Debt-based "ripple" bitcoin (or any other similar system) is not fully interchangeable; you can use BTC IOUs within ripple and pass them around, but you cannot send an IOU across the bitcoin network. This is different than with fractional reserve; where 'created' money can be withdrawn, spent, and intermingled without any differentiation.. I can spend a fractionally-reserve created dollar at walgreens as easily as a bona-fide fed printed dollar bill.
You cannot send a Ripple BTC to my bitcoin-qt wallet, nor will bitpay/coinbase/blockchain or any other blockchain-audited wallet accept a btc-iou.
edit: i basically agree with your other point that the the stated reasons in OP are not the reasons bitcoin will likely undergo s-curve adoption
The process of redemption of BTC IOUs for actual BTCs on the Ripple network resembles the process of redemption of gold-backed USD for gold. Similar to gold being transmitted over a different network than gold-backed USD (the former being physical,) BTC backed notes would be transmitted over a different network - something like Ripple.
Fractional reserve banking can also be practiced directly with BTC, simply by lending against deposits.
(explained here: http://www.cnbc.com/id/101048897)
That's an understatement! It was the national policy of an entire country i.e. France (well I guess not all their citizens directly practiced this suspicion) to withdraw its gold reserves in the US for precisely this reason, until nixon closed the window in 1970.
Doesn't pretty much every major country still keep some fraction of its gold reserves in the basement of the NY Federal Reserve?
There is, however, a key difference in that unlike contemporary FRB, any FRB with bitcoin will necessarily have all of the inflationary effects of monetary expansion through debt exactly counteracted by deflationary effects of debt amortization and bankruptcies.
Fractional reserve banking can happen with Bitcoin, but as a user, you do not have to participate. You can hold your coins in your own wallet and not have to worry about what your bank is doing with it. This means you can never lose your coins from a run on the bank.
Now, if you want to, you can loan your coins out with interest. Or you can give them to a bank and collect an interest rate. But when you do this, you're taking a risk, and you should assume any losses from this risk on your own, and nobody needs to be insured for it. If you don't want to lose your coins, keep them in your own wallet.
You do not have to use a bank account for USD - you can use safety deposit boxes or other secure locations. This is analogous to how you would store large amounts of bitcoin privately.
I think the incentive to use a bank for BTC will ultimately be greater than for USD, since the risk of theft is less predictable or manageable by the average consumer. Holding a large bitcoin balance is terrifying - any keylogger or other compromise could result in complete loss. With physical USD, at least you know intuitively how to protect it.
> Fractional reserve banking entails the creation of new money that is fungible with already preexisting money, i.e. it can be used interchangeably within the currency’s payment systems. This is impossible with Bitcoin.
Not true. Currency can easily be issued against bitcoin. When USD was backed by gold, there was plenty of fractional reserve banking and no-one could issue more gold. In fact, there is already debt-based money backed by BTC issued on the Ripple network.
EDIT: I should add, that fractional reserve banking does not mean infinite money supply. Depending on the amount of reserves required (by customers, government, etc.), as long is it's greater than 0%, there is a limit on the supply. E.g. if the reserve is 20%, only 80 BTC can be loaned against 100, and only 64 against wherever the 80 is deposited, and on-and-on until it approaches 0. Fractional reserve is not necessarily a bad method to allow for risk assessed expansion and contraction of money supply.
> ...blah blah... make it certain that ... Bitcoin will be adopted as the global currency
Oh really? It's certain that the globe will adopt a currency because of it's asymptotic money supply and proof of work algorithm? That makes no sense at all.
The world will adopt bitcoin because it's an efficient means of exchange and safe as a value store / investment from dilution by central banks.
Also, the "security" row in the currency comparison chart is misguided. Bitcoin is far less secure than bank maintained fiat currency networks, because in the latter, fraudulent transactions and electronic theft are generally reversible.