[1] http://www.opensecrets.org/bigpicture/reelect.php
[2] http://www.msnbc.com/morning-joe/poll-republicans-are-%E2%80...
So there's a 10% approval rate, and assume that congress is roughly 50/50 by party. Even if we assume that the GOP's approval rate is 0%, then that leaves the Democrats with only a 20% approval.
Clearly the problem is across the board. While you're throwing stones at the other guy, I think you ought to get your own house in order.
We're trying here not to make this a partisan issue, but to look at systemic solutions.
The problem is that there now really are three parties: Dems, GOP, and the tea party. While historically there have been many nutcases that got elected, our current problem is that the tea party consists of people with extreme far right, even anarchist views. Moreover, they have enough people in the House to cause trouble. The thing is, they win in either case: if they manage to shut the government down, or hinder some of its functions, they are doing what they promised. If they do not, they can still cause enough trouble and blame the system they are a part of.
In the long run, I actually hope that the republicans divorce themselves from the tea party, and become slightly more centrist. This will be a short term loss, but in the long run they will then appear to be the most reasonable ones.
Also, the tea party republicans have all been reelected recently, so they can't possibly be caused by the high reelection rate. In fact, you would probably see more of them if the advantages of incumbency were diminished.
No, it wasn't. Whatever you think about the opinion claim ("as full of bad incumbents") the fact claim ("as unpopular") is wrong: Congress' current approval ratings are at the lowest since approval of Congress has been tracked.
> Also, the tea party republicans have all been reelected recently, so they can't possibly be caused by the high reelection rate.
Assuming that you mean "first elected" when you say "reelected", which is the only way this claim even makes sense, then, yes, that's true. What they are a in part a product of is not "the reelection rate", per se, but a particular factor which also contributes to the reelection rate, specifically, districts in which there is no substantial party competition.
These districts mean that a committed faction of the dominant party, even if it is not itself an overall majority faction, can keep a candidate in office quite easily.
A better (also less inflammatory) case would exclude condemning the tea party for their political views and tactics and include mentioning politicians like Tom Delay, Duke Cunningham, William Jefferson, Jesse Jackson Jr., and Charlie Rangel who were all convicted or censured for corrupt behavior. Many of them subsequently won primary or general election races!
I actually agree that incumbency is probably too big of an advantage, especially in primary races, but I think the recent primary success of tea party republicans undermines that argument if anything.
EDIT: Regarding popularity, since the 9/11 fervor wore off, congressional approval has been maybe 25% at best. The tea party didn't exactly break anything that wasn't broken already.
If you read my other comments on this thread, you'll see I agree that incumbents are too advantaged, but the incumbents that were defeated by the tea party also had high re-election rates.
Invectives aside, I was noting that tea party republicans are actually a point against the advantage of incumbency.
Its a good thing for there to be meaningful choices in general election. Gerrymandering to maximize competitive districts is one way to acheive very minor improvements in this area (party-blind redistricting isn't likely to do much at all), at the cost of creating a small number of hypermajority districts.
Better ways to do it don't focus on redistricting, but focus on changing the election and nomination system so that: 1) There are more parties that are competitive than in FPTP, and 2) Competitive parties are incentivized to offer more candidates than they currently are for any given election (which, currently, is the seats they are likely to win, rounded up to the nearest whole number.)
STV, or a similar candidate-centered proportional system, in multimember districts for legislative elections is one way to do this, and supports both more viable parties and more candidates per party, and thus more viable choices in general elections. And, like any multimember district proportional system, it reduces the impact of reapportionment methods, so you don't have to worry about trying to control gerrymandering.