Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of...
by qznc on Sunday November 03, 2013 @04:59PM
(#6665310)
I agree that a kickstarter for science would be an interesting experiment. It would be quite a change for scientists, if they have to propose to the public instead of experts and politicians.
I'm in Germany, so no direct experience with the US system. Nevertheless, the symptoms are the basically the same here.
Re:A Dig Through Old Files Reminds Me Why I’m So Critical of...
by neumann on Sunday November 03, 2013 @06:02PM
(#6665551)
There is already a few:
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/1azr7w/why_isnt_t...
To be less flippant: There's MORE accountability. If you crowd-fund, people will criticize you publically. when was the last time you saw public comment on an NIH grants review? On a DARPA Call for Proposal? If you don't take public money, to a first approximation you get ONE chance to screw things up by dazzling people. The next time, people are more likely to be wise onto your shenanigans.
Think of it this way: Yes, there are spectacular failures on kickstarter. But yet, there are still good projects that get funded. The economic model, despite all of its naysayers, STILL works to produce good content. Think of all the video games that have successfully migrated to the platform with private micropatronage, and contrast with this: http://www.slate.com/articles/business/moneybox/2012/06/_38_...
Now, consider that this may be happening in publically funded academic science (Arsenic Life, for example).