"Biographies of living persons must be written conservatively, with regard for the subject's privacy. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, not a tabloid paper; it is not our job to be sensationalist, or to be the primary vehicle for the spread of titillating claims about people's lives. The possibility of harm to living subjects is one of the important factors to be considered when exercising editorial judgment."
Re:Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales colludes with NY Times to suppres...
by tptacek on Wednesday July 08, 2009 @04:18PM
(#694588)
Yes. And while I can't flag this article as another misleading duplicate, I can point out that this simply isn't news: there's a huge amount of "true information" that is surpressed from WP every day based on WP's policies about what they do and don't want in the encyclopedia.
I think part of the disconnect is that people see WP as a news source (it is not), the Hitchhiker's Guide (it is not), and a general-purpose lessaiz-faire commons for sharing information of all sorts (it is not). WP is a community effort to build an encyclopedia. That's all.
The day I saw it (and again today), it was locked, but it definitely included unflattering information. If Jimmy Wales is on the side of Jimmy Wales, he evidently acknowledges the principle of posting objective information in Wikipedia.
Re:Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales colludes with NY Times to suppres...
by tptacek on Wednesday July 08, 2009 @05:01PM
(#694688)
You just sidestepped the point of the original comment. Wales didn't have to do anything. The request was directly in line with WP's stated policies. During the 4 months I spent on WP in 2007, WP:BLP was a constant presence in edit wars.
Re:Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales colludes with NY Times to suppres...
by jacquesm on Wednesday July 08, 2009 @07:20PM
(#694890)
Sorry for the guardian, but no news was suppressed, a persons life was protected.
Your really have to weigh these things carefully.
That not everybody has 'friends in high places' ensuring such a treatment is maybe a reason to review the policy of WP, but the word 'censorship' is not even applicable. News is important, human lives are more important.
Re:Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales colludes with NY Times to suppres...
by anamax on Thursday July 09, 2009 @12:50AM
(#695241)
> News is important, human lives are more important.
SOME human lives are more important. Others must be sacrificed to "if it bleeds, it leads".
There were other requests to keep quiet about kidnapping in the same circumstance for exactly the same reason while this was going on. They didn't get the same consideration.
Re:Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales colludes with NY Times to suppres...
by onreact-com on Wednesday July 08, 2009 @04:44PM
(#694640)
The real issue here is not Wikipedia. It's the fact that for 6 months a single call was enough to shut up the whole global press. Just imagine how often the others call: governments, corporations, Scientology...
Re:Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales colludes with NY Times to suppres...
by tptacek on Wednesday July 08, 2009 @05:00PM
(#694683)
When your single call is "if you run this story, one of our reporters will die", the reporter on the other end of the phone is going to take that call very seriously.
That doesn't mean a single call that said "don't run that story about the real reason Sarah Palin resigned" is going to work the same way.
Re:Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales colludes with NY Times to suppres...
by tptacek on Wednesday July 08, 2009 @06:13PM
(#694830)
No, and that's my point. It was a unique situation created by the nature of the information at play and the people handling it. And you can make a federal case out of that happening, but it isn't an ominous Orwellian phenomenon.
Re:Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales colludes with NY Times to suppres...
by onreact-com on Thursday July 09, 2009 @06:54AM
(#695598)
Don't run tis story or someone will die?
Don't write this or the terrorists strike. Don't write about our soldiers killing and raping in Iraq as they may die in retaliation. Don't write about that epidemic or more people may die due to panic...
News is always about life and death.
This way the Chinese also argue when subduing information about the Tian'anmen massacre "to prevent more people from dying".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biographies_of_living_persons
"Biographies of living persons must be written conservatively, with regard for the subject's privacy. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, not a tabloid paper; it is not our job to be sensationalist, or to be the primary vehicle for the spread of titillating claims about people's lives. The possibility of harm to living subjects is one of the important factors to be considered when exercising editorial judgment."
I think part of the disconnect is that people see WP as a news source (it is not), the Hitchhiker's Guide (it is not), and a general-purpose lessaiz-faire commons for sharing information of all sorts (it is not). WP is a community effort to build an encyclopedia. That's all.
The claim that the Internet -- and Wikipedia in particular -- inevitably routes around censorship is wrong.
Wikipedia won't publish damaging information about you if Wales is on your side, but otherwise beware.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jimmy_Wales
The day I saw it (and again today), it was locked, but it definitely included unflattering information. If Jimmy Wales is on the side of Jimmy Wales, he evidently acknowledges the principle of posting objective information in Wikipedia.
Your really have to weigh these things carefully.
That not everybody has 'friends in high places' ensuring such a treatment is maybe a reason to review the policy of WP, but the word 'censorship' is not even applicable. News is important, human lives are more important.
SOME human lives are more important. Others must be sacrificed to "if it bleeds, it leads".
There were other requests to keep quiet about kidnapping in the same circumstance for exactly the same reason while this was going on. They didn't get the same consideration.
Then again, they weren't reporters.
That doesn't mean a single call that said "don't run that story about the real reason Sarah Palin resigned" is going to work the same way.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lewinsky_scandal
Don't write this or the terrorists strike. Don't write about our soldiers killing and raping in Iraq as they may die in retaliation. Don't write about that epidemic or more people may die due to panic...
News is always about life and death.
This way the Chinese also argue when subduing information about the Tian'anmen massacre "to prevent more people from dying".
You mean "unreasonable" requests like wrt other kidnappings?
Of course it's unreasonable to keep quiet to protect "those people" - they're not reporters.