Re:Engineer's Solution: Neutral Redistricting so Reelection ...
by dragonwriter on Thursday October 17, 2013 @01:58PM
(#6567004)
> A serious question: why is it an inherently good thing for reelection to be less assured?
Its a good thing for there to be meaningful choices in general election. Gerrymandering to maximize competitive districts is one way to acheive very minor improvements in this area (party-blind redistricting isn't likely to do much at all), at the cost of creating a small number of hypermajority districts.
Better ways to do it don't focus on redistricting, but focus on changing the election and nomination system so that:
1) There are more parties that are competitive than in FPTP, and
2) Competitive parties are incentivized to offer more candidates than they currently are for any given election (which, currently, is the seats they are likely to win, rounded up to the nearest whole number.)
STV, or a similar candidate-centered proportional system, in multimember districts for legislative elections is one way to do this, and supports both more viable parties and more candidates per party, and thus more viable choices in general elections. And, like any multimember district proportional system, it reduces the impact of reapportionment methods, so you don't have to worry about trying to control gerrymandering.
Its a good thing for there to be meaningful choices in general election. Gerrymandering to maximize competitive districts is one way to acheive very minor improvements in this area (party-blind redistricting isn't likely to do much at all), at the cost of creating a small number of hypermajority districts.
Better ways to do it don't focus on redistricting, but focus on changing the election and nomination system so that: 1) There are more parties that are competitive than in FPTP, and 2) Competitive parties are incentivized to offer more candidates than they currently are for any given election (which, currently, is the seats they are likely to win, rounded up to the nearest whole number.)
STV, or a similar candidate-centered proportional system, in multimember districts for legislative elections is one way to do this, and supports both more viable parties and more candidates per party, and thus more viable choices in general elections. And, like any multimember district proportional system, it reduces the impact of reapportionment methods, so you don't have to worry about trying to control gerrymandering.