Note: I am certainly not arguing that this is a good thing for anyone by any means at all.
By claim, I suppose you mean sue over? In that case the answer is no. There's this notion that companies legally have to be run so as to maximize shareholder value, and there's some case law in Delaware to support that notion. But what overlooked is the context of those decisions. Invariably the litigation has to do with change of control or measures designed to encourage/discourage same. Outside of those contexts, the business judgment rule reigns supreme. So long as there's no self dealing and the company doesn't lie in its public statements, it is almost impossible for a shareholder to win a derivative breach of fiduciary duty case.
Corporate officers have wide latitude in determining what actions are in the best interest of the corporation.
In a case like this, the incentive to initiate Nuclear Armageddon for profit has to be balanced against the cost of making developers hate you and desecrating your reputation and standing in the community. It is by no means clear that starting a war in which all sides are susceptible to take heavy losses will be in the interest of shareholders.
Patents are a weapon, and if one huge corporation has no "weapons" to defend itself with, then others with "weapons" will attack it. That's why they all have to participate.
In this case, they all - Google included - rushed towards a particularly juicy weapons cache, and whoever got their hands on it was going to use it on the others.
This is fucking ridiculous and disgusting, of course. But it's not the fault of these corporations - they're forced to play, because if one doesn't, then others will just force a massive competitive disadvantage on it. The real problem is the US patent system, the US courts, and the culture of feverish bullshit litigation at every turn that pervades the US.
4.5 billion dollars. If lawyers are even taking 1% of that - good gosh. So many other things in this world 45 million could be better spent on.
Saying that doing something wrong is rewarding is not sufficient.
The first step in this is speaking up and saying, "Hey, this is really obviously wrong".
Part of the reason that the law doesn't have to get every incentive and disincentive right is because there are other mechanisms available.
I'd like to say that I was going to avoid doing business with these parties, but I already wasn't doing business with these parties, at least not to the best of my knoweldge.
https://www.eff.org/issues/current-legislative-proposals-pat...
By launching the mother of all trolls to the disgust of the industry at large, they're adding fuel to the fire and making it more likely that stronger anti-troll legislation will pass. Certainly you can expect Google to dump several million dollars more into lobbying for it now. But if that legislation passes and decimates the weaponization capacity of the patent arsenal they just paid billions of dollars for, they've just wasted billions of dollars.
Similarly, the general consensus here seems to be that what they're doing is totally unacceptable. Here where we have the people who choose which platforms to develop for, whose choices collectively make or break those platforms. Yesterday if you had a choice between hiring an extra developer to develop a Windows Phone version of your app or using the money to improve or advertise the Android version, you were more likely than you are today to do the thing that benefits Microsoft. Similarly, if you're Samsung or Asustek or Huawei and Microsoft has just loosed the troll upon you, well, good luck trying to negotiate favorable terms for any of them to ship Microsoft technology in any of their products.
And on top of all of that, how can they not expect Google to respond? If you start a war you can expect the other side to return fire. Maybe not in kind (by setting loose their own patent trolling entity), or maybe they will, but one way or another it's not like Google is incapable of striking back. What happens when they throw a billion dollars into WINE and Samba? Or add support for Kerberos, LDAP and Group Policy to the Google API so that companies don't need Windows domain controllers anymore? Doing things like that probably wouldn't move the needle on Google's bottom line, but it would stab Microsoft in the face. Which is what happens when you make enemies.
As I understand it, this company was formed during the purchase of the Nortel patents, which happened a couple of years ago. Not just right now. The company which was formed from investment of Apple, Microsoft, etc, is not under their direct control anymore. They basically paid a bunch of money to grant themselves immunity from these patents while creating a hazard / barrier to others.
The fact that the timing of this happening at the same time as patent reform is on the table wasn't predictable some years ago is just part of the point -- you can't always predict blowback. The risk is part of the cost.
Good thing "rewarding" was not used as a sufficient threshold for either cs705's comment or mine then.
Edit: also, apple and microsoft also actually make things. This puts them in a different class than patent trolls like lodsys(sp?)
How did we ever arrive at the place where we believe that everyone else must lose in order for someone to win? How did we get to a point where we believe that we have to take from someone else's plate when there's more than enough to go around? How did we lose the vision that bringing the highest performance, service, features and functionality is "The Right Way" to deliver and compete, instead of destroying ourselves? How did we become so misguided that, even with a broken patent system, we are not intelligent enough and civil enough to simply do "The Right Thing?"
None of this activity is in the spirit of the Hacker Ethos, regardless of the broken system. At what point did we lose our bearing?
I'm reminded of Joshua's observation from WarGames:
"A strange game. The only winning move is not to play."
Sigh...
With the majority of people, who are generally decent, the honor system is workable. Problems arise with a minority of people who are willing to exploit loopholes and engage in freeloading (e.g., patent trolls). This creates the tragedy of the commons [1]. With the existence of freeloaders, it is necessary to carefully craft public policy to discourage freeloading and rent seeking. Right now the US (and perhaps international) patent system does just the opposite.
The best we can hope for is to mitigate the effects of cheating. Attempts to completely stamp out cheating (such as the patent system) are doomed to failure.
Also, and this is a minor quibble, despite it's frequent attribution to him, there is no evidence that Sir Winston actually ever said that.
Just because you can steal something when nobody is looking doesn't mean it's justified to be stolen.
But thats the point. You can blame the companies all you want, another will always be there to step up and take advantage of it. I do blame the companies, but what does it matter? Are we likely going to see an Apple Boycott? I doubt it, and changing one companies business practices will have little impact on the industry as a whole.
But the patent system - that's a single target we can all align against, whose elimination would solve these issues immediately.
> Every system has its exploits, will you blame those systems for their failures?
The system is responsible for maintaining the most beneficial incentives possible. In some cases, it is difficult or even impossible to remove those exploits, and in those cases I look to blame individuals to the maximum extent possible. But in this particular example, there is little to no apparent benefit to having (the current) patent system in place, and only perverse incentives. While it doesn't absolve the companies of their behavior, I don't see how it can be viewed as anything other than an inevitable outcome (given the system design). In that light, I may avoid Apple products for instance, but am generally uninterested in any complaint or action that isn't targeted at the root cause which for all intents and purposes can be fixed!
I absolutely blame the patent system, and it's absurd of you to suggest otherwise.
This meme needs to die.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/09/09/h...
"There are no statutes that put the shareholder at the top of the corporate priority list."
"Nor does the law require, as many believe, that executives and directors owe a special fiduciary duty to shareholders."
It needs to die.
Edit: And there are many, many other places you can find support for this.
All that has to happen is that shareholders (which are often other corporations) need to act RESPONSIBLY, and you're right, this meme will die. I expect the sun to go red giant, first, though.
I'm reminded of the phrase, Those who do not read history are doomed to repeat it.
It's easier to maximize profitability than it is to maximize growth. This is why more companies pursue the first path.
The vast majority of single actions that a corporation takes are not mandated under some simplistic view of "maximising shareholder value".
Money alone makes a poor measure of business as business is there to do stuff and money is just one of the processes involved.
What would they do, just let Google acquire even more mobile-related patents? You think Google would never sue them? Let's not be naive, the only reason Google is a good citizen with patents today is because a retaliation would make a dent on them, and they know it.
The parent is right, the problem is the patent system, which gives a disproportional power to the holder and creates these power dynamics, "eat or be eaten". There's no space for ethics or fairness there.
Google has gone as far doing an "open patent non-assertion pledge" which is far beyond just not using patents: http://www.google.com/patents/opnpledge/
Twitter has an Innovator Patent agreement: https://blog.twitter.com/2012/introducing-innovators-patent-...
Do you really think Google won't do the same to younger tech companies a decade from now?
What do you do after that. Leave the companies that didn't pay alone ?
There used to be a time where companies would have been doing just that. But in mobile market, there is no competition anymore, there is a very rough war. 2 market leader (Nokia, Blackberry) have basically been pushed out of the market in less than 5 years. That's like incredible speed ( I work in financial software company, it takes decades of continuous bad strategy to doom a company ). Their error of judgement was all considered minor and the correction they have done should have been more than enough to limit the losses. In addition of that, only 2 players on the market manage to make money, a lot of money.
In that climate, anything that can give you even a few months edge can be the difference between competing and becoming irrelevant.
The smartphone market is brutal - too brutal for regular competition strategies.
I like the saying anyway, though, however said it.
Apple does not have to participate in this. They chose to cause they anti-competative to the bone.
Regardless of who wins, we have already lost, because we have a patent system that discourages innovation and competition in software!
Maybe the prospect of patent Armageddon will finally force lawmakers to address the issue head on. I'm hopeful. As Winston Churchill supposedly said, "you can always count on Americans to do the right thing -- after they've tried everything else."
--
PS. I highly recommend Gary Reback's 2002 article, "Patently Absurd," which accurately depicts how patents are used by large corporations: http://www.forbes.com/asap/2002/0624/044_print.html
--
Edits: grammar and style; also, added PS and qualified quote with "supposedly," because it's unclear if Churchill ever actually said those words (thanks icebraining and drabiega for pointing that out).