News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 14, 2013 @07:59PM (#6550486)
The Chinese are making incendiary comments because the U.S.-centric world order has done well for them. The U.S. Navy patrols the world's seas and so protects global marine trade routes. The U.S. military provides security guarantees which liberate a large chunk of global demand, e.g. Japan, Korea, Singapore, and the EU, for consumption. And the U.S. financial system lubricates the global flow of capital, goods, and services.

I agree that the global economy has put too much faith in the U.S. political and financial system. Diversification would encourage competition as well as increase systemic resilience. The present situation, where a U.S. default literally means the implosion of the current world order, is encouraging previously taboo debate to come out into the open.

A collapse of the U.S. dollar today shakes up a world in which China is ascending. I'd get mad if someone threatened to flip the game board just as I started getting ahead, too.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by peterpumkin on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:06PM (#6551043)
"The U.S. military provides security guarantees which liberate a large chunk of global demand, e.g. Japan, Korea, Singapore, and the EU, for consumption. And the U.S. financial system lubricates the global flow of capital, goods, and services."

You don't actually believe that? The sole function of the US military is to protect US interests - no one else's! How would you feel if the Chinese navy parked itself in the Gulf of Mexico claiming to protect the free flow of global commerce? You would correctly proclaim that to be nonsense. Some goes for the US military. Don't believe the propaganda...

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbooth on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:14PM (#6551078)
That's true, however the US has a huge interest and 65 year track record supporting global free trade, which is a system that other countries can get on board with.

Certain oil-producing nations aside, this isn't mercantilism, and if the EU and East Asia had a problem with our military presence then we'd probably hear more than token protests about it.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by nradov on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @12:58AM (#6551592)
Foreign navies have visited the Gulf of Mexico many times and the US government hasn't complained.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbigelow76 on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:07PM (#6550516)
I would like to see Obama start to feel out the possible response in the international financial community to unilaterally raising the debt ceiling so this idiocy could be done for good. Just knowing he was doing it would probably cause Republicans to cave so they don't have to admit not authorizing their own expenditures is devoid of all logic.

I hate politics.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by rayiner on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:19PM (#6550831)
Of all of the unconstitutional things Obama has been alleged of doing, blatantly disregarding the Constitution's allocation of the power of the purse to the House and unilaterally raising the debt ceiling to placate the "international financial community" would undoubtedly be the most egregious. It would effectively be a coup d'état and the right's hand-waving about Obama being a dictator will have become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbooth on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:11PM (#6551064)
So you're a lawyer, right? Politically I get what you're saying but legally, with the 14th amendment and all, he has to either illegally prioritize or illegally ignore the debt limit. Maybe ignoring the debt limit has more constitutional standing than reprioritizing the congressional budget. No idea on my end.

Personally, if we're prioritizing, I think he should do some math where they pay all treasury bonds, on time and 100%, and then just cut every other expenditure in half (or whichever % works out), across the board. Social security checks, contractor payments, gov't worker payments, etc. Anybody refuses to do work, send the half-paid national guard after them and order them, since we're in crazytown anyways. And tell them to write their congressman.

That's possibly the "least illegal" option, and certainly the most politically palatable, as far as respecting congress's self-contradictory legal orders in this mess.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by rayiner on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:46PM (#6551190)
The fact that the 14th amendment prohibits reneging on the public debt does not mean that the President is empowered to ignore the other provisions of the Constitution in order to avert a Constitutional breach by Congress. Section V of the 14th amendment clearly gives Congress the power to enforce the other provisions of the amendment.

See: http://www.volokh.com/2013/10/03/14th-amendment-option-table.

As for the illegality of prioritizing payments, as far as I can tell, out of the mandatory expenditures only a small amount is Constitutionally required (specifically, judges' salaries). The rest is only statutorily mandatory. As you correctly perceive, it seems preferable to commit a statutory violation to avoid a Constitutional one.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by waps on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:55PM (#6551219)
Believe it or not, lawyers deal with conflicting laws all the time. There's a few general principles, the most important "rule of thumb" is :

Constitution trumps amendments (but only in certain high-up courts), which trumps normal law, which trumps contracts (written "generally" before oral ones), which trumps common sense ("what a good house father would do"). The sum total of all these things form "the law" as viewed from the perspective of a person (so yes, you are legally obligated to "generally be good" even when the law doesn't explicitly require it (e.g. help people involved in accidents))

Basically since the government debt obligations are contracts, while the debt ceiling is a law, Obama has no choice in the matter : any lawful payments (like medicare, ...) have to be fulfilled before any contract is paid. So barring a new law (the "agreement" the news talks about), on Okt 17, the US should default. Maybe Obama can delay it a few days, but certainly no more.

Please note that congress is doing exactly what it was designed to do. Congress, whether you agree with it or not, represents the will of the people of the united states and Obama is ignoring it, refusing to do so much as negotiate (or so claims congress, and I see no reason to doubt their claims). He knew years in advance that this was coming and gambled. Every executive who has fought congress on this has failed, again something Obama is perfectly aware of (it featured prominently in his education for one thing, hell, it's one of the main forces that brought us democracy in the first place).

In case someone doesn't know this : Obama's a lawyer. Lawyers tend to be lawyers first, people second. And he has a history of this sort of thing : expect him to follow the law over common sense.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by AlexMax on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @02:21AM (#6551791)
> Please note that congress is doing exactly what it was designed to do. Congress, whether you agree with it or not, represents the will of the people of the united states and Obama is ignoring it, refusing to do so much as negotiate (or so claims congress, and I see no reason to doubt their claims). He knew years in advance that this was coming and gambled. Every executive who has fought congress on this has failed, again something Obama is perfectly aware of (it featured prominently in his education for one thing, hell, it's one of the main forces that brought us democracy in the first place).

The Affordable Care Act was passed through normal legislative processes and defended by the judicial system. It has also survived an almost constant legislative assault since then.

Shutting down the government and threatening default over a piece of legislation you don't like is not part of the normal legislative process. It's radical. And you can even argue that with cute little last minute rule changes like HR 368 that it's borderline undemocratic as well. The American people may have mixed opinions on the Affordable Care Act, but I highly doubt they wanted the federal government shut down over it.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by aboodman on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @02:44AM (#6551856)
Congress is not doing what it was 'designed' to do. The Hastert Rule (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hastert_Rule) was only introduced in the last 30 years or so, and has never been followed as dogmatically as Boehner is following it now.

By refusing to bring a bill to a vote unless a majority of his party openly supports it, Boehner is explicitly preventing compromise.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by waps on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @04:18AM (#6552101)
That's not what I mean. Congress is refusing to finance a government whose actions it doesn't support. Which is exactly what it's supposed to do, and is in fact one of it's core functions.

The power of the purse is allocated to the house.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by polymatter on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @08:34AM (#6552833)
Boehner is refusing to allow Congress a vote to finance the government. This is not the same as Congress refusing to finance the government.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by mkr-hn on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:42AM (#6565253)
Days later, congress voted to finance the government. They collectively decided it would be easier to build a better government on an economy that isn't in a nosedive.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dllthomas on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @09:05AM (#6552976)
Constitution trumps laws trump contracts, but this particular contract is specifically blessed ("shall not be questioned") in a way no other contracts or laws are.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by digikata on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @01:28AM (#6551660)
I'm thinking that looking at this Constitutional conflict is a lot like when you know you're about to execute latent untested paths in your production codebase. Except that, of course, you're not just crashing a webserver in this case...
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dllthomas on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:48PM (#6551195)
Bullshit. Congress has been exercising the power of the purse all along, passing budgets with deficits. Congress does not have the power to default on our obligations. The executive taking corrective action is worse than the congress doing so, but it's the congresses fault for failing to do their jobs not any sort of power grab.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by rayiner on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:53PM (#6551206)
It might be unconstitutional for Congress to default on our obligations, under the 14th amendment. At the same time, by the terms of the 14th amendment itself, Congress is the one entrusted with enforcing that requirement. The Constitution does not require that for every possible violation by one branch, some other branch be able to cure that violation.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dctoedt on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:04PM (#6551255)
> At the same time, by the terms of the 14th amendment itself, Congress is the one entrusted with enforcing that requirement.

Yeah, but Article II charges the President with taking care that the laws be faithfully executed. To quote Lincoln (in a different context, certainly), "are all the laws but one to go unexecuted and the Government itself go to pieces lest that one be violated?" Obama would be on solid legal ground in saying that he has to reconcile conflicting congressional mandates by ignoring the debt ceiling.

(On the other hand, I read today that any debt that was issued above the debt ceiling would be a lot more costly because buyers would insist on premium interest rates to compensate for the increased legal risk that the debt would be held invalid.)

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dllthomas on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:57PM (#6551225)
Laws in violation of the Constitution are not laws. If the Congress sets up a situation where the only legal option is default some component of that setup is not law. The fact that Congress is granted powers to make laws that enforce the article doesn't mean the article only has effect through actions of Congress.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbigelow76 on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:52PM (#6550978)
It's not about "placating" anybody, it's about standing up and walking away from the table instead of playing Russian roulette with your crazy, drunk, suicidal uncle.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by sixothree on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:54PM (#6550985)
I like how you casually ignore the whole 14th amendment thingy.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by krapp on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:01PM (#6551019)
This isn't about reality, it's about politics.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:14PM (#6550542)
Obama met with the large banks on 2 October, telling them it might be worse than they expected [1].

Wall Street was pretty chill through the middle of last week [2]. Once it started calling it became apparent that there was little it could do [3].

The expectation appears to be that Obama will prioritise payments after 17 October to avoid a default. Once a critical point is reached he will use "creative accounting," in the IMF's words, to come up with a solution. Him failing at that, the expectation is the Federal Reserve will find a way to credit the U.S. Treasury's account. All these options, it should be noted, involve the selective suspension of the rule of law - the lesser of the evils.

[1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/10/02/us-usa-fiscal-obam...

[2] http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/10/09/complacency-on-wall-s...

[3] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/04/business/economy/business-...

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by patmcguire on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:35PM (#6550632)
Not paying is also illegal, though. So if they don't increase the debt ceiling there's no way not to break the law.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbigelow76 on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:44PM (#6550678)
Nobody outside of the US cares about what's legal (in this instance), they just want assurances the inmates aren't running the asylum and the house of cards won't come tumbling down.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by yapcguy on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:13PM (#6550537)
Why should the debt ceiling be raised?

The debt ceiling has nothing to do with meeting ones obligations to creditors.

If the debt ceiling isn't raised, simply prioritize what the country's money is going to be spent on.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:15PM (#6550548)
"If the debt ceiling isn't raised, simply prioritize what the country's money is going to be spent on."

1. That could be a form of default. Not on the U.S. debt, but on its contracts.

2. Cash flows are lumpy - that's part of why we have government debt. Even reducing all non-debt payments to zero, the U.S. Treasury will have to default at some point before mid-November. There simply isn't enough money in the U.S. Treasury's account at the Federal Reserve to keep its cheques from bouncing.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by tdees40 on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:25PM (#6550581)
Perhaps more to the point, Obama doesn't have the legal authority to prioritize certain payments. If he doesn't pay something, then he would be in violation of the law. He can't just unilaterally not pay bills. This isn't some little technical problem, it's a real constraint. If the debt ceiling isn't raised, Obama is both (1) required by law to spend certain monies and (2) not allowed to borrow to spend that money. This could provoke a very real constitutional/legal crisis with no clear resolution.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by summerdown2 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @09:11AM (#6559424)
Could he effectively write cheques to pay each bill, and watch the cheques bounce when he runs out of money? That way it's not his fault?
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by fleitz on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:35PM (#6550633)
If he is unable to fulfill his obligations as required by law, I guess the only legal option is resignation.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by AnIrishDuck on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:35PM (#6550914)
And then what? The vice president would become the president, and he would have the exact same problem. The executive branch can't just miraculously disappear, even if congress is acting like a schizophrenic moron.

The most likely outcome, if the executive branch has no legal course of action, is to choose the "least illegal" course of action [1]. The linked article from the Columbia Law Review has a detailed analysis of the three options. Here's the most plausible picks:

- Selective repayment. Pick and choose which payment obligations to discharge. There's obvious political issues here. Who gets paid, and who doesn't? Social security over Medicare? Military contractors over NASA?

- Increase taxation without the authorization of congress. Again, many inherently political questions. Who do we increase taxes on? In many ways, this is a mirror image of option #1.

- Issue new debt not authorized by congress. The biggest issues here are market factors, not political questions. How will the market react to this unauthorized debt? If it refuses to buy at low interest rates, this option is not likely to solve the underlying problem.

Several humerous non-options are also debunked in [1], to illustrate what "more unconstitutional" looks like:

- Sell Alaska back to the Russians. Use the proceeds to buy time.

- Mint coins, and by fiat appraise them for massive amounts. Sell them to the fed, and pay off the debt with the new funds.

Just read the article. It's a bit biased, but its analysis of options appears on the whole quite reasonable (I am not a constitutional scholar).

1. http://www.columbialawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/...

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by bilbo0s on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:19PM (#6550836)
I think that the depth of the hypothetical that tdees postulates has eluded you...

it would not be Obama who has a Constitutional/Legal crisis...

it would be the United States.

It would be, quite literally, US Law mandating the violation of ...

US Law.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by fleitz on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:33PM (#6550903)
Which the president as head of the executive branch is required to execute.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbooth on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:06PM (#6551038)
It's been spelled out like 6 times in this thread that this crisis creates contradictory legal obligations for the executive branch that are logically impossible to fulfill.

If you're really not understanding that, perhaps you should consider rephrasing your objection as a humble question.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by bilbo0s on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:46PM (#6550958)
Sigh...

OK... let's walk your suggestion through.

The President resigns.

The Vice-President succeeds.

The Vice-President is now the President.

Now the NEW President is obliged by US Law...

to violate US Law.

So we enact your solution again...

The NEW President resigns...

This time the Speaker succeeds...

The Speaker is now the President.

Now THAT new President is obliged by US Law...

to violate US Law.

So we enact your solution again...

Do you see the problem yet?

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by fleitz on Monday October 14, 2013 @11:22PM (#6551315)
Not really, eventually you run out of people to execute laws that can't be executed. Eventually the government becomes a laughing stock and folds.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by pyre on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @12:08AM (#6551453)
Many people starve to death (among other things) in the ensuing confusion... Either you're very angry at the world, or you're just a troll.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by fleitz on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @01:37AM (#6551670)
Have you ever considered that in the last 15 years more people have died as a result of the actions of the US government than are prevented from starving to death by the US government?
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by pyre on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:10AM (#6553281)
If you want to contribute something constructive to this conversation, then I suggest that you put together some sort of report/study to demonstrate your thought that over the last 15 years more people have died as a result of US government actions than would die in the ensuing chaos around the fall of western civilization.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by ericmason on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:22PM (#6550567)
They can always sell off some assets. Welcome to reality.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by bjterry on Monday October 14, 2013 @10:04PM (#6551030)
Obama should sell start selling indulgences. Every non-violent federal offender has a one-time opportunity to have their case dropped for $100,000. I'm pretty sure lots of people could pony up the cash through friends and family, if necessary. As a bonus, save costs on the Justice Department.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:24PM (#6550579)
You don't buy the furniture out of a burning house. A fire sale of a country's public assets in the midst of a political and financial meltdown isn't going to find much real demand.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jlgreco on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:32PM (#6550614)
The US certainly has assets that other would be willing to buy. As an obviously inflammatory/terrible example: I am sure many corporations or nations would leap at the chance to buy the mineral rights of national parks. How much would the Chinese give us for the right to stripmine Yosemite? A lot I bet. (Obviously that is a horrible idea, we should never stripmine our national parks...)
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by JumpCrisscross on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:39PM (#6550652)
You own Blackberry stock. It's your largest holding. You've seen it lose 90% of its value in the last 5 years. The CEO asks if you'd like to buy a cafeteria pass, good for free meals at the company cafeteria for the next 50 years.

Most investors would say no. If a company is selling its cafeteria food to stay afloat, chances are (a) there won't be a company tomorrow or (b) it will find some way to repudiate inconvenient contracts, e.g. go bankrupt.

Some very smart people bought into an Argentinian oil and gas deal. Then the friendly government became less friendly and their deeds were worthless pieces of paper.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by bilbo0s on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:26PM (#6550863)
What Crisscross is trying to say is...

Even if you buy assets from a government in turmoil...

what is the likelihood that any new government emerging from that turmoil will allow you to keep the assets you purchased?

Historically... the odds have not been favorable to investors.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jlgreco on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:32PM (#6550895)
This is true, but I don't think we are anywhere close to there yet. If we started selling off land, I suspect there would still be buyers.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by yapcguy on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:39PM (#6550658)
Au contraire, the best time to find a bargain is from a forced seller!
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by hobs on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:12PM (#6550799)
True, but the specific analogy basically means that you wait until it all burns down at least.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by seanmcdirmid on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:34PM (#6550627)
We could sell California to China I guess.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by 21echoes on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:24PM (#6550580)
> The debt ceiling has nothing to do with meeting ones obligations to creditors.

yes, it completely does. the US does not have the cash on hand to continue paying out to its creditors. to continue to pay its creditors, it must borrow more money.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by pekk on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:52PM (#6550974)
The debt ceiling has everything to do with meeting obligations to creditors, and that is why it should be raised. Start with false premises, end up with false conclusions.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by jbigelow76 on Monday October 14, 2013 @08:22PM (#6550566)
Because if it's unilaterally raised it ceases to be a weapon.
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by dingaling on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @02:58AM (#6551906)
> The U.S. Navy patrols the world's seas and so protects global marine trade routes.

One of the most active navies in anti-piracy operations off the Horn of Africa is.. the People's Liberation Army Navy. They have had a presence on-station since December 2008.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by CmonDev on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @04:17AM (#6552096)
Who do you think pays for those services? Where does the trillion-dollar debt come from?
Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by mcantelon on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:17PM (#6550827)
Given that the US seems to be preparing for war against China, these comments are unsurprising.

http://yalejournal.org/2013/06/12/who-authorized-preparation...

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by nl on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:40PM (#6550936)
The US isn't preparing for war with China, except in the most general sense of "preparing". The Pentagon does see China as a military threat, and has prepared plans for war (I'm sure someone will point out that the Pentagon has plans for war with Canada, too).

The phrase the US seems to be preparing for war against China implies that there is political will behind the idea of actually putting plans into practice and going to war.

That isn't the case, and I find it extremely unlikely that will change in current environment.

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by mcantelon on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @01:42AM (#6551688)
>there is political will behind the idea of actually putting plans into practice

It's well beyond a contingency plan, like plans for war with Canada is.

"“the Air-Sea Battle concept has prompted Navy officials to make significant shifts in the service's FY2014-FY2018 budget plan” towards exactly the sorts of electronic, cyber, and anti-submarine weapons systems that the war plan for China calls for.”"

http://thediplomat.com/2013/09/03/air-sea-battle-a-dangerous...

"ASB Concept, coordinated through the ASB office, is designed to develop the force over the long-term, and will continue to inform institutional, conceptual, and programmatic changes for the Services for years to come."

http://www.defense.gov/pubs/ASB-ConceptImplementation-Summar...

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by nl on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @01:50AM (#6551704)
You know what that is?

That's Pentagon code for "fighting terrorists doesn't let us buy aircraft carriers and F22s. We need a bigger enemy to show we need more money"

Re:China's State Press Calls for 'Building a de-Americanized... by mcantelon on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @02:15AM (#6551772)
Yup. Kind of like the Cold War.