News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by acheron on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:57AM (#6565337)
Much of the so-called "gerrymandering" is required by the VRA, which this proposal would certainly violate. http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2013/10/15/how_mic...

This looks like a terrible gerrymander. But there is actually something of a method to this madness. The GOP actually didn’t have much choice but to pack voters into Detroit- and Flint-based districts. Detroit has had two African-American-majority districts since the 1960s, and Republicans were probably required under the Voting Rights Act to retain both of them.

This was no easy task. The 13th and 14th districts had both seen their African-American populations drop below 60 percent, and both had suffered severe population losses in the 2000s, requiring them to take on quite a few additional citizens. Making matters worse, there were barely enough African-Americans in all of Wayne County to create two African-American-majority districts entirely within that county’s borders.

Since it was impossible (and possibly unconstitutional) to draw lines to make sure every African-American in the county was in the minority-majority district, redistricters needed to add those voters from Oakland County, which has a growing African-American population. This is actually the source of the odd appendage we see jutting northward from Detroit; it crosses Oakland County to take in heavily minority Pontiac. Even with all this, both districts are only 56 percent African-American and the 14th still elected a white Democrat over an African-American incumbent in the 2012 primaries.

The neighboring districts were then all pushed toward Republicans, as the most loyal Democratic constituents were removed to comply with the VRA. Even a Democratic legislature would have drawn something akin to these districts; there just aren’t many other options. No neighboring district is left with an African-American population in excess of 11 percent under this map, suggesting that the heavily African-American precincts in the state were pretty well gobbled up.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by jskonhovd on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:02AM (#6565364)
Proportional Representation is a much better way to give representation to minority groups.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proportional_Representation

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by pionar on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:06AM (#6565805)
Nope. In the US, we don't vote for parties, we vote for individual people. Political parties are not the solution. The FPTP system we have is a reflection of the framers' desire to avoid parties. Unfortunately, in the 200+ years since, parties are now the norm.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:56PM (#6566585)
> In the US, we don't vote for parties, we vote for individual people.

Proportional representation doesn't have involve voting for parties (party list proportional is one mechanism for achieving proportionality; another method for acheiving proportionality is using voting systems like Single Transferrable Vote in multimember districts -- the latter method is just as candidate-centered as the FPTP-in-single-member-districts system used in the United States, yet provides proportional results [the degree or proportionality varies with the size of the districts.])

While its less proportional, in partisan terms, than party-list proportional (assuming usual sizes of legislatures and manageable numbers of seats per district for STV), it counterbalances that by being more sensitive to general election voter concerns in selection between candidates of the same party.

> The FPTP system we have is a reflection of the framers' desire to avoid parties.

No, its not. The framers were familiar with FPTP, and familiar with the way that parties operated under it. It wasn't a new idea that they were trying out expecting that it would avoid the formation of parties.

It's inaccurate to even say that "the framers" had a coherent desire to avoid parties -- Washington certainly did, and this certainly got more urgent for him as the First Party System took hold during is term as President; Hamilton may have initially opposed parties in the traditional democratic sense since he was more inclined to a life-term aristocracy (remember that he wanted both Presidents and Senators to serve "in good behavior" -- that is, for life subject to impeachment -- the way that in the Constitution-as-it-ended-up federal judges do), but he seems to have readily accepted political parties as the second-best choice; Jefferson clearly saw parties as an inherent part of democracy, and the absence of parties as a feature of despotism, and actually seemed to see a two party system divided on a particular axis -- which he referred to as Whig v. Tory -- as fundamental and inherent in the nature of mankind, though he also was clearly opposed to tribal adherence to parties.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by buerkle on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:32PM (#6566416)
Washington was certainly against the idea of parties, but I'm not sure the rest of the framers' had a specific desire to avoid parties. The two party system developed very quickly with the federalists and anti-federalists.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by adeaver on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:08AM (#6565830)
We are suppose to vote for people, sadly far too many people vote along party lines regardless of the qualities of the actual people involved.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by wadetandy on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:05PM (#6566241)
That is still different than voting for a party. In proportional representation you would cast your ballot for e.g. The Democratic Party. If they got 54% of the vote, they would get to then appoint 54% of the representation for that district. In this way, a very heavily Tea Party district would still have representation for the democratic minority, just less.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 17, 2013 @01:52PM (#6566970)
> In proportional representation you would cast your ballot for e.g. The Democratic Party.

You are confusing "proportional representation" (which is a continuous-valued property of many election systems) with "party list proportional" which is a particular election system for achieving a high value of proportional representation.

Notably, Single Transferrable Vote is a system in which people vote for candidates as they do in FPTP elections (except using preference ballots), but which is designed to acheive proportional representation.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by bld on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:57PM (#6566590)
We can keep FPTP without the pathologies of plurality voting with something like Approval or Condorcet voting.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by robobenjie on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:23AM (#6565949)
Surely if we are changing the law to require districts be chosen by shortest line method we would change the law so that it was legal to do so.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by humanrebar on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:28PM (#6566389)
Any passed law would be appealed to the Supreme Court. If the courts strike the law down, there would have to be a Constitutional amendment. The U.S. has not seen that substantial of an amendment since alcohol was legalized.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 17, 2013 @02:11PM (#6567112)
> Much of the so-called "gerrymandering" is required by the VRA

Not by the VRA alone, but by the VRA combined with the statutory requirement for single-member districts, combined with the expected outcomes of FPTP elections.

Keep the VRA and eliminate FPTP in single-member districts, and you don't need to gerrymander to preserve expected minority representation (plus, you represent everyone better, not just the particular racial minority being protected by the VRA.)

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by Lendal on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:29AM (#6565188)
In my city there is a river which roughly splits it into two equal halves. You identify yourself by which side of the river you live on. But this algorithm completely ignores this natural division and instead uses an arbitrarily angled line which doesn't take into account the people who live there and how they wish to be naturally divided.

Doomed to fail.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by peteretep on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:50AM (#6565299)
That's sort of the point. The problem it's trying to solve is election of extremist representatives with little incentive to pander to both (all three?) sides of their electors.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by loumf on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:17AM (#6565472)
Rather than just drawing lines, the areas should be built up from the census blocks (or some similar thing -- zipcodes, e.g.). It should also try to keep entire small towns together.

This would tend to make areas that make more sense. They would have roughly the same shape, but people living at the boundaries would be more "correct".

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by asmithmd1 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:51AM (#6566160)
I like these maps:

http://commoncensus.org/maps.php#regional_maps

Drawn by answers to the question: "What city has the most influence over the area where you live"

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by loumf on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:19AM (#6565484)
Another -- also "never going to happen" solution is to just grow the House. It used to grow with population and then we stopped. If districts were smaller, it would be easier to make them less gerrymandered and pseudo-proportional representation falls out as a side-effect.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by Glyptodon on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:18PM (#6566337)
I completely agree - I think capping the size of the House was one of the worst things that ever happened in terms of getting effective representation.

And with modern tech, there's no reason not to, even if it means the House of Reps needs a new building. In fact, I'd suggest that they get one, but that we build it in Wyoming, Kansas, Colorado, or Nebraska.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 17, 2013 @02:02PM (#6567038)
> If districts were smaller, it would be easier to make them less gerrymandered and pseudo-proportional representation falls out as a side-effect.

Until you get very close to the limit case of 1 voter per district, more districts doesn't really reduce the opportunity for gerrymandering.

Simply using a candidate-centered election system which produces proportional results in multimember districts neatly eliminates the benefits of gerrymandering.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by mattlutze on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:40AM (#6565637)
At this point they may need to use RFK stadium for floor votes, if we were for example to return to the population density per rep that existed before the growth stopped. Using Wikipedia's numbers, we'd have just over 1,050 reps if we used the same density as 1929 when it was capped.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by xahrepap on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:56AM (#6565732)
But we have the internet now. They don't need to all meet in the same room anymore.

Having more of them would also make it more difficult to buy votes.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by mattlutze on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:50AM (#6565707)
And, at roughly original numbers, ~7,400 representatives.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by stevekinney on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:06AM (#6565809)
That's a lot of people to filibuster.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by Jtsummers on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:56AM (#6566189)
Fortunately the House doesn't have filibusters anymore.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by kldavis4 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:18PM (#6566343)
For more on this idea see this article by George Kenney: http://www.commondreams.org/views04/0120-08.htm
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by binarymax on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:26AM (#6565161)
Definitely interesting, but there is an unfortunate side effect with the algorithm that tends to split up cities. Cities often have a vested interest as a whole - so having 2 or more reps per city as opposed to 1 is going to cause strife.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by aestra on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:35PM (#6566449)
New York City has no fewer than 12 congressional districts. Everything is just fine.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York%27s_congressional_dist...

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by IgorPartola on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:50AM (#6566149)
If a city has a vested interest and votes together for like-minded candidates, wouldn't it have a more loud voice in DC?
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by walshemj on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:54AM (#6566178)
Doesn't hurt London or Edinburgh to have multiple MP's
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by cschmidt on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:34AM (#6565589)
That reminds me of a paper published in the journal Operations Research.

The Geo-Graph in Practice: Creating United States Congressional Districts from Census Blocks

http://cho.pol.illinois.edu/wendy/papers/geographs.pdf [pdf file, obviously]

It was a finalist for a best paper award on public service in OR.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by kens on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:31AM (#6566014)
A serious question: why is it an inherently good thing for reelection to be less assured? I'd think that in many "natural" districts, you'd either have a clear tilt in the population, or a popular politician who always gets reelected because they do a good job and people like them. (I agree that crazy gerrymandering is a problem, but I often see this attitude that there's something wrong if a district isn't competitive.)
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by IgorPartola on Thursday October 17, 2013 @11:36AM (#6566052)
Because the congress has a 90% reelection rate [1] and a 10% approval rate [2]. In short, the tea party members can go nuts and destroy parts of the government, yet be sure they will still get elected.

[1] http://www.opensecrets.org/bigpicture/reelect.php

[2] http://www.msnbc.com/morning-joe/poll-republicans-are-%E2%80...

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by CWuestefeld on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:35PM (#6566450)
I was going to give you an upvote based on your first sentence. But your second sentence's blind partisanship, combined with the obvious (yet overlooked) conclusion from the numbers you cited, make me back off.

So there's a 10% approval rate, and assume that congress is roughly 50/50 by party. Even if we assume that the GOP's approval rate is 0%, then that leaves the Democrats with only a 20% approval.

Clearly the problem is across the board. While you're throwing stones at the other guy, I think you ought to get your own house in order.

We're trying here not to make this a partisan issue, but to look at systemic solutions.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by IgorPartola on Thursday October 17, 2013 @01:21PM (#6566742)
I am not fond of most members of the House or the Senate. The tea partiers are nuts, the republicans are divided and out of touch, and the democrats are weak. Contrary to what you might have gleamed from that one sentence, I am not a democrat. Not that it matters here, but I believe the job of the government is to provide safety for its people: safety from hunger, poverty, sickness and foreign threats. I would love to see the US get its social programs right, expanding some of them to provide a broader and more sane social safety net for those in need. At the same time, I'd love to cut the spending on the military to fund the social programs. Then, I would want to get rid of things like the IRS in favor of a much simpler system. Basically, dramatically reduce the cost of running the government, but boost things that are actually important.

The problem is that there now really are three parties: Dems, GOP, and the tea party. While historically there have been many nutcases that got elected, our current problem is that the tea party consists of people with extreme far right, even anarchist views. Moreover, they have enough people in the House to cause trouble. The thing is, they win in either case: if they manage to shut the government down, or hinder some of its functions, they are doing what they promised. If they do not, they can still cause enough trouble and blame the system they are a part of.

In the long run, I actually hope that the republicans divorce themselves from the tea party, and become slightly more centrist. This will be a short term loss, but in the long run they will then appear to be the most reasonable ones.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by humanrebar on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:35PM (#6566444)
Congress was as unpopular and as full of bad incumbents before the tea party organized.

Also, the tea party republicans have all been reelected recently, so they can't possibly be caused by the high reelection rate. In fact, you would probably see more of them if the advantages of incumbency were diminished.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 17, 2013 @02:08PM (#6567089)
> Congress was as unpopular and as full of bad incumbents before the tea party organized.

No, it wasn't. Whatever you think about the opinion claim ("as full of bad incumbents") the fact claim ("as unpopular") is wrong: Congress' current approval ratings are at the lowest since approval of Congress has been tracked.

> Also, the tea party republicans have all been reelected recently, so they can't possibly be caused by the high reelection rate.

Assuming that you mean "first elected" when you say "reelected", which is the only way this claim even makes sense, then, yes, that's true. What they are a in part a product of is not "the reelection rate", per se, but a particular factor which also contributes to the reelection rate, specifically, districts in which there is no substantial party competition.

These districts mean that a committed faction of the dominant party, even if it is not itself an overall majority faction, can keep a candidate in office quite easily.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by humanrebar on Thursday October 17, 2013 @03:44PM (#6567662)
Sorry. I mistyped. I did mean "first elected".

A better (also less inflammatory) case would exclude condemning the tea party for their political views and tactics and include mentioning politicians like Tom Delay, Duke Cunningham, William Jefferson, Jesse Jackson Jr., and Charlie Rangel who were all convicted or censured for corrupt behavior. Many of them subsequently won primary or general election races!

I actually agree that incumbency is probably too big of an advantage, especially in primary races, but I think the recent primary success of tea party republicans undermines that argument if anything.

EDIT: Regarding popularity, since the 9/11 fervor wore off, congressional approval has been maybe 25% at best. The tea party didn't exactly break anything that wasn't broken already.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by IgorPartola on Thursday October 17, 2013 @01:23PM (#6566749)
The tea party has a high re-election rate. Even if they didn't, the barrier of entry is so low that any elected member that is not extreme enough will be replaced by a challenger that displays the right amount of zeal.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by humanrebar on Thursday October 17, 2013 @03:55PM (#6567721)
> The tea party has a high re-election rate.

If you read my other comments on this thread, you'll see I agree that incumbents are too advantaged, but the incumbents that were defeated by the tea party also had high re-election rates.

Invectives aside, I was noting that tea party republicans are actually a point against the advantage of incumbency.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by dragonwriter on Thursday October 17, 2013 @01:58PM (#6567004)
> A serious question: why is it an inherently good thing for reelection to be less assured?

Its a good thing for there to be meaningful choices in general election. Gerrymandering to maximize competitive districts is one way to acheive very minor improvements in this area (party-blind redistricting isn't likely to do much at all), at the cost of creating a small number of hypermajority districts.

Better ways to do it don't focus on redistricting, but focus on changing the election and nomination system so that: 1) There are more parties that are competitive than in FPTP, and 2) Competitive parties are incentivized to offer more candidates than they currently are for any given election (which, currently, is the seats they are likely to win, rounded up to the nearest whole number.)

STV, or a similar candidate-centered proportional system, in multimember districts for legislative elections is one way to do this, and supports both more viable parties and more candidates per party, and thus more viable choices in general elections. And, like any multimember district proportional system, it reduces the impact of reapportionment methods, so you don't have to worry about trying to control gerrymandering.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by exo762 on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:22AM (#6565503)
What about changing voting system from FPTP to something that actually makes sense and does not produce lame two party system?
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by DennisP on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:44PM (#6566509)
That's the main topic of the site OP linked to. http://rangevoting.org/
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by rlpb on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:42PM (#6566488)
Why must districts be geographical in nature? I don't identify myself with where I live. I identify myself with the communities of which I am a member, and these span much larger areas.

To me, geographical districts have the effect of filtering out like-minded people. For example: hackers don't get a voice (except perhaps in the Bay area), since they are scattered all over.

Why must this be so?

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by andrewljohnson on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:44PM (#6566507)
Because it enables federated, but different, freedoms. How can you move to avoid communities and laws you don't like, if they are not geographically disparate?
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by rlpb on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:47PM (#6566522)
In general, I cannot move to avoid laws I don't like, except by leaving the country (or state). The laws that bother me are not local in nature.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by jeffasinger on Thursday October 17, 2013 @12:44PM (#6566508)
A system where candidates were elected in the house not by district but nationwide number of votes would take care of this.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by coldcode on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:26AM (#6565158)
Makes sense which is why it will never happen.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by jccooper on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:48AM (#6565694)
That's nice, but is clearly illegal. The Voting Rights Act basically requires safe minority districts. Elegance of district lines is a secondary (or less) consideration. Might work for particular large homogenous areas, if you can find some.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by gte910h on Thursday October 17, 2013 @02:06PM (#6567072)
VRA is just a law, like this would be.

VRA is used in court challenges to overturn STATE redistricting efforts, but isn't inherently more powerful than any other federal law when "head to head". This law would change/supersede parts of it.

Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by brianolson on Thursday October 17, 2013 @03:43PM (#6567660)
Alternative algorithmic redistricting optimizes for compactness: http://bdistricting.com/2010/
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by jskonhovd on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:58AM (#6565338)
This is absolutely a better method that the current process of gerrymandering. Texas, Illinois, Florida, and California are awful.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by msrpotus on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:10AM (#6565422)
California has nonpartisan redistricting already. Just because it doesn't look good on a map doesn't mean it isn't fair.
Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ... by jskonhovd on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:25AM (#6565527)
Ok. Yeah, you guys got in recently.

http://wedrawthelines.ca.gov/commission.html