I think we've already crossed that line. As far as I know, they don't do it directly, but prison lobbying groups have worked hard to increase the use of mandatory minimum sentences, make sentencing harsher, and keep the war on drugs going.
To me the line is where prisons go from making use of a labor pool that already exists, to actively trying to increase the size of that labor pool.
Imagine an hypothetical situation in which a prison teaches its occupants to code, pays them market wages, and turns a profit. If demand for programmers was high, this prison would be heavily incentivized to lobby for more prisoners, but you'd be hard-pressed to call the nature of the work "exploitative".
Imagine, just as every other time it has ever been tried, the cheap labor underbids the free-world companies that have to air-condition their offices, and control/prevent worker-worker violence, (raping, killing, and stealing) in order to attract talent. Imagine what that will do to the job market for programmers.
Also, isn't the gov't kind of forbidden to compete with private enterprise, especially the skilled labor markets?
If your point is so difficult to discern, maybe you haven't made it very well. I think I've deciphered your meaning now. You contend that a non-exploitative prison owner might earn such profits from non-exploitation that she would seek to increase the multitudes upon which she inflicts her non-exploitation.
This proposition has at least a couple of problems. First, a good measure of whether a practice is exploitative or not is whether people would freely choose it, so it's a bad sign when your SOP requires locks on the cells. Second, from a purely commercial perspective, we would expect a "just" prison owner to be indifferent (in the long term) to how many are imprisoned. That is, she would charge society a suitable administration fee, and transfer most resources directly to the charges in her care. A "kind" prison owner would lose money on every prisoner, so she would actually lobby for fewer of them! Then we come to the sort of prison owners we actually have, and it's no surprise they want to transform the nation itself into a vast prison.
What we're talking about here, however, is whether prison work programs themselves are rehabilitative or exploitative for the prisoners themselves. My claim is that prisons lobbying to get more people into said programs is irrelevant when considering the quality and fairness of the programs themselves.
I do not accept the idea that by doing a crime, you forfeit your all your human rights.
If the programs are entirely optional, it might be OK. As is, it is utterly exploitative.
It's also a silly hypothetical, in that it misunderstands the motive for prisoner labor. Replace "prison" with "community center":
> Imagine an hypothetical situation in which a community center teaches its occupants to code, pays them market wages, and turns a profit.
Compare potential outcomes. Wouldn't that be a lot easier to run and couldn't you expect much better outcomes? Of course. And it's also true for any other kind of labor; equally paid non-criminals with specific inclinations to the work doing it by choice are going to outperform prisoners if you're paying them equally. Which leads us to the actual reason why prison labor is even a thing at all: because it's coercive and thus artificially cheap. There's no other reason to do it! If prisons had to pay prisoners market wages, there'd be no reason to employ them at all; they could just employ other people. It's just not a valid hypothetical.
It's like saying, "we could get rid of traffic problems by not allowing any vehicles on the road."
The same applies here. Whether or not prison owners campaign for policies that would put more people in prison is irrelevant to the question of whether those prisoners are being treated fairly.
Additionally--and I suspect this is what the GP was going for--the lobbying effort clarifies the underlying intentions. The people demanding that prisoners work are doing so not under the banner of exploitation, but under rhetoric about prisoners "giving back to society". That prison organizations are lobbying for more prisoners reveals their real intentions, which is why it's used as evidence of the exploitative nature of the penal system.
Some might object that the term invokes a comparison to the forced labor camps in countries with much worse human rights situations than our own. But that seems a lot like saying that house slaves didn't count as "real" slaves, because their lot was much better than those forced to work in mines.
It's been made abundantly clear in the "10x programmer" threads that there is no valid way to measure programmer productivity, so from where exactly does the speculative average here derive?
These jokers call my home a few times per year. They use inmates on work release, who often try to give you the impression that they are affiliated with a church/charity/etc. They sell normal household products at outrageously inflated prices. http://www.americanhelpinghands.org/ Also Known As U.S. Disadvantaged Industries, Inc.
Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.
A lot of well-thought-out political ideologies maintain that there isn't a line at all.
"Section 1. Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction."
In calling out prison labor as an acceptable form of slavery, the 13th amendment implicitly declares it a form of slavery.
Either way, I don't think it is technically a loophole. Exception is a good word for it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UNICOR ->
Under current law, all physically able inmates who are not a security risk or have a health exception are required to work, either for UNICOR or at some other prison job. Inmates earn from US$0.23 per hour up to a maximum of US$1.15 per hour, and all inmates with court-ordered financial obligations must use at least 50% of this UNICOR income to satisfy those debts.
I think work and education/skills are key to being a healthy human. I just worry that prison labor could easily cross over from being rehabilitative to being exploitative.