was at its highest in the 20th century (stats for earlier periods are harder to estimate, though long-term data series such as those collected by Angus Maddison might show this -- and the railroad and industrialization booms of the 1840s and 1880s were likely close). The US was the world's largest producer of oil (though it had just begun importing from Saudi Arabia), and it had essentially no rivals for industrial production (Europe and Japan had been seriously damaged by the war and were rebuilding, Korea and China wouldn't emerge for decades).

The Korean War was in the 1950s

For three years, 1950-1953. The US's troop commitment was 300,000. That compares with 16 million US troops in WWII. Fatalities alone were nearly as much as the Korean War deployment at 292,000. Korea was significant, but much less significant.

and Jim Crow was in full swing.

And starting to crack. Though it peaked in the 1960s, the Civil Rights movement had its roots in the 1950s, particularly the 1955 Montgomery Bus Boycott. No, it wasn't great, and there's still a huge amount of inequity, but things were finally starting to change.

And yes, there's a reason Nina Simone (and many others) left for France. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hBiAtwQZnHs

Life expectancy was much lower.

Not all that much especially when compared with improvements over the prior 50-100 years. Life expectancy at birth was about 66 years in 1951 for white males, 72 for women, vs. 75 and 80 years in 2004. That compares with 38 and 40 in 1850. The biggest single-decade jump for men was between 1911 and 1919 (six years), about the same for women. Much of that came from improved safety (particularly industrial conditions and automobiles), some in behavior and environment (decreased smoking, drinking, and air pollution). It was earlier advances in antiseptics, anesthesia, sanitation, waste disposal, food preservation, nutrition, and pharmaceuticals which accounted for the big jumps. For men, 1900 - 1950 saw an 18.08 year increase, 1950 - 2000 an 8.49 year increase.

http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0005140.html

Just about any consumer good from today is clearly superior to the 1950s equivalent.

I'll grant increased capabilities, complexity, and decreased costs, though overengineering (or lack of corner-cutting) meant that many electrical and mechanical products were more durable then. There's also the question of just how much such advances impact on quality of life.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:56AM (#6960100)
A 1950's upper middle class lifestyle involved owning a relatively large house, and sane working hours with in many cases only one wage earner.

It's simply false that you can live this way today on the same dollar amount.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by refurb on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:40PM (#6960265)
Actually houses have gotten significantly larger since the 1950s.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:42PM (#6960276)
Houses affordable by single wage earning families? I think not.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by refurb on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @02:06PM (#6960660)
Bingo! People talk about single wage earnings supporting a family and owning a house. Keep in mind that house was likely small by today's standards.

I don't think it's reasonable to complain that you can't sustain a family and a house that is 1.5x what they were in the 1950s, on a single income.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by collyw on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @05:57AM (#6962784)
In the UK and much of Europe houses are not any bigger.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by malandrew on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:24PM (#6960199)
Even in among the lower middle class lifestyles, you'd have exactly the same minus the "relatively large house".

However, if you go back 50 years earlier, the lower class lifestyle was not that different from the favella living in slums around the world, where entire families lived in one or two rooms and everyone in the family who was able was responsible for contributing to making ends meet.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by akgerber on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:46PM (#6960296)
The lower middle classes can't afford a house/apartment in places with laws that make it difficult to build new houses or apartments, including many places with lots of tech jobs. But in rural areas, or many Midwestern cities, or much of the Sunbelt, a house is still very much within reach. But many of the most productive regions of the country are zoned such that very little new housing is built, and rising incomes for some just mean more competition for existing housing.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:03PM (#6960369)
Of course houses are cheap in places with no jobs.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by dllthomas on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @02:12PM (#6960682)
A basic income would help jobs follow people.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by malandrew on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @08:05AM (#6962924)
I've never seen this argument for a basic income, but it's a super interesting one to think about.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:36PM (#6960249)
The lower middle classes can't own any house at all with just one wage earner.

Your second point (which I agree with) seems to imply that the US standard of living peaked in the 50's

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bmelton on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:04PM (#6960375)
> The lower middle classes can't own any house at all with just one wage earner.

The lower bound on lower middle class is, according to Wikipedia, $32,500. There are plenty of houses available for purchase in the $60,000 range, which is well inside of affordability ranges.

There are a plethora of rural homes available within those ranges, but that level of income isn't necessarily exclusionary to city dwelling either. Dallas, San Antonio, Cleveland, Cincinnati, St. Louis, Tampa, etc., are all very affordable, and at least according to MSN[1], has homes available for less than the lower bound on lower middle class.

[1] - http://realestate.msn.com/what-you-must-earn-to-buy-a-home-i...

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:07PM (#6960394)
Are there plenty of jobs near those cheap houses?
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bmelton on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:16PM (#6960448)
In Cincinnati, Tampa, etc., one would have to assume so. Regardless, that wasn't the point -- the point was that

> The lower middle classes can't own any house at all with just one wage earner

is not a true statement. If you'd like to qualify it further, feel free. I suspect I'd have to research more to answer, and I don't necessarily disagree with the sentiment you're suggesting, but presenting falsities as facts doesn't do any argument any particular good.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bmelton on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:53PM (#6960330)
Well, definitions have changed, completely. The average home size in 1950 was ~1000 square feet, while the average home size in 2004 is ~2400 square feet.

Similarly, the 'sane working hours' you mention, generally speaking, were 48 hours a week or more. In the 'upper' middle class, more hours were spent at the office as well. Today, the average worker works ~37 hours.

Assuming job accessibility (which I have no idea if there's a guarantee of or not), and more reasonable home purchasing, I think it's not "simply false" that one can live the same way as they did in the 50s on the equivalent working wage, one simply has to make more apt comparisons to see that the goal posts have shifted.

The average 1950s family only owned one car, while the average family of today owns more than one (likely, to support the second job). If each of us bought houses half the size of what we're currently buying, and half the cars, we'd likely be in greater parity with our 1950s brethren. Also, they had to pay less than half of what we did for college, and they also likely didn't borrow in order to afford it, which factors in even further in measuring debt load.

Anyway, I think your comparison is somewhat rose-colored.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by catonthe on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @05:00PM (#6961285)
> The average 1950s family only owned one car, while the average family of today owns more than one (likely, to support the second job)

Actually, it's an even greater difference than that. The median household income in 1955 was about $4k, while today it's about $50k. In 1955 the cheapest Ford cost about $2k, or half the median household income, whereas today the cheapest Honda costs about $16k, or a little less than a third of median household income.

If we just leave it at that, it sounds like things are about the same. However, the cheapest Honda today comes with airbags, air conditioning, power windows and locks, an FM radio, and a whole host of other features that were luxuries reserved for the most expensive cars (if they were even available at all). On top of that, my (and others') experience with modern Hondas is that they can easily go for 200k miles without major repairs or tune-ups, whereas 100k miles was considered a major achievement for a Ford of that era. Realistically, this difference in longevity alone means that a car from the 1950's cost about three times as many working hours as a car of today.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by vkou on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @05:08PM (#6961309)
The average worker works 37 hours these days, because of a big shift to part-time no-benefits jobs. So, you've got people working 30 hours to make ends meet, and you've got people working 50 because 'that's what's expected if you want to go anywhere.'
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bmelton on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @05:26PM (#6961353)
To be fair, I probably misstated. The average of working hours is ~37, which doesn't necessarily mean that the average worker works that at all. It could be the averages are between 40 hour weeks and 20 hour weeks, and that's where it falls. Honestly, I don't know, nor was I attempting to ascribe motivation to the numbers, except to point out that stated premise was factually incorrect -- workers in the 50s did not work fewer hours, nor did they have larger houses.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:06PM (#6960385)
I think you're actually proving my point - a second car isn't an indicator of marvelous bounty. It's a liability required to support a necessary second job and higher debt load.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bmelton on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:13PM (#6960427)
It probably says more about the courting culture and independence in America than anything else. I suspect (but have zero proof or support for) that fewer marriages are formed from high school sweethearts than was the case in the 50s, which means that many relationships start with 2 cars vs 1.

Beyond that, cars were still a relative novelty in the 50s, and ownership was more sparse. I'd have to research to see, percentage-wise, what the cost equated to. It's possible that their rarity meant that purchasing one car was equivalent to purchasing two, in today's age, but again, I don't have figures on that.

And, of course, I think you're dramatically underestimating the role of gender equality on the work force. Women work, many times because they choose to, not necessarily because they have to.

Regardless, the point you made simply isn't supportable by the raw facts that you presented, nor were necessarily the facts that you presented even factual. I don't disagree necessarily that the upper middle class of today is disadvantaged relative to the upper middle class of the 50s, but if that's the case, it's not because they worked less hours or owned larger homes.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:17PM (#6960452)
That may be true. I think the more general point (which you seem to agree with) is that touting simplistic indicators and claiming that people are better off today, is inconclusive and by no means the 'given truth' that many here assert.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bmelton on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:26PM (#6960478)
Yeah, I really don't know, to be honest. It depends, I'm sure, on which indicators one measures against.

I think in some ways, even the poor are better off. In some ways, even the wealthy are probably worse off. I agree that any notion of "We're all {better|worse} off than 1950" is naive without a greater degree of specificity. It's equivalent to saying that football was "better" in the 50s. How? Certainly not in player safety. Certainly not economically. In pure terms of game play, what metrics? Certainly not in passing. Etc.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by trevorstrohman on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:04AM (#6959840)
This Hans Rosling talk from a few years ago shows how most indicators are improving worldwide (e.g. reductions in child mortality, GDP per capita).

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVimVzgtD6w

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:00PM (#6960117)
Depression is also rising to epidemic proportions, suggesting that improving economic indicators may simply not have anything to do with quality of life.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:06AM (#6962454)
GDP in particular has some huge problems as a measure of economic good.

There are numerous alternative measures which have been proposed, though none have been widely adopted: FISH, GPI, UNHDI, GSDP, GESDI, etc.

"Nobel Laureate: Examine Alternatives to GDP"

http://www.scientificamerican.com/podcast/episode.cfm?id=nob...

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by ak217 on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @03:52PM (#6961081)
More like, mental health is not directly correlated with quality of life. Freed from the preoccupation of having to fight or work hard for basic needs, many people fail to find meaning in their life.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by collyw on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @06:03AM (#6962788)
Are you seriously suggesting that there are more incidences of mental health issues because people have easier lives?
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by philwelch on Thursday December 26, 2013 @08:57AM (#6966252)
Why does that seem implausible?
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Thursday December 26, 2013 @02:10PM (#6967507)
Because a life of mental illness is not easy.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by philwelch on Friday December 27, 2013 @11:45AM (#6971341)
But an easy life can make one neurotic.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:09PM (#6971765)
How?
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @05:08PM (#6961310)
Poor mental health = a low quality of life
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by eruditely on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @05:20PM (#6961335)
Measuring averages from the extreme is not-accurate(via Taleb)
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gress on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @06:09PM (#6961487)
What has that got to do with anything that has been said?
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bmelton on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @02:33PM (#6960777)
I would probably be inclined to agree with that. From a report I read recently (which I can't find again, sorry) pertaining to my home town of Memphis, TN, apparently the general conclusion was that Memphians were happier than Nashvillians, despite the latter having better access to health care, better access to higher paying jobs, better community features (arts, entertainment, etc.)

The report didn't postulate on what the actual cause might have been, or how happiness was measured (or, if it was, I've forgotten), but I found it interesting, and it does support your point here. It seems that, at least since I've been paying attention, America has been trying to optimize for wealth or income, though statistically, it seems that there is validity to the notion that money doesn't buy happiness. If we could better isolate the causes of happiness, we could start optimizing for those factors instead.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by pigeons on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:36AM (#6970969)
Nashvillians don't want to be happy or else many wouldn't be able to effectively do their jobs of writing and performing country music.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bmelton on Tuesday January 07, 2014 @08:27PM (#7021132)
Eh. That argument cuts both ways. Memphis blues aren't quite as big a deal as Nashville country, but it exists, and, on paper at least, should make musicians wont to sadness.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by coldtea on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:32AM (#6959994)
>This assumes that wealth is a zero-sum game, so it can be traded around but not created.

And it very much is.

>It's hard to reconcile that view with the fact that standards-of-living have been growing, more or less worldwide, for the two centuries.

Those are not personal wealth.

Increased standards of living are a kind of background element, as they are more or less shared by the population. Statistically they even out, and only differences from them matter.

A guy living in a trailer park today, with a tv, microwave, electricity, some medical access etc, would be considered living like a king, compared to a 1600's peasant working in some feudal farm. That doesn't mean he feels (or is viewed) as such in our society.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by sliverstorm on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:46PM (#6960301)
Increased standards of living are a kind of background element, as they are more or less shared by the population.

You seem to have gone backwards, and defined wealth as "only the things other people don't have", in which case of course it becomes a zero-sum. But that isn't what wealth is.

The modern understanding of Wealth is the abundance of valuable resources or material possessions. [...] In this larger understanding of wealth, an individual, community, region or country that possesses an abundance of such possessions or resources to the benefit of the common good is known as wealthy. -- Wikipedia

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by agonz253 on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:32PM (#6960228)
>This assumes that wealth is a zero-sum game, so it can be traded around but not created.

>And it very much is.

You may be confusing wealth with money, which is in fact a zero-sum game. Wealth, on the other hand, can be created and it's been constantly created all the time throughout history. The section on the Pie Fallacy in this article may help clarify it: http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:36PM (#6960247)
> You may be confusing wealth with money, which is in fact a zero-sum game. Wealth, on the other hand, can be created

So can money.

Neither wealth nor money is zero-sum.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by collyw on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @06:10AM (#6962799)
Unfortunately money can be created for some by restricting access to wealth.

Restrictions on housebuilding is a perfect example in the UK with its dysfunctional housing market. The older generations are happy to have their house prices artificially inflated by not allowing enough homes to be built for the younger generations and immigrants. Keeps rents and prices high while not creating any wealth.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by fspeech on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @04:53PM (#6961267)
Money as a form of credit is zero sum. For example on the other side of every US dollar is debt security (government or mortgage) that the Fed has bought. Money only has meaning if someone (maybe indirectly) owes you that money. But it is correct that absolute wealth (or what economists call utility) is not zero sum. To focus on relative wealth is to invite unhappiness that no one or system can help. We don't live in Lake Woebegone.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by kamaal on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @04:59PM (#6961282)
Yes, wealth can be created. But creation of wealth isn't uniformly distributed, And beyond all it is a zero sum game at constant points in time.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by benched on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:16PM (#6960173)
This trope is so tired. Yes, I live better than a medieval peasant, and I have access to more computing power than ever. Yet, the standard of living across my entire family and most people I know is blatantly lower, in terms of human basics like housing and togetherness, than in my grandparents time, despite the fact that my grandparents were factory workers without even high school educations, and I am an experienced software engineer.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by twoodfin on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:33PM (#6960520)
I think you have a rose-tinted view of the past. To take one example: I have much more togetherness with people in my family who would not be currently alive had they died of diseases with dramatically higher mortality rates 40 years ago.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by xrange on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:00PM (#6960357)
Can we ask where you live? I wonder how local real-estate prices effect things. For example, I live in fly-over county in a $115,000, 1400 sq. ft. house on a large lot, while my brother-in-law lives in an 800 sq, ft. house on a tiny lot in Seattle that is apparently worth more than $400,000. I support my wife and 4 kids on one income, while he and his wife both work to support their two kids. So even though I make considerably less money, we have a lifestyle that is on par with the 1950's ideal.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by Crito on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @06:08PM (#6961486)
So... how many women do you know that have died in childbirth?
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by coldtea on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @07:07PM (#6961657)
So, how does that matter in this discussion? And the 1500s people didn't knew many who died from car accidents or obesity either.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by Crito on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @09:02PM (#6961917)
> So, how does that matter in this discussion?

...how does it not?

Are you seriously attempting to make the case that automobile accidents and overabundance of food have made all of our other advancements a complete wash? That is delusional.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by coldtea on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:28PM (#6960219)
I think we are in agreement!

I only gave the example to say that what's basic is relative (compared to current standards), so saying that a trailer-park person has more access to more things than a peasant doesn't mean anything.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by kbolino on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @12:54PM (#6960333)
If living better than a medieval peasant doesn't mean anything, then why do so few people want to live like medieval peasants?
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by coldtea on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @07:15PM (#6961667)
For one, because most people can not even point Canada on the map, much less know anything about the living conditions in the medieval age.

In fact, most things people associate with the middle ages are either BS or happened at other times. Witch-huns and the Inquisition for example, are phenomena of the Renaissance, not of the middle ages. Even the Plague happened on the tail end of the middle ages entering into the Renaissance.

Heck, even fewer know that the ratio of holidays (what we'd call bank holidays today) to work was extremely higher in the middle ages compared to today.

Most homeless/coupon-living/trailer individuals would be much better off in the middle ages compared to today.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gnaritas on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @10:39AM (#6959733)
> This assumes that wealth is a zero-sum game, so it can be traded around but not created.

And you assume that because it's not always zero-sum, that it never is, a position just as fallacious.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bermanoid on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:27AM (#6959970)
To swat down an argument one need only show that it's flawed, not that its converse is proven.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gnaritas on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:31AM (#6959987)
True, but you can do so without fallacious reasoning that make you both wrong. Wealth is sometimes a zero-sum game and sometimes not a zero-sum game; not everyone who makes money is creating value for the world, but they usually are.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by run4_too on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:34PM (#6960525)
Value for the world != things I happen to think are worth a lot.

Your view is hampered by your ignorance of the definition of the word value.

If people are making money (i.e. selling a product or service for a profit) they are by definition creating value by default.

The fact that you may not find what they are doing valuable is as irrelevant to the equation as the fact that I don't like broccoli.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @01:29PM (#6963746)
> Your view is hampered by your ignorance of the definition of the word value.

Given your reply, I'd say it's your ignorance on display here.

> If people are making money (i.e. selling a product or service for a profit) they are by definition creating value by default.

False. This naive notion assumes everyone is honest and consumers are informed, both of which aren't true. Plenty of people make money by duping customers into thinking they're providing value when they aren't and relying on customers laziness to take the loss when they figure out it was a scam.

That someone voluntarily gave you money does not mean you provided them value. There is no value in Homeopathy, there is no value in fake magic aura balancing bracelets; these are simply people scamming stupid people for money by pretending to add value.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by PavlovsCat on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @10:51AM (#6959782)
When I am healthy, or plant a fruit tree (on previously unused land), or come up with a better or healthier way of doing something, nobody else looses anything. (That has been going on since the dawn of time if you will, and certainly not just since the last 200 years.)

But on the other hand, a million dollars is in no small part worth a lot because most people don't have it; if everybody did, that wouldn't make everybody rich, it would just mean a loaf of bread now costs a million dollars. You can't just ignore that "because rising standards of living". Wealth is first and foremost a word, not an actual thing, and the associated concepts can be complex... but wealth purely in the sense of market shares, of bank accounts, even of being an expert in comparison to non-experts.. there is so much of what we tend to consider as wealth that is obviously a zero-sum game.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by king_jester on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @10:21AM (#6959666)
Wealth is not zero-sum nor need it be, the only thing required for wealth inequality is that the current pool of wealth be heavily consumed and dominated by a small segment of people, leaving very little of the remaining pool for others.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by jedmeyers on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @06:25PM (#6961541)
This small segment of people actually created this wealth. Why shouldn't they be the one consuming it? And you cannot call the sum of all wealth owned by people "a pool" because it is not concentrated in one place nor should be.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:08AM (#6962460)
It's hard to reconcile that view with the fact that standards-of-living have been growing, more or less worldwide , for the two centuries.

Much of that standard-of-living increase has been dug or pumped out of the ground in the form of coal, oil, or gas:

http://ourfiniteworld.com/2012/08/29/the-long-term-tie-betwe...

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by collyw on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @06:18AM (#6962815)
>It's hard to reconcile that view with the fact that standards-of-living have been growing, more or less worldwide , for the two centuries.

Inequality has been growing a lot the last three decades

http://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/dec/17/living-standa...