News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:19AM (#6920931)
In Germany, even the low-speed trains have met a powerful competition in form of coach bus lines.

The coaches are brand new, offer free WiFi, and are vastly cheaper than even the lowest-price DB tickets.

edit: another quite popular travel solution is car sharing("Mitfahrgelegenheit"); this is especially useful if you must drive with your own car (e.g. because you carry stuff you can't transport in a train/airplane) and want to lower your own travel costs.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by CookWithMe on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:23AM (#6921197)
I was really excited about the coach bus lines - until I took a trip with one. Did you take a (longer) trip with one yet?

In an IC(E), I can open my 13" Laptop and work fine, even if the person in front of me lowers their seat. On the particular bus I was riding, the table was just too small. Plus, the bus has much more unexpected movements than a train, I couldn't even look on a tablet screen for too long without feeling some travel-sickness. It was a very long, very boring ride.

The WiFi, btw, was a joke on the autobahn. It was working a bit in the cities...

Also, the trip took more than an hour longer than was planned, and the traffic on the autobahn was absolutely fine (I did the same trip with a car a couple of times). Driving into the cities took lots of time, but again the traffic probably would have looked the same any other average day.

It definitely is cheaper though...

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by mercer on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @10:02AM (#6921426)
I regularly travel between Amsterdam and Berlin, and I have had the same experience.

I avoid the bus because it sucks, I avoid flights because they actually feel longer and more exhausting, and because the door-to-door advantage is only two hours (out of 6 or 7 total). Whenever I can, I take the train.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by pjmlp on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @10:40AM (#6921663)
Same experience here.

Although I could live happier without "problems in course of operations". :)

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @10:38AM (#6921649)
I've done lots of trips since the first coach lines started... and yes, the WiFi quality tends to suck (but so does your cellphone internet).
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by chaz on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:34AM (#6920993)
In the northeast US, too. If I wanted to go from Manhattan to Boston this afternoon: $200 by plane, $75-100 by train, $15 by Boltbus. All take about 4 hours. Plane is going to cost more because it's a bit of a haul to get to JFK or Newark airports -- about $8 + 1 hour by public transportation, or about $50 + 30 min by taxi. Planning out a week or two, though, airfare can be as little as $75. Train stays the same price.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by rayiner on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:04AM (#6921095)
At least part of the issue is that Boltbus is traveling on heavily subsidized highways. On the Northeast Regional, ticket fares more than cover costs. In comparison, only about 50% of highway construction and maintenance is paid for by highway and gas taxes and trucking fees, with the rest coming from general taxes. New York in particular is a state which funds highway maintenance heavily out of general tax revenue.

Still, I think air travel is the clear loser in the comparison. The public transit route to LGA or JFK is a bus trip through not very pleasant parts of Harlem and Queens, and is just a huge PITA with luggage. Strolling into Penn Station is a breeze.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by twoodfin on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @10:21AM (#6921550)
Roads are certainly "subsidized" in the U.S., but given how much economic and civic activity they enable relative to the general revenue required, I don't think it's fair to call that subsidy "heavy". I doubt it's outrageous when considered per passenger-mile relative to, say, the non-fee general revenue that goes to the TSA, FAA, airport improvement, etc.

The federal highways that represented the majority of that Boltbus' trip could easily be funded by gas taxes and other essentially user fees if you raised them marginally and removed the requirement that something like 1/6 of that funding be redirected to subsidize public transit. With a few regional exceptions, Amtrak absolutely could not exist without general revenue: As you raised fares, passengers would vanish. And I'm skeptical that Northeast Regional fares really do cover any more than the operating expenses. Are they sufficient to cover capital expenses as well?

State and local road funding is trickier, because it's inefficient to build toll booths along small roads and local gas taxes can be evaded in border areas by driving to another locality. But almost everyone uses local roads, so paying for them out of local taxes isn't a terrible solution. Regardless, if we could switch to GPS-based taxation without too much of a row, I am quite sure that state and local roads would continue to exist and grow without any "subsidy".

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by patrickg_zill on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:46PM (#6924832)
People keep saying this. But, it is BS.

When you ask them for a link, they trot out something from 30 years ago from the DOT, or a recent study, with no real numbers, from PIRG, a decidedly left-leaning and biased source.

Want REAL numbers? Look up the CAFR financial report for any toll road or turnpike.

Dig into it, find out the actual maintenance costs (not the cost of everything else like hiring people to take toll money), divide by the miles of toll road covered. Then, you will have an actual handle on what maintenance of roads costs.

Hint: it is a lot less than you think and far less than the total amount of road fees, vehicle taxes like the sales tax, registration costs, fuel taxes, etc. that the govt takes in each year.

Don't forget, every 18 wheeler you see has a 12% Federal excise tax on its first sale (and such trucks are usually over $100K, thus at least $12K taxes); and each year, every commercial truck has to pay a sliding scale under Form 2290 to even register their vehicle for plates, from $100 to $550.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by potatolicious on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @01:47PM (#6922926)
Purely a personal pet peeve, but BoltBus also gets to be cheaper because they don't have to build or rent space in bus terminals.

Instead they stop and pick up on busy, narrow streets in Manhattan and their passengers frequently block the sidewalk to such an extent that it forces pedestrians into traffic.

Ditto all the other coach lines. At least the sketchy Chinatown bus lines have the decency to pick up on less busy streets in the Lower East Side, the BoltBuses have no reservations about gunking up the works during rush hour in Midtown.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by chaz on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:13PM (#6924669)
BoltBus to Boston was moved last month from its Penn Station location (at the request of NYC DOT & a community board) to 33rd St between 11th and 12th -- a dead block pretty far away from anything. They sent out an email two weeks ago asking for cust feedback on an "opportunity" to move to 1st Ave between 38th and 39th. They wanted feedback within a couple of days to tell the city, so the city obviously has some control/input, but I don't know the extent.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by protomyth on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @12:11PM (#6922209)
"At least part of the issue is that Boltbus is traveling on heavily subsidized highways. On the Northeast Regional, ticket fares more than cover costs."

You might want the check on that since Amtrack is heavily subsidized by taxpayers[1] and rail is the original subsidized transportation.

Here's a thought experiment. What if you took all the rail in the northeast[2] and made it private roads for automated buses? Would it be better or worse? I imagine you can crank the speed on an automated bus on a closed road.

1) In 2010, Amtrak earned about $2.51 billion on $3.74 billion in expenses.

2) yes, big impact on cargo hauling - the thing American rail is optimized for

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by cfmcdonald on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @12:38PM (#6922410)
Amtrak loses money in most of the country, but the Northeast Corridor is profitable.

http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2013/03/01/amtrak_profit...

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by protomyth on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @12:49PM (#6922493)
The Brookings Institute reports relies on accounting information that is suspect[1] and it looks like the route is a money loser when capital costs are taken into account[2]. The Inspector General's report is one of those nasty reports that show some manipulation.

1) http://www.oig.dot.gov/sites/dot/files/Amtrak's%20New%20Cost...

2) http://cs.trains.com/trn/b/fred-frailey/archive/2011/05/13/i...

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by pathdependent on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:34AM (#6920999)
Although Amtrak (esp on the East Coast) could not be construed as high speed, I suspect they are having a problem with buses too. Previously, I used Amtrak without fail to get from NJ to DC and back. Now, I take BoltBus or MegaBus unless they are fully booked. The bus takes 1-2 hours longer but usually costs about 1/5 to 1/6 the cost of Amtrak. Plus, they both have fantastic customer service whereas Amtrak seems to not care at all about their customers. (Admittedly, I've had some bad experiences on Amtrak, but I don't think they are particularly unusual.)
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by jzwinck on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:15AM (#6921159)
Amtrak in the east surely does not care about "low tech" or "slower pace" people one whit. For example, all eastern corridor trains are off-limits for bicycles, all the time. And the NYC-Montreal service, while being the perfect duration for a night train (11 hours or so), only runs during the day, making it positively absurd for anyone to take the entire journey (it's not cheap enough for the unemployed).

Some buses will take bicycles, and they have more services each day too. Amtrak may as well not exist except for specific commuter services such as NYC-Boston Acela (which is not value for money unless you're in the 1%).

NJ Transit, LIRR, and Metro-North are fairly cheap, compared to their counterparts elsewhere in the first world. Too bad they're not long-distance.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by superuser2 on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @10:35PM (#6925739)
Amtrak is excellent for Milwaukee<->Chicago. 1.5 hours, impervious to traffic, clean, comfortable (like a first class airplane seat), $24. It gets pretty high utilization too.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by rayiner on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:06AM (#6921100)
My wife and I ride Amtrak all the time between Wilmington and DC, because with a 1 year old the extra room is a godsend. We've had uniformly positive experiences with the customer service, both the Red Caps who always give us a hand with the stroller and finding a seat at the end of a car, to the ticketing protocol that automatically refunds no-shows (although unfortunately that's changing in March).
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by notacoward on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:26AM (#6921214)
I've been pretty happy with the Acela service between Boston and NYC, but it is considerably more expensive than the buses. Sometimes it's even more expensive than some of the planes, though they're more comfortable and quicker when you account for airport traffic/parking and TSA nonsense.

I've also tried four of the bus lines. They're generally cool, but there are significant differences in terms of convenience of the pick-up and drop-off points at both ends. They don't all go right to the door of Penn Station. ;) Still, for someone on a budget, they just whip the alternatives. The only way either trains or planes could win would be to offer a significant reduction in total door-to-door travel time with prices no worse than double. I don't see any way they'll be able to do that.

If people want to improve the long-distance transportation infrastructure, I think high speed rail is the wrong place to look. There are surely better ways to take advantage of the train right-of-way and station infrastructure, probably some variant on electric buses traveling at the same speed as today.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by aroch on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:12AM (#6921142)
MegaBus around here has some pretty horrid customer service. Buses are frequently quite late (by several hours even), drivers then speed at 10-15MPH over the posted limit to try and make up time. The built in WiFi is generally either broken or basically inoperable (EDGE mobiledata is faster!). On top of that, the drivers are usually asshats about everything.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by Toenex on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:34AM (#6920994)
There is a similar ticket price disparity here in the UK too. You can travel from Manchester to London and back for less than £30 on the coach but it will cost over £100 for a similar journey by train. The downside is the time it takes; nearly 5 hours each way on the coach versus just over 2 on the train.

Personally I never consider using the coach as I own a car and would always perceive it to take longer than it would for me to drive, although it would cost a lot less. Whilst I would travel by train over taking the car as I'm not that keen on driving and somewhat perversely actually enjoy it. However, my main reason for not travelling by coach is that they always make me feel sick.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by rahoulb on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:52AM (#6921049)
I went to a one day conference in London and, to save costs, decided to take the coach overnight (depart Leeds at 1am and then leaving London at 9pm in the evening - sleeping on the coach both ways).

The train worked out at £40ish each way (I didn't know I was going till a couple of weeks in advance, if it had been months I'm sure I could have bought tickets for less).

Using Megabus, I paid £4 to get there, £8 to get back ... and then had to pay £9 to get a taxi from the city centre to my house.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by leoedin on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:20AM (#6921181)
The train does have a huge speed advantage though. That Leeds-London train takes a tad over 2 hours, while the bus is more like 4.

The entire "privatised" monopoly train system is ridiculous though. I'm dreading the day I turn 26, because it will basically mean that I can no longer afford to travel by train.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by gadders on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:13AM (#6921148)
Was that a regular Megabus, or the special Sleeper Service one with beds?
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by rahoulb on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @10:24AM (#6921564)
Just the regular one. The seats were surprisingly comfortable - but I have been told that I could "sleep on a stick"
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by yoodenvranx on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:51AM (#6921046)
Yeah, riding train in Germany is just too expensive. Unfortunately I still have to use it because currently it is more flexible than the bus lines. I really hope that the competition will drive the train prices down, but that's something I don't believe in...

Visiting my girlfriend at the other and of Germany costs 220 Euro if I pay the full price. Sometimes you get cheaper tickets but that's still too much. Just visiting each other twice a month cost about 400 Euro which woudl be better invested in a vacation or something similar.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by claudius on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @12:04PM (#6922158)
Train prices are not too high, the other means of transport are too cheap – both regular cars and coaches receive heavy subsidies and cause existential costs for the environment without having any advantage whatsoever.

And if you get a BahnCard 50, the price cap for a return ticket is 140 € second class (~200 first class). The (underpriced) BahnCard 100 is at about 4000 €/year second class (and 7000€ for first), which is also a completely reasonable price to ask for a year’s worth of transportation.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by EdwardDiego on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @04:49AM (#6926705)
I particularly enjoyed the German Rail Pass when I was there recently. Something like 240€ got me 3 days of unlimited travel within a month on the ICE trains (and S-Bahn) around Germany and to Brussels, which worked out fantastic for my travel plans - from Frankfurt to Hamburg, Hamburg to Brussels, and then Brussels to München. Worked out a lot cheaper than flying and the time cost was about comparable. Mostly it was far more comfortable too - apart from the bit where I caught the train from Köln to Brussels at the end of the weekend and ended up sitting on my bags by the toilets because it was so crammed.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @12:37PM (#6922396)
Problem with the BC100 is that you have to put up the whole amount upfront and that it's for a full year only - I wouldn't mind something like a 1-month "Bahn Flat" for 350€ or such.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by switch007 on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @03:05AM (#6926402)
€4000/year is incredible value. That's about the same price in the UK to commute 60 miles daily from Surrey to London.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by rixx on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:04AM (#6921096)
Prices won't go down, probably, but bus lines will diversify. They work really well and many people use them.

Random comparison: Stuttgart–Berlin is 6 hours, 140€ by train and 8 hours, 25€ by bus, going two or three times a day.

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by darklajid on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:06AM (#6921101)
Care to share some links? I just declined meeting my brother today, because the trip (70km) costs vastly more money than I'd spend on a train ticket and still a lot more than the route costs by car. We're talking about slow trains (Regionalverkehr) here..

That said, I haven't actually encountered those coaches before..

Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @10:59AM (#6921782)
Sure, just go on meinfernbus.de. ADAC/Deutsche Post have launched the "Postbus", and if you're into carsharing, I recommend mitfahrgelegenheit.de.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by neokya on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @02:33AM (#6926325)
I recently used Meinfernbus to travel from Frankfurt Airport (yes airport) to Hannover. It's comfortable and very cheap, 15 euro.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by hessenwolf on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @08:51AM (#6921047)
Luckily, DB are raising their prices, in some cases by over 8%, to remain competitive.
Re:High Speed Trains are Killing the European Railway Network by prawn on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @07:27PM (#6924996)
The buses can be pretty decent in Turkey also.