MSG has not been shown to have harmful effects after myriad studies - but people continue to believe it and repeat the myth:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glutamic_acid_%28flavor%29#Safe...
Therefore, it's not just that "burning wood" causes harm, but that a certain level of exposure to burning wood causes harm.
You may think me a pedant, but consider the top post in this sub-thread:
> Drinking a warm cup of coffee or hot chocolate next to a wood fire during
> a cold night is possibly one of the most enjoyable and stress reducing
> activities I can think of. Life isn't about evaluating every risk.
Which is clearly talking about recreational wood burning. I would argue that one cannot (typically) demonstrate harm from such an activity, either because the exposure is too short or the blame cannot be laid on any one particular entity.Therefore, I would say that they are indeed not different at all, at least with regard to a practical implementation of property law. Otherwise, nearly anything could be misconstrued as harm. (e.g., I have dependents and snowboarding could cause me to break my leg and put me out of work, which would cause harm to those relying on me.)
This is the trouble with silly polemical arguments - they run out of control really easily!
Here is that bit, found it - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1oR0EYaOHY
But you're also framing this in terms of personal experiences with limited spheres of effect. Operating wood burning stoves in a neighborhood would appear (I'm not 100% sure on his evidence here, but going with it) to lead to the harm of others. As he opens: "There is no amount of wood smoke that is good to breathe."
At the end of the day, I don't think it's about getting people to overcome their emotional attachments, or convincing them with logic. It's about stirring them out of their apathy. Both believes and nonbelievers will have to confront the third category.
I'm not sure how to apply that analysis to a religious belief, which leads me to conclude that the analogy drawn by Sam Harris is flawed in at least some cases.
Here's a small list of that has a high probability of harming my body:
* Snowboard when I'm not at my prime
* Use MSG in my cooking once in awhile
* Smoke seldomly
* Eat fatty meats such as lamb / duck
* No sleep consistently
* Have too much stress
No one is going to refute these scientifically, but at the same time, just because we ignore the warnings, do not mean that we do not accept the warning as truthful. There is simply a more complex heuristic function we use to evaluate our decisions than a purely risk adverse one.