News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by powera on Sunday November 03, 2013 @12:38PM (#6664096)
There are always people who say "Science is still the best way of determining true statements" in response to these articles.

But this isn't science. It's pure politics. And politics is probably the worst way of determining true statements.

Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by ExpiredLink on Sunday November 03, 2013 @02:03PM (#6664498)
> "Science is still the best way of determining true statements"

Science is still the best way to refute false statements.

Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by sillysaurus2 on Sunday November 03, 2013 @03:50PM (#6664990)
... mathematically-testable false statements. Most hypotheses in life aren't, such as "If I become a poet, then I'll be happy."

That seems like kind of an absurd example, but thinking along those lines reveals how startlingly few hypotheses fall within the domain of science.

Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by DerpDerpDerp on Sunday November 03, 2013 @04:17PM (#6665105)
I... isn't this a rather testable hypothesis?

It just would be a very time consuming experiment to run, and the cost of being wrong would be high, but I don't see how it isn't possible to get empirical results about if being a poet would, in fact, make you happy.

Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by sillysaurus2 on Sunday November 03, 2013 @04:28PM (#6665168)
Actually, the success of science is its ability to predict what will occur in a wide variety of situations. Otherwise science wouldn't have been such a big deal.

If it were possible to specify how much happiness is enough, and how much happiness isn't, precisely, then it would be science. That's the only way to make generalizations from the results. But the threshold of happiness is imprecise, so therefore it's not science.

Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by alexlawford on Sunday November 03, 2013 @07:38PM (#6665920)
It would be easy enough to show that becoming a poet didn't make someone happy. But if they became a poet, and then became happy? Surely its pretty obvious that the connection wouldn't be testable in the slightest.
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by qznc on Sunday November 03, 2013 @01:28PM (#6664350)
The hard problem is: How to fund science, without also funding "politicians" (or liars or whatever)?
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by dnautics on Sunday November 03, 2013 @02:41PM (#6664661)
Reach into your pocketbook, pull out that blank check, write in the figures and a signature, and send it in the mail. Most science research orgs are 501(c)3 organizations - for whatever that's worth - in any case they will be happy to take your money.
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by qznc on Sunday November 03, 2013 @03:40PM (#6664934)
Basically,you suggest crowd-funding or patronage depending on my bank account. I believe these approaches are even more susceptible to dazzlers.
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by dnautics on Sunday November 03, 2013 @03:58PM (#6665019)
you've never met a federal grants administrator, have you? I've met only two non-stupid ones, ever. The first was my neighbor as a child (who was a physics administrator for the NSF who had the foresight to argue to pull the SSC - because of serious problems with the site - to say the least), the second was my former boss, who quit her highly successful position in academia (long story, won't get into her reasons for doing so).

To be less flippant: There's MORE accountability. If you crowd-fund, people will criticize you publically. when was the last time you saw public comment on an NIH grants review? On a DARPA Call for Proposal? If you don't take public money, to a first approximation you get ONE chance to screw things up by dazzling people. The next time, people are more likely to be wise onto your shenanigans.

Think of it this way: Yes, there are spectacular failures on kickstarter. But yet, there are still good projects that get funded. The economic model, despite all of its naysayers, STILL works to produce good content. Think of all the video games that have successfully migrated to the platform with private micropatronage, and contrast with this: http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2012/06/_38_...

Now, consider that this may be happening in publically funded academic science (Arsenic Life, for example).

Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by qznc on Sunday November 03, 2013 @04:59PM (#6665310)
I agree that a kickstarter for science would be an interesting experiment. It would be quite a change for scientists, if they have to propose to the public instead of experts and politicians.

I'm in Germany, so no direct experience with the US system. Nevertheless, the symptoms are the basically the same here.

Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by neumann on Sunday November 03, 2013 @06:02PM (#6665551)
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by dnautics on Sunday November 03, 2013 @06:44PM (#6665681)
Well, I'm biased, since that's what I'm doing (details in my profile). I have strong opinions about how it should be done to be honest with your donors.
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by crusso on Sunday November 03, 2013 @01:07PM (#6664258)
Exactly. The very nature of the tools used to advance and succeed in politics are anathema to doing good science.

Treating science like you treat politics or marketing is akin to going to war in the name of Jesus or Gandhi.

Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by dnautics on Sunday November 03, 2013 @02:43PM (#6664665)
Does it not seem silly, then, to use a political apparatus to fund science?
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of... by qznc on Sunday November 03, 2013 @05:01PM (#6665323)
I think it makes sense to use tax money for science which benefits the general population. The distribution is tricky of course, but it is with all tax money.