Re:Modelling a Basic Income with Python and Monte Carlo Simu...
by ataggart on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:21AM
(#6725687)
Because this is just mathematical cargo-cult scientism. If the basis for deciding "the model itself may require tweaking or redesign" is that "you still think the results look wrong", you're not doing science.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Modelling a Basic Income with Python and Monte Carlo Simu...
by tptacek on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:31AM
(#6725775)
It's not scientism. You're simply jumping to an invalid conclusion. Stucchio could not have been clearer that simple Python monte carlo models were tools for discussion, not magic oracles.
Re:Modelling a Basic Income with Python and Monte Carlo Simu...
by JackFr on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @11:23AM
(#6726224)
Tools for discussion about what? Python coding? Monte Carlo methods?
Re:Modelling a Basic Income with Python and Monte Carlo Simu...
by Bsharp on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @10:38AM
(#6725840)
Unrealistic results are an indicator that something might be wrong with the model design or model choice which deserves investigating. Why is that such a bad thing?
If you're modeling investment growth and your model is:
future_value = investment_amt * (interest_rate ^ num_years)
or future_value = investment_amt * (1 + (interest_rate * num_years))
you might realize after running it a few times and seeing incorrect results that the model is flawed (first case) or inappropriate (second case) and fix it to: future_value = investment_amt * ((1 + interest_rate) ^ num_years)