E.g. "I’ll model this by assuming the number of non workers will increase by up to 5%, or decrease by up to 20%: I disagree, I made my model assuming that the number of non-workers increases by between 60 and 80%."
Okay, now instead of arguing about basic income in the abstract, you're arguing about projections of how much the number of non-workers changes. The latter is a lot more concrete and easier to analyze further.
Statistics don't come after lies and damn lies accidentally. A naive model of liquid cooling ends in a fatal explosion and the discovery of phase change.
(Disappointed by the downvotes... I'm not trying to be pithy.)
Incidentally, I am not convinced that tarot cards cannot be useful at generating insights - privileging random hypotheses and reconsidering your situation could be a useful means of reducing the impact of hypotheses you're privileging for other reasons. Everything must still be evaluated in light of actual evidence, though, of course, before conclusions are drawn.
Only if the model is accurate. If (as in the case of tarot reading and failed gambling) you have a system that doesn't correspond to the world you will draw conclusions that are detailed and reproducible but not insightful of the world. Inaccurate models are only misleading, not vaguely insightful.
I really don't understand all the negativity here.
If you're modeling investment growth and your model is:
future_value = investment_amt * (interest_rate ^ num_years)
or future_value = investment_amt * (1 + (interest_rate * num_years))
you might realize after running it a few times and seeing incorrect results that the model is flawed (first case) or inappropriate (second case) and fix it to: future_value = investment_amt * ((1 + interest_rate) ^ num_years)So, despite the fact that there was some trifling value to the post, he's really going to garner a lot of negativity.
> The basis of any informed discussion is a mathematical model.
And then towards the end:
> My conclusions are simply the logical result of my assumptions plus basic math - if I’m wrong, either Python is computing the wrong answer, I got really unlucky in all 32,768 simulation runs, or one of my assumptions is wrong.
> My assumption being wrong is the most likely possibility. Luckily, this is a problem that is solvable via code.
That sounds to me like him asserting mathematical models, expressed in code are the only reasonable means we have for knowledge. I don't think he's quite made that case.
"shut the fuck up and write some fucking code"
This is explicitly an assertion that there won't be anything important that can be added to the debate that cannot be expressed in code.
On the flip side, he absolutely doesn't assert that the particular model is the end-all in terms of anything - he expresses desire to see improvements.
Obviously gathering data would be an incredibly valuable contribution to the discussion. I should have been more clear on that point, I guess I just thought it went without saying.
Even with what I consider to be a wildly unrealistic assumption, the Basic Job is still cheaper than the Basic Income in well over 50% of possible worlds.
I repeat: write some fucking code. Don't just say you did, actually do it.
> The basis of any informed discussion is a mathematical model. The best way to think of a mathematical model is a way to force everyone to clearly enumerate all assumptions being made, and to accept all logical reasoning that follows from those assumptions. Given a model, everyone involved in a discussion can agree that either the conclusions of the model are correct, or one of the assumptions going into the model must be false. This is very important when disagreement is reached - disagreement in the conclusions implies disagreement with some assumption, so it makes sense to figure out which assumption is the cause of disagreement.
It’s also important not to be blinded by a model. The involvement of numbers does not make an argument empirically correct - it simply makes it more understandable and less likely to be logically flawed.
He knows the limitations of mathematical modeling and is simply presenting a basic simulation of these two policies subject to various assumptions.
And what’s worse, they seem like something dependable. Isn’t it very hard to judge how much a model has to do with reality? A discussion about a model might be a perfectly scientific, constructive and relevant discussion about a theoretical world that has almost nothing to do with the real one.
The "real world" is a necessary component for the scientific method. By comparing model predictions to real-world experiments, it allows refuting and refining models and theories. How else would you evaluate theories, to separate the chaff from the grain?
The feedback from observation is absolutely vital.
You're basically saying that economy is not science, in the sense above. Which I agree with. It is madness.
This doesn't mean that things outside science cannot be useful -- just that it's not science.
"it simply makes it more understandable and less likely to be logically flawed" -- yes to the first part, no to the second.
A set of iPython notebooks on Github could inspire the inner economist in us all.
I think Climate Change and Securitized Credit crisis also taught this lesson for me: people with models can persuade people into believing anything. It's just a new way to lie with statistics.
There are dozens of completely arbitrary assumptions and nobody could possibly know if they were anything close to being right
> If you disagree, write code.
Ok..
"With a Basic Job, you can’t - your choices are a Basic Job for $14480 or possibly a McJob for marginally more (say $15000). I’ll model this by assuming the number of non workers will increase by up to 5%, or decrease by up to 20%:"
I disagree, I made my model assuming that the number of non-workers increases by between 60 and 80%
Oh look! My results show that basic income is better! Great, that's what I believed before hand, my model must be good.
edit: I'm all for mathematical modelling, but there needs to be some kind of basis for the assumptions, and it helps if there are less than a bajillion assumptions too. Anyone could tweak all the assumptions so they still sound reasonable and come up with any conclusion they wanted from this model