News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gnaritas on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @10:39AM (#6959733)
> This assumes that wealth is a zero-sum game, so it can be traded around but not created.

And you assume that because it's not always zero-sum, that it never is, a position just as fallacious.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by bermanoid on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:27AM (#6959970)
To swat down an argument one need only show that it's flawed, not that its converse is proven.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gnaritas on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:31AM (#6959987)
True, but you can do so without fallacious reasoning that make you both wrong. Wealth is sometimes a zero-sum game and sometimes not a zero-sum game; not everyone who makes money is creating value for the world, but they usually are.
Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by run4_too on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @01:34PM (#6960525)
Value for the world != things I happen to think are worth a lot.

Your view is hampered by your ignorance of the definition of the word value.

If people are making money (i.e. selling a product or service for a profit) they are by definition creating value by default.

The fact that you may not find what they are doing valuable is as irrelevant to the equation as the fact that I don't like broccoli.

Re:The real use of money is to buy freedom by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @01:29PM (#6963746)
> Your view is hampered by your ignorance of the definition of the word value.

Given your reply, I'd say it's your ignorance on display here.

> If people are making money (i.e. selling a product or service for a profit) they are by definition creating value by default.

False. This naive notion assumes everyone is honest and consumers are informed, both of which aren't true. Plenty of people make money by duping customers into thinking they're providing value when they aren't and relying on customers laziness to take the loss when they figure out it was a scam.

That someone voluntarily gave you money does not mean you provided them value. There is no value in Homeopathy, there is no value in fake magic aura balancing bracelets; these are simply people scamming stupid people for money by pretending to add value.