News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by contextual on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:07PM (#6881892)
If the suffering of animals matters, then eating meat is morally wrong. Animals are non-human persons who are aware of their own existence and who feel a wide range of emotions, just like we do.

Killing animals may still be acceptable in western society, but it's wrong. It's wrong just as slavery in the United States in the 18th and 19th century was once acceptable but wrong. Just as hanging, drawing and quartering to an audience of thousands in Europe was acceptable but wrong.

To disregard the pain and suffering of animal persons without regard for their interests - just because they're not human, is a form of racism. Peter Singer[1] calls it 'speciesism'.

We don't need technological advances in this society as much as we need advances in morality.

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Singer

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by chollida1 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:28PM (#6882064)
> Killing animals may still be acceptable in western society, but it's wrong. It's wrong just as slavery in the United States in the 18th and 19th century was once acceptable but wrong. Just as hanging, drawing and quartering to an audience of thousands in Europe was acceptable but wrong.

Wow, wait until you watch an animal kingdom video. Your mind is about to be blown but the amount of animal on animal violence you'll see.

I mean blue whales will eat litterally 10 of thousands of shrimp in one meal.

Lions will attack and pick on the weakest of the gazelles. nature must have really gotten it wrong.

Look, you just can't come out and state that eating meat is wrong without providing some sort of rational around it. Just claiming its morally wrong doesn't really make an impressive argument at all.

The biggest problem you make is to lump together the poor treatment of animals and the eating of meat. Many farms treat animals in ways that are considered by the vast majority of people to be fair and proper.

Many people who eat meat have educated themselves and consider you to be wrong about the ethics of eating meat.

TD/DR, you just can't take your own beliefs, state them as fact and then state that they are the correct moral thing to do and any one who dares disagree with your narrow beliefs is just wrong.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by swombat on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:50PM (#6882258)
Nature is not morally right. In fact, nature is amoral. Pointing to nature and saying "nature does it so it's ok" is a bit like pointing at a landslide and saying "nature does it so it's ok to build my house like this". It's meaningless.

Unlike most animals (as far as we know) we are in the unique position of being moral creatures. We created this morality idea, which was not present in nature before us.

Killing any kind of sentient creature whose death could have been avoided is immoral (whether legal or not). That some countries still apply the barbarous death penalty doesn't make it less immoral. We don't know exactly the level of sentience of the animals we kill and eat, but they are at the very least self-conscious to some extent. Pigs, squids, dolphins, dogs, cats, etc, are all clearly human-like in some ways. Killing such animals is not that far off from killing sentient beings.

I think it's a fair statement to say that killing animals is wrong.

That being said...

The issue is complex. There is a lot of historical baggage that we have to deal with here. And it could be argued that many of those species only exist because we eat them (or at least that most of their numbers exist only because we eat them). Endless such arguments can be contrived. None of them make it right, but they explain why this is not a simple "X is wrong, let's stop doing X" situation.

I say all this above as a meat eater, btw. I eat (a lot of) meat. That I do so while knowing that it's morally wrong is, I guess, just one of those "contradictions" that we humans get to live with.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by chollida1 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:58PM (#6882314)
> Nature is not morally right. In fact, nature is amoral. Pointing to nature and saying "nature does it so it's ok" is a bit like pointing at a landslide and saying "nature does it so it's ok to build my house like this". It's meaningless.

Completely agree here, luckily I never made that argument:) I basically made a tongue in check throw away remark

> Killing any kind of sentient creature whose death could have been avoided is immoral (whether legal or not)

Here we disagree if by sentient creature you included animals, which I'm assuming you do or you'd just say humans:)

Look I recognize your name on this site now and I respect a lot of what you say but you just can't make this statement and assume its a fact that isn't debatable. Because its very much debatable.

Look we just disagree on this point, which is fine as its all opinion based and no right or wrong here.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by swombat on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:21PM (#6882505)
Everything's debatable! But there are pretty strong arguments for "killing sentient beings is wrong".

Most morality stems from the Golden Rule (treat others as you'd want to be treated). If we take that as a given (a reasonable non-controversial starting point imho), then we can easily agree that breeding and killing other humans for food is immoral.

The Golden Rule is generally applied to a small subset of sentient beings, of course. However, one thing is observable throughout history, which is that the group of beings included in the Golden Rule has generally gone up with time. It used to be only a subset of humans, and has progressively grown to include most (and yet still not all) humans in most (still not all) cases. But it continues to grow. And already some types of treatment are considered abhorrent even when applied to non-humans.

For example, we may debate eating pigs, but we would presumably all agree that deliberately torturing a pig for your own personal satisfaction is immoral (hence all the laws against cruelty to animals).

This progress of history seems pretty constant - it may be the only progress we can measure as far as the question "are we getting more civilised" goes. Our measure of progress is, how many more groups do we include under the shield of this Golden Rule.

It's pretty reasonable to predict that, unless things go very badly for humanity, eventually many animals that we currently breed and kill for food will come join us on the safe side of the Golden Rule. We may start with the more inspiring or cuddly ones like Dolphins or Whales, but can you doubt that humanity from 500 years in the future will consider eating a dolphin as abhorrent as we would consider, say, eating someone's pet labrador?

Did eating someone's pet become less moral over time, or has it always been immoral, but before it was tolerated? What about eating other humans? What about other applications of the Golden Rule?

Obviously you can respond that morality is a moving target... and you're right. But then you're still agreeing that the topic we're discussing is something that could easily be conceived as immoral in the future (unlike, say, petting a cat or painting a nice painting, which are unlikely to ever be considered immoral as far as we can predict without resorting to extreme scenarios).

I take the view that something which will be immoral in 500 years is already immoral, we're just too undeveloped to realise it yet, much in the same way that I'd say that death penalty or torture were always immoral, but people weren't civilised enough to realise it in the past.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by bane on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:17PM (#6882958)
> It's pretty reasonable to predict that, unless things go very badly for humanity, eventually many animals that we currently breed and kill for food will come join us on the safe side of the Golden Rule. We may start with the more inspiring or cuddly ones like Dolphins or Whales, but can you doubt that humanity from 500 years in the future will consider eating a dolphin as abhorrent as we would consider, say, eating someone's pet labrador?

Interestingly, humans rarely live as a solo species. Most concentrations of humans are part of a larger menagerie of symbiotic utility and pest animals that rely on human existence and activity and despite the constant presence, it's rare that those animals ever enter even the most carnivorous human diet outside of very specific cases.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by bane on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:52PM (#6882757)
But it's not, meat is so essential to human diets that unlike all other non-meat eating animals, we evolved away the mechanisms for surviving on plant only diets (or at least the kinds of plants a human would be expected to find in their local environment - shipping scientifically engineered and manufactured yeast paste halfway around the planet is kind of cheating).

Reducing the arguments to "because we don't strictly need to, modern civilization can construct a balanced diet without meat" requires that we follow this argument and consider all elements of chosen behavior that go beyond what modern society has made possible that will strictly allow for life-sustainment and reduce life to an ascetic, needs only, life-style where every person is "morally" wrong for occupying more than a 6'x8' housing unit that are stacked into constructs as tall as modern engineering will allow and for using more than x number of joules for life-sustainment etc. etc. ad nauseam. Arguing that doing anything other than strictly necessary life-sustaining activities is morally questionable becomes absurd.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by welly on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:09AM (#6887204)
Is meat that essential to human diets when millions upon millions of non-meat eaters have successfully lived without consuming meat?

You simply can't say that meat is "so essential" because it clearly isn't, any more.

I eat meat for no other reason than pleasure, convenience and laziness but I, and most probably everyone else on the planet, could easily sustain a healthy, long life not eating meat.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by bane on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:10AM (#6888323)
Yes. There are specific nutrients that humans can't synthesize and have absolutely zero plant sources. The obvious one is animal protein, which is structured and metabolized differently than plant protein. But more specifically:

- Vitamin B12, you don't need a lot of it (a few grams of meat per week provides more than 100% of the dietary sources), but every single study of populations of Vegans shows that the majority of them are deficient and have Hyperhomocysteinemia as a result. Hyperhomocysteinemia is only ever seen in four populations, the extreme elderly (due to age related nutrition absorption and metabolic issues), third world countries with chronic poverty, extreme alcoholics and vegans. You can get by for a very long time as B12 deficient, but it will catch up to you and the result isn't particularly pleasant. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6883090 some more I've compiled on this

- DHA (Docosahexaenoic Acid), an Omega-3, pretty much available only from animal sources (and a very small algae source which is often used as a supplement precursor) has been shown important to normal cognitive functioning. Every study I'm aware of has shown that vegans are deficient in DHA (even though it can be synthesized from ALA which is the kind of Omega-3 found in flax seeds and chia etc. it's preferentially synthesized to EPA another Omega-3 which also has plant sources). Omega-3 is essential and not all O3FAs are equal. Despite being able to find DHA in algae in sea vegetables, most vegans simply don't eat enough of it.

- Vitamin A - readily discussed in Vegan sources as "available in plants, but hard to get sufficient quantities of a complete source". Vitamin A is a group of compounds, not just one, and plant sources don't offer a complete source. It's readily available in animal sources, especially liver. Vegans are typically deficient in retinol which is used in the development of epithelial cells an essential and basic component of animal tissue.

Non-essential, but had to very hard to impossible to get in plant form in sufficient quantities (i.e. studies of vegan populations show shortfalls in the majority of the studied population):

- Arginine (partially synthesized by humans, but needs to be supplemented by food sources. Animal sources are much better sources than plans. But if you eat sufficient plant sources, which majority populations of vegans have been shown not to do, you can get by.

- Creatine, synthesized by Arginine, along with Methionine (which is better sourced from eggs then plants as well) and glycine (which is readily synthesized by humans), has been shown to be majority population deficient in every study of vegans I'm aware of. Creatine is important for muscle development and maintenance. You'll find that vegan athletes are aware of this dietary shortfall and supplement.

- Carnosine, only available in animal sources. Carnosine has been shown to be an important dipeptide and important in normal muscle function (where it can be used to significantly boost performance with sources of beta-Alanine). It also has been shown to be a major preventative factor in Alzheimers, Diabetes proper skin function and various age related illnesses suggesting long term consumption is important for healthy long-term living.

- Vitamin-D - especially in northern latitudes or people who don't get enough sun exposure. The primary dietary sources are all animal sources (beef liver, eggs, cheese, fish, etc.). Vegans have shown to have higher rates of vitamin D deficiency than other populations.

and it goes on and on and on.

Vegan diets also make adequate nutrition decisions and monitoring more complicated. For example, complete Zinc intake should be at around 15mg per day, but diets high in phytates require more as phytates disrupt zinc absorption. Similarly iron intake has to be measured at higher doses as what humans actually need is Heme, which is synthesized from Iron. Heme only has animal sources, which is generally used to explain anemia that's common vegan populations.

In addition, animal sources are simply required for normal child development even if adults can get by for longer periods without some of the above. Studies of children raised on vegan diets show significant health and cognitive deficits as animal sources are either the only or the best sources of critical bone, blood, muscle and brain development.

Long term studies of vegans have shown that over 90% of vegans are deficient in one or more of the above, despite supplements being a traditional part of the vegan diet. Most vegans do not stay vegans for more than a few years as the health and nutrition deficits build up, they'll wax on and off the diet -- this provides essential B12 at interval, and since B12 doesn't require constant intake, is usually enough to keep off the worst effects of B12 deficiency. Carnosine however has been shown to be a significant problem in long-term vegan (and vegetarian) diets and is generally attributed to the reason why vegans, despite being healthier in several categories, die at ages and rates similar to omnivores.

Every single one of these deficiencies and health issues are solved on normal omnivorous diets.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by dyadic on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:55PM (#6882295)
Contextual's point is that there is less difference between humans and other animals than most people like to think.

It's a difficult sell, not least because humans are omnivores and by that it is natural to eat meat. But our higher level thinking allows us to reason and determine our own morals, if killing / eating other humans is wrong and animals are not that different from humans then how can killing and eating animals be right?

I sympathise with this view, but still enjoy eating meat, it's a situation that's becoming more uncomfortable all of the time.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by elif on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:51PM (#6882261)
So your counterpoint logic is verbatim the http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalistic_fallacy

Cruelty to animals for survival might have some moral justification. However, as vegans prove every day, survival is no-longer a reasonable justification.

Therefore what we're left with is the willful choice to cause suffering for our own pleasure. Please explain to me how that is morally justifiable.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by dharmach on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:55PM (#6882292)
There are things animals do and you don't and there are things you do and animals don't. Does not make much sense to say you would do something because animals are doing so.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by asciimo on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:43PM (#6882205)
For some animals, killing is necessary for survival. For humans, it is optional. Arguably recreational.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by worldsayshi on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:43PM (#6885934)
He provided argument, if we think that people should be treated humanely we should treat animals humanely because animals are people. You on the other hand are providing an appeal to nature fallacy.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by watty on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:21PM (#6882006)
No, killing an animal for food is not as morally wrong as slavery or murdering a person. Are you joking?

Animals all over the planet kill each other for food. It's part of life. Farm animals are not people and never will be. It's silly to think they deserve the rights of people or to be on the same moral high grounds as people.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by contextual on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:36PM (#6882142)
Recent research is showing animals are much more intelligent then previously assumed. Parrots reason like three year old children[1], mice feel empathy and grimace in agony[2,3], elephants grieve[4] and birds hold funerals for their dead[5].

When we harm or show an incorrect appreciation for other sentient beings, it shows not only disrespect and lack of understanding and compassion, but it diminishes human dignity.

[1] http://m.livescience.com/22178-parrots-reason-three-year-old...

[2] http://www.cosmosmagazine.com/news/researchers-say-mice-feel...

[3] http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2010-07/squint-if-it-h...

[4] http://www.tor.com/blogs/2013/06/when-doves-cry-scientific-a...

[5] http://news.discovery.com/animals/birds-hold-avian-funerals-...

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by jmngomes on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:38PM (#6882157)
"Animals all over the planet kill each other for food. It's part of life."

Agreed. But the least you can (and should) do is spare them the suffering and kill them instantly.

Animals deserve, at the very least, the right to not be put through unnecessary suffering.

They're not people, that's correct. Humans are the highly evolved species of the planet. In fact, we're so evolved that we've come to realize that taking pleasure in others' pain (animals included), just like the lack of ability to feel remorse or empathy, are potential indicators of serious mental illness (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_triad).

It's precisely because we're more advanced that we should show some humanity (I think this is a common sense definition) and not harm sentient beings without a clear need to do so.

Or we can just treat anything and everything like expendable resources. Sounds a tad inhuman to me.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by gambiting on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:12PM (#6881936)
So is there no middle ground then? Is it a simple case of you can't have one without another?

I believe that you can eat meat, provided that animals live in a decent,stress-free environment. I know it's very hard to find meat that carries any sort of a guarantee on it,but at least here in EU "free range" and "organic" mean something that is legally enforceable, so every time I buy chicken/beef/pork that is organic I hope that these animals were kept in good conditions.

I do feel sorry for the American readers,for whom the meat industry is just a massive black box with no way of finding out what is going on - and I genuinely believe that if I lived in America, I would have stopped eating meat too,for that very reason.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by Loughla on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:26PM (#6882055)
Not all of America falls into the category of being completely ignorant to where their food comes from, or eat food that was raised in factory farms.

Many Americans (in the fly-over states) have access to local butchers that can drive you to the actual field where the animal lived.

We recently bought a side of beef for the family from one of these shops. There are eight within a day's driving distance to me (midwest Illinois). I know the first name of the young man that bottle fed and raised the hamburgers I eat.

A majority of individuals in the communities near my home purchase their meat (beef and pork at least) this way. There are other options for people, they are just more expensive, or are perceived as being more expensive.

Please don't lump the entire country into one box. Do you realize how many people there are in the US, or how very large this country is?

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by Zikes on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:39PM (#6882176)
Flyover states have such a low population density that this solution works, however the demand throughout the country is so staggeringly high that it's not at all a viable solution for everyone. That's why the larger meat industries exist, they're the only ones capable of handling the volume necessary.

That means that even less of the country is ignorant about the source of their meat than you would think, but not everyone is in a position to be able to do something about it. Many of us don't have the options available to you, and if we did and we all chose the most ethically sourced options available, the prices would either be astronomically high or the previously ethical source companies would have to resort to less ethical measures to be able to keep up with demand.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by contextual on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:19PM (#6881991)
By abstaining and choosing plant-based alternatives to meat, we stop factory farming, and we support the humane treatment and dignity of animals.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by kaoD on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:23PM (#6882022)
No, there's no middle ground. Killing is killing.

Would it be moral to kill you if I'd let you live in a decent, stress-free environment before your death?

Would it be moral to raise human children, give them a nice childhood and then kill them before they reach adulthood because they're super tasty then?

I'm not saying I agree (or don't) with GP, just noting that you missed his point.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by coldtea on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:39PM (#6882175)
>No, there's no middle ground. Killing is killing.

That's a tautology. It doesn't tell us anything.

The real question is, what makes EVERY killing wrong?

Are you wrong for taking antibiotics? If not, why not? After all "killing is killing".

Are you a murderer for killing a mosquito? Why not? Since, you know, "killing is killing".

Should a lion be punished for eating an antelope? Why not? After all, "killing is killing".

Should a man that caught 10 fish be put to prison for life, just the same as a man that killed 10 people? If not, why, since "killing is killing"?

Perhaps you were wrong, and now you see that not all killing is equal?

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by kaoD on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:46PM (#6882229)
Using antibiotics is a defensive reaction against an attack. It's not killing if you're legitimately defending yourself (even law considers this situation).

Indeed, you're a murderer for killing a mosquito without a reason.

About the lion/fishing analogies, bringing law here doesn't make sense. Law is an artificial system. Punishment is essentially arbitrary. Both the lion and the fisher are essentially murderers anyway, regardless of their punishment.

---

After some downvotes I think I have to say this again: I don't hold these views and acknowledge it's a muddy topic, but you can't ignore these facts! These are legitimate points. I'm just playing devil's advocate here.

My personal opinion is: the lion would eat you. The mosquito would eat you (if it could). That's just how nature works.

But then again, killing another person is just how nature works too, right? I eat meat and will eat meat forever, though I can't help but feel like such an hypocrite for doing so while condemning murdering people.

Not killing people is just an implicit agreement. I won't kill you if you don't kill me. It's not "morally good" or "morally bad", not killing other people is just convenient! The punishment for murder is just the punishment for breaking this agreement.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by direwolf on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @06:03PM (#6884522)
I think the antibiotic example is quite telling. Let's press it a little further. As you correctly point out, killing in self-defense is considered legitimate by most (but certainly not all) people. If someone pulls out a gun and starts shooting at me, most people would agree that it is morally acceptable to pull out a gun and shoot my attacker. But the legitimacy of that self-defense is limited by the principle of proportionality. If instead I pull out an AK-47 and rake back and forth with indiscriminate automatic fire, killing not only my attacker but also 15 innocent bystanders, pretty much everyone would agree that I acted immorally. The death of my attacker would be in self-defense, but I'd still be on the hook for 15 murders.

That second example is more akin to taking antibiotics. If we accept that killing microbes is wrong, and accept your argument that using antibiotics is moral because it's legitimate self-defense, we have a problem. Antibiotics kill a lot more than just the invading bacteria. So does radiation and chemotherapy. In fact, they kill a lot of microbes who live in a symbiotic relationship with me and live in my body because they help me break down food or fight infections.

The point is, things are a lot more complicated than simply saying that all forms of killing are immoral. At some point we have to accept that there is an ordering of life forms, and killing some of them to save ourselves is acceptable. If we don't, using antibiotics, chemotherapy, radiation, or other similar forms of care crucial to modern medicine is immoral. Once we accept that not all killing is wrong, it becomes an issue of line-drawing.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by coldtea on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:03PM (#6882340)
>But then again, killing another person is just how nature works too, right? I eat meat and will eat meat forever, though I can't help but feel like such an hypocrite for doing so while condemning murdering people.

I fail to see the hypocrisy. You condemn murdering people because a) they are your OWN kind, and b) they have brains capable of writing HN posts.

How about just constraining our moral obligation to just: don't eat/murder your own kind?

Let's get to that first, abolishing capital penalty, war, murder and such, and then we can worry about eating steaks and/or prawns...

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by simplemath on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:27PM (#6882559)
You eat plants. This kills the plant.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by gambiting on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:31PM (#6882094)
I didn't. You equal animal life to human life, hence your statements like "Would it be moral to kill you if I'd let you live in a decent, stress-free environment before your death?".

I do not find them equal - I find animals worth carrying about, I would like them to have decent lives, but ultimately - they are food and if they are killed quickly and painlessly then I don't have a problem with it.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by coldtea on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:41PM (#6882186)
>Not sure if your argument holds. We're essentially food too, so it'd be okay to kill and eat you.

Only we have laws that prevent you for doing so, and a culture that says it's bad. Otherwise, have a go at it.

Canibals, which lack such laws and culture are totally fine with eating other people.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by theorique on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:22PM (#6882997)
Cultures in which this was acceptable did not generally do it to members of their own tribe (in-group). It was only something to be done to rival tribe members (out-group) who were defeated in battle. It was an expression of domination and disrespect to opponents.

(At least in Papua New Guinea - other regions YMMV)

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by kaoD on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:50PM (#6882256)
Precisely my point.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by kaoD on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:38PM (#6882154)
Not sure if your argument holds.

We're essentially food too, so it'd be okay to kill and eat you.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by enraged_camel on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:13PM (#6882433)
Well, yes. It used to be OK. In some parts of Africa and the Amazon, it still is.

But human society as a whole has moved on from the practice of cannibalism.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by astalwick on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:29PM (#6882071)
So, but, that's just ignoring the reality of the world.

Fact is: people eat meat. People will continue to eat meat, that's not something that's going to change (in the short term, anyway). Given that, how can we improve the treatment of these animals?

I feel that equating eating meat with murder is just sacrificing the good for the perfect.

Lets find a way to give consumers better choice. We should be aware of the treatment of the meat we consume (and articles like these are helpful in that sense), and we should be able to make purchasing choices on that basis. We should be able to buy ethically raised / humanely slaughtered meats at the grocery store.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by kaoD on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:35PM (#6882130)
No, you're ignoring the reality of the issue! Whether people eat meat or not doesn't matter. How is "a lot of people do it" even a point?

Slavery was a "world reality" too. Would you have suggested a compromise instead of just banning slavery?

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by PetrolMan on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:39PM (#6882170)
Nothing is ever so black and white. I'd argue that there is a difference between killing an insect and killing a human. The difference, in my mind, is that we think an insect lacks the same capacity for experiencing pain.

Edit: In the US, a lot of how cruelty is valued is based on how alike the animal is to us. Mammals get more attention than birds, which get more attention than fish. There is a hierarchy and I think it's based on how closely the animal resembles us, a part of which is the capacity for pain and suffering.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by kaoD on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:41PM (#6882188)
> we think an insect lacks the same capacity for experiencing pain

Who thinks that? Is it true or you'd just like to think it that way?

It isn't even relevant. We're talking about meat here. Animals made of meat have the same capacity for experiencing pain and self-awareness. Animals want to live and try avoid death. Even mosquitoes.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by PetrolMan on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:55PM (#6882291)
We do know that insects are far, far less complicated creatures. The difference between a human brain at 100 trillion or so synapses and a fruit fly at a few million is huge. I'm simply arguing that the necessary level of complexity isn't there for a fruit fly. I'm also arguing that this is more of a continuum than a clear line.

> Animals made of meat have the same capacity for experiencing pain.

This is what I don't see as a clear and obvious truth. You shouldn't get on my case for throwing something out there without any kind of validation and then do the same thing yourself.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by kaoD on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:57PM (#6882311)
> This is what I don't see as a clear and obvious truth.

So their nervous system and brain pain centers (which look just like ours), the physical reaction to pain, the chemical reaction to pain (stress, releasing adrenaline...) and all the death avoidance... that's just a ploy?

I'm not sure about mosquitoes, but I'm pretty sure meaty animals do feel pain.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by coldtea on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:35PM (#6882133)
>It's wrong just as slavery in the United States in the 18th and 19th century was once acceptable but wrong.

Just as? Are you kidding me? For one, animals kill and eat other animals ALL THE TIME. It's what they do.

>To disregard the pain and suffering of animal persons without regard for their interests - just because they're not human, is a form of racism. Peter Singer[1] calls it 'speciesism'.

That's just a word made up for that disregard. The invention of an ad-hoc word for it doesn't automatically make the disregard imoral or bad, much less "as bad as slavery".

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by elif on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:04PM (#6882361)
You are reading too much into the "just as"

The author is trying to communicate equivalency in the seemingly paradoxical categorization of being both "acceptable" and "wrong" through providing examples of things which also fit this hard-to-grasp classification.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by huherto on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:18PM (#6881988)
I am aware that we are causing pain to animals. But eating meat gives me so much happiness that I am not willing to live without it.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by timje1 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:23PM (#6882025)
This is a good reply to the argument that I hear used a lot:

"You just need to educate yourself. Read this website and watch this video: you'll never want to eat meat again!"

What if I'm educated, have read the books, the websites, and still choose meat?

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by richardw on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:31PM (#6882581)
Well, nothing. Everyone has different balances of desire and empathy.

In my country there's a huge deal about rhino poaching for their horns. Pictures of dead rhinos with only their horns chopped off generally horrify us and most can't imagine why someone would kill a rhino for its horn. However, I recently read something about how these pictures have no impact on foreign purchasers of rhino horn - the desire for the commodity far outweighs any feeling for the animal, despite it being endangered.

So you might care about the rhino, but not about your food. Some might care about orphans, but not rhinos or food. Others might care about everything but vegetables. Who is correct? I don't know, but I think it's important to at least engage with the issue so our decisions are conscious. The end result isn't as important as simply having gone through the process.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by arsenerei on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:07PM (#6882385)
That was not GP's argument and it certainly wasn't a good reply. GP simply effectively said, "The circumstances are irrelevant to me, it makes me feel good so I'll do it." Your argument is you have an intimate understanding of where you food comes from and you're okay with that.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by contextual on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:51PM (#6882748)
Some people, no matter what harm their actions may cause others, will only change if it's convenient. Congratulations, you are one of them.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by api on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:21PM (#6882009)
Totally tangential point:

I sometimes draw an analogy between veganism and the extreme anti-force / volitionalist stance of radical libertarians. In both cases is may be radically moral, but the problem with the libertarian case is similar to what you just said.

Government force is just so easy. Is there some systemic social ill that manifests in an emergent fashion from the market? Pass a law and force it to change. Wealth redistribution by force improves the lives of the vast majority of people too.

There may be force-free alternatives to these mechanisms, but it's clear that if they exist they are more difficult. Thus most people are willing to sacrifice some of their (and their neighbors) freedom and autonomy for free health care, free retirement, easy fixes to emergent problems and tragedies of the commons, etc.

I can't say I'm different. I would prefer to have a "softened" market in which some wealth is redistributed by force to me and my middle class contemporaries (as well as to those less fortunate than me) even if it is less moral according to a radical moral theory.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by spikels on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:01PM (#6882329)
I'm glad to finally see someone who supports wealth redistribution clear that it requires force (as well as being in their own self-interest). While I can respect this widely held position I am personally uncomfortable with this aspect. I wish we could achieve the goals of redistribution (btw-these goals need to be clarified) without force (i.e. voluntary charity). This actually seems possible to me because of the strong interest in charity by so many especially the very wealthy and the incredible inefficiency in the delivery of aid to the poor.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by api on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:41PM (#6882679)
Yep. I also wish I could get vegan meat, but it isn't available on the market yet. :)
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by timjahn on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:16PM (#6881967)
Where does the food chain fit in? The idea of certain species and groups of animals being higher and lower on the food chain than others.

Do we just ignore that? Genuinely curious.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by redidas on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:19PM (#6881994)
The animal as people logic doesn't hold up. With this reasoning what do we do about animals that hunt and kill other animals for food. Are they behaving immorally because they must kill to survive?
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by onedognight on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:40PM (#6882177)
> The animal as people logic doesn't hold up.

Likewise with slavery and Human Rights. Human's have been enslaving people for eons, why stop now? Power dynamics are inevitable. Who cares if you are enslaved, or eaten for that matter? The logic simply doesn't hold up.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by timje1 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:26PM (#6882052)
Animals are not usually described as having immoral / moral actions. However, to foolishly continue your strawman: by allowing the animals to kill one another, are their keepers acting immorally?
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by vijayr on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:39PM (#6882166)
There is a difference between animals killing animals for food, and humans killing animals for food.

Animals kill other animals, only when they are hungry. They also don't raise animals in a confined, cruel environment, pump them with drugs, don't beat them, treat them like crap etc. Humans do all of these. Animals also don't waste - every inch of meat is eaten, while we liberally waste.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by jules on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:01PM (#6882331)
> Animals kill other animals, only when they are hungry.

False. I've seen cats killing birds and then not eating them many times.

> They also don't raise animals in a confined, cruel environment, pump them with drugs, don't beat them, treat them like crap etc.

Strawman. He didn't say that we should treat animals like crap. It is possible to treat animals well, except for the killing part, and that's what this discussion is about.

> Animals also don't waste - every inch of meat is eaten, while we liberally waste.

Also false. Lions kill animals and then only eat a small part of it. Sure, later other animals & bacteria eat the rest, but the same applies for humans.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by dublinben on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:25PM (#6882042)
Animals are only moral actors when we're the ones causing them harm. When they're causing other animals harm, they're not moral actors, just animals doing what they do.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by lukifer on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:37PM (#6882152)
To take it to the extreme, we can't know for sure that carrots don't experience suffering due to our raising them for food.

We have canines for a reason; meat is part of our evolutionary heritage. I respect the moral decision not to eat animals, and the fact that we do not raise livestock more humanely is unforgivable; but eschewing all animal proteins is extremely detrimental to one's health (the poster child being Steve Jobs in his last ten years of life).

Given that consciousness is a spectrum and not purely binary, I think the proper middle ground is to eat primarily fish (whose nervous systems are probably closer to carrots than to cows) and by-products such as eggs and cheese (from animals who are well-cared-for). If one does choose to eat red meat, it should at least come from pasture farms where the animal has a real life before it is slaughtered.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by hedning on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:03PM (#6882351)
Steve Jobs had cancer for the most of those 10 years. It seems he tried a vegan diet to treat it among other things, that was silly. That does not make him a poster child for vegans, it seems like he wasn't even vegan before the cancer.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by lukifer on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:17PM (#6882471)
He tried to treat it with specific subsets of veganism, such as fruit-only and nut-only diets. My understanding is that he was vegetarian/vegan for most of his adult life; please correct me if I'm wrong.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by hedning on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:39PM (#6882657)
Might be. I was just going off wikipedia, which only noted anything about veganism as a treatment for the cancer. But it sounds like you know more about it than me.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by arsenerei on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:14PM (#6882442)
> We have canines for a reason; meat is part of our evolutionary heritage.

Gorillas also have canines[0]; they're herbivores.

> by-products such as eggs and cheese (from animals who are well-cared-for).

In some sense, eating eggs and cheese is actually worse than eating meat.

0 - http://www.igorilla.org/assets/images/who/mgsilverteethcu.jp...

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by jessaustin on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:47PM (#6882233)
We have canines for a reason; meat is part of our evolutionary heritage.

I'm sure that's why horses have canines, as well, but they don't eat much meat!

Of course I agree with the overall point; in fact I shot a delicious young deer a few weeks ago. I sometimes wonder whether the meat-is-murder trolls aren't really just cannibals hoping to mainstream their own predilections.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by tspiteri on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:57PM (#6882309)
Horses had canines for fighting, not for eating.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by jessaustin on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:10PM (#6882408)
Really? Any cite for that? Kipling doesn't count!

I've seen lots of horse fights, among individuals with and without wolf-teeth. In few of those were the bites even deep enough along the mandible to engage the canines, and in no case did the bite come from the side to emphasize the canine.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by tspiteri on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:12PM (#6882429)
I found it here: http://www.horseandhound.co.uk/horse-care/horse-care-tips/ca...

The relevant part follows:

Originally “fighting teeth”, they have no occlusal contact, i.e. the opposing upper and lower canines do not meet, so they are of no benefit in the eating process.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by jessaustin on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:35PM (#6883085)
Somewhere, Steven Jay Gould is very disappointed.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by asciimo on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:53PM (#6882275)
Are you saying that Steve Jobs died of a plant-based diet? Citation, please.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by lukifer on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @01:22PM (#6882517)
I'm saying it was a drag coefficient on his general health.

http://newsfeed.time.com/2013/01/29/steve-jobs-fruitarian-di...

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by lucideer on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:44PM (#6882208)
Three questions for you:

1. are carnivorous animals immoral?

2. where do you draw the line in your definition of racism/'speciesism' - homo sapiens -vs- non-homo-sapiens, mammals -vs- non-mammals, mammals/birds/fish/etc. -vs- metazoa/insects/amoeboids/plants/etc./etc./etc.?

3. if suffering of animals as a result of the meat industry is morally wrong, what are your thoughts on suffering of animals caused by non-meat food industries? If grain/crop agriculture killed more animals than the livestock industry what would you do? Stop eating?

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by haberman on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:25PM (#6882040)
If eating meat is just as wrong as slavery, surely it must also be wrong to fail to intervene in nature when animals eat each other. And the very existence of purely carnivorous species is immoral.
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by nine_k on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:41PM (#6882190)
To soothe you I could say that it's advances in technology that will lead us to eating meat without killing animals. Currently lab-grown meat is ridiculously expensive, but so was everything new, before it got to industrial scale.

When factory-grown meat takes over the shelves of meat departments, cow and chicken population of the world will dwindle significantly. Only milk cows and egg-laying hens will remain, along with a small population grown specifically for slaughter, for those perverts that prefer natural, pasture-grown certified organic meat.

Finally humans' beloved pets, cats and dogs, will stop being animal racists and stop feeding on the suffering of other, less fortunate animals.

The only remaining area of unethical killing will be the pesky wild nature, where merciless foxes eat rabbits, and brutal trouts eat lesser fish, which eats small defenseless crustaceans, which.., etc. But I'm sure that progressive humankind will find a way to sort this out eventually, too.

Irony aside, have you heard about the "first noble truth" of Buddhism? Very short and rather enlightening; google it.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by contextual on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @02:00PM (#6882810)
Shame on you for trying to distort the precepts of Buddha. Stop embarrassing yourself!
Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by nzp on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @09:53PM (#6885594)
But he's not distorting, what he said is actually very much in line with at least Theravada Buddhist view on morality. Here, I've posted this[0] a few hours ago because of this discussion and a comment I made above. Straight from the horse's mouth, approximately.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6884572

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by contextual on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @08:30AM (#6887510)
Theravada isn't what Buddha taught. It's an 'innovation' of what Buddha taught. It's a different school of thought and has a different monastic code.

Why don't you read a real book instead of learning from YouTube celebrities? Learn the truth.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by nzp on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:04AM (#6888285)
Why thank you, how very Buddhist of you. :)

EDIT: ... to assume so much.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by theonemind on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:36PM (#6882143)
Slavery was not expedient. It's hard to subjugate masses of people. Morality has only ever held sway to the extent it's convenient. Why is the US not a British colony? The Atlantic Ocean. The colonials got feisty, and it became more trouble than it was worth to keep them under heel.

I'm surprised this is not more readily apparent to people. Justice is a fiction. The Republican form of government has helped create stable governments, and acknowledges the inherent FORCE the govererned people can bring to bear against those in power if the government doesn't operate at least somewhat in their interest. Again, morality as popularly conceived has nothing to do with it. It has more to do with the propensity of kings to end up with their heads chopped off. It always boils down to the sword. If animals could organize and rip out faces off for eating them, society would suddenly have a great moral revelation that eating animals is wrong.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by api on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:18PM (#6881989)
Technological advances can enable advances in morality, or at least ease them. Soon we will be able to grow meat and milk at least without the animal.

I for one would immediately switch to vegan meat and dairy.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by secstate on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:56PM (#6882302)
Oh man ... flame war alert.

The reality of course, is more nuanced. Rarely do absolutist statements like "Killing animals is wrong," bare fruit in the pragmatic reality of everyday experience.

For one thing, freeing all livestock and allowing them to live as nature intended, would be releasing them into a much more savage existence. An analog to freeing slaves does not exist because people have the capacity to improve their station, while animals in the wild fall back to basic survival.

My wife and I run a backyard hog farm, raising animals on pasture with ready access to clean water and plenty of highly nutritious food. In return for the kindness we show them, at a pre-determined point in their life, we kill them and eat their meat.

I will not do that for my children, because the (mostly) tacit contract I have with them and their own capacity allows them pay back my kindness and generosity with their nuanced human emotion and industrial capacity.

Most animals do not have such an industrial capacity. Though where they do (horses, mules, etc...) there actually does exist a very different contract (i.e. we don't eat them).

The problem with your black and white view of morality is that it fails to account for the reality that if I keep 15 hogs, eventually they will die, because all life dies. If they live into old age and become emaciated and weak, their bodies are useless to me. Aside from perhaps companionship, they have not had a net positive impact on my life. Why then should I care for them?

As members of the Animal Liberation Front have discovered, releasing animals back into the wild is rarely a kindness to them. If you ever look closely at a wild rabbit, you find them swarming with parasites and usually living with chronic low-grade infection of some sort or another. Compare that with rabbits raised humanely and holistically in a small-scale rabbit farm and the differences are stark, indeed.

None of this applies, of course, to an industrial farm where animals are treated, as a phase of the end product instead of animal. But that's a whole different argument from "killing animals is wrong." I have no problem arguing that industrial farming is, at it's best, amoral, and more importantly completely unsustainable. But nature has a way of handling unsustainable behavior.

EDIT: Dairy animals would be another classification of animals that we do not kill for their meat. Of course, they do die, as one of our dairy goats did a few days ago. But then we dig a hole, say some kind words and let the decomposition feed the apple trees in our orchard.

Re:The Price We Pay for Cheap Meat by ebbv on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:38PM (#6882160)
The only animal suffering I'm worried about right now is the horse you're on.