News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Fireplace Delusion (2012) by modeless on Saturday October 19, 2013 @05:10PM (#6577840)
It's not about the harm you're doing to your own body, it's about the harm you're doing to other people and their property without their consent. Snowboarding or missing sleep doesn't harm anyone else. Burning wood does, and that's why it's different.
Re:The Fireplace Delusion (2012) by electronvolt on Saturday October 19, 2013 @05:21PM (#6577886)
However, missing sleep and then driving (a rather common occurrence) is incredibly dangerous to the person doing it and others. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sleep-deprived_driving) In fact, I think it's fair to argue that sleep deprivation plus daily activities (work or otherwise) likely puts more people at risk than burning wood, many of them without their consent (as they are not the sleep deprived ones).
Re:The Fireplace Delusion (2012) by burntsushi on Saturday October 19, 2013 @05:47PM (#6578007)
I disagree that it is different. Not every theoretical harm to property is a violation of consent. In practice, one has to demonstrate harm and be able to assign blame to an entity. In most cases, short term exposure to burning wood won't cause any demonstrable harm. (Just ask the residents of Providence, RI on Saturday nights during the summer.)

Therefore, it's not just that "burning wood" causes harm, but that a certain level of exposure to burning wood causes harm.

You may think me a pedant, but consider the top post in this sub-thread:

    > Drinking a warm cup of coffee or hot chocolate next to a wood fire during 
    > a cold night is possibly one of the most enjoyable and stress reducing 
    > activities I can think of. Life isn't about evaluating every risk.
Which is clearly talking about recreational wood burning. I would argue that one cannot (typically) demonstrate harm from such an activity, either because the exposure is too short or the blame cannot be laid on any one particular entity.

Therefore, I would say that they are indeed not different at all, at least with regard to a practical implementation of property law. Otherwise, nearly anything could be misconstrued as harm. (e.g., I have dependents and snowboarding could cause me to break my leg and put me out of work, which would cause harm to those relying on me.)

Re:The Fireplace Delusion (2012) by sgt101 on Saturday October 19, 2013 @05:44PM (#6578001)
What about your loved ones? Run into a tree and break your neck and life is not too rosy for them is it? Also your argument can be stretched to eating: if I eat some bread, it is harming you... because you can't eat it, so you starve, also their excreta might suddenly overwhelm and drown you (as you sleep).

This is the trouble with silly polemical arguments - they run out of control really easily!